This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Deontological Ethics Is Too Rigid In Its Emphasis On Duties, Utilitarian Ethics Too Keen To Override Basic Human Rights.

1047 words - 4 pages

Deontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties, utilitarianethics too keen to override basic human rights.Deontology and utilitarianism are both types of ethics referring to how onereacts in a certain situation. Deontology is based on following a set of duties andsticking to these duties no matter what the consequences whereas utilitarianism isbased on choosing the best outcome over a short term and long term even if it meansdepriving people of basic human rights for example. However does this mean thatdeontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties and that utilitarian ethics istoo keen to override basic human rights?According to a deontologist ones actions must be determined by a set of dutiesregardless of whether the long term consequences are good or bad. A deontologistbelieves in human morals and that every human has certain rights and these morals andrights should not be betrayed no matter what the cost for example sacrificing one lifeto save one hundred lives would be unacceptable to the deontologist despite the factthe consequences would be better overall.The biggest problem with deontology is knowing which set of duties to follow,there could be a great variation in systems between people from different backgrounds,different social classes, different religions and people from different cultures. Forexample a Protestant English Lord would have different morals and a different set ofduties than a lower class Indian Hindu. It is very difficult to tell which set of duties, ifany, is the right one.Deontologists suffer many problems when their duties seem to conflict withthemselves or with other duties. One has a duty to save lives but what if in order to dothis one must betray another duty for example a husbands sick wife needs life savingmedicine but the husband cannot afford to buy it, should he steal the medicine in orderto save his wives life or should he not betray his morals and allow his wife to die. Thisraises the question as to how do we tell which duty is the most important and which isthe least? If the consequences of each are to be considered then this would make it aconsequentialist view and not a deontological one. Single duty conflicts cause just asmany problems such as two people imminently need a heart transplant but only oneorgan is available, a deontologist has a duty to save lives but on this occasion only oneout of the two can be saved. This is known as the doctrine of double effect and is saidthat since it is impossible to save both lives, ones duty to save lives has not beenbroken.Deontology does encounter many problems but also has a number of merits.Since deontologists refuse to betray human rights, every human is guaranteed theserights will not be broken. Deontology would also normally let justice prevail and this isa good quality indeed.According to Utilitarianism On Liberty by John Stuart Mill, mankind is underthe governance of two sovereign masters one being pleasure and the other being...

Find Another Essay On Deontological ethics is too rigid in its emphasis on duties, utilitarian ethics too keen to override basic human rights.

What is meant by the term 'Situation Ethics' and is Love too general a term on which to make Moral Decisions?

2480 words - 10 pages not always possible if you want to abide by the law. Although it is necessary to love, to what extent is it necessary to love at all costs?Situation ethics is also considered an adolescent ethic in some circumstances. In other words it is arrogant, as it turns its back on laws and traditions. A lot of these laws and traditions come from the bible, so therefore agape can be considered self defeating. It is not practical to follow this ethic as we

Business Ethics With Special Emphasis on Asia

2251 words - 9 pages what is right or wrong, and then doing the right thing -- but the "right thing" in not nearly as straightforward as conveyed in a great deal of business ethics literature. However, ethicists assert that there is a right thing to do based on moral principle, and others believe the right thing to do depends on the situation.http://www.uwm.eduWhat is Business Ethics?This is just an extension of the definition above and means to know what is right or

Animals Have Rights Too

530 words - 2 pages Most human beings are inherently speciesist; meaning that they believe one species is superior to another. (Singer, Peter. Animal Liberation. Harper Perennial Modern Classics, 2009. 6. Print.) It can be argued that this is just an expansion of the hardship of human equality, and just as we were once desensitized to others race or gender, we are now doing the same to animals. In addition, we don’t give much thought to what goes on beyond our own

Situation Ethics, Natural Moral Law And Utilitarian Approach To Sexual Ethics - Philosophy and Ethics - Essay

1607 words - 7 pages ‘Demonstrate The Differences Between The Situation Ethics, Natural Moral Law And Utilitarian Approach To Sexual Ethics.’ In Christianity, sex before marriage is typically scorned. Therefore, Christian youth are advised to don ‘Purity Rings’ which symbolise their pledge to abstain from sex until they are married (however, Ariely claims that providing youth with condoms is more effective as they tend to behave irrationally when aroused and break

The Fallacy of Utilitarian Thinking - Introduction to Ethics - Essay

1365 words - 6 pages considering the inevitability of irrational predispositions, basic human attachment, and of contractual obligations in a normal society and by conceptualizing a community driven exclusively by utilitarian calculations, this essay will seek to conclude that Utilitarianism is a fundamentally flawed and ultimately implausible moral theory. [1: Smart, J.J.C., and Bernard Williams. Utilitarianism: For and Against. Cambridge University Press, 2008

Nietzsche: Human, All Too Human

1165 words - 5 pages Nietzsche has had one of the greatest and most profound impacts on philosophy and modern thought. Nietzsche was one of the first existentialism thinkers who coined the phrase “God is dead.” In other words, Nietzsche realized that all human beings wrestled with certain difficulties and existentialist in life that is all apart of being human. Many of Nietzsche’s work was determining and distinguishing the desire to know the struggles of life

Business Ethics: Deontological Ethics What do I believe?

1168 words - 5 pages CONFIDENTIALWhat do I believe?Ethical Theory: Deontological EthicsDeontological ethics relates to things such as duties, principles and obligations of individuals. I believe Kant's view is intended to show how there can be moral requirements that do not depend on whether the actions required produce good consequences. In making decisions based on this theory, it is important to treat people with respect, expect respect in return. The decision

Business Ethics Paper with titled "Monitoring Business Ethics in the US Pharmaceutical Industry". Essay analyzes industry using utilitarian theory

695 words - 3 pages consider the fact that U.S. companies are located in a capitalistic society, where basic rights of property protection (including patent rights) take precedence over the right to life.12 U.S. policies in general, are based on the principle of Adam Smith and "an invisible hand" concept, which advocates that "competitive markets are the best means for attaining utilitarian goals" (Desjardins, 2003, p. 30). 13 Pharmaceutical companies claim that rising

Ethics and its Relation to Leadership

977 words - 4 pages power and essentially will gain power by doing so. If ethics were used on a daily basis in every company there would never be scandal. Ethics can’t be neglected. This is because business is usually about doing what is best for number one, not about what is right thing to do. Martha Stewart comes to my mind when speaking about ethics. There is feeling of uneasiness when dealing with this topic. Why is it like

Immanuel Kant's Ethics Of Pure Duty and John Stuart Mill's Utilitarian Ethics Of Justice

2730 words - 11 pages will always be morally and ethically right. Kant was the key advocate in history of what is called deontological ethics. Deontology is the study of duty. On Kant's view, the sole feature that gives an action moral worth is not the outcome that is achieved by the action, but the motive that is behind the action. Kantian belief is that free will is indispensable to morality. To be moral is to do something because it is the right thing and to do

Biomedical Ethics: Human Clonging

960 words - 4 pages Biomedical Ethics: Human Cloning In February 1997, Scotland announced the first successful cloning of an adult sheep. Due to this historic scientific breakthrough by Ian Wilmut and his colleagues, the cloning of humans is becoming closer to reality and is open for public scrutiny. For those who are against human cloning, cloning presents as much a moral problem as a technical problem. Ethically, cloning humans is inconceivable and there is not

Similar Essays

Deontological Ethics Essay

1233 words - 5 pages Deontological Theory of Ethics Introduction      When ethics is explored, and an inquiry into its origin and sources are explored to find definition and clarity around ethics, one initial discovery will be that two main views on ethical behavior emerge. One of those theories is the deontological theory of ethics. Ethics and ethical decisions surround themselves around what is the goodness or badness of any particular

Utilitarian Ethics Essay

417 words - 2 pages greater good of the sheep population in the future you should kill all your sheep, regardless of whether or not their showing signs of this disease.The utilitarian view on suicide is my main reasoning for going towards the utilitarian philosophy of ethics. There are too many situations in which I believe that suicide in morally right, examples being the terminally ill, some situations dealing with loss of a function or limbs (paralysis), and any

Exploration Of Deontological Ethics Essay

1289 words - 5 pages Exploration of Deontological Ethics Deontological ethics is concerned not with the action itself but the consequences of the action. Moral value is conferred by virtue of the actions in themselves. If a certain act is wrong, then it is wrong in all circumstances and conditions, irrespective of the consequences. This view of ethic stands in opposition to teleological views such as utilitarianism, which hold the view

Ethics Within The Meat Packing Industry, Comparison Of Utilitarian And Deontological Perspectives

1667 words - 7 pages unnerving. The fact that the conditions were "overly" dangerous and the fact that there seemed to be no adherence to any safety standards in the industry caused the group to take action. "Working conditions in the U.S. meat and poultry industry are so hazardous and the tactics that employers use to prevent workers from organizing so threatening that the industry consistently violates basic human rights. In sum, the United States is failing to meet its