Defending Prospero In Shakespeare's The Tempest

1796 words - 7 pages

Defending Prospero in The Tempest

   In William Shakespeare's The Tempest, the character of Prospero brings about a great deal of debate. Modern literary critics are quick to use him as a poster child for English colonial practice in the sixteenth and seventeenth century. Many see him as person who desires complete control of everything around him from the fish-like monster Caliban to his spirit servant Ariel, even his own daughter Miranda. Others believe that Prospero's sole motive is revenge on his brother Antonio and those associated with the established power in Naples and Milan. Taken out of context, these are reasonable conclusions. However, in the development of the play, it is quite clear that these critics are incorrect. Shakespeare does not use Prospero as the symbol of European expansion westward and although Prospero is quite powerful, he is not a power hungry egomaniac. Instead, Prospero is the very figure of a noble father. He loves his daughter so much that he sacrifices everything to give her the best opportunities for a good life. He is the slave of duty, working for the good of his people. His desire for revenge is also clearly not a motivation as he finds the strength to forgive his brother at the play's conclusion. Therefore it seems that Shakespeare's character is not being used to show the dark side of humanity, but rather the nobility of humanity and the model of a seventeenth century father.


When it comes to Miranda, Prospero can never do enough for her. Prospero's second lines states, "I have done nothing but in care of thee, of thee, my dear one, thee, my daughter" (Prospero, I, ii, 19-20). Although this line can be interpreted many ways, even as an outright lie, the assumption has to be made that Prospero is telling the truth. Miranda is the only person on the island who loves Prospero and the only one that fully trusts him. Prospero is wise and would not knowledgeably violate the trust of not only his daughter, but the only person on the island that cares for him. However, even if these words were empty, his actions are not. When Caliban threatened to attack and rape Miranda, Prospero was forced to use his magic to keep Caliban captive so that there would no longer be any immediate threat to her. Prospero's decision to indenture Caliban puts him on tentative moral footing, but it is difficult to believe that Prospero had any other choice. His only other options would have been to kill Caliban or to leave the island himself. To readjust Caliban's nature would have been impossible considering that Caliban himself implies that if he had another opportunity, he would try to rape Miranda again. Leaving the island altogether is the completely moral choice, but obviously if had been that simple, Prospero would already have escaped rather than causing a storm to set events in motion.


Furthermore, Prospero's decision to try to couple Miranda and Ferdinand was an act of love, not a play for power....

Find Another Essay On Defending Prospero in Shakespeare's The Tempest

The Characters of Prospero and Caliban in The Tempest

1591 words - 6 pages The Conflict between Passion and Intellect in The Tempest      During the time of Shakespeare, society had a hierarchical structure. In Shakespeare's play, The Tempest, the characters of Prospero and Caliban, represent two different extremes on the social spectrum: the ruler, and the ruled. Their positions on the social hierarchy are largely due to the fact that Caliban responds almost wholly to passions, feelings of pleasure -- his senses

Relationship between Prospero, Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest

1478 words - 6 pages Relationship between Prospero, Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest    Shakespeare’s play, The Tempest is set on a mysterious island surrounded by the ocean. Here the magician Prospero is ruler of the isle with his two servants Caliban and Ariel.  Caliban is the abrasive, foul-mouthed son of the evil witch Sycorax. When Prospero was shipwrecked on the island Prospero treated him kindly but their relationship changed when Caliban tried to rape

Caliban in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1868 words - 7 pages be presented as such, Caliban is in fact a human being and not a monster, misunderstood only because Prospero, the colonizer, has unjustly depicted him as being merely a primitive native. At the time of The Tempest, settlers began moving out of Britain to colonize America, Africa and parts of Asia. Laying a claim to overseas territory was becoming increasingly important to national identity and power. The voyages of Christopher Columbus and

European Colonization in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1306 words - 5 pages No Critique of European Colonization in The Tempest    Since the 1960s, several critics have found a critique of colonialism in their respective readings of Shakespeare's The Tempest. The most radical of these analyses takes Prospero to be a European invader of the magical but primitive land that he comes to rule, using his superior knowledge to enslave its original inhabitants, most notably Caliban, and forcing them to do his bidding

Art and Nature in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1151 words - 5 pages Shakespeare bid farewell to his.  Prospero's island of paradise is no longer a place for enchantment, but instead a bare island, lacking "Spirits to enforce, art to enchant" (Tempest, 121).  The lonely state of nature without art to enhance it is one of Shakespeare's final points.  Prospero realizes then he must move back from whence his came, to his dukedom in Italy.  The island is now regarded as a place of transition where reality is reaffirmed

Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest

2268 words - 9 pages Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest Although Miranda’s mother and Sycorax never actually appear in The Tempest, their memories occupy a precarious position in Prospero’s will to power. Prospero invokes the memory of Miranda’s mother to legitimize his lineage, yet feels threatened by the control she exerts over it. His narration deftly erases his wife’s presence from Miranda’s memory, rendering him the sole purveyor of his

Prospero’s Loss in Shakespeare's The Tempest

2061 words - 8 pages Prospero’s Loss in The Tempest     Shakespeare’s The Tempest is a play about loss - more specifically, Prospero’s loss. Prospero is a tragic hero, in a sense, because he makes the transition from having everything to having nothing. He loses his daughter. He brings his enemies under his power only to eventually lose control and release them. In the end, he gives up his influence on the world – including his incredible power over nature

Importance of Environment in Shakespeare's The Tempest

2000 words - 8 pages calm in the heavens and in the minds of men, ignorance to self-knowledge and evil to good. Prospero also has to learn to quell the stormy passions in him. "Above all, as ruler and as magus, he must have absolute purity of mind in order to invoke celestial influences and must abstain from passions, which hurt the mind and pervert the judgment of reason." (Adapted from J. H. Walter's Introduction in The Player's Shakespeare's edition of The Tempest

Importance of Language in Shakespeare's The Tempest

1866 words - 7 pages authors evaluate Shakespeare's play The Tempest to be a romance with a "comic subplot", and thereby show how important the interpretation of the language and interaction is in finding meaning in the play. Literary critic Richard Hillman says that, in general, romantic dramas are characterized by their fantasy-like atmosphere with love as the main focus or concern of the play, and they usually exhibit a complete disregard for normal or

The Theme of Colonialism in Shakespeare's Tempest

2640 words - 11 pages characters in the play. The roles the characters have in the play are an essential in the expression of colonization and how it destined for failure. In The Tempest, Shakespeare shows hints of colonization problems in a subtle manner. The character Prospero, for example, can be seen playing the role of the colonist, because he was usurped from his dukedom for neglecting his duties as a duke, he sees the island as a way to be able to exercise

The Christ–like Prospero of Shakespeare’s The Tempest

1395 words - 6 pages The Christ–like Prospero of Shakespeare’s The Tempest It is not only the goodness of man which, according to traditional Christian concepts ,is not germane to himself. His very being, and his ultimate destiny stems alike from a principle that is infinitely beyond him (Morris 143). What was Prospero attempting to accomplish through the creation of the storm? Why would he go to that length of natural disaster, if the events would only

Similar Essays

The Dictatorial Prospero Of Shakespeare's The Tempest

1525 words - 6 pages The Dictatorial Prospero of The Tempest        Motivation often propels people to achieve high goals. Sometimes, however, motivation is too strong a tool and can manifest into selfish desires. The exploitation of the weak invariably results from the strong abusing their power, especially in a political setting. In William Shakespeare's ‘The Tempest’, Prospero is displayed as a tyrannical character who spawns a disastrous storm as part of a

Shakespeare's Presentation Of The Relationship Between Prospero And Caliban In The Tempest

1755 words - 7 pages Shakespeare's Presentation of the Relationship between Prospero and Caliban in The Tempest Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest’ is set on a small island between Tunis and Naples. The play is initially based around Prospero; once Duke of Milan, a loving father to Miranda and inhabitant of the island for the past twelve years, after being usurped by his scheming brother Antonio. When exploring the relationship between Prospero and

Prospero And Caliban Of William Shakespeare's The Tempest

1034 words - 4 pages Prospero and Caliban of William Shakespeare's The Tempest   Within The Tempest, characters such as Prospero and Caliban share an intimate connection. Without some kind of malevolent force motivating the action of the play, none of the major characters would come into contact with each other. A violent storm, formed by Prospero's magic, subjects the foreign characters to the might of his mysterious power. Issues of control become a central

An Essay About Transformation By Theatre In Shakespeare's "The Tempest". Transformation Of Prospero, Of The Audience And Of Shakespeare Himself

972 words - 4 pages 1. The Transformation of ProsperoIn Shakespeare's "The Tempest" the figure of Prospero, the former Duke of Milan, forms the key element of all actions and developments throughout the play. He incorporates absolute power over the other characters and generates the plot of the play almost uninfluenced. For an in-depth understanding of the play it is therefore indispensable to analyse whether or not he undertakes a transformation in character or