This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Debate On Gene Therapy Essay

1067 words - 4 pages

Genes are made of DNA – the code of life (Gene Therapy- The Great Debate!). The changes in genes may cause serious problems, which we called genetic disorder. In theory, the only method to cure genetic disorders is gene therapy, which basically means the replacement of genes in order to correct the loss or change in people’s DNA. Although gene therapy gives patients with genetic disorders a permanent cure, it is controversial because it has safety and efficacy problems, and raises ethical issues.

Gene therapy enables patients to survive incurable diseases. In the field of genetic diseases, ADA-SCID, CGD and hemophilia are three main ones. ADA-SCID is known as the bubble boy disease. CGD is related to immune system that would lead to fungal infections which are fatal. Patients with Hemophilia are not able to induce bold bleeding (Gene therapy for diseases, 2011). Gene therapy also has good effects on cancer treatment and neurodegenerative diseases, which include Parkinson’s disease and Huntington’s disease. Viral infections, including influenza, HIV and hepatitis can also be treats by it (Gene therapy for diseases, 2011). According to the Science Daily in 2011, gene therapy now can apply to heart failures and neurologic diseases as well.
Gene therapy gives patients who born with diseases that are incurable to traditional medicine a permanent cure. If patients received germ-line therapy, which involves replacing disordered genes in sperms or eggs, their offspring would also have correct gene orders. The positive effect would influence the whole family.

However, the safety of gene therapy should be carefully considered. First, it may cause angiogenesis, which may trigger nonfunctional vessels or stimulation of angiogenesis in tumors (Safety Issues with Gene Therapy). Second, gene therapy often uses viral vectors to carry the correct genes. The viral vectors insert foreign DNA into host genome and it may lead to gene silencing or even tumor development (Safety Issues with Gene Therapy). Moreover, immature technology may insert viral vectors into wrong place and it would trigger unpredictable results, like tumor or gene mutation. (Rocholl, B.)

The efficacy of gene therapy should also be questioned. Despite being very expensive, gene therapy may not work because of the immature technology. People’s own immune system may have rejection and it may cause the failure of gene therapy or make viruses fail to express themselves (Bergeson, E., 1997). For example, a virus used in treatment of cystic fibrosis produced an inflammatory response. (Rocholl, B) Moreover, cells divide infrequently and the replacing genes in gene therapy may insert into cells that are dividing, which cause the failure of gene therapy. (Rocholl, B)

The heated discussions of gene therapy focus on its ethical problems. Before performing gene therapy, a gene test is required. Doctors need to test or screen the whole DNA to ensure the disordered gene. However, this process is...

Find Another Essay On Debate on Gene Therapy

Position Paper: Gene Therapy in Humans

1726 words - 7 pages in the field every day. The topic of gene therapy in humans is one that is highly debated due to the ethical implications connected to the science. Both sides of the debate have various reasons for their position, but the main factors come down to the ethics of changing someone’s genome and the consequences that accompany the altercations. The two types of gene therapy, somatic and germ-line are seen in different lights. There is more debate over

The Ethical Controversy of Gene Therapy

1623 words - 6 pages somatic cells but it will not pass to his off-spring. Thus it doesn’t change the original genetic structure of that individual. Public debate over the ethics of using gene therapy began after the research of the recombinant DNA technology started in 1960. Many felt that somatic cell gene therapy is merely an extension of conventional therapies posing few ethical problems. Some gene therapies introduce novel ways to produce medical which are now

A Look at Gene Therapy

1697 words - 7 pages Would you consider altering your DNA if it could save your life? Scientist have been working on gene therapy since the 1970's, this biotechnological form of medicine is the attempt to medically modify cells to help eliminate or prevent diseases by correcting defective genes. Imagine the possibilities of having your DNA tested for heritable diseases and being able to eliminate such diseases from your future. From 1990-2003 the Department of

Gene Therapy and Genetic Disorders

1397 words - 6 pages . Genetic gene therapy considered for use on embryos to be implanted via in-vitro fertilization has been one of the most controversial issues. If an embryo is deemed “imperfect” by a scientist, doctor or parent, are we again putting man in a position to play “God” and dispose of an embryo and simply replace it with another with more positive attributes? The definition of imperfect is very

Gene Therapy

1035 words - 5 pages Gene therapy. These words to some seem frightening and new, but make no mistake, research has shown that gene therapy used on terrible diseases such a cystic fibrosis provide promising results to finding cures in the future (“How Does Gene Therapy Work?”). Cystic fibrosis is a terrifying hereditary condition that affects a person’s endocrine gland causing thick mucus to block one’s bronchi, pancreatic ducts, and intestines (About Cystic

Gene Therapy

1676 words - 7 pages as to whether or not it is ethical to continue the advancement of gene therapy.Those in opposition of gene therapy, on the other hand, support strong arguments that make the technology such a controversial debate. One major discussion of debate is that the use of gene therapy may lead to the development of superior human beings that may, like in some sort of science fiction movie, take over the world. It is likely that the misuse of gene therapy

The Pros and Cons of Gene Therapy

2200 words - 9 pages the faulty genes of normal body cells. Germ line therapy is altering genes in gametes. Everyone on earth carries a few defective genes. Most of us are unaware of this fact however, unless we are afflicted with a genetic disease. Approximately one in ten people have, or will develop, a disease that is a direct result of faulty genes. (www.ghr.nlm.nih.gov/handbook/therapy/genetherapy) The possible future uses for gene therapy are seemingly endless

Human Gene Therapy

1901 words - 8 pages therapy would be a permanent treatment and change in the body rather than requiring repeated applications of an outside force or substance (Nichols, 1988). Germ line gene therapy, where genetic changes would be passed on deliberately to future generation, have caused more of a debate. Leroy Walters, director of the Center for bioethics at Georgetown University, explains that there would be two basic rationales for using germ line gene therapy

Gene Therapy

1121 words - 4 pages safer Drug therapy is a known and tried method. Although tis not offering the possibility of a cure it is thought of as being safer. There is no guarantee that the healthy gene will end up in its intended place. With this said there is a risk that could cause even more damage to the genetic make-up, which could cause severe consequences for the patient. HOW DOES IT IMPACT ON: INDIVIDUALS? SOCIETY? SCIENCE COMMUNITY? INDIVIDUALS: For the

he Ethical Effects of Modern Biotechnology: Genetically Modified Organisms and Human Engineering

1150 words - 5 pages the use of the same treatments for minute problems becomes a larger ethical debate. Critics fear that people may begin to use gene therapy treatments to help combat issues such as eyesight or obesity. They fear that they may even stretch to problems such as character or physical appearance. The most dangerous agreement is that if everyone uses gene therapy to produce the most desirable characteristics humans could experience a loss of genetic

Gene Therapy Saves Lives

1995 words - 8 pages combined immunodeficiency, or SCID. The disease lacks a gene in charge of the body's immune system called adenosine deaminase. Tim could be helped through a process called gene therapy, but he won't because there is too much debate on the ethnicity of gene therapy; too much even to save his life.       The use of gene therapy to prevent illness and disease by changing a person's genetic makeup is a good use of science. Gene therapy is an

Similar Essays

The Debate Over Gene Therapy Essay

850 words - 3 pages developed leukemia after two years of experimental gene therapy in London Hospital, UK. The techniques still have some drawbacks because gene therapy is a rather developing remedy. Four out of ten patients with SCID in France were found that there was a defect on chromosome which leaded to the development of leukemia. Through the study, it is found that the curative gene which was inserted into patients’ blood stem cells turned on a cancer gene

Gene Therapy And Its Effect On Cancer

3602 words - 14 pages Gene Therapy and Its Effect on Cancer The era of scientific advancement in the twentieth century has encouraged several scientific fields to merge into a new, futuristic science called Biotechnology. One idea behind Biotechnical science is taking advantage of molecular biology. At the forefront of this advancement is gene therapy which " attempts to treat disease at its origin on the molecular level"(Kreeger,1996). "Essentially, this

Accounting 100 Essay

1240 words - 5 pages continued receiving traditional drug therapy made it difficult to determine the true efficiency of the gene therapy on its own.As the function of many genes continue to be discovered it may be increasingly difficult to define which gene traits are considered to be diseases versus those that should be classified as physical and mental or psychological traits. Unfortunately, the distinction between gene therapies for diseases enhanced by the desired

The Potential Power Of Gene Therapy

1736 words - 7 pages will not allow the patients to incur potential harm on themselves knowingly or inadvertently (596). Figure Gene therapy used to cure immunological disorder The major ethical controversy is whether to alter the natural human genetic structure. Many researchers have been successful in curing both genetic and non-genetic diseases by altering the somatic cells of the individual. This type of therapy has been readily