This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Democracy In Indonesia Essay

3498 words - 14 pages

Democracy in Indonesia


It seems to me that, if it is admitted that some day we may be forced to have some form of democracy in Siam, we must prepare ourselves gradually. We must learn and educate ourselves. We must learn and experiment so as to have a better idea of how a parliamentary government would work in Siam. We must try to educate people to be politically conscious, to realize their interests so they will not be misled by agitators of mere dreamers of Utopia. If we have a parliament, we must teach the people how to vote and elect representatives who will really have their interests at heart.

King Prachatipok of Siam, 1927

When the Berlin Wall fell the world thought with the assistance of a superpower that democratization could happen overnight. This has not proven true. On the contrary, what is usually prevailed is a false sense of democracy, an illiberal democracy. The road to democracy is slow and arduous. During the Dutch rule over what was later Indonesia and 22 years before its independence, King Prachatipok understood what was needed to democratize. Even so, since World War II Indonesia has not evolved into a liberal democracy and may be one of the countries furthest from democracy in of all Southeast Asia. What must happen? What has happened? Why has this happened? And what can the United States do to promote democracy and protect human rights in Indonesia?

Economic growth, which is necessary for the creation of a middle class, is the crucial first step toward democratization. For a democracy to be successful a country must have a certain economic and social structures. The consensus remains that there is no viable alternative to the market economy and that capitalist development is associated with the ascent of democracy (Dahl, p. 181). This ascent leads to two structural effects: strengthening the working class and subordinate classes and weakening landowners (Rueschemeyer, p.48). The stability of democracy depends on the loss of this disparity between classes (Singer, p. 53). Some of these structures were in place between 1974-1990 when the number of new democracies increased suddenly. However, since the early 1990s the increase has slowed considerably.

Fourteen centuries ago Aristotle in The Politics asked, "What is the best constitution and what is the best life for the majority of states and majority of men?" (Aristotle, p.265) Aristotle believed that there wasinsecurity at the extremes and that the "middle citizens in a state are the most secure..." (Aristotle, p.267) Hence a state which operates through the middle people has the best chance of having a well-run constitution. (Aristotle, p.267) The middle class (hoi mesoi translates, "those in the middle of moderate wealth") are most likely to have a free government. (Mulgan, p.108). The middle class are unlikely to have another class opposed to them as the rich and the poor are to each other, and most importantly the middle class is more likely to...

Find Another Essay On Democracy in Indonesia

History evolution in Indonesia Essay

1289 words - 6 pages Indonesia is now 68 years old in August 2013, of course, Indonesia has undergone many changes in both the constitution and system of government since 1945. The first Indonesian Government system is parliamentary democracy (1945-1959), later changed to Guided democracy (1959-1965), and in 1965 changed again as a new order (1965-1988) and changed again to reform the system of government (1998-present ). Indonesian changing the system of government

Doing Small Arm Defense Good Trading with Indonesia

1149 words - 5 pages business which cannot be separated from diplomatic and historical relations of the countries. The US - Indonesia are mutual beneficial partnership in trade, counterterrorism, military-to-military cooperation, and democracy promotion. They can be tighter than how they currently. The close relationship permits small arm trading easy from them which could be harsh for the countries where the US has some restrictions. The countries where are not a

Trading in Indonesia

2252 words - 10 pages in Jakarta, Medan, and Central Java. It started with the banners insisted Soeharto to resign, and hope for democracy, and later on after that, several persuasive banners of ‘Ganyang Cina’ or kill the Chinese were hanged, after the companies started firing the workers. There are several theories that the protest was deliberately planned. Just right the time when Soeharto left Indonesia to Egypt on a duty, the riot broke down. It started mainly in

The Republic of Indonesia

1960 words - 8 pages model was aborted, thus removing military representative’s formal involvement in the government administration. On 20 September 2004 the president and the vice president were elected by direct popular vote for the first time, which previously selected by the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR). This Indonesia government soon became the world’s third most populous democracy. (4) I assess that Indonesia is keen to conveying its foreign relations

Australia and Indonesia: The East Timor Conflict and the main themes of their post-war relationship

2015 words - 8 pages Timor put great pressure on the Australian government. The government at the time supported Indonesia in there claim for sovereignty of East Timor. From the Australian public's side there were many people holding the memories of the assistance East Timor gave to Australia during World War II along with the large number of East Timorese refugees who strongly felt the government was going against the things they claim to stand for- liberal democracy

Business Analysis of Indonesia

4802 words - 19 pages position, Indonesia has a fascinating history, heritage, and is among the most culturally rich countries in the world. Indonesia has an estimated population of around 237 million people, is the world's fourth most populous nation and is the world's third largest democracy. The country is unique in many ways as half of the population is under thirty years of age and it is the largest Muslim majority country. There are over 330 distinct recognized

Comparative Analysis of Indonesia and Laos

1831 words - 8 pages The central theme of this report will evaluate the health systems of two developing nations in Southeast Asia. The two nations that have been studied are Indonesia and Laos. The Republic of Indonesia is a developing nation, the fourth largest country in the world by population and the world’s third-largest democracy. The nation faces challenges with improving their health system and the health of their people. The second nation Laos is known as

Attention has been focused on the emergence of radical groups associated with Islam in Indonesia. Discuss if this is a new phenomenon in Indonesia

2384 words - 10 pages ://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/770263.stm5)Bruinessen Martin van (2002), “Genealogies of Islamic Radicalism in post-Suharto Indonesia”6)Bruinessen Martin van (2002), “The violent fringes of Indonesia’s radical Islam” ISIM Newsletter 117)Bruinessen Martin van (2003), “Post-Suharto Muslim engagements with civil society and democracy”, paper presented at the Third International Conference and Workshop “Indonesia in

"There is no way of keeping profits up but by keeping wages down" (David Ricardo)

2011 words - 8 pages of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry warned that investors would prefer to invest their money in countries that have low production costs and good labour relations and when on to add that "there are better markets than Indonesia now, particularly China" (Guerin, 2002).In summary, evidence from Indonesia supports earlier assumptions. Wages were lower under Suharto's totalitarian regime and with the introduction of democracy, workers

Lessons of the Imperialist Propaganda (Indonesian History)

749 words - 3 pages Pancasila, the foundation of the Indonesian government based on belief in God, nationalism, humanitarianism, social justice, and democracy.      6 August 1945 was the date the Allies dropped the first atomic bomb in Hiroshima. This incident acted as a major distraction to the Japanese occupation in Indonesia. The next day, Jakarta witnessed the birth of PPKI, the Preparatory Committee for Indonesia’s Independence. The first

Indonesia: A Profile

1850 words - 7 pages constitution-making in transition’, Kompas Book Publishing, Jakarta ISBN 978-979-709-394-5. Legge, JD 1968, ‘General Suharto's New Order’, Royal Institute of International Affairs, vol. 44, no.1, pp. 40–47. Nasution, AB 2001, ‘The transition to democracy: Lessons from the tragedy of Konstituante in Crafting Indonesian Democracy’, Mizan Media Utama, Jakarta, ISBN 979-433-287-9 Taylor, JG 2003, ‘Indonesia: Peoples and history,’ Yale University Press, p. 325. Vickers, V 2005, ‘A History of modern Indonesia’, Cambridge University Press, p. 163.

Similar Essays

Indonesia An Essay On It's Geography, Climate, Early History, Natural Resources And Government

627 words - 3 pages rice Indonesia might not be able to survive.Indonesia has an Indian - style democracy. It contains twenty - seven provinces each of which are governed by a governor. Above him is the president and under him is the district leader. There are also town and village leaders. The president serves for a five year term and can be reelected. Indonesia has six branches of government including a House of Representatives and a Supreme Court. Making decisions takes a long time because in an Indian - style democracy everyone's opinions are heard and considered. In a way the democracy leaders in Indonesia are much like our American leaders today.

Indonesian Democracy And Islam: Midterm Essay

994 words - 4 pages Despite Huntington’s view in the failure of the democratic experiment in Islamic countries, Indonesia has proven to be the contradiction that has successfully proven the compatibility of Islam with democracy. After the fall of Suharto, moderate Muslims substantially contributed towards the progress of democratic consolidation over the past decade through the rise of cultural Islam. Furthermore, having not attained the majority of votes in three

Historical Evolution In Indonesia Essay

1240 words - 5 pages Democracy as the political system in Indonesia has a long history and many processes until it could be formed as the political system like nowadays. Indonesia with its proclamation proved the independence of the country and announced freedom from colonialism. However, although the independence of Indonesia stated it as a sovereign country, the people of the country still have a problem in sovereignty. It made the government set different

Historical Evolution Of Political System In Indonesia

746 words - 3 pages independence by Soekarno in 1945, Indonesia started to create its own political system. It started with the era of Soekarno as president with guided democracy. Then, after 5 years passed, the leaders thought that the political system should be change to parliamentary democracy. In this political system, it pointed the prime minister as the head of the government and the role of president as the head of the state. Parliamentary democracy showed the