Democracy, Liberalism, And Canadian Federalism Essay

1656 words - 7 pages

Do liberty and democracy diminish, or enhance principles of Canadian federalism? This remains a crucial question in determining whether or not liberty, which stands for individual and minority rights, can be properly balanced with democracy, generally understood as the will of the majority, while both of course, within the context of Canadian federalism. Also, it shall remain important to remember that the road to confederation has been long, turbulent, and sometimes troublesome and that the establishment of these principles have come a long way in shaping the very nature of Canadian federalism today. Therefore we must remember the past, in order to finally see that democracy, in concordance with liberty will enhance -the principles of Canadian federalism for the present, and future.La Selva and Vernon believe that the three most important values to modern politics and federalism are liberty, equality, and fraternity. But in relation to Canadian federalism however, it seems as if only their position on liberty can be adequately applied. They construct a kind of political liberty, far off from the modern conception of liberty where emphasis on the individual lies and in doing so, they imply that liberty is to mean the freedom from external influence, and the inherent right to self-government and self-determination. To accomplish this, they believed that the best check on government power in a federal system would be the constitutional protection of the division of powers. They relate this to liberty through the argument that the more difficult it is to monopolize political power, the harder it would be to for an individual, or group to enforce their political upon the nation. More specialized, and independent branches of government would mean greater, divided jurisdictional powers, and the less likelihood of collusion between political sections. It is through this separation of powers, that La Selva and Vernon believe, that individual liberty, free of outside influence, can contribute to Canadian federalism.Their positions on equality, and fraternity, are much less applicable. Regarding equality, the terms, and concepts they use seem much too radical to make a connection, or even a possible integration in Canada's foreseeable future. They introduce a nation with both socialism and federalism, as well as a political equality where interests would be weighed individually, and not equally. All of this of course, under a nation where the provinces would be divided equally in territorial size, and where provinces would have exclusive jurisdiction over all matters within their respective province's boundaries. Such proposals are just too difficult to implement, and even consider within the constitutional regime Canada is currently in.Fraternity's lack of relevance can be best described by La Selva and Vernon themselves where they state that it is 'too difficult to analyze precisely and too difficult of an ideal to realize satisfactorily' (La Selva and...

Find Another Essay On Democracy, Liberalism, and Canadian Federalism

Quebec nationalism Essay

3224 words - 13 pages is to keep Canada a unified country come to understand the different perspectives in the unity debate and to fully have an accurate depiction of the history of Quebec and its nationalistic endeavors. Quebec nationalism has provided a coherent and palpable threat to Canadian federalism. It is easy for English Canadians to express many reasons why Quebec should not separate, but the threat imminently looms with Quecbecers. The more difficult task

The New Science of Politics Essay

1039 words - 4 pages of expression eventually led to the ratification of the Constitution with a Bill of Rights in 1791 and the birth of dual federalism. Although today in the twenty -first century we have more of a regulated federalism, the basic concepts of protection of individual rights along with free expression of ideas is still at the core of our current political philosophy. The founders intentions, primarily fueled by the Federalists, sought to create a national system under which the new area of democracy would thrive in the shadow of what they perceived to be an oppressive past with mother England.

What Kind of Democracy? What Democracy are we in ?

1241 words - 5 pages as voting. Tribalism excludes any minorities such as, women, slaves, or foreigners when making decisions as a state.Now a days our world is heading towards liberal democracy considering the fact that, liberalism will guarantee that citizen's rights comes first before state , it will help reinforce unchecked state power and religious dogma and also abolish political censorship , slavery , torture , women's and minority groups unequal rights

Canada's North

565 words - 3 pages ). Such small words with great meaning are questioned while others such as: neo-liberalism and democracy are used as large blanket terms, which evolve to encompass various situations as the uses of these words see fit (Campbell 99). In so that the ability to understand and accept that what comes with this ‘modern’ understanding of Canada stemmed from the development of past affairs. The ability to transition and change your method of with the times


1568 words - 6 pages democracy as a tool of oppression instead of a means of emancipation. Following the collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union many have argued that ‘western liberal democracy’ is the best form of government and ideally suited to the modern world. Some even claim that it is the ‘moral leader’ of the world. Parekh describes democracy as “defined and structured within the limits set by liberalism.” Liberalism preceded democracy

The history of Federalism in the United States and it's roots, meaning, and effects.

1256 words - 5 pages Federalism has been one of the most controversial terms in American Government since its creation in 1789. Confusion over the meaning of federalism and disagreement over its implications have not ceased since the debate over the constitution. Federalism, adding to its problematic history has never conformed precisely to any theoretical idea. The definition that we have come to study of federalism is: A political system in which power is divided

Biography on Pierre Elliott Trudeau

953 words - 4 pages lead the Liberals to a majority in 1980. In this campaign, he actually embraced the symbols of cultural nationalism, especially in English Canada. He encouraged the funding of the Genie awards for Canadian films and supported Canadian content rules for radio and television.The 1980 election was a turning point in Canadian federalism, for Trudeau returned to power with a single-minded mission. His masterful victory in the 1980 referendum positioned

Political Fumble: The War Measures Act, the implications of the institution of the war measures act of 1970 by former prime minister Pierre Trudeau.

1302 words - 5 pages that the War Measures Act had become a ?symbol of the rampant socialism enveloping Canada? which threatens the free-market? . In an edition of the Wall Street Journal, America?s most prominent capitalist publication, an editorial sharply criticized the act as being an attack on democracy in the western world and having damaged Canada?s image among the business community . Thus, both Canadian businesses as well the Canadian economic image abroad


967 words - 4 pages constitution replaced it with another, more balanced, version that has worked for over two centuries. During the time, however the history of federalism has been incessantly disrupted by a constant debate between those who wanted to enlarge the central government and those who demanded that states’ rights be strictly respected and even expanded.      During Reconstruction the war argument over the use of federal power

Should the Canadian Federation be Centralized or Decentralized?

1973 words - 8 pages have on the issue of being equal. This paper will argue that the Canadian federation should be a decentralized system for the obvious advantages that it brings the nation; seen through economic benefits, public participation and multiculturalism. Fiscal Federalism The first argument of this paper shall discuss the use of fiscal federalism as a highly beneficial and worthwhile cost for maintenance of policy proposals. As fiscal federalism is

The Consequences of an Increasingly Globalized World

1379 words - 6 pages Globalisation on international migration, Geneva: International Labour Organisation, c2000. Ronald L. Watts, Federalism: the Canadian experience, Pretoria: HSRC Publishers, 1997. Stephen J. Randell and Roger Gibbins (ed), Federalism and the new world order, Calgary: University of Calgary Press, c1994. The 1973 Oil Crisis, retrieved 10 April 2009, from USA Patriot Act, retrieved 10 April 2009, from

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Liberalism And Democracy

1550 words - 6 pages Analysis of Liberalism and Democracy Liberalism has an ambivalent relationship with democracy, as liberals are against collective power, but support political equality. In the nineteenth century liberals were often opposed to democracy as they saw it as a threat to individual rights - the people are not a single entity but rather a collection of individuals with different opinions and interests, and so it is impossible

Perspectives Of Austrian And Canadian Federalism

2979 words - 12 pages formation of teachers and pupils thereby contributing to the collective togetherness of the nation (Erk 15)15. The widespread support of centralization in Austria is made clear by this case study. Canada’s constitutional origins have some similarities to Austria’s. Like Austria there were two conceptions of what federalism should look like. On one hand there was John A. MacDonald who constitutional scholar John A. Rohr called “a Canadian

Initiative And Ideologies: Liberalism And Social Democracy As Applied To Modern Legislation

1259 words - 5 pages banning bonuses and mandating shareholder consent in major decisions. A recent proposition also suggested implementing an initiative that “would permit companies to award their best-paid worker no more than 12 times what the worst paid.” (Stamm) This measure invokes sentiments similar to those invoked by historic ideologies. The societal problems that Locke and Bernstein attempted to address with Liberalism and Social Democracy respectively manifest

Canadian Democracy: A Lack Of Transparency And Accountability In Canadian Politics

1384 words - 6 pages , media, and opposition members in order to fulfill a personal or hidden agenda. The sheer manipulation that is possible by a Prime Minister completely undermines the transparency and accountability of true democracy. References Jackson, D., & Jackson, R.J. (2002). Canadian government in transition (3rd ed.). Toronto: Pearson Education Canada Inc. Kendall, D., Linden, R., & Murray, J. L. (2008). Sociology in our times: The essentials (4th Cdn ed.). Toronto: Nelson Education Inc. Martin, L. (2010). Harperland: The politics of control. Toronto, ON: Penguin Group.