This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Defenses For Democracy Essay

1468 words - 6 pages

Defenses for Democracy


Is liberty a bad thing? Socrates seemed to think so. In Book VIII
of Plato's Republic, Socrates criticizes democracy by attacking three of
its most important aspects: liberty, equality, and majority rule. He
asserts that because of these things, a democratic city will always fall
into tyranny. I disagree, and feel that all three of the principles are
essential to a fair and just city, and only in their absence can a city be
taken into tyranny.

Socrates begins his observations on the defects of a democratic
government by first attacking liberty. His main argument is that there is
entirely too much of it. People in a democracy are free to do what they
wish in their lives and are free to chose what if any job they will do.
Socrates asks if, like the man with the democratic soul, they will not
just pass the time and not get much done (Plato, 557e).

This may be true, but people who do not work do not eat. In
Socrates city, much like in a communist regime, all of the people in a
city are responsible for the common good of all of the other members of
their city. A man who does nothing would truly be a burden on this
society, but unlike in Socrates city, or a communist state, in a capitalist
democracy people are responsible for their own survival, and a man
must work if he is to have a food, shelter, and all of the other
necessities of life.

When describing his just city, Socrates was very much in favor of
specialization of labor (Plato, 367e-372b), so for a man to try many
things would go against his concept of what belongs in a good city. But
Shouldn?t one try one?s hand at many tasks until one find a job that best
fulfills one?s soul? In Alienated Labor, Karl Marx argues that separation
of labor is fundamentally wrong in that it alienates the laborer not only
from his labor, but also from himself and society as a whole(Good Life,
272). Socrates himself claims that a just soul must find work that is
best for the ?rational? part of the soul (Plato, 434d-444e)
Socrates also claims that criminals in a democratic city have too
much freedom. He asks Adeimantus if he had not seen men
?sentenced to death or exile, nonetheless staying and carrying on right
in the middle of things...?(Plato 558a). A democracy has laws and
punishments as does every other government.

Justice is always dependent on the wisdom of people, and people
are fallible. Perhaps criminals do go free sometimes when given a trial
by their peers, but monarchies and tyrannies are no less fallible. History
is full of wrongly accused people being put to death, and horrible men
being set free, in all kinds of government. Trial by a jury of peers, as is
found in a democracy, helps to alleviate this much better than judgment
passed by a ruling body. According to Lysander Spooner, trial by jury
is the watchdog of liberty, and when jurors are truly taken
indiscriminately, and do theirs jobs...

Find Another Essay On Defenses for Democracy

Early Origins of Athens, Greece Essay

956 words - 4 pages Early origins in Athens, Greece can be traced back as early as 7000 B.C.E. It is unclear if the name is derived from the Goddess Athena, or if the goddess was named after the city. In the center of the city is the Acropolis, a high, rocky plateau overlooking the Mediterranean sea. This site was most likely chosen for settlement due to its natural defenses inland, surrounded by mountains, with the acropolis protecting settlers from seaside

The Berlin Wall Essay

952 words - 4 pages the wall look like a symbol of tyranny. In order to save their economy, Soviets locked the East Berliners inside and anyone that tried to pass it would be shot for doing so and thousands tried to escape while some say up to 171 people died during an attempt to do so. On the other hand, the West used it as a method of showing the world that democracy was the better way to go. "Freedom has many flaws and our democracy is imperfect, but we have never

Significance of Canada's Role in the Korean War

1079 words - 5 pages . Canada sent approximately 27,000 troops to serve for the Korean War, and in doing so bestowed Korea with safety and flourishing democracy that still exist today, and hopefully for the years to come. Works Cited Bercunson J. David. "Canadian Played Important Role in Korean War." Share News [Toronto] N.d., The Canadian Experience Ed., Family Sec.: N. Pag. Web. 11 Apr. 2014. N.p., n.d. Web. Brian Catchpole. “The Commonwealth in Korea

Ancient Athens: The Prototype for Western Democracy

1546 words - 7 pages Ancient Athens serves as a beacon within Western antiquity as the center for culture with its cultural advancements impacting the culture of today. Founded nearly 9,000 years ago, Athens formed itself as the center of Greek culture and education during the classical period. Considered the prototype for Western Democracy, it allowed for the rise of a citizenship of voters, something unique in the ancient world. The Athenian love of physical

Dashiell Hammett

1172 words - 5 pages crucial time when the cooperation of all democratic forces is so essential, this attack throws a very dubious light on the character of the whole Dies investigation. It emphasizes the need for the greatest alertness on the part of all democracy-loving American people." He noted, "If it were my life, I would give it for what I think democracy is ... (but) I don't let cops or judges tell me what I think democracy is." When called before HUAC, for a

Dashiell Hammett

1172 words - 5 pages crucial time when the cooperation of all democratic forces is so essential, this attack throws a very dubious light on the character of the whole Dies investigation. It emphasizes the need for the greatest alertness on the part of all democracy-loving American people." He noted, "If it were my life, I would give it for what I think democracy is ... (but) I don't let cops or judges tell me what I think democracy is." When called before HUAC, for a

Dashiell Hammett

1172 words - 5 pages crucial time when the cooperation of all democratic forces is so essential, this attack throws a very dubious light on the character of the whole Dies investigation. It emphasizes the need for the greatest alertness on the part of all democracy-loving American people." He noted, "If it were my life, I would give it for what I think democracy is ... (but) I don't let cops or judges tell me what I think democracy is." When called before HUAC, for a

The war on terror

1680 words - 7 pages threats, civil liberties have been violated and human rights have been abused. After the 9/11 attack on Twin Towers and the Pentagon the U.S. government has called for new forms of defense against possible attacks like the previous ones. These defenses that were put in place defile the citizen’s liberties mainly in form of violating one’s own privacy through the 2001 USA Patriot Act. The Patriot Act was made with the intention to protect the

Is America Nosy or Needed?

1463 words - 6 pages peacefully deter world conflicts. In January 1917, he set up private negotiations with Britain and Germany to obtain their agreement for America's mediation in a peace plan (Trumn). Based on this research, World War 1 was the first international dilemma in which the United States took involvement in. It shows that the United State’s main concern was peace and for the world to move on under democracy. In summation, if the United States did not

Canada’s Reluctant Decision to Participate in the Korean War

1522 words - 7 pages forces, including Canada, foresaw the danger if the USSR continued to magnify in other parts of the world, such as Asia. “A swift and sudden assault on a peaceful nation had an obvious meaning for us all. Hence…many of the free democracies, my own country included, have applied themselves to the task of jointly building up our defenses against aggression” (Pearson 132). The USSR supported North Korea’s invasion of South Korea. It was seen as an

Jesus

947 words - 4 pages . Webcam Editorials, Opinion Post Editorial "¢ Affront to Democracy Opinion Columns "¢ William Raspberry: "¢ Choosing Us or Them "¢ Jackson Diehl: "¢ Plans, Snags for NATO Graphics "¢ Anthrax Victims So Far "¢ Anthrax in D.C. Area "¢ Other Deadly Agents Transcripts "¢ Bush Addresses U.N."¢ Bush Television Speech "¢ On Homeland Security "¢ Post's Interview With "¢ India's Prime Minister "¢ More Transcripts "¢ More Newsletters

Similar Essays

America And The First World War

652 words - 3 pages warfare and the Zimmerman note, President Wilson asked Congress for permission to go to war, and on April 6, 1917, congress officially declared it. President Wilson, along with many Americans, justified their involvement as said in document k, "an act of high principle and idealism... [and]...as a crusade to make the world safe for democracy."While these are some of the main events, there are many other theories regarding why the US entered into

The History Of Everything And Anything Laguna Hills/ Sophomore Essay

2197 words - 9 pages Paris. The king, not being very happy about it, didn't have a                                choice. The next morning, the women and the king headed for the city. The                            women, very happily, sang “now we won't have to go so far when we want to see                                  our king.”(history book). The March on Versailles contributed to the growth of                        democracy by taking King Louis XVI back to

Suffrage For The People: A Report On The Electoral College And Possible Alternatives

1795 words - 7 pages leader simply on the basis of more money. Another considerable flaw is, as in the recent 2000 election, a candidate who wins the popular vote does not always win the electoral vote. If our system of government truly is for, by, and of the people, should not its people be the ones deciding their nation's political, economical, and social future? That is, after all, the very basis of democracy, something that those who oppose the College say the

Shadowlands Essay

2359 words - 10 pages ready to strike just in case of an air attack,” said Prime. “Okay then I will watch the walls with the tripwires from the tower. The fort mortar mauler was a tremendous and extremely fortified fort, only able to be breached by hovercraft jets. The fort got its name because one day long ago the enemy Iron Griffin was eliminating all the rebels who didn’t vote for him, and here they prevailed. With the great air defenses and mortars that bordered