Dead Beat Dads: Minorities Not Worthy Of Civil Rights?

2056 words - 8 pages

Fathers every year in Washington go to jail for nothing more than being broke (Deadbeat). They are called “dead beat dads” by their peers, scorn by society, and treated as subclass citizens (ASSOCIATED). This is a very grim reality that men of every age range face daily. Both men and women make the choices which result in babies. Conversely, women are given a choice at every stage of the child’s development to adopt out, abort, or even use contraception (Why). Therefore, men and women share equal responsibility for the children they conceive. However, men do not have the same options, or protections, women do (Why). As a result, DCS hunts men down, treating men like criminals until they lay a golden egg (House; ASSOCIATED). Some men never do lay the golden egg, and these are the truly “dead broke” dads (Miller; Deadbeat). Overall, this is a list of inequalities which are simply unconstitutional. Each one of these amounting to another violation of men’s fundamental rights (civil liberties).
In making my case, I first provide a description of the two laws which contribute to imprisonment of alleged fathers, then describe the cases in which alleged fathers may lose their licenses even commercial licenses. First, contempt of court is often used when there is already a support order in place and the father cannot make his obligations under the order. Contempt requires only bad faith to be proven, and only requires a preponderance of evidence. Contempt is not held to the same standard as criminal hearings (though it can still lead to loss of liberty). Second, Federal Criminal Non-support can be used in cases where the alleged father is out of state. Non-support however, requires much more substantiated evidence. For a non-support case you must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that, the father does not reside in the same state as his child, DCS has exhausted every other remedy for collections, there have been no payments in six months, and the father can pay support. However, merely bringing the charge against a father is enough to have him spend the night in jail, possibly losing his job. Finally, when unemployed fathers cannot meet their obligations they can lose their licenses (even commercial). There is no requirement of evidence for these cases, DCS can simply revoke the father’s license until all support owed is paid.
Now, I’ll cover two interesting hearings which clearly demonstrate how these violations lead to imprisonment. My presentation begins with a Washingtonian, Robin Miller. He’s what some would call a “deadbeat dad.” The story, as he tells it, begins with a child support hearing (Miller). At this hearing he had $540 he planned to pay on his order (Miller). Unfortunately, $540 wasn’t enough for the DA who threatened jail time if he could not come up with $2500 (Miller). As a result, Robin Miller refused to sign any order and kept the money he was going to pay (Miller). Miller believed he would need this money in order to pay for...

Find Another Essay On Dead-Beat Dads: Minorities Not Worthy Of Civil Rights?

The Significance of Equality: Civil Rights

1662 words - 7 pages the land, has reached the conclusion that it is competent for a State to regulate the enjoyment by citizens of their civil rights solely upon the basis of race For the first time in history, blacks know that they are protected under the law, and that the Supreme Court supports them on the endeavors they have made throughout history. For once, they are understood for being a person, not just a black person, but under the law they are equivalent

The Civil Rights Act of 1964

1897 words - 8 pages history. After passing the Civil Rights Act of 1964 however, no longer could segregation be legal or tolerated. In public places the rights of a black person were to be equal to that of a white person. In employment, blacks, minorities, and women could not be discriminated against. The federal government cut off funds to any business, educational institution, state or local government that practiced racial discrimination. To enforce the Civil

Civil Rights Movement of Mahatma Gandhi

799 words - 3 pages was meant to help only Indians but later it allied with African National Congress. He took part in many black civil rights movements as well. In no time he became a nationwide hero amongst minorities. Words spread in his home country India. By the time he went back to India he had already become a hero to millions of Indians. II. Gandhi was the prominent factor in India’s independence and he managed to do so with non-violence. A. In 1915, he

The decline of the civil rights movement

4641 words - 19 pages real issue and showing that the 'problem' of civil rights is not one that should be considered solved.[1: "Criminal Justice Fact Sheet." NAACP. Web. 23 Sept. 2014. <>.][2: "The Journal of Negro Education." The Journal of Negro Education. Web. 24 Sept. 2014. <>.][3: "Table A-2. Employment Status of the Civilian Population by Race, Sex, and Age." U.S

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act

1811 words - 7 pages Fair Labor Standards Act (EEOC, 2006).The Civil Rights Act of 1991 expanded Title VII coverage to include emigrant American citizens employed outside of the U.S. by American employers. Additionally, there are some Title VII provisions for non-U.S. citizens within the U.S., but not outside of it. While undocumented workers are covered under Title VII, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission is in the process of reconsidering remedies for

History of Civil Rights in America

1584 words - 6 pages Board of Education reversed the ruling of Plessy v. Ferguson. It found that this practice was unconstitutional and required by law that blacks and whites be integrated in every facet of daily life. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was brought forth after many businesses and cities, especially those in the South were not adhering to the ruling of Brown v. the Board of Education. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was “to enforce the constitutional right

Music of the Civil Rights Era

1289 words - 5 pages Civil Rights Movement and others argue that without his songs of protest and remorse, the cause of civil rights would have been better off without him and may have ended sooner without the constant reminder of an end in the back of the government’s head (Ward). However, everyone can agree that music had an important part in the movement forward of the Civil Rights cause, whether or not the bias be in the direction of a negative connotation or a

Rosa Parks: The Mother of Civil Rights

1158 words - 5 pages found guilty. Rosa Parks was sitting on a one of these buses on her way home from work when she was asked by the bus driver to get up from her seat so that a white man that had just entered the bus could sit down (“Refuses”). Parks refused to move from her seat, this action was not pre-meditated and was not part of any sort of plan that her civil rights group had planned out. Rosa was arrested immediately and convicted of breaking the bus code

Frederick Douglass: The Father of Civil Rights

2354 words - 10 pages In February 1818, Frederick Douglass, America’s most famous civil rights leader was born into one of the country’s most appalling institutions, slavery. He visualized a diverse nation without discrimination and hate. Frederick became one of the most well-known writers, lecturers and abolitionists. Above all, Frederick Douglass was dedicated to obtaining freedom and justice for all Americans, especially African Americans. Frederick Augustus

visual culture of civil rights movement

778 words - 4 pages derived from visual cues, does it not stand that attitudes towards race can be manipulated with a direct and strategic use of visual images? Civil rights activists often found themselves asking this question and it served to form the foundation of a visual culture intended to change the minds of a nation. Activist believed that the prevailing attitudes towards race during the civil rights movement could be altered with a strong and strategic

History of The Civil Rights Movement

1957 words - 8 pages live in poverty and unemployment while denying them the same rights as other Americans. Separate but equal would no longer be accepted. The period immediately following the Civil War is known as the Reconstruction Era. It lasted until about 1877. In 1866, Southern states adopted laws, known as Black Codes meant to ensure the South of not only a cheap labor force but also to restrict the Freedmen, the term used to describe the newly freed slaves

Similar Essays

"Dead Beat" Dads? Essay

1137 words - 5 pages transsexual or an autogynephilic transsexual. Autogynephilia is a term coined by Ray Blanchard and is defined as “inner-directed heterosexuality. That is, autogynephilic males are like heterosexual men, except that their primary sexual attraction is to the image or idea of themselves as women” (Bailey). The authors associate this condition with other paraphilias such as masochism. The authors argue that if you are not homosexual then you are most

History Of Civil Rights Essay

1601 words - 6 pages not always respected to all human beings, especially women and blacks. When the constitution was first written, many Americans understood the meaning of the famous inscripture "all men are created equal" to mean that all white males were created equal, likewise with other civil rights guarantees as well. As a result, blacks were enslaved, and women were persecuted throughout the late 1700's and early 1800's.During the 1850's abolitionists in the

History Of Civil Rights Essay

438 words - 2 pages 1776 -- Declaration of Independence, "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."13th Amendment in 1865 -- abolished slavery, but did not give blacks equality.Civil Rights Act of 1866 -- "all persons shall have the same make and enforce contracts, to sue, be parties, give evidence, and to the full and equal benefit of all laws..."14th

Chronology Of Civil Rights Movement Essay

1784 words - 7 pages all-black schools in the South punished and even expelled student protesters. The sheer success of student-led sit-ins, though, won blacks sympathy from many whites, an accomplishment that leaders such as King knew would be necessary in order to change the status quo.The Election of 1960Not surprisingly, civil rights became a major issue in the 1960 presidential campaign. Although Republican candidate Richard M. Nixon would not admit his support