Death Penalty Fair, Just And Moral Essay

1094 words - 4 pages

The death penalty has been a controversial issue for many years. Its opponents provide numerous arguments in support of its abolition. Fundamentally, they contend that capital punishment is a racist, immoral act that is nothing more than a legal murder (Sharp par 1-4). In my opinion their statements are either word games or powerful claims that are wrongly accepted as fact. In this paper I will critically evaluate the arguments presented by those that oppose the death penalty. I contend that their arguments either overlook the facts or simply present them in a negative manner.There is a common argument that death penalty is racist, only punishes the poor and, therefore, is applied unfairly. This argument is logically flawed. Those that perpetuate it are arguably asserting that if the death penalty were imposed fairly it would be acceptable. Consequently, this argument is lends support more to improvement of the justice system than abolition of the death penalty. Now, suppose that this argument is in fact about the racism in death penalty. Please note, however, that "statistical analysis demonstrates no consensus that wealthy capital murders are less likely to be executed than their poorer ilk". In fact, statistics indicate that "wealthy capital murderers may be more likely to be executed" (Sharp par 39); demonstrating that a murderer's social class is not determinative of their likelihood to be executed. . Furthermore in regards to the racist aspect of the argument, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People Legal Defense Fund (NAACP LDF ) has shown that "the majority of those on death row are white"(Sharp par 39). The argument that the death penalty is racist or unfair is easily refuted. It is a logically flawed argument lacking factual substantiation.The next common argument is that death penalty is a legalized murder. Citizens United for Alternatives to Death Penalty (CUADP), an anti-death penalty lobby group asserts: "We kill people to show that killing people is wrong" (CUADP par 5). This slogan carries a message that may seem very convincing. However, it is only an example of the frequently used word games mentioned earlier. The slogan misses a very important point that the words kill, murder and execute are not interchangeable.One can kill someone in self-defense - that is killing, but not murder. Murder is "the unlawful and malicious or premeditated killing of one human being by another". When using the correct words the slogan changes to "We execute people to show that murder is wrong". It does not sound as catchy but it is much more truthful, warning that those who commit murder will be executed. Analogously, execution is not a murder, but a punishment. It is the punishment of a criminal who committed murder and in doing so intentionally and maliciously robbed another human being of his or her life (Carmical par 2). Using the wrong words to describe the death penalty may make it seem cruel and hypocritical, but when...

Find Another Essay On Death Penalty-Fair, Just and Moral

The Death Penalty: Just Punishment Or Murder

3173 words - 13 pages The Death Penalty: PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 The Death Penalty: Just Punishment or MurderJules ThompsonAshford UniversityCrime and SocietySOC 305Patrick NorrisNovember 29, 2009The Death Penalty: Just Punishment or MurderOne of the most debated topics in America today is how society should deal with the persons who commit the most violent, offensive and heinous crimes against society. Historically the punishment for these crimes was death. This

Just Say No to the Death Penalty

1350 words - 6 pages extra $1.6 billion on capital trials between 1982 and 1997. The states of New Jersey and New York have gotten rid of the death penalty altogether. New Jersey spent $253 million dollars over a twenty five year period and never executed a single inmate (deathpenaltyinfo.org). New York spent $170 million over a course of just a nine year period and also had zero executions (deathpenaltyinfo, reports). Both states came to realize the death penalty

The Death Penalty: A Just Method of Punishment

2100 words - 8 pages the fact that the majority of society agrees that the death penalty is a just and fair way to punish convicted murderers. The death penalty is justifiable because it deters crime and coincides with the justice system's belief that the punishment should fit the crime. The death penalty deters crime by executing criminals who committed heinous crimes and uses them as an example to others who would also commit heinous crimes. Prison time can deter

A Fair and Just Sentence

5315 words - 21 pages A Fair and Just Sentence Both detectives held a gun, but neither of them could shoot at Richards. The gunman was hiding closely behind his hostage and exposing little of his body to them. Smith knew he couldn't risk a shot. There were too many people in the tavern, and most of them were behind Richards. He might hit one of them if he missed the gunman. And he probably would miss. The target being offered to him was much too small. Smith

Death Penalty and Deterrence

3489 words - 14 pages Death Penalty and Deterrence Ever since the beginning of time man has committed crimes. Crimes were described as acts which go against the social and moral norms of society and people. People have learned to deal with these crimes in many different ways. One of the most used forms of dealing with crime is punishing those who commit crimes. There are numerous ways in which people have punished those who commit crimes throughout history from

Death Penalty And Discrimination

1644 words - 7 pages hire a lawyer to represent them at their trial (Cook 23). People are being executed not because of the heinousness of their crime, but because of the incompetence of their lawyers.Throughout the history of our nation the death sentence has been allowed to pass as a deterrent, just, protective, and fair way to punish those who disobey the law. But the true, discriminating, unjust, and unfair reality of this punishment has never been recognized. There

Death Penalty and Morality

2260 words - 9 pages DEATH PENALT AND MORALITYCapital Punishment is the legal infliction of thedeath penalty. In the United States capitalpunishment is legal in thirty-nine of the fiftystates. Beginning in 1973, prison populations beganan inevitable growth. There were 204,211 inmates in1973, and by 1977 the number of prisoners had grown to285,456, which later grew to 315,974 in 1980. By1976, it was clear that the death penalty had to bereinstated. America's twenty

Death Penalty: Pros and Cons

1025 words - 4 pages Capital punishment has been the center of much controversy dating back to its origins. Although the roots of capital punishment can be traced as far back as 1697 BC, arguments over its effectiveness and morality continue in the midst of its existence today. There are many people who have come up with arguments for both sides. Most people who believe that the death penalty is a fair punishment use the argument, "lex talionis", meaning, "an eye

Children And The Death Penalty

1359 words - 5 pages the families and loved ones of the victims. But the use of the death penalty is a denial of the right to life and the right not to be subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment, basic rights to which all human beings are entitled, No matter who they are or what they have done. There is an overwhelming international legal and moral consensus against any nation executing juvenile offenders. However heinous the crime, the sentencing to

Minors and the Death Penalty

985 words - 4 pages A.     Should the death penalty be given to minors? The two groups against this issue, are the religious and medical groups. They believe they are too young to know what they have done. The medical groups believe adolescents are less developed than adults and should not be held to the same standards. . The opposing side, held mostly by state officials, feel if they are old enough to commit the crime they, old enough to

The Death Penalty and Juveniles

796 words - 3 pages be treated with the same consequences.Some people think the death penalty is too high a price to pay for a juvenile who is just going through adolescence and who does not have the full mental capacity required to understand the punishment associated with committing a crime. Anti-death penalty types think that the death penalty is too cruel and inhumane a punishment for a juvenile that has committed a very cruel and inhumane crime, like murder, to

Similar Essays

Fair Punishment And The Death Penalty

908 words - 4 pages Fair Punishment and the Death Penalty 94 federal attorneys have the power to submit a case to Janet Reno (Willing 3A). These attorneys seek the death penalty for these cases, and why should they not? Whys should one who has taken a life, or even several, deserve the air that they breathe? Capital punishment is a harsh punishment created for people who have committed harsh crimes. The death penalty should be used to punish violent

Just Punishment? The Death Penalty Essay

2211 words - 9 pages The death penalty is a just punishment for the horrific crimes that are committed in today's society. Today's criminals knowingly kill the innocent and should receive the appropriate punishment. Sadly, people have become numb to the daily bombardment of these heinous murders that seemingly take place on a daily basis, still the death penalty is supported by a large majority of Americans. The facts and fallacies are continually debated by both

Death Penalty: Why It Is Moral And Humane

691 words - 3 pages The Death PenaltyFor several decades the death penalty has been a litigious issue. Numerous intellectuals as well as the general public often debate the morality of capital punishment and whether or not it should be legal. The death penalty should be legal because of the theory of "an eye for an eye", how it helps in reducing murders, and the fact that the death penalty is not inhumane.Though there is no question in many minds of American

The Death Penalty Just Punishment For Murder

1148 words - 5 pages The Death Penalty - Just Punishment for Murder Essay has Problems with Format The death penalty has always been and continues to be a very controversial issue. People on both sides of the issue argue endlessly to gain further support for their movements. While opponents of capital punishment are quick to point out that the United States remains one of the few Western countries that continue to support the death penalty, Americans are also