This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Dead Man Walking V The Life Of David Gale Crestwood High School Compare And Contrast

1395 words - 6 pages

Ali Choucair
English 101
“In the end, the only way that we can measure the significance of our own lives is by valuing the lives of others.” “The life of David Gale”, and “Dead Man Walking”, are two films that have similarities and differences. Both men in the films are on death row and have a few days until their time expires, and one turns out to be innocent. The theme of both movies is about the two men receiving redemption and forgiveness among themselves and society.
In “The Life Of David Gale” the film introduces David Gale as a well known and intelligent professor at the University of Austin. David was advocated for the abolishment of capital punishment. David’s activist Constance Hallway, plays a big role throughout the film. David’s former student who later expelled set him up to having sex at a party when intoxicated and finds himself being accused of rape, however, he was also convicted for the murder of his colleague Constance. David’s life took a turn and he felt worthless and lonely. They figure to planned the death of Constance his fellow activist to prove people on death row of their innocents: “No one who looks through that glass sees a person, they see a crime.” As David was on his death row, he agreed to give reporter Bitsey Bloom, the exclusive story from him to hear his side of the story in hopes of preserving his memory for his family. Furthermore Bitsey had only three days to interview David, before David’s execution. Days before his death, David gives hints to Bitsey to help her get closer to unveiling the truth. On his last couple minutes Bitsey finds a tape that reveals the truth but comes with seconds short to save his life.
Matthew Poncelet, is on death row and is close to his execution date. He calls upon Sister Helen, who is a nun working and teaching in the New Orleans housing projects for high school dropouts. She has never dealt with anyone on death row. Matthew is corresponded with Sister Helen, she is willing to help him with one last appeal to maintain his innocency of the murders of a young couple. Sister Helen’s fire impression of Matthew is seen as an arrogant, sexist, and racist not even pretending to feel any kind of remorse of the couple. Sister Helen begins to form a bond with Matthew and she visits both his families and their relatives of the victims, in order to learn more about the case. The families of the victims despites the fact that she's standing aside the murder of their loved ones. As things began to look bleak for Matthew, Sister Helen does all that she can do to comfort and console the hardened convict. She's a strong believer of forgiving everyone. As she frequently visit him she builds a special relationship with him. On the day of Matthews execution, Sister Helen tells Matthew to take responsibility of his actions. That's the only way he will serve redemption.
Bitsey and Sister Helen both have several things in common. They both have impacted the men’s lives on death row. The...

Find Another Essay On Dead Man Walking v The Life of David Gale - Crestwood High School - Compare and Contrast

Compare and Contrast High School versus College

698 words - 3 pages silent crowd.      With so many students and so many faces in each class, college professors don’t personally get to know their students. A professor wouldn’t even notice if a student didn’t attend class one day, or if that person was taking that class at all. In big classes, the professor won’t even know a students’ name by the last day of class. In high school, teachers get to know their students on a first and last

Compare and Contrast High School versus College

1238 words - 5 pages Every student typically has a great high school career. Classes are not very difficult; AP courses are an exception. Student workload is minimal, obtaining good grades is not much of a struggle, and exams are typically easy to pass. Course load outside the class is no more then a few hours of homework each week. Teachers and faculty help facilitate a moderately laid back culture to learning. The school system supports students to make

Compare and Contrast "Frankenstein" and "The Dead"

1122 words - 4 pages Compare and Contrast "Frankenstein" and "The Dead"Reading contemporary novels and stories has been one of my passions since childhood. Throughout the years, I have changed the genre considerably, yet never ventured into classical authors until this semester. Unlike the contemporary books I've read, these classical works demand much more reader participation and involvement. Two examples of such demands of their readers can be found in Mary

Theme of Religion in "Dead Man Walking"

1161 words - 5 pages In everyday society, we are faced with diverse issues that force us to make a decision. Whether or not our decisions are right or wrong. In the movie “Dead Man Walking”, directed by Tim Robbins, he exemplifies the following actions throughout the film. Faith and doubt is a recurring theme in the course of the film. Where we see Christians, in essence, questioning their faith. We also notice a contradiction between the Christian bible and the

Dead Man Walking: The Death Penalty

1026 words - 4 pages I believe that the movie Dead Man Walking impacted my life greatly. It was a very emotional and moving movie. This was an excellent movie because it portrayed the feelings of both the families of the victims and the murder himself. It shows how much pain and suffering the families had to go through with all the sadness and hatred against Matthew Poncelant. The movie also showed how that the families' hatred did not go away after Matthew was

Dead Man Walking: Capital Punishment

1030 words - 4 pages I believe that the movie Dead Man Walking impacted my life greatly. It was a very emotional and moving movie. This was an excellent movie because it portrayed the feelings of both the families of the victims and the murder himself. It shows how much pain and suffering the families had to go through with all the sadness and hatred against Matthew Poncelant. The movie also showed how that the families' hatred did not go away after Matthew was

The Sanctuary of School and College Prepares People for Life - Compare and Contrast Essay

551 words - 3 pages English 112 Title: The Sanctuary of School by Linda Barry and College Prepares People for Life by Freeman Harboski; compare and contrast The two essays, “The Sanctuary of School,” by Linda Barry and “ College Prepares People for Life”; Freeman Hrabowski has similarities, both writers concerned with the education of students. Both essays imply that schools may not be doing enough to have students ready for life and college. They differ as

Compare And Contrast The Writings Of Confucius, Hammurabi, And The Book Of The Dead

715 words - 3 pages the penalties for the crimes are very stiff, but fair. I feel that it is fair that "If he has broken the limb of a patrician, his limb shall be broken" It's like in the Bible "An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth." In Egypt, in the Book of the Dead, a man couldn't proceed into the after life unless he was found innocent of any wrong doing on Earth. In Confucius' writings, he never actually says the word "justice", but he does say "Great Man

The Issue of Capital Punishment as in the film Dead Man Walking

1450 words - 6 pages innocent person has been executed. In the film "Dead Man Walking" specific arguments against Capital Punishment, taking into mind the crime committed, crop up. Matthew's partner in crime got a life sentence instead of a death penalty because he could afford a better lawyer. Leaders commonly use Capital Punishment to win votes. Also Matthew's Family was affected greatly, his younger brother was bullied at school following

Sister Helen Prejean's Dead Man Walking

1421 words - 6 pages Sister Helen Prejean's Dead Man Walking Dead Man Walking was an autobiography written by Sister Helen Prejean. The novel tells about Prejean's life in dealing with her intimate journey through her dealings with capital punishment. Prejean was a Roman Catholic nun that worked in St. Thomas. She worked in a New Orleans housing project for black residents. In January of 1982, Prejean was asked to be a pen pal with a death row inmate

Compare and Contrast essay Capitalism V. Communism

817 words - 3 pages As the feudal system in Europe began crumbling with the dawn of the Industrial Revolution a void was created in the European social and economic structure, Scottish philosopher Adam Smith took it upon himself to fill this void and in 1776 published The Wealth of Nations; just as Newton’s Principia Mathematica laid the foundation for modern physics so to did Adam’s work lay the foundation for modern economics. For the next 70 years Adam

Similar Essays

Dead Man Walking Essay

1100 words - 4 pages DEAD MAN WALKING      Dead Man Walking is a great book that deals with one of our nations most controversial issues: capital punishment. The books narrator, Sister Helen Prejean, discusses her personal views on capital punishment. She was a spiritual advisor and friend to two death row inmates; Elmo Patrick Sonnier and Robert Lee Willie. From her experiences, she developed views on the death penalty. She believed it

Dead Man Walking Essay

1006 words - 4 pages Dead Man Walking      The film “Dead Man Walking” is a film about redemption. The film is directed by Tim Robbins. Susan Sarandon plays a Nun called Sister Helen Prejean. She is asked by a convicted murderer to get him a lawyer, and then later is asked to be his spiritual advisor. The convicted killer is named Matthew Poncelet, and he is played by Sean Penn. The film is set in the Angola state penitentiary, in

Dead Man Walking Essay

1048 words - 4 pages People in society today have changed their feelings towards humanity and religious practises. This change is seen clearly in the movie "Dead Man Walking." The characters go through changes in their view of religion and their feelings about human morality and humanity towards each other. The characters of Sister Helen, Matthew, and the victims parents all went through these changes during the movie for different reasons. These emotional

Compare And Contrast High School Versus College

957 words - 4 pages college lectures is that I am no longer forced to listen. I pay the money, I make the decisions. In addition to the lectures, sports and a student’s social life are also different in college. Sports are either taken more serious or they are not. Even the social life of a student is subject to change. They could have been the most popular kid in high school and then come to college and have no one know them. “You have brains in your head. You