This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Death Of A Contradictory Salesman In The Ambiguous Birthday Party

1463 words - 6 pages

Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman is a realist play which criticizes modern society; Harold Pinter’s The Birthday Party is an absurdist play that examines human existence and language through deformed realism. There is apparently nothing common between the two plays; however, there is a similarity: contradiction and ambiguity are shown in the language of both plays. As I look into this issue, differences in the features and purposes of contradiction and ambiguity are found.
By contradiction and ambiguity, I mean that many details in the plays are contradicting according to different conversations in different scenes. As a result, no real happening can be obtained.
In Death of a Salesman, we cannot determine if Willy Loman was once a successful salesman or not. In Willy’s imaginary past, he described himself as a well-liked salesman who had opened up the market in New England. Later, when he talks with Howard, he claims that he averaged one hundred and seventy dollars a week in 1928, but Howard says that he never achieved that. Both of them are unreliable since Willy lives in dreams whereas Howard just wants to walk through the conversation, leaving an unclear answer to the question. Linda affirms Willy’s words by telling her sons that when Willy was young, his buyers were glad to see him and he was a pioneer of new territories for the company. Yet, her words are as well not trustworthy because Linda always backs up Willy’s fantasies. Just as she admits to Biff, she will do everything to keep Willy happy and bright.
There are even more equivocal points in The Birthday Party. As stated by Dukore (1962), “each piece of knowledge is a half-knowledge” (p. 44). McBride (2012) also observes that “the only truth of The Birthday Party is that there is no truth”. Although the play is titled “The Birthday Party”, we remain uncertain whether it is Stanley’s birthday or not even after we have finished reading. Meg determines that it is Stanley’s birthday and she is hiding the secret that it is his birthday from Stanley; she also insists that though Stanley denies it. Azizmohammadi and Kohzadi analyze that the distinct versions from different characters enable various interpretations (2011). Another example is the interrogation scene, in which Goldberg and McCann keep forcing accusations on Stanley, who appears to be ignorant of the charges. For example, when McCann asks why Stanley left the organization, Stanley seems to have no idea of what they are talking about. As they contend that Stanley has killed his wife, it seems that only Goldberg and McCann understand what has happened and Stanley doesn't even know that he had a wife. What’s more, readers know very little about the intruders Goldberg and McCann. It is implied that they come from an organization which is somehow linked to Stanley, but we are not informed the background of the constitution and the reasons for Stanley’s treatment. Neither can we get any clue of what they are going to do with...

Find Another Essay On Death of a contradictory salesman in the ambiguous birthday party

The Death of a Salesman Essay

1448 words - 6 pages , Death of a Salesman, Arthur Miller depicts the last days of a tired old salesman who throughout his life, believed that personality will make one successful. However, this salesman, who goes by the name of Willy Loman, was not granted happiness and fulfillment. These come from developing character. Thus, Willy’s failures as a businessman, husband, and father stem from his failure of character. In the Death of a Salesman, Willy’s failure as a

The death of a salesman Essay

775 words - 3 pages Linda, in contrast, displays little of the boisterous intensity of Willy. Rather, she is dependable and kind, perpetually attempting to smooth out conflicts that Willy might encounter. Linda has a similar longing for an idealized past, but has learned to suppress her dreams and her dissatisfaction with her husband and sons. Miller indicates that she is a woman with deep regrets about her life; she must continually reconcile her husband with her

The Character of Uncle Ben in Death of a Salesman

2588 words - 10 pages The Character of Uncle Ben in Death of a Salesman The character of Ben in Arthur Miller's Death of A Salesman serves a complex dramatic function.  He is Willy Loman's real brother, the idealized memory of that brother, and an aspect of Willy's own personality, and these distinct functions are sometimes simultaneous.  Through his aggressive actions and vibrant speech, the audience is given a strong contrast to Willy's self-doubt and self

The Power of Love in Death of a Salesman

1642 words - 7 pages The Power of Love in Death of a Salesman    Love is one of the most confusing emotions that one can experience. It is simple yet complicated, unconditional but demanding, overused and unique. It is hard to explain what its means to feel love, to feel loved, or to be in love, however, there are aspects of love that are easily expressed. For example, ones unquestionable affection to the one they love, or the hardships and sacrifice that

The Power of Women in Death of a Salesman

860 words - 3 pages In the play Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, there are several female characters. Linda Loman is a loyal and nurturing wife and mother and is the person who holds the family together. The other women in the play are wanton and pull the Loman family apart. Both types of women in the play hold a position of power over the pitiful men, whether it is as a matriarch or a whore. Willy, Biff, and Happy Loman all have a common weakness: lack of

Discuss the representation of masculinities in Death of a Salesman

1504 words - 6 pages IntroductionDeath of a Salesman reveals the story of an American man confronting failure in a success-driven society and shows the tragic path which eventually leads to his suicide. Willy Loman believes in what he considers the promise of the American Dream wholeheartedly, which is based on the Declaration of Independence stated by Thomas Jefferson in 1776: "We believe that all men are born with these inalienable rights - life, liberty and the

The American Dream Conspiracy in Death of a Salesman

1747 words - 7 pages Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman tells the story of the failure of a salesman, Willy Loman. Although not all Americans are salesmen, most of us share Willy’s dream of success. We are all partners in the American Dream and parties to the conspiracy of silence surrounding the fact that failures must outnumber successes.(Samantaray, 2014) Miller amalgamates the archetypal tragic hero with the mundane American citizen. The result is the anti

The American Dream in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

819 words - 3 pages The American Dream in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman The American Dream ~ for many, it is the unlocked door that leads to happiness.  It is the hope for a future filled with success and fortune.  Although most people have a similar idea of what the American Dream is, they may have different ideas on how to achieve it.  For Willy Loman, a struggling salesman, achieving this dream would be a major accomplishment.  Unfortunately, his

The Loman Sons in Death of a Salesman

869 words - 3 pages There is no such thing as a perfect life; everyone has conflicts that they must contend with. The ways in which people deal with these personal conflicts can differ as much as the people themselves. Some insist on ignoring the problem or live in denial for as long as possible, while others face up to the problem to get it out of the way. Arthur Miller' play "Death of a Salesman," centers around the Loman family's inability to perceive between

The American Dream in Death of a Salesman

2454 words - 10 pages from being a potential reality, into being a dream, like the name implies. Most of Miller´s plays are directly or indirectly about the American Dream, because ultimately this dream wasn´t going to succeed as lots of people wished. 'Death of a Salesman´ written in 1949, is a moving destruction of the whole myth. To be hard working, honest and have ambition were the ways of the American Dream. This lead onto success

Family Issues in the Play Death of a Salesman

1206 words - 5 pages The play, Death of a Salesman, is a tragic drama about an aging salesman who tries to do all he can to support his family and make them lead successful lives. The struggling salesman, Willy Loman has two sons, Biff and Happy, whom he tries to drive towards success. Willy believes that being well liked and making a good and lasting impression are the keys to success and tries to teach this philosophy to his two sons. Biff, being the favorite son

Similar Essays

The Automobile In Death Of A Salesman

1716 words - 7 pages The Automobile in Death of a Salesman        In modern society, most Americans own an automobile. In the wealthier households, a family of four may own as many as three to four automobiles, one for each driver living in the house. However, the automobile has not always been a staple of living in America.  In the 1940s, a family with an automobile was considered well-to-do, as well as wealthy and hard-working.  It is during this time period

The Mistress In Death Of A Salesman

619 words - 2 pages The Mistress in Death of a Salesman The mistress, sultry yet sophisticated, played a larger part in the play, Death of A Salesman, than most would imagine. While she does not make an appearance in the play, she does appear in Willy’s remembered time. During his daydreams, she is referred to as “the woman”. The woman in Death of A Salesman never appears in the play, but has a noteworthy presence because she affects the action, theme, and

Death Of A Salesman Why The Play Ends In Death

569 words - 2 pages Arthur Miller uses Willy and the characters around him to tell the story of a tragic hero, whose only flaw is his inability to question the validity of the American Dream. Willy is a common man whose conflicted, lonely and seemingly false character has been created with only one end, death. It is only through the story of his life, his denial, his struggle in attempting to gain his ‘rightful’ position in society, and finally his death that gives

The Death Of A Salesman Essay

1122 words - 4 pages Death of a Salesman: In the play, Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman: Willy Loman, a sympathetic salesman and despicable father who's "life is a casting off" has some traits that match Aristotle's views of a tragic hero. Willy's series of "ups and downs" is identical to Aristole's views of proper tragic figure; a king with flaws. His faulty personality, the financial struggles, and his inabiltity are three substantital flaws that contribute to