This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Deliberating The Ethics Of Armed Ua Vs

1249 words - 5 pages

The development and deployment of any new form of weaponry requires us to evaluate if this advancement is beneficial or harmful to humanity. We must make sure that this new weaponry fits into the code of ethics and values to which we subscribe. The creation of armed Unmanned Arial Vehicles (UAVs) has caused concern among some. They believe that this advancement, if left to its own devices, is detrimental to humanity. These concerns have prompted various approaches, which attempt to eliminate or reduce the concerns associated with armed UAVs. Noel Sharkey, author of the article “Death Strikes from the Sky: The Calculus of Proportionality”, and Robert Sparrow, author of the article “Predators or Plowshares? Arms Control of Robotic Weapons” both offer their own concerns and solutions relating to armed UAVs. They share some common concerns, but their main concerns about UAVs are different, and likewise, their methods of resolving these issues are different.
Sharkey and Sparrow both agree that the number of UAVs and the number UAV missions will increase in the future. One rationale behind this increase comes from how successful UAV missions have been in the past. Sharkey starts by showing how useful UAVs have been during missions over Iraq and Afghanistan. This success has prompted an increase in the production of UAVs, as well as an increase in funding to train more operators. He further states the success of UAVs by stating, “UAVs are the most requested resource from ground forces”. Sparrow offers additional reasons why the use of UAVs will become more prevalent. He worries that the benefits of UAVs are so great, that we will underestimate the pitfalls of their use. One benefit mentioned by Sparrow is how UAVs reduce the risks of soldiers. Producing more UAVs means that more soldiers can operate from a safe distance. Sparrow also argues that the higher level of surveillance made possible by UAVs will serve as more pressure toward increased production and deployment.
These two men differ when it comes to why these increases are a problem. The main concern of Sharkey deals with decapitation attacks, which are targeted attacks made against high-value enemies, usually a leader-figure of an enemy organization. Many of Sharkey’s arguments are made against decapitation attacks in general, but he shows that UAVs increase the urgency of his concerns. He points out that one function of UAVs is the capability to carry out decapitation attacks, the first such attack being in Yemen during 2002. His specific concern with UAVs is that the reduced risk they offer will increase the number of decapitation attacks carried out by the military. For each mission, you weigh the risks versus the rewards. Many times, a mission might fail approval because the risk of losing a soldier is not worth the intended outcome of the mission. Sharkey argues that more decapitation attacks will be approved, because the risk of losing an allied soldier is removed from the equation.

Find Another Essay On Deliberating the Ethics of Armed UAVs

Geography: The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC)

1934 words - 8 pages relationships in the region. Threats The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) is the largest, oldest, and most influential threat group operating in Colombia. FARC targets government officials and military forces in jungle and urban environments with land mines, ambushes, kidnappings, and snipers. As of late 2012, however, representatives of FARC and the Colombian government are engaging in peace talks in Havana. In March 2014, FARC

The New Era of Criminal Justice: A Brief History of Unmanned Armed Vehicles

2429 words - 10 pages of UAVs Throughout the history of the world, the country that had the highest vantage point in a battle usually one, Xeroxes defeating Leonidas, during the medieval periods castle walls towered to the sky so that the castle could see attackers a ways off. Once our ancestors found a way to get higher into the sky the way we fought our battles have changed. During the French war, the French army created balloon companies that monitored enemy

"Zimbabwe achieved independence through a combination of negotiation and armed force". Discuss, for the period of 1965 to 1980. (70)

1313 words - 5 pages should the Federation dissolve, Britain would not grant a 'white' Rhodesia independence. The government imposed totalitarian measures and used armed forces to imprison African opposition and censored the press. Had Britain been willing to negotiate, armed force would not have been used.Rhodesia's Unilateral Declaration of Independence was announced on November 11th, 1965. This was a direct act of rebellion against Britain. Independent African

The Ethics of Medicine

1747 words - 7 pages . Hard decisions always have to be made in medicine. These decisions include things as simple as whether or not to give a patient a minimally invasive surgery, and as complex as what to do in the case of a young girl becoming pregnant and wanting an abortion, against her parent's wishes or knowledge. I first became interested in the Hippocratic Oath after spending seven months researching medical ethics and fallibility of humans practicing medicine

The Ethics of Torture

1607 words - 6 pages , Virtue Ethics, and Natural Rights Ethics. Kantianism is the collection of theories of the philosopher Immanuel Kant. He stated a categorical imperative which is in essence: ‘do unto others as you would want them to do unto you’ (Bible 2); universalism is a necessity. His theories focus on the reasoning behind actions rather than the consequences as the past three perspectives we have looked at have. He also states an ends formula which vies

The Ethics of Care

2203 words - 9 pages capacity to recognize and respond to the needs of others and to moderate our behavior by appeal to the good or harm it might cause to others” (Sanchez, 2013, p. 2). As shown in the Ethics of Care lecture caring for other begins in the environment of a home. It is based off of parents and guidance one is surrounded by when they are young. The impulse to help others in need is even shown in children when they see others in some type of distress

The Ethics of Euthanasia

1417 words - 6 pages Bioethics is the study of moral issues in the fields of medical treatment and research. The idea of bioethics is based upon several different codes of ethics, some of these being the ancient Greek Hippocratic oath, which stated above all to "do no harm," and the professional code of ethics written in the 18th century by Thomas Percival, a British doctor. The code written by Percival was the basis for the first official code of ethics that was

The ethics of abortion

1316 words - 5 pages whether or not a fetus is the sort of being whose life is seriously wrong to end." (Readings in Health Care Ethics, 241) This assumption allows Marquis to set up his thesis which states "that abortion is, except possibly in rare cases, seriously immoral, that it is in the same moral category as killing innocent adult human beings." (ibid)Marquis's arguments are set up in a dialectical essay format. He first argues from his anti-abortion

The Ethics of Potions

836 words - 4 pages The Ethics of Potions: Potions, like most things in life have pros and cons, what are these and how do they affect the average 1st year potions student? I will organize this essay by beginning with a basic history of the connotations of potions, then branching in to their dangers, their necessity and finding the balance when using potions. Potions under correct, good and honest use can be of great help and perhaps save many a life. Yet we

The Ethics of Engineering

787 words - 4 pages Ethics refer to those habits or standards that are considered to show good character and conduct. In the professional practice of engineering, engineers are confronted with different ethical issues and interpersonal conflicts. These cases could range from a small scale involving few people to larger conflicts where the outcome influences the engineering community and the society at large. Classically, engineering education does not duly address

The Ethics of Ambiguity

1899 words - 8 pages people less fortunate, and still there are those that sit on a couch all day watching TV as their years monotonously pass by. In The Ethics of Ambiguity, Simone de Beauvoir develops an existentialist view that explains the details of an ambiguous existence and how those who exist should act in this world. De Beauvoir relies on an individual’s freedom to argue that existence is ambiguous and that each individual should act with the intention of

Similar Essays

Armed Teachers: Superheroes Of The Future?

1973 words - 8 pages their insurance carriers and school district attorneys on the risks and liability of arming non-law enforcement, school employees.” Trump makes a good point in regards to getting written opinions from insurance carriers because of the probability that their insurance may go up or the possibility that the insurer may drop them if non-law enforcement personnel are armed in a school setting. One would wonder, if school boards assumed the role of

The Revolutionary Armed Forces Of Columbia

1517 words - 6 pages The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Columbia The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Columbia, or FARC, have been waging a guerilla war against the Columbian government for thirty-eight years. The organization has a Marxist-Socialist ideological base and has been terrorizing Columbia for some time now. The most recent development is Senator Martha Catalina Daniels was shot twice in the head and killed on March 3. Her body and two others

The Legitimacy Of The Armed Struggle Of The Tamil People

2526 words - 11 pages resort to rebellion against tyranny andoppression, that human rights should be protectedby the rule of law."The rise of the armed struggle of the Tamil people constituted theTamil rebellion against a continuing Sinhala oppression over aperiod of several decades. The gross consistent and continuingviolations of the human rights of the Tamil people have been welldocumented by innumerable reports of human rightsorganisations as well as of

Coltan And Armed Conflicts In The Democratic Republic Of Congo

2658 words - 11 pages Introduction The role of minerals as fuels to armed conflicts in poor countries has been long debated. Conversely, to date, policy initiatives towards the eradication of those clashes have not achieved any noteworthy breakthrough. This work addresses the specific case of the deadly conflicts in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and the strategic position of a specific mineral commodity (coltan) in such framework. It starts with a short