Defense Of Slavery Essay

1097 words - 4 pages


Throughout history many things have happened that were by many thought to be unconscionable. Yet, the people who were putting their mark of unacceptance upon those committing these thought to be deplorable acts, were unaware of the actual situations, and in many cases, committing the same acts themselves. This was true during the Holy Wars, the Crusades and similar events. People who were not involved, often thought these acts of inhumanity to be reprehensible, but the parties involved, in their minds, had just cause
for what they were doing. When looking back at events such as these, one can’t help but wonder, “what the heck were they thinking?” When in actuality the people of those times felt that what they were doing was totally justified. The same is true for the institution of slavery. In modern times however, most people find such an institution to be worthless and inhumane. When one observes slavery through the eyes of a southerner during that
period, a plethora of justifications would be present. Also, Southerners of that time had reason to believe that the basis of the northern economy was more corrupt than theirs.
     When defending slavery the first aspect that one must look at is that slavery was the basis of the southern economy. To put an end to slavery without reimbursement for southern losses would have been crippling to their whole economic structure.1 Reimbursement was also practically impossible since slaves, being human, were able to reproduce like the rest of their white counterparts. Though slaves needed not to be paid for their work on plantations, money was needed to provide for their care. That means that the south did not have a leg up on the north who had to pay the sometimes almost
non-existent wages of their workers. To be a slave at certain plantations could in many situations have been more comfortable than being a free northern factory worker. At times slaves were proud to be slaves for certain people. A sense of pride and dignity could be carried with a slave of the right owner. This was a much better feeling than the down in the dumps feelings that many northern workers had.
     In the North people worked in factories. The conditions in these factories were in many cases worse than that of even the worst of plantations involved in the slave trade. Wages were almost non-existent, and the conditions of living at a factory was meager at
best. Owners of these factories were greedy and did not care about the lives of their employees because they knew that if their workers did not make it, then there would always be more people to come and work for them. Slave holders always had to make sure that they took care of their slaves like they took care of the rest of their property,
with care and pride. For if a slave were to perish, then that was a loss of money that wasalready spent, not just a loss of another replaceable worker.
     Another...

Find Another Essay On Defense Of Slavery

Pro-Slavery Arguments Essay

668 words - 3 pages Slavery was at its peak both economically and controversially during the 19th century. The proslavery forces of the south proposed many arguments to defend their institution that they held dear. Legal, religion, and economic arguments were all used to justify their support of slavery. The largest defense of slavery came from the political aspects of it.Legal arguments and defenses were used more frequently than any means of support. The largest

John Brown Was Not Justified in His Raids

1289 words - 5 pages it is in self defense and this was certainly not the case for John Brown. His attacks were an act of revenge and punishment upon slave owners, resulting in the murder of many of those who did not own slaves. Though he believed he was doing God’s will in ending the sin of slavery, he ignored God’s commandment “Thou shall not kill” as mentioned before, someone cannot follow one Biblical passage and ignore others in order to justify one’s actions

How Douglass Dispelled the Illusions of Slavery

1110 words - 5 pages argued that most of the devout slaveholders were also the cruelest, as they depended upon their religion as a “sanctifier of the most hateful frauds” (92). One pious and cruel slaveholder Douglass described was Mr. Hopkins, whose aim was to “alarm [the slaves’] fears” and “strike terror into” the slaves by whipping them with no reason (93). Douglass proved that slaveholders used the existence of slavery in the Bible as a defense for their actions

Slavery in the Upper And Lower South

1270 words - 5 pages embedded in Southern life and customs, white leadership reacted to attacks on slavery after 1830 with an ever more defiant defense of the institution, which reinforced a growing sense among white Southerners that their values eventually divided them from their fellow citizens in the Union. The South of 1860 was uniformly committed to a single cash crop, cotton. During its reign, however, regional differences emerged between the Lower South

Comparing Historical Essays About Slavery: comparing writings of John C. Calhoun, George Fitzhugh, Frederick Douglass, and William Craft

1256 words - 5 pages William Craft provide a compelling challenge to these pro-slavery arguments.In Calhoun's essay, "A Defense of Slavery," written in 1837, he states that slavery is the way of life for people, and if it is abolished, society will be destroyed. Calhoun thinks that slaves are happier and better off because of whites and the system of slavery. He says, "there never has yet existed a wealthy and civilized society in which one portion of the community did

John Brown was not justified in his raids

884 words - 4 pages John Brown was a man you lived in the mid eighteen-hundreds and who fought against slavery. John Brown had a very strong belief that slavery was wrong, and this is true, but he thought that in order to abolish slavery, violence would be the best way, that’s where he went wrong because violence cannot be justified unless it is in self-defense, Brown’s attacks were not in self-defense they were acts of revenge upon slave owners, therefore Brown’s

An Analysis of Slavery and Freedom

952 words - 4 pages Description: This about the rise of the New World with freedom and slavery. This essay include historical evidence of the contradictory belief's of our past leaders.Hope this helps someone.An Analysis of Slavery and Freedomas the American ParadoxBy Megan SmoakMr. Harris – HIS 131“The rise of liberty and equality in this country [America] was accompanied by the rise of slavery,” (Slavery and Freedom: An American Paradox, page 5

What is Wrong with Slavery?: Utilitarian Thought

880 words - 4 pages both an animal and a slave are a man’s property, and both receive the same punishment, the damage is always much worst on a slave. This is because slaves have thoughts, feelings, and responsibility – he is the same species as his owner yet he cannot escape. Hare says in order to show the wrongfulness of slavery, the world has to see slavery as what is actually is and he conveys this through examples of historical context. Hare’s defense of utilitarianism is that this doctrine is moral reasoning that can be used to show and prove what is wrong with slavery, instead of simply just showing dissent and spouting out cries of unjust.

Disposable People: Modern Day Slavery

1244 words - 5 pages to grasp the magnitude of the situation. I tried unsuccessfully to tell myself that this couldn’t happen in modern times, especially in a city such as Paris. How could this be happening? In the following pages of Kevin Bale’s shocking account of the rampant problem of modern day slavery, I learned of more gruesome details of this horrific crime against humanity, such as the different types of slavery, as well as his best estimate of the number

Slavery in Aristotle's Works

3553 words - 14 pages slavery is just. No argument is needed to conclude that Aristotle made a terrible ethical and moral error in defending slavery. Further we must accept that the argument of the abolition of slavery was available to him as his defense of slavery is in response to critics who claim slavery is unjust. What sparks intriguing debate is questioning why Aristotle defended slavery, and whether there is a flaw in Aristotle’s logic in his defense of

The Abolitionist Movement

2274 words - 9 pages obtaining their freedom and prohibiting African Americans from ever holding offices in government.4 Walker directly attacked the Southern defense of slavery, which stated that slavery was a positive good. It is considered the paternalist view of slavery. Southern slaveholder believed that “slavery was blessing, not a curse, that blacks were wholly unqualified for liberty and far better off in slavery than the savagery of Africa or the penury of

Similar Essays

Antebellum Period In The South Essay

743 words - 3 pages In the South during the antebellum period, slave holders in the south defended the institution of slavery using social/political, religious/ideological, economic, and even scientific evidence to defend slavery, nearer to the end of slavery they were more fervent in their defense of slavery because as they years went on the abolitionists of the north were more fervent in abolishing slavery. Earlier, closer to that start of the antebellum period

The Transformation Of Slavery's Defense Essay

640 words - 3 pages The Transformation of Slavery's Defense During the early 1800’s the demand for cotton had risen and it was now “King” of plantations in the southern region of the United States, where the climate was best suited. Now more then ever, slavery had become an essential component of most every cotton producing plantation. The Southerners knew slavery was wrong, but made justifications for it; within a span of 30 years these justifications had

Slavery In The United States Essay

1552 words - 7 pages slavery. With this in mind, the South began to construct arguments in order to defend and legitimize their reasoning as to why slavery should exist and not become abolished. This paper is meant to argue against the Southerners’ defenses of slavery. The South had constructed several different arguments to defend their position on slavery, and among them were the Religious Defense, the Political Defense, and the Economic Argument. Though the South

Article Analysis: The Effect That Public Perception Had On French Royal Society

953 words - 4 pages slavery as a labor force. Although these commonly cited reasons in the defense of the institution of slavery sound somewhat sensible, they are often far overplayed in an effort to cover-up the underlying rational behind forcing others to work against their will. In the following articles, many of these commonly cited explanations are devalued and replaced with the truth. Wright, Gavin. “Slavery and American Agricultural History.” Agricultural