Death Penalty In America With Graphs And Stuff Geog 222 University Of Arizona Essay

1265 words - 6 pages

Kyle Leuer
GEOG 222
Assignment 4
The Ineffectiveness of Capital Punishment
When analyzing whether or not the death penalty is an effective punishment for hardened criminals, you must look to both the financial and social cost. It is easy to calculate the financial cost but much more difficult to quantitatively equate the social cost. In this paper I will present the arguments for and against the use of capital punishment and present a means of measuring the deterrent effect of the death penalty.
The death penalty is the highest degree of punishment that can be applied in a criminal case. Some believe that execution violates our basic rights and is an inhumane practice that needs to be discontinued. According to the Legal Information Institute of Cornell, “The U.S. Supreme Court has determined that a penalty must be proportional to the crime; otherwise, the punishment violates the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition against cruel and unusual punishments” (Death Penalty). The use of execution is supposed to be reserved for only the most heinous of crimes so that the punishment is proportionate to the crime. Unfortunately, there are many cases where the crime did not match the punishment and offenders had their eighth amendment violated. Historically a large number of the cases that violated constitutional rights took place in the south.
As you can easily see in Fig. 1 most executions going all the way back to 1977 have predominately taken place in the south. From the article titled Still Unfair, Still Arbitrary-But Do We Care? Samuel Gross states that “the death penalty for rape was essentially reserved for black men who were convicted of raping white women in southern states” (Gross, 518). The racial motivation for applying punishment superseded the defendants right to a punishment that was equal to that of their crime. Racially motivated sentencing has been a key arguing point for those that oppose the death penalty. From a study written about the death penalty system of Connecticut, by John J. Donohue, it is said that minority defendants within the city of Waterbury, Connecticut that were charged with killing multiple white victims were 91.2 percent likely to be sentenced to death, whereas white on white murderer only faced a .57 percent chance. “In other words, the minority defendant in Waterbury would be 160 times more likely to get a sustained death sentence than the comparable white defendant in the rest of the state” (Donohue, 1). This case not only shows the racial disparity but also the unequal application of capital punishment based on geography.
Perhaps the most common argument used in favor of the death penalty is its effectiveness as a deterrent for criminal behavior. Below I have included a chart from the Death Penalty Information Center that shows the rate of murder in states with and without capital Punishment. It is easy to see that states without capital punishment have consistently had lower murder rates when...

Find Another Essay On Death penalty in america with graphs and stuff - Geog 222 University of Arizona - essay

America Needs the Death Penalty Essay

1223 words - 5 pages In 1973 Author Shawcross was convicted of raping and murdering two children in upstate New York; however, after serving 15 years Shawcross was paroled in 1988. In a horrific 21-month killing spree, Shawcross took 11 more lives. That is 11 innocent people who would be alive today had justice been served (Pataki, Deterrent 2). With the topic of the death penalty comes a lot of controversy which is rooted from questions like: is the death

The Death Penalty Should be Abolished in America

1227 words - 5 pages permanent. Beccaria’s essay acted as the chief catalyst behind the widespread abolition movement against the death penalty. Currently, the debate over capital punishment rages on with fervor on both ends. Those in favor of capital punishment find it necessary in deterring future murders, punishing murders, and bringing closure to victims. Although their argument seems of sound mind however, after close analysis of history and statistical data, the

America Needs a Tougher Death Penalty

1067 words - 4 pages America Needs a Tougher Death Penalty   Pain. Anger. Frustration. Hatred. These feeble words do not describe the anguish felt by the families of murder victims. Ted Bundy was responsible for the deaths of more than 50 young women across the United States.(Lamar 34) Bundy was finally sentenced to death by the state of Florida in 1978 for the kidnapping and brutal murder of a 12 year old girl and the deaths of 2 Florida State sorority

Death Penalty Annotated Bibliograpy - Texas A&M University Corpus Christi, English 1301 - Essay

1972 words - 8 pages University of Denver Sturm College. She was formerly a law clerk in a Colorado state district court, which helped her tremendously with her research to write this article. I believe that the motivation for this article was to make the Colorado government rethink the decision to allow the death penalty to be used, because typically it is used more on a certain race and people are constantly saying that it is a racial issue not just a political issue

The Death Penalty in America: Who is More Apt To Support It

2431 words - 10 pages . (2003) shows that members of faiths that express a more authoritarian and individualist values will tend to have higher support for the death penalty.In addition to gender, race, and religious affiliation a person's level of education has an impact on their position on the death penalty. According to Warr (1984), the study found that 68% of respondents with low levels of education were in favor of the death penalty as punishment, when

Argument Essay in favor of abolishing the death penalty with lists "Reasons For Abolishing the Death Penalty"

4046 words - 16 pages Reasons for Abolishing the Death Penalty by Nanette FlemingThere are many things that I don't agree with in today's society, but out of all the wrong doings that take place, I believe the death penalty is the worst of them all. I am strongly against the death penalty because it violates God's rules, costs the tax payers too much money, prisoners could be wrongly convicted, and it is cruel and unusual punishment.The first reason why I do not

This essay discusses the two opposing viewpoints of death penalty with its pros and cons. It also gives some facts about people dieing from the death penalty

575 words - 2 pages were marrying a Jew, not confessing to a crime, and treason. By the 1700s, 222 crimes were punishable by death in Britain. It was the country that influenced America to use the death penalty more than any other country. There are currently 38 states in the U.S. with the death penalty. The most common crime is first-degree murder.Death penalties come at a high price. In Texas, a death penalty case costs taxpayer an average of $2.3 million, which is

Critical analysis of whitewashing paper - brock university geog 2p01 - critical essay

1419 words - 6 pages Running Head: CRITICAL PAPER 2 6 Running Head: CRITICAL PAPER 2 GEOG 2P01: Critical Paper #2 Alexander Nahorny (5885454) Dr. Catherine Nash Seminar 5 March 22, 2018 The academic article in which I have chosen to re-read more critically and further examine is, Uncovering the white place: whitewashing at work (Reitman, 2006). The article and study was done by Dr. Meredith Reitman, from the Department of Geography at the University of Wisconsin

Ending the Death Penalty Basic Argument Essay in favor of ending the death penalty

443 words - 2 pages the individual has been convicted of, is a mortal sin. I believe that religious beliefs, such as the Ten Commandments, are the corner stone for our law system.Also, there is the fact that tax payers waste too much of their money with the death penalty in place. The average death penalty case is appealed three times. This means that the tax payers must pay for the same trial to be heard three times. This is a very expensive practice. Why spend the

Dancing With Death Penalty

785 words - 4 pages required to publicly reveal the drugs and methods to be used to carry out the execution (Richey1). If felons were put in prison there would be no need for state correction officials to reveal all of that information because the drugs and methods would not be used to begin with. Lawyers of death row inmates say they must know this information so that they can adequately protect their clients form unnecessary pain and suffering during state

Essay on Chipotle and its Economics - Complete with graphs, statistics.. etc

2209 words - 9 pages is to be thorough, but brief. It is not a full-blown market or product analysis.There is a late penalty for each day that the project is late. Two percent of the total points possible from the project are deducted for each class day that the project is late. Time is a scarce commodity at the end of the semester. This penalty helps ensure that projects are turned in with sufficient time to be read and graded before the end of the semester.For the

Similar Essays

The Death Penalty In America Essay

2208 words - 9 pages many states and even countries. When you compare opinions on this issue between, for example, Michigan and Texas, or countries such as the United States and France, you will find that there are many reasons why the death penalty is considered a necessary evil in some places and outright evil in others. One of the most glaring differences between nations and states with and without the death penalty is the political ideologies that are most

An Analysis Of The Death Penalty Controversy In America

1848 words - 7 pages Capital punishment, the lawful taking of a person's life after conviction of a crime, is a highly controversial issue. It has raised difficult ethical, practical, and legal debates. In most of the industrialized world, the death penalty is outlawed and is no longer an issue of concern. However, it is still used in the United States. At present, the U.S. government and 38 states allow the death penalty. Methods of execution include lethal

The Death Penalty: Methods Of Execution In America

1929 words - 8 pages Crime in America is something that has been around for many decades. While a large number of crimes are considered minor, many more result in the serious injury or death of another human being. “When we think about crimes, we … normally focus on inherently wrongful acts that harm or threaten to harm persons or property” (Bibas 22). The death penalty, also called capital punishment, has been used as a means of punishing the most violent of

America Needs The Death Penalty Essay

839 words - 3 pages pretends to Lily Burk a sophomore student; she was killed by a parolee at seventeen years of age. In 2009 parolee Charlie Samuel, 50 years old was charged with robbery, abduction, and slaying (Parolee to Stand Trial in Lily Burk’s Murder). The death penalty gives closure to the victim’s families. Countless families can be accounted for watching the convicted murdered put to death. The sense of relief is priceless, and knowing that no one else