Democracy Vs Dictatorship: Case Studies. Essay

1138 words - 5 pages

"Freedom is to society what health is to the individual." [Lord Bolingbroke]. A society without freedom ultimately jeopardizes the well being of its citizens and social prosperity. When deciding to what extent governments should be involved in society, the following questions must be addressed: What methods are in place to keep the government accountable? Is open dissent against the government permissible? Are minorities treated fairly, or are they suppressed? Asking these questions spawned two different ideologies: democracy and dictatorship. In a more dictatorial society, the government has far more control over people's lives. Since power is centralized, the government is able to do what they want with little opposition and are not obligated to obtain the permission of the people. Individuals tend to have less rights and freedoms, change is slow to take place, there is more corruption, elitism is often prominent, and violence is a more common solution to problems. On the positive end, military tends to stronger, unity is greater, and government tends to be more effective in decision-making. An avid supporter of this form of government was Thomas Carlyle. Carlyle believed that a great leader was needed to run a country. He also believed that a community that assured stability was more enhanced than a community that supported individualism. Democracies place the power within the hands of the people. Consequently, the people are given the right to elect officials to represent and govern them, and through the use of free speech and the right to dissent, are able to greatly influence the choices the government make. When all else fails, through accountability mechanisms, citizens are able to force unwanted authority out of office. By doing this, there tends to be a greater amount of accountability, provision for changes, egalitarianism, rights, and freedoms. However, there are always negatives aspects to everything. Some of the greater negative aspects include ineffectiveness and reduced security for the nation. An advocate of democracy was Charles Baron de Montesquieu. Montesquieu believed that in a government checks and balances are required to keep the government accountable for any decisions they make. Upon further analysis the issue continues to remain complex; however, due to the fact that in a democracy power is separated to keep the government accountable and open dissent is allowed as long as it remains peaceful, and dictatorship often has unchecked corruption, limited accountability and demand complete obedience from its citizens in terms of dissent, a moderate democracy is the best way for governments to be involved in peoples lives.Dictatorships do not allow opposition and therefore do not allow any type of dissent against the government. In 1989 in Tiananmen Square, China, approximately four-million protestors were angrily protesting against the government for inflation and demanded an end to corruption within the economy. The Chinese...

Find Another Essay On Democracy vs Dictatorship: Case studies.

In what ways did the institutional legacy of the Franco regime shape Spain's transition to democracy?

3821 words - 15 pages was a dictator he actually ignited the transition to democracy. The institutional legacy of Franco is characterised by the 'poderes fácticos.' These centres of power enjoyed major political influence and shaped Spain's transition from a dictatorship rule to one of democracy."Doubtlessly there are but two valid ways for people to conduct their lives: one religion and the other military-or, if you wish, only one since there is no religion

On Acceptability of Tyranny: The Ineptitudes of Democracy

1947 words - 8 pages until subtle dictatorship occurs as was the case with Rome. The decadence of a democratic society forces it to lean inexorably towards dictatorship by natural as well as cultural impulse.Many now reading this could perhaps be angry at calm promotion of dictatorship as the "best" government and at the bereavement of democracy. Others may be pleased, and others confused, indifferent or undecided. Dictatorship cannot work, at least not in the long

Pakistan is better off Being Ruled by a Dictator than by a Democratically Elected Government

1319 words - 5 pages government. Moreover, problems such as rigging in frequent elections and corruption, as in the case of democracy, or a disturbance in peace and harmony as a result of political factions, do not arise in dictatorship. It guarantees smooth running of the system because the system is run by a competent and professional person.Democracy is also considered as a government of the rich and dictatorship of majority. It lowers/ruins the moral standards and

Pakistan is better off Being Ruled by a Dictator than by a Democratically Elected Government

1309 words - 5 pages generous dictator, means that he/she will actually work out in the best interests of the people. Dictatorship implies stability of government in a way that it ensures uniformity of opinion, crushes all the disruptive forces effectively and decision has to be taken by just one person and others do not have any say in the working of the government. Moreover, problems such as rigging in frequent elections and corruption, as in the case of democracy, or

theory on democracy

1537 words - 7 pages view of genuine democracy, a system in support of communism that he refers to as Popular Dictatorship. Badiou makes a persuasive argument for the necessity of riots in creating a genuine democracy because the minority involved in those riots ultimately represent the general will i.e. the emergence of truth. Riots show the inequalities of a society and for this reason he applauds the Arab Uprising and other mass movements for their stance against

Democratization Theories Developed by Moore, Rueschemeyer, and Collier.

1423 words - 6 pages concluded that we are still in a state of democratization because, at least from my understanding, the ultimate goal of democracy is overall freedom, balance of powers, and equality for all, which surprisingly still has not been reached.In Barrington Moore's Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy: Landlord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World, he says "No Bourgeoisie, No Democracy." He examines the historical and contemporary causes

Democracy in Latin America

3430 words - 14 pages Latin America still face serious problems in matters as grinding poverty, huge social gaps, corruption, drug dealing, inefficient governments and most importantly governments who promote and use military. The real question is why democracy actually failed even though democracy is what people want. Paraguay is a case of failure in transition democracy because of the corruption and other things that will be argued in this essay. Paraguay and Ecuador

Arab Democracy, fiction or Reality?

4961 words - 20 pages . The choices of names were also significant; in each case the word "party" was deliberately avoided, given its powerful connotations of division and lack of national purpose (Roger, 150). Thus opposition was crushed and the promise of democracy had been officially put on hold, till this day, as we live under the banner of the Republic.An important point is in need of clarification at this stage, by the end of 1956 Nasser's popularity had soared

Democracy to Dictatorship in Lord of the Flies

1120 words - 4 pages Democracy to Dictatorship in Lord of the Flies        Lord of the Flies by William Golding is a novel that represents a microcosm of society in a tale about children stranded on an island. Of the group of young boys there are two who want to lead for the duration of their stay, Jack and Ralph.  Through the opposing characters of Jack and Ralph, Golding reveals the gradual process from democracy to dictatorship from Ralph's democratic


2874 words - 12 pages ideology that satisfies man’s universal right to freedom, which trumps all other ideologies, is founded and adopted. In this case, the perfect ideology, according to Fukuyama, is liberal democracy. To prove that a liberal democracy is the best form of government, Fukuyama looks at what has challenged liberal democracy as the perfect forms of government: fascism and communism. Fascism had many weaknesses, mainly because it encouraged a belligerent

PNAC- Downfall of the United States

1780 words - 7 pages not only means the return of the draft, but also loss of personal freedoms and sacrifice by the American people "to preserve the American way of life." Doesn't this sound like what we hear and read in the daily news? The question of war with Iraq becomes, - is the U.S. bringing democracy to Iraq or a dictatorship to America? Americans should read from the diary of Hermann Goering, President of the Reichstag, Nazi Party, and Luftwaffe Commander in

Similar Essays

Democracy Case Studies (Canada) Essay

1785 words - 7 pages EXECUTIVE BRANCHMethod of Electing and Term of OfficeThe Leader of Canada is called a Prime Minster, who is the leader of the party in power. The PM becomes the PM by having the most seats in Parliament, in other words, the party who has the most elected members becomes the party in power.Usually, the term of government for the Canadian system is 3-5 years. When there is a minority government, the term is shorter because of the possibility of a

Internationalism Vs Nationalism: Case Studies Essay

1227 words - 5 pages best way to cooperate between nations stems from effective use of internationalism. With internationalism, free trade can directly benefit a nations economy, and diplomatic negotiations before action in conflict mediation ensure that the political independence of a nation is not violated.The internationalist ideology supports methods of collective security, as was the case in the Persian-Gulf war. In 1990, Saddam Hussein accused the country of

Dictatorship Essay

637 words - 3 pages anyone to pick a side. Dictatorship is not always seen for its positive aspects such as stable government, efficiency, less room for corruption, and a lesser crime rate. In a dictatorship, decision-making lies with one person and others do not have any say in the working of the government which offers a kind of stability. Problems such as frequent elections, as in the case of democracy, or a disruption of peace due to political factions, do not

Liberalism Essay

1568 words - 6 pages institution and the media, and influencing the public opinion so as to minimize public debate on issues, which brings its privileges into question. On the other hand others would argue that only liberal democracy could guarantee the individual liberties of its citizens and prevent the development into dictatorship. In the western countries where the wealthier section of the population are numerically over-represented in executive and