Democratic Eco Humanism Market Civilization Essay

2760 words - 11 pages

Democratic EcoHumanism Market Civilization

In an effort to dramatize his neo-Polanyian critique of neo-liberal global capitalism, Stephen Gill questions the tenability of his own term market civilization, proposing it as oxymoronic in that a market civilization qua the neo-liberal order contradicts Gill's view of civilization qua democratic eco-humanism (i.e. representation, civility, social well-being and inclusion). In this formation, Gill's argument is essentially circular in its reliance on his own subjective standard of civilization, (democratic eco-humanism), to prove the uncivilized nature of the neo-liberal order. By adopting a more objective, (and necessarily more general), definition of civilization, we can disband with Gill's tautology, allowing us to embrace the term market civilization as a precise definition of neo-liberal global capitalism. In doing so, however, we merely adjust Gill's propensity for grandiose formulations; what remains is his well-reasoned explication of the inherent contradictions of neo-liberalism, an explication that underscores the ways in which Anglo-American neo-liberalism departs from a certain aesthetic of civilization as democratic eco-humanism. Though he fails to prove the system uncivilized in the broad sense, Gill's arguments make a strong case for the rise of a Polanyian double movement that would address the critical excesses of the neo-liberal order.
To understand Gill's claim about the oxymoronic nature of market civilization, one must understand the differences between the two relevant definitions of civilization. In Gill's words: "civilization implies not only a pattern of society (def. 1) but also an active historical process that fosters a more humanized, literate and civil way of life, involving social well-being on a broad and inclusive basis (def. 2). (Gill, 422)" Gill's claim regards only the second definition, a version of which the American Heritage Dictionary pictures as: "An advanced state of intellectual, cultural, and material development, progress in the arts and sciences, the extensive use of writing, and the appearance of complex political and social institutions."(American Heritage) Though Gill's version of civilization mirrors closely the story told by the dictionary, both claims about the parameters of civilization are so problematically subjective as to add little or nothing to Gill's analysis of neo-liberalism.
The fallacy of both definitions of civilization is rooted in a subjective set of truth claims masked in an ethos of democratic eco-humanism that is as guilty of attempting to proclaim the end of history as neo-liberalism itself. The embedded nature of these claims makes them initially hard to penetrate; broader political participation, literacy, civility and wealth distribution all function in a sort of Hegelian determinism where humanity appears to be progressing towards ever-deeper understanding of civilization qua democratic eco-humanism. And yet this...

Find Another Essay On Democratic EcoHumanism Market Civilization

The Election of 1896 Essay

1007 words - 5 pages main political division of the period. In order to arrive at this conclusion, one must merely examine the platforms presented by the Republican and Democratic parties. For example, the Democratic party declared that it was, “unalterably opposed to monometallism”, and that, the demonetization of silver resulted in, “the appreciation of gold and a corresponding fall in prices of commodities produced by the people; a heavy increase in the burden of

Cold War's Impact on America Politically, Socially, and Economically

1736 words - 7 pages nations of foreign control. In turn the United States would insure the survival of Great Britain. The basic goals of the United Nations were to create global scale free-market capitalism, and to increase the worldwide standard of living. The world would be democratic in order to enable self-determination and give everyone self-respect. The United Nations would also provide international security and protection for everyone. The charter was the

Public Sphere and The Ideals of a Democratic Society

1235 words - 5 pages area where people could meet and freely discuss issues within society (Ironstone March 21, 2014). On the other hand, the emergence of communicative technologies ties in with the idea of communicative capitalism, which emphasizes that the market is the “site of democratic aspirations” (Dean 2005, p. 54). Using Nancy Fraser, Jürgen Habermas, and Jodi Dean’s ideas, this essay will argue that nor the public sphere or societies endless access to

The Protestant and the Merchant

2030 words - 9 pages The Protestant Reformation was integral in shaping Western Europe from a religious perspective, but arguably, the resulting divergence of Christianity was just as important to the development of Western Europe's political and economic climate. The adoption of Protestant beliefs would serve as a catalyst for the sharp rise in capitalist, mercantilist, and democratic thought and practice. The process by which democracy, capitalism and to an

Participation in Urban Planning of China

967 words - 4 pages Participation in urban planning of China Introduction With the development of society and economic, public participation has been a popular topic which attracted people from different fields. On the basic of various theories of urban planning, a great amount of market economy countries have successively established public participation system in the field of urban planning. These successful experiences provide a good guide for China urban

Marketing a product in Ukraine

946 words - 4 pages be social as well as cultural forces that are of great significance when entering this market. The history of this state shows that the population has always been divided between the Eastern or Slavic civilization (primarily, left bank of the river Dnipro) and Western or European civilization (primarily, right bank of the same river) (Arnold, 2001, 14). Therefore, this division should be taken into careful consideration. There is also a

The Filter Bubble

1020 words - 5 pages personalization began; our computer monitors became one-way mirrors reflecting consumer interests (3). We assume that when we Google a term, we all see the same results, but algorithm suggests what is particularly best for you (2). Our behaviour has become a commodity to be bought and sold where each click signal sends a stream of information to be auctioned off to the highest commercial bidder (7). Therefore, the Internet is masked as a democratic


2283 words - 9 pages of the Mayan civilization that spread southwards from the Yucatán peninsula through modern Guatemala to the city of Copán, now in north-west Honduras. The Mayan civilization collapsed long before the arrival of Christopher Columbus, who visited Trujillo in north-east Honduras in 1502 on his third voyage to the new world. The country was colonized by Spain after some resistance by the Lenca peoples of the central highlands. Their chief, Lempira

Turkey's Accession to the European Union

1189 words - 5 pages relationship. Since the start of Turkey’s EU accession negotiations at the beginning of October 2005, relations have gained a new momentum and ambiguity has begun to disappear. Turkey & EU History The founder of the Republic of Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, “pointed to achieving and even going beyond the level of contemporary civilization as the goal of the Turkish nation. In the framework of this goal, he played a major role in the

Classical Ancient Greece

1407 words - 6 pages Classical Era of Greece which spans from about 500 BCE to around 320 BCE. During this time in Greece there were many conflicts and wars, but there was also much growth in the cultural aspects of their society. Imagine walking down the market in Athens. On the left market stalls carrying all types of dried herbs. There is a stall full of different shapes and styles of bread, all made from barley. Down from it, there sits a stall with wheels, blocks

Athens Excluded: Metics

1448 words - 6 pages Athenian citizen. Therefore it can be concluded that Athens could not be considered a democratic state.Metics were usually of Greek background from other city-states ( In most Greek city-states, there were few foreign residents. However, in Athens, Metics amount to approximately half the free population (, 2003). Metics came to Athens in search for a life of prosperity and freedom, but due to the lack of political rights

Similar Essays

Civilization Essay

910 words - 4 pages 1. Discuss the world economy of the nineteenth century, explaining how it functioned and how the West benefited most from the global market involved. We currently live in a globalized economy. This is often referred to as the second one because from 1870 til World War I, the world markets were globalized. This previous period, called the new industrial Revolution, is where the world's markets integrated and then collapsed between the two

Karl Polanyi's "The Great Transformation" Essay

2485 words - 10 pages on self-interest. Such an organization of economic life is entirely unnatural" (249). For Polanyi, a more natural organization of economic life could (only) exist in socialist society. He explains that "socialism is, essentially, the tendency inherent in an industrial civilization to transcend the self-regulating market by consciously subordinating it to a democratic society. . . . Economic liberation is only half of the solution; the other half

Ancient Greece Essay

956 words - 4 pages Ancient Greece was the birthplace of Western civilization about 3rd millennium to the 1st century. They were known for their philosophy, architecture, drama, government, and science. Geographically it indicates the heartland of Greek communities on the north coast and nearby islands of the Mediterranean Sea. Culturally, though it indicates how the ancient Greeks spoke. How they worshipped and understood the physical world.Greek civilization

Industrial States & The Rise Of The West

1728 words - 7 pages economies consist of primary, secondary, and tertiary sectors with jobs increasingly located in the tertiary sector. The market economy developed out of this. Both capitalist and socialist systems developed in industrial societies.One of the characteristics of a modernized society is the emergence of a market economy, based on competition and principles of supply and demand to establish the value of goods and services. Yet, as the text describes