This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Death In Venice: Timeless Psychoanalysis Through Greek Allusions

1787 words - 7 pages

With the advent of film and the ability to produce visual representation of fictional (or non-fictional) characters, situations, and settings, one of the natural courses has been to adapt literary works to the new medium. Throughout time we have seen this occur endlessly, with subjectively varying results. Literature has been adapted to forms such as staged plays, live readings, as well as other visual forms, such as painting, sculpture, or photography, and in each adaption to a new medium, aspects of the tangible essence of the fiction are translated to fit its new form of expression. In Thomas Mann’s Death in Venice, the struggle of the novels protagonist Gustave Aschenbach reaches back to Greek Mythology via contemplations of emotion versus reason. In the novel, this is done using internal dialogues to vividly express the conflict that resides in humanity between instinctual and conditioned thought regarding beauty in the world, in Aschenbach’s own internal debates. However, in the translation to film, many of the internal dialogues must be represented visually, with different forms of symbolism that, while easily conveyed in text, are more difficult to embody in such an external and demonstrative medium. In this paper, I look to explore the references Thomas Mann made to Greek Mythology and their meanings, and how both are interpreted and in some cases changed in the translation to film.
To begin, we first must start with one of the concepts that often frame Death in Venice, the conflict between reason and emotion expressed in terms of two Greek gods, Apollo and Dionysus. In the novel, these gods are referenced symbolically throughout via the use of first person description, through subtle leads alluding to the mythology of these two entities. In the initial chapter, when Aschenbach notices the man who inspires his trip to Venice, much of the description centers around the exotic and/or unusual things, such as the Byzantine styling of the mortuary chapel or the “Greek crosses…hieratic motifs” (Mann 24) of the façade. At first, these just seem like exoticisms, placed to frame the man, as well as Mann/Aschenbach’s emotive swing. The fact that Aschenbach, who we learn in the second chapter has led a life of responsibility and a drive to achieve and avoid idleness (29) is suddenly swayed by the exoticism surrounding this man, and particularly the influence of the east, as “the version of the myth that Mann mainly adheres to, Dionysus came to Greece from India” (“The origin of Dionysus”).
In the film, we do not have this same scene, as a visual translation of this would be extremely difficult to convey, given it is mostly a dialogue within Aschenbach. The change in his attitude towards traveling, from that of “nothing more than a necessary health precaution” (26) to “not span the bow too far and willfully stifle a desire that had erupted with him with such vivid force” (27), displays the first step towards impulsive and emotional Dionysian...

Find Another Essay On Death in Venice: Timeless Psychoanalysis through Greek Allusions

Symbols, Symbolism and Irony in Thomas Mann's Death in Venice

2303 words - 9 pages : 1 Mythology summaries taken from 2 Othello, Act 2, Scene 1, lines 189-190 Works Cited: "Death in Venice," Thomas Mann, Michael Henry Heim (Translator) Publisher: Harper Perennial (May 31, 2005) Othello, Act 2, Scene 1, lines 189-190 Greek Mythology For Dummies

Closely Examines Shakespeare's Use of Classical Allusions to Violent Death in Hamlet

1710 words - 7 pages One of the most striking classical references in Hamlet is to the fall of Troy and the death of its king, Priam. Hamlet wishes the player to recite a speech he .".cheifly loved..." and recites the first thirteen lines for him. Within the first five lines of this speech the audience is bombarded with images of darkness, ."" . Hamlet describes .".Hellish Pyrrhus..." raging through

The art of decadence in the city of venice: Death In Venice

2455 words - 10 pages The premise of decadence was tremendously popular in late 19th century European literature. In addition, the degeneracy of the individual and society at large was represented in numerous contemporary works by Mann. In Death in Venice, the theme of decadence caused by aestheticism appears through Gustav von Achenbach’s eccentric, specifically homoerotic, feelings towards a Polish boy named Tadzio. Although his feelings spring from a sound

Death In Venice: The Power Of The Unconscious Mind

1003 words - 4 pages The Austrian psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud suggested that the powers motivating man and woman are that mainly of the unconscious. By the power of dreams, a person?s repressed mind comes out in the unconscious. Freud believed that actions in dreams are those that are not rationally accepted by the conscious mind, and therefore the unconscious mind acts as a censor. In Gustav von Aschenbach?s dreams in Death in Venice by Thomas Mann, his thoughts

Death In Venice - an disturbed artist's tragic vision

1017 words - 4 pages Death in Venice : a disturbed artist with a tragic visionAschenbach was certainly an artist. A very decent one. He had his life planned out, was very accurate and organized. Perhaps even a bit boring, monotonous. He was a hard-working man, he had that certain motus animi continuus. He was seen as a genius. From the beginning, he wanted to become known, to become famous, but his life was empty. He yearned for a change of pace, for some action

Essay on Death and Love in The Merchant of Venice

1686 words - 7 pages Death and Love in The Merchant of Venice        Everyone loves a martyr. He's that guy who not only suffered but died for his cause, his passion, his love. Bassanio may not be the most worthy cause to die for, but in Act IV of Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice, Antonio is resigned to do so. In his final words before Shylock is set to extract his pound of flesh, Antonio has abandoned efforts to prevent his punishment and assures Bassanio

Death and its Personofication in Greek Mythology and Other Cultures

2039 words - 9 pages universe, or does our body just appear wherever we are destined to be. The grim reaper is what many of us believe is the carrier between the two worlds and the keeper of our bodies. The Grim Reaper is known as the personification of death. He comes for every person, like an hourglass hand waiting for the last drop of sand to fall. Many remember him in a long black cloak, with a tall razor sharp blade wait to cut through to your soul. His skull

Essay on Art as a Reflection of Life in Death in Venice

1216 words - 5 pages Art as a Reflection of Life in Death in Venice     Death in Venice explores the relationship between an artist, namely Gustave von Aschenbach, and the world in which he lives. Aschenbach, destined to be an artist from a young age, represents art, while his surroundings represent life. As the story unfolds, Aschenbach endeavors on a journey in an attempt to relinquish his position in society as an artist. Aschenbach wants to experience

Essay on Relationship between Art and Life in Death in Venice

1416 words - 6 pages Relationship between Art and Life Explored in Death in Venice      The novella Death in Venice by Thomas Mann examines the nature of the relationship between art and life. The progression of the main character, Gustave Von Aschenbach, illustrates the concept of an Apollinian/Dionysian continuum. Apollo is the Greek god of art, thus something Apollinian places an emphasis on form. Dionysus is the Greek god of wine and chaos, hence something

How Is the Conflict between Rationality and Irrationality Developed in "Death in Venice?"

2636 words - 11 pages The purpose of this essay is to examine the conflict between rationality and irrationality in Death in Venice and to assess how this conflict is developed and possibly resolved. This conflict is fought and described throughout the short story with reference to ancient Greek gods, predominately Apollo and Dionysus and through the philosopher and philosophy of Plato. Through contemporary influences such as Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, Mann

Arising of Magic Realism Through Allusions to the Bible and Tragedians of the Greeks and Romans in Gabriel Garcia Marquez's 100 Years of Solitude

1368 words - 5 pages Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s novel, One Hundred Years of Solitude, is a novel often associated with magic realism. Throughout the novel, the idea of magic realism is promoted through intertext examples of The Bible. Magic realism is defined as an artistic style in which magical elements or irrational scenarios appear in an otherwise realistic or "normal" setting. The many intertextual examples throughout the work are alluded from outside

Similar Essays

Greek Mythology In Thomas Mann's Death In Venice

1401 words - 6 pages Thomas Mann alludes to Greek mythology throughout his novella Death in Venice. One of the Greek mythological themes alluded to in Death in Venice is the struggle known as Apollonian vs. Dionysion. Thomas Mann was strongly influenced by the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche and his teachings on the Apollonian vs. Dionysion struggle. According to Nietzsche’s teachings every individual contains characteristics from both Greek gods and the

Death In Venice: Symbolism, Opinions, Etc

2135 words - 9 pages the book, I didn't try mixing up my symbolism that came out when I read the short book the second time and tried to put connections from the beginning to the end, with the actual summary or plot of the book, which is what I got out of it the first time when I read the book, so I separated these two underlined thing with italics:'Death in Venice' by Thomas Mann, starts out with the main character, Aschenbach, on a morning after one of his struggling

Melville Shows Anger At Christianity Through Biblical Allusions In Moby Dick

1356 words - 5 pages ignorant when it comes to shipping and whaling. He only boards the Pequod to "gr[o]w merry again" in an attempt to add some adventure to his lackluster life (38). Throughout Moby Dick, the other sailors treat him as an outcast because of his lack of sea knowledge. Through it all, Ishmael displays unwavering faith when he downplays the dangers of whaling. When he says his “body is but the lees of my better being," he believes no physical harm can

The Triumph Of Disaster In Thomas Mann's Death In Venice

1971 words - 8 pages transfer through the extent of his writing arsenal. Like all celebrated authors, Mann displays his abilities as a writer in this classic. By applying them so they become imperative to the novel, Mann exploits his strengths well. One such adequacy in "Death in Venice" is displayed when, on the ship, Aschenbach is disgusted by the old man trying to defy time through a wig, false teeth, and rouge. Little did he know that he himself will soon come to