This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Debate Paper

966 words - 4 pages

Summary:
Maggie Gallagher, an author, journalist, and Yale graduate, supports the affirmative case that same-sex marriage will hurt America. Jonathan Rauch, an author on gay marriage and a Yale graduate, supports the negative case. Both Jonathan and Maggie agree that same sex-marriage will contribute an important change to marriage, and that marriage is in serious trouble in America. Maggie claims that the change that same-sex marriage will have on marriage will have a negative effect, on the other hand Jonathan advocates that same-sex marriage will have a positive effect on marriage.
Gallagher begins her argument by stating that gay marriage divides into two sides. One side is that gay ...view middle of the document...

Rauch argues that if two people love each other they should be allowed to be married. He says the fundamental principle for marriage is a proposal, which makes you responsible for another human being, is does not matter if you are a same-sex or different-sex couples.
Rauch gives three reasons why same-sex marriage should be allowed: same-sex couples already live together, marriage will not be a discriminative government program, and since all men are created equally then same-sex couples should be treated the same as different-sex couples. He claims that the government cannot stop same-sex couples from living together, and that marriage would just legalize their marriage. His argument concerning a discriminative government is, why should the government have any right to dictate who gets married and who cannot. Finally Rauch believes that his last argument, that all men are created equal, says that this follows the golden rule, treat others as you would treat yourself. Rauch claims that if different-sex couples do not want to give up their marriages they should not require same-sex couples to give up their marriages. He says that do not give anyone else a standard that you would not give yourself.
Response:
Gallagher makes a better case, because she answered all of the questions thrown at her and asked Rauch very good questions. On the other hand, Rauch asked some good questions but he did not answer all of Gallagher’s questions. But one of the questions was hard to give to one side was the question of who does marriage benefit the children or the adults? Gallagher believes that marriage is supposed good for the children. She says that children...

Find Another Essay On Debate Paper

A Theoretical and Historical Comparison Debate Paper on the Beliefs and Perceptions

894 words - 4 pages In the article "Neo-Paganism and Witchcraft" by Carol Matthews, she explores the definition and what constitutes Neopaganism, as well as how it is not a sole religion but many. Neopaganism is "a spiritual orientation" (Matthews 339) that uses a variety of ritual practices that have been taken from mythology and "pre-Christian rites, primarily from an ancient Mediterranean source" (Matthews 339). With the use of many techniques such as prayers and

This paper argues pro-legalization for the incessant marijuana debate. It includes statistics, quotes from doctors, and facts to back up the positive effects of the use of marijuana

1119 words - 4 pages Obviously the current drug policy of our government today is fails to be effective. Drug laws have been a main cause for the increase of street crime, corruption, violence, and disrespect for the criminal justice system. We see stories on the news about people being killed on the street every day over drugs. To many people drugs are only an inner-city problem, but in reality they affect all of us users and non-users. I believe that the negative

Tupac Dead or Alive. This paper is focused on the large debate over whether the popular rap artist had faked his own death or if he truly was murdered

1890 words - 8 pages IntroductionIt's now the year 2001. The year 2002 approaches fast. For Tupac fans, it means much more than just a new year. To the die-hard Tupac fans it means one more year until the long awaited resurrection. However, to other Tupac fans it just means another year has passed since his death.Tupac has brought his fans together with his music, poetry and acting. But this dead or alive dilemma has split these fans into two groups. Those who

Commercialization Of Gametes. This Paper Describes The Debate About Women Selling Their Eggs (Gametes) For Money. It Includes Many Points About Why One Would Be Against Such A Practice

601 words - 3 pages "Commercialization of Gametes""Brainy Beauties Finance College by Selling Their Eggs" is the headline of one Internet source taken from a bulletin board at a prestigious college. College students are being offered thousands of dollars to donate eggs to infertile couples due to their brains and beauty. Some women are making this procedure, which can be extremely painful, a habit in order to finance their college education. Some people, especially

Immunization Debate

878 words - 4 pages many studies conducting to show whether it can trigger serious reactions and disorders. In 1998, Andrew Wakefield published an observation of 12 children that linked the measles, mumps, and rubella combination vaccine with intestinal problems which he believed led to autism. Once people heard this news, they become alarmed. However, many large studies had been conducted and found no association between the two so Dr. Wakefield’s original paper

The Canadian Flag Debate

1318 words - 5 pages , "It seems that every Canadian with a pot of paint, a piece of paper and artistic pretensions sat down to draw a flag." The next day he said that the Parliamentary mail rooms were just built up with drawings for a possible design of the new Canadian Flag. In Canada it surely showed that many Canadians were eager to help out in the great Canadian flag debate and to prove to Canada that they were willing to help out whenever needed.The Canadian flag

Health Policy Debate

854 words - 4 pages In this paper will discuss the health care policy debate by explaining the current health policy debate regarding the Affordable Care Act. This paper will showcase the values, markets, and morals as well as the fairness and availability of care. It will look at who wins and who loses and discuss equity, efficiency, and effectiveness. Lastly, this paper will show my own experiences and opinions of the healthcare debate and where I stand on the

The Sweatshop Debate

1088 words - 4 pages NIKE: THE SWEATSHOP DEBATE1Nike: The Sweatshop DebateMGT/448Date: November 25, 2014IntroductionThis paper is about a case study entitled: "Nike: The Sweatshop Debate." Legal, cultural, and ethical challenges that confront Nike's global business will be described. In addition, various roles that host governments have played in the debate will be determined and a summary of the strategic and operational challenges facing global managers for the

The Vaccination-Autism Debate

1456 words - 6 pages Before the rise of the vaccination-autism debate in 1988, the safety of the MMR vaccine was put in doubt because of its negative effects related to Urabe mumps stress that would result to meningitis. A case had been presented before a court in Britain in the 1980s indicating that the MMR vaccine caused Urabe mumps strain. The adverse reactions of the MMR vaccines was brought before the American and the Canadian authorities because of the reports

Marijuana: The Great Debate

2697 words - 11 pages Marijuana. Detroit: Greenhaven Press. (Reprinted from Position Paper in Support of the New Jersey Compassionate Use Medical Marijuana Act, 2009) Retrieved from http://ic.galegroup.com.byui.idm.oclc.org/ Golan, G. J. (2010). Editorials, Op-ed Columns Frame Medical Marijuana Debate. Newspaper Research Journal, 31(3), 50-61. Grinspoon, L. (2009). Marijuana is beneficial. In A. Gillard (Ed.), At Issue. Marijuana. Detroit: Greenhaven Press. (Reprinted

Technology Debate in Education

1134 words - 5 pages Debate in Education Gruszczynska, Guy and Richard (p.203) define digital media as an electronic media which serves as the current form of data storage, whereby the data itself is stored in digital form. Digital media refers to the transmission and storage technical aspect of any information or rather to the “end product. When someone talks of end product he is referring to the final product yielded from these digital forms of storage or

Similar Essays

Martial Law Debate Paper

681 words - 3 pages Name: Randelle Adano Frances Ong Katherine Ong CN:#1 #22 #23 NEGATIVE Section: Grade 8- Commitment Date Submitted: This house will reinstate martial law to promote order and discipline in the Philippines. I. Argument (CLAIM) Martial Law will not promulgate peace and order in the Philippines. II. Evidence (EXAMPLE) The World Bank's estimated that a fraction of people living in poverty has increased 24% in 1974 to 40% in 1986 and

Martial Law Debate Paper

681 words - 3 pages Name: Randelle Adano Frances Ong Katherine Ong CN:#1 #22 #23 NEGATIVE Section: Grade 8- Commitment Date Submitted: This house will reinstate martial law to promote order and discipline in the Philippines. I. Argument (CLAIM) Martial Law will not promulgate peace and order in the Philippines. II. Evidence (EXAMPLE) The World Bank's estimated that a fraction of people living in poverty has increased 24% in 1974 to 40% in 1986 and

This Is A Paper For A Debate About Creation Vs Evolution. The Opinion Is Creation

2240 words - 9 pages Evolution vs. Creation is indeed the Great Debate of our scientific times. In any scientific debate, the theories must be tested according to the evidence. We propose that the burden of evidence should be upon the Evolutionists, since Creation has been the historic and inherent default throughout virtually all cultures and religions. Of course, Evolutionists, who view themselves as the only "scientists" in the debate, insist that the burden of

A Theoretical And Historical Comparison Debate Paper On The Beliefs And Perceptions

2063 words - 9 pages its many subcategories and have changed over time. The anthropologist E.E. Evans-Pritchard, studied and recorded this pre-modern witchcraft from what he calls, "a primitive society" (Evans-Pritchard 18) known as the Azande. Evans-Pritchard's theory of witchcraft in the Azande community was "combined with his own skepticism regarding the truth behind witches, thus isolating the debate that witchcraft is a type of specialty case" (Mills 18). Evans