This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Democracy Individualism Essay

4386 words - 18 pages

Democracy Individualism

There is growing consensus in the United States of the potential collapse of democracy, and many scholars question whether America will be able to address the challenges necessary to avert it. At the heart of the issue is the disintegration of civil society. In a remarkable book on the subject – Democracy on Trial – Jean Elshtain (1995: 5) notes, “As a civic question – and it is by no means a civic matter alone – the locus of despair speaks to the loss of civil society. This deepening emptiness, and kind of evacuation of civic spaces, lies in the background of our current discontents, helping to explain why democracy is going through an ordeal of self-understanding as we near the end of the twentieth century.”
Through example and illumination of contemporary societal distress Elshtain is successful in painting a picture of eminent despair – “the growth of cynicism and the atrophy of civil society; too much acquisitive individualism that translates ‘wants’ into ‘rights’; an increase in disrespect of, even contempt for, the rule-governed practices that make democracy work; a politics of displacement that disdains any distinction between public and private and aims to open up all aspects of life to the harsh glare of publicity; the neglect of practical politics in favor of proclamations of one’s unassailable and exclusive identity as a member of a group defined by race, ethnicity, gender, or sexual preference; and a waning of our ability to transmit democratic dispositions and dreams to succeeding generations through education” (117-118).
Through this rendition Elshtain is successful in pointing to the degradation of civil society, most specifically as the result of increased individualism. This tautological approach, however, risks undermining potential solutions by ignoring the foundational reasons for increased individualism in the United States. In fact it is possible to have both negative and positive developments of individualism, a better understanding of which can be seen by an analysis of individual needs and individual reactions to environmental stimuli. Such an analysis may lend to a better understanding of not only how “negative individualism” develops in the U.S., but appropriate means by which these negative developments of individualism can be avoided in the future without loss of unique American individualism that stands as a forefront of American success and prosperity.
Such an analysis, however, must consider both the individual as a unique human being, with individual wants, desires, and needs, as well as the individual responding to environmental queues which affect their behavior by providing either impetus for, or roadblocks to, their needs and desires. Civil society begins to atrophy when collective behavior is the result of a sufficient number of individuals who feel that collective ends are thwarting their own individual needs, resulting in further exaggeration of negative individualism...

Find Another Essay On Democracy Individualism

appropriate relation between Confucianism and democracy

780 words - 4 pages of democracy in supporting the notion of human rights (Huntington, 1991). However, Confucianism is not only rejected by scholars for its compatibility with democracy, but also by Chinese scholars. Liang Shuming clearly stated democracy would not be viable in Chinese society which was strongly influenced by Confucianism (Li, 1997). It is worried that individualism advocated by democracy would disrupt ‘relationships’ laid down in Confucianism and a

Confucianism v. Democracy Essay

1064 words - 4 pages unavoidable. In contrast, Confucianism plays down the negative side of human nature and claims that human beings were born upright (Confucius 6.17).Another difference is that unlike democracy, which is associated with individualism, Confucianism places a premium on families. To clarify, family values do not necessarily conflict with democracy seeing as the family has always been the basic social unit in society. However, what makes Confucianism distinct

Response to Turner's Essay on The Significance of the Frontier in American History

666 words - 3 pages United States generates a popular sense of American patriotism and supports a highly cultural appraisal of the frontier. "The most important effect of the frontier has been in the promotion of democracy here and in Europe. As has been indicated, the frontier is productive of individualism." (Turner, 34) Over the last century, however, Turner's thesis received ongoing criticism as well as support for his claims, which has

The American Character

1125 words - 5 pages , and people are respected on the basis of intellect and virtue" (chap. 3, Democracy in America). What Tocqueville is saying is that people should treat each other with equality and in a sense, fairness. Within Frederick Jackson Turner's Frontier Thesis, Turner agrees, "But the democracy born of free land, strong in selfishness and individualism, intolerant of administrative experience and education, and pressing individual liberty beyond its proper

Promoting Democracy In the Middle east

861 words - 4 pages I negate the resolution U.S efforts to promote democracy in the Middle East are desirable. The value that I hold in this round is autonomy. Autonomy is defined as the power or right of a country or region to govern itself. When practicing autonomy it serves as a model for the people whose interests are reflected in the principles of government. The criterion held in this round is individualism. The Middle East should be allowed to follow by

Individualism And Its Place In Society

1186 words - 5 pages question how does a government keep its citizens locked in to the events occurring around them, Mill and De Tocqueville both offer different answers. De Tocqueville proposes the very American idea that free institutions (i.e. unions) keep the populace interested, further he feels that individualism has little or no place in democracy at all. In stark contrast, Mill suggests that the individuality of a human should be nurtured to an extent where

PLSC2211 term paper

846 words - 4 pages Introduction Thomas Hobbes is frequently credited as being a forefather to modern liberalism. With his beliefs on individualism, along with his agreeance and acceptance of intellectual and moral autonomy it is easy to understand why many modern liberals would agree with Hobbes’s political philosophy. However, Thomas Hobbes does not support the concept of a democratic government, rather he supported the notion of a absolutist government up

An Analysis of Democracy

1174 words - 5 pages dictatorships is that free countries confront such abuses openly and directly." The overpowering sentiment in America toward democracy is one of high esteem and greatness. Democracy has ended the long reign of Christian principles as king and now sits upon the throne in the hearts and mind of the majority of Americans. Democracy is often directly associated with other high ideals in America, such as justice, individualism, equality, fairness, and

Democracy in America

1989 words - 8 pages sovereignty of the Union alone is in danger.      Tocqueville emphasizes that one of the most important problems in American democracy, or any other democracy, is that of individualism. He compares and contrasts egotism from individualism. However, individualism may cause one to sever himself with the world, which can create an entrance for the entry of tyranny and the end of democracy in America. Egotism centers one on himself. Individualism can

Influences on Early American L

1136 words - 5 pages , which Jefferson espoused, was one of the great destroyers of this individualism. It is an example of American culture being shaped by the forces of democracy. Even though you might think rule by the majority is conducive to individualism it is not. Rule by the majority fosters dependence on others because of the tremendous pressure it puts on the minority to conform to mass ideals. Jefferson, a great believer in the individualistic spirit

Alexis deTocqueville

3390 words - 14 pages individual minds, the evil would only have changed character…For myself, when I feel the hand of power lie heavy on my brow, I care but little to know who oppresses me…” Here, Tocqueville expresses that if democracy is to survive, or if it is to fulfill the expectations surrounding it, individualism as a social force must have its anti-social tendencies neutralized, and society in turn must be rendered incapable of destroying the

Similar Essays

Contrasting Individualism And Collectivism Essay

621 words - 2 pages -scale questionnaires, which distinguish between horizontal and vertical individualism and collectivism. Horizontal and vertical individualism fundamentally differ in the sense that while vertical individualism is associated with the idea of the individual being unique and typically encourages actively going against the group with a focus on authority ranking, horizontal individualism promotes democracy and high equality and puts less emphasis on

Tocqueville´S Faults Of Democracy In America

959 words - 4 pages to be established. One major problem that Tocqueville identified with America and democracy is the development of individualism. He defined individualism as “a mature and considered feeling, which disposes each member of the community to sever himself from the mass of his fellow-creatures; and to draw apart with his family and friends; so that, after he had thus formed a little circle of his own, he willingly leaves society at large to itself

Americans And Individualism Essay

988 words - 4 pages , like anyone else, were subject to law, to civilization, and to basic rules of behavior, and had duties as citizens to protect each other's freedom and safety. However, these were obligations whose existence did not depend on the particular government that the people had chosen. In fact, the government was subject to these things just as much as individuals were. Individualism taken too far could undermine democracy and make society vulnerable to

Frederick Jackson Turner's Observations About The Birth Of Democracy

637 words - 3 pages mentioned beforehand, the West was more of an individualistic society. Unlike its counterpart, the people that moved west became pragmatic laborers. Though considered common men, they could live on their own, without dependence on others and without being compared to each other on a social level. This also made them dismissive of centralized political power. This type of individualism and egalitarianism has promoted democracy throughout American history