Definition Of Impartial Essay

832 words - 3 pages

Subjectivity, impartiality and Ethics
Subjectivity, impartiality and Ethics While it is debated as to whether or not we can obtain pure impartiality, I'd like to attempt to submit a definition of what I mean by "impartial". I could use the dictionary, but words often take on a personal meaning. Ironic, really, that I'm offering a subjective definition of impartial. A thing can be said to be impartial if it fits, consistently, within a larger and falsifiable framework or explains the operations of that framework with greater clarity. Multiple subjects must be able to perceive, and understand, this relationship between object and framework. The trouble with non-natural philosophy is that one has to rely on axioms (or bullshit - they're really the same) to establish one's position. In making my argument for a definition of 'impartial', I now have to create supporting arguments (likely without end) to build up this framework. And thus, religion called out to some. "Take it on faith" is easier, but less intellectually stimulating. A) A thing fits, consistently, within a larger and falsifiable framework OR it explains the operations of that framework with greater clarity. B) Multiple subjects must be able to perceive, and understand, this relationship between object and framework. C) The thing is impartial. Premise A, Dissected First, “Consistently”. By this, I mean simply that it fits in with other empirical studies, experiments, theories, etc. For example, it was once sensible to conclude that the Earth was flat based on the available evidence (if one didn’t look too far). This was inconsistent with the reality revealed by exploring the cosmos, as well as experiments mapping the lengths of shadows during different parts of the day, etc. Reality is the ultimate arbiter here. The larger and falsifiable framework is the empirical universe. Explaining the operations of that framework with greater clarity means that a theory or observation has accurate predictive power. Premise B, Dissected Multiple subjects. The individual cannot be said to be impartial or anything approaching it. In such a relationship between one individual and one object, the subject is always going to play a role. By creating a collective of subjects, we begin to cancel out differences, to find an average perception. Granted, this is a human-average - with our species' biases and shortcomings - but there are no other (known) entities who can enter into this dialogue. Perception and understanding. These subjects should be able to describe what they have...

Find Another Essay On Definition of Impartial

The Effect of Shared Culture of Journalists on the Selection and Presentation of News

1063 words - 4 pages criticise that as the BBC are impartial to both main political parties, bias stories would not occur. Gate keeping in the media sees how editors choose particular sorties to enter public media. This theory of gate keeping was created by David White. He sees gate keeping as an 'informal process of censorship'. Gate Keeping is a selection process of eligible news stories. Editors are the main "gate keepers." They

John Locke: Second Treatise of Civil Government

903 words - 4 pages in cases where our own interests are not directly under threat to help enforce the law of nature. Still, the person who is most likely to enforce the law under these circumstances is the person who has been wronged. The basic principle of justice is that the punishment should be proportionate to the crime. When victims are judging a crime; they likely to judge it of greater severity than an impartial judge. As a result, there will be miscarriages

Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union

546 words - 2 pages UCC, article 2 involves sales among other issues. These rules are to govern commercial transactions. Article 2 is also applied by federal courts to sales contracts governed by federal law.The difference between selling and licensing is significant. The definition of a license is "a contract that transfers limited rights in intellectual property and informational rights" (Cheeseman 2004). The definition of a sale is" the passing of title from

True or False: Corrective Justice is the Most Important Form of Justice

1028 words - 5 pages ensure that the unjust and unfair conduct elicited by the unjust and unfair individual is fairly, impartially, and justly cited, given the opportunity to mount a defence, sentenced, and punished in proportion to the crime committed. This is why corrective justice is the most important form of justice; in all aspects, it strives to be fair, impartial, and just which is the very definition of justice. Reciprocal Justice demonstrates the equality

Ratification of Constitution

982 words - 4 pages expounds further in Federalist No. 39 (Page 135) about the constitutional limits of government to “certain enumerated objects only,” and the states being delegated the remaining “objects”. Federalism was created in the Constitution and while it seems a difficult concept U.S. Attorney General, Edwin Meese’s definition is very simply put “institution design was to divide sovereignty between two different levels of political entities, the nation and

Jeremy Bentham and John Mill's Classical Utilitarianism

1398 words - 6 pages question of whether anybody can truly be impartial in terms of determining the greatest happiness produced by an action. The idea of impartiality appears to be ideal on the surface, diminishing the influence of social structures, class and racism. Mill recognises the fundamentality of a balanced perspective upon making moral decisions, “Utilitarianism requires [the moral agent] to be as strictly impartial as a disinterested and benevolent spectator

Bill 60, a.k.a. The Quebec Charter of Values

972 words - 4 pages requests (National Assembly, Bill 60, 2014). This definition can be interpreted in simpler terms. To begin, people who work in governmental positions, for example, must be impartial when it comes to religious elements and show how non-religious or spiritual the State is (National Assembly, Bill 60, 2014). Furthermore, when it comes to accommodation requests made on religious grounds, some elements have to be respected. There are many examples

Judicial Activism

1643 words - 7 pages it exists on our current Supreme Court, and ultimately hold our highest court to the initial intent for which it was first created. For many, judicial activism means any judgment that does not meet their own political purposes. Therefore, before having a discussion on judicial activism, there must first be an agreed upon definition of what actually constitutes judicial activism. In The Challenge of Democracy, the


1310 words - 5 pages captures a moral agreement among the civilians; however, civil law, as an interpretation or product of fallible human judgment, remains subject to bias and corruption. Conversely, while the definition of justice varies on an individual basis, justice as a whole remains constant and impartial to prejudice. Therefore, while Creon’s condemnation of Antigone may capture the common reaction towards a woman's defiance, to a large extent his actions do

Critique Essay

635 words - 3 pages takes various studies from the previous 10 years and draws up intriguing conclusions concerning how gender discrepancies, remorse, and physical and mental health exemplify the hookup culture. Garcia, while presenting facts and studies, develops a thorough and neutral perspective on the advantages and disadvantages of a typical one-night stand. Despite increasingly impartial attitudes toward the hookup culture, research has consistently demonstrated

Euthryphro And Divine Command Theory

856 words - 3 pages establish what it is exactly that God is or is not commanding us to do. The basis for establishing what God commands has to be impartial and credible. Impartiality must exist for the definition of God's commands so as to apply to all persons, regardless of their beliefs, and credibility must be leant to the definition of the commands for any value to be placed in them.The Euthyphro objection appears as such, "For consider: is the holy loved by

Similar Essays

Koori Courts Should They Be Trailed And Raised In Australia

998 words - 4 pages must remain impartial, which embraces the racial discrimination factors. Every judge states before entering on the duties of the office of judge, in an oath:"I, _______, do solemnly and sincerely promise and swear that I will duly and faithfully, and to the best of my skill and knowledge, execute the powers and trusts reposed in me as chief justice, so help me god."The oath above states that all judges, before entering a court room, swears under

Innocent Judged By Ignorants Essay

1853 words - 7 pages defined as a sworn of people brought together to make an impartial verdict in court or to set penalty or judgment. Using this definition it is clear that the purpose of using juries is to be as fair and equal as possible when making life changing decisions. The term jury of peers comes from a used method where court chose people randomly from any root of society. They were put together in court without any connection to the accused and they had to

How To Define Terrorism Essay

1558 words - 6 pages civilians is not. What can be seen to be important in any impartial definition is the marked distinction between the objectives and the means used to achieve such. For example, the goals of guerilla warfare and terrorism are remarkably similar, however they can be separated from one another by the means employed to achieve these goals. A guerilla's target is a traditionally military one, in contrast a terrorist deliberately targets civilians. The

Analysis Of Sidgwick's Third Axiom

1207 words - 5 pages Utilitarianism or some other ethical framework. In conclusion, I have argued that Sidgwick’s third axiom is analytic. By supposing that the point of view of the universe is an impartial perspective that has an understanding of good, promotes it, and is a perspective that all rational beings ought to adopt, Sidgwick made the axiom true by definition. Given Sidgwick’s position on tautological principles, I argued that the axiom lacks utility and