This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Deontology And Utilitarianism: Ethical Theories For Nurses

1383 words - 6 pages

Deontology and Utilitarianism: Ethical Theories for Nurses
Ethics is not a concept that is thought about often, but it is practiced on a daily basis. Even while unconscious of the fact, people consider ethics while making every choice in life. There are many theories to which people allude, but two radically different theories that are sometimes practiced are deontology and utilitarianism. Deontology deals with actions in a situation while utilitarianism examines the consequences of those actions. While polar opposites on the broad spectrum of ethics, deontology and utilitarianism are bioethical theories that can be applied to nursing practice and personal life situations.
Kant’s Deontology
German philosopher Immanuel Kant popularized the philosophy of deontology, which is described as actions that are based on obligation rather than personal gain or happiness (Rich & Butts, 2014). While developing his theory, Kant deemed two qualities that are essential for an action to be deemed an ethical. First, he believed it was never acceptable to sacrifice freedom of others to achieve a desired goal. In other words, he believed in equal respect for all humans. Each human has a right for freedom and justice, and if an action takes away the freedom of another, it is no longer ethical or morally correct. Secondly, he held that good will is most important, and that what is good is not determined by the outcome of the situation but by the action made (Johnson, 2008). In short, he simply meant that the consequences of a situation do not matter, only the intention of an action. Kant also declared that for an act to be considered morally correct, the act must be driven by duty alone. By extension, there could be no other motivation such as love, family, or lust. Finally, Kant stated that an action must be absolute in order to be deemed morally correct (Rich & Butts, 2014). In other words, an act must be able to be applied to all situations to be seen as acceptable. Like the Golden Rule, a person should not perform an act that he would not want done to himself such as infidelity, lying, or stealing. While most consider these examples to be negative behaviors, is it safe to say that these should be an absolute? Kant stated that for an action to be considered moral, it had to be an absolute truth (Johnson, 2008). With Kant, if a parent told a child that Santa was real, which technically is a lie, or if someone lied about a surprise birthday party, it would be considered a horrible act.
On the other hand, utilitarianism, or teleology, consists of the concept that an action or deed is weighed by the amount of goodness or happiness it produces (Rich & Butts, 2014). Basically, no action or rule is considered morally wrong or right until it is weighted against the amount of pleasure it created. Where deontology focused on the action of a situation, teleology is primarily concerned with the consequences of the action. One of its famous promoters,...

Find Another Essay On Deontology and Utilitarianism: Ethical Theories for Nurses

Ethical Dilemmas Faced by Nurses and Other Healthcare Professionals

2778 words - 11 pages sufficient, nurses must advocate for the patient by contacting the physician. By doing this, nurses are working for the good of the patient that may unable to verbally express their pain and perspective. Autonomy is the ethical principle which involves recognizing the rights of individuals and their self-determination. (Gastman, 2013). Healthcare professionals must respect all individuals that they interact with and provide care to. Often time

Critisism for Rule and Act Utilitarianism

1379 words - 6 pages “Utilitarianism is the view that the supreme principle of morality is to act so as to produce as much happiness as possible, each person counting equally” (Mill, 114). By ‘happiness’, this includes anything that is pleasurable and free of pain. Simply put, utilitarianism is the theory that an action is right, as long as it produces the greatest good for the most number of people (Peetush). The central point to this theory is that one must

Principles and Standards for Reistered Nurses

1241 words - 5 pages keeping them free from harm and respecting the individual’s values and wishes. Ethical Principles and Theories Ethical principles and values influence my own practice in nursing. In the journal, Ethics and Nursing Research1: Development, Theories and Principles Noble-Adams discusses beneficence, respect for human dignity, justice, and autonomy. These ethical standards help to keep the patient free from harm. During bedside procedures, for

New Managerial Tools and Technology for Nurses

1236 words - 5 pages New Managerial Tools and Technology for Nurses The purpose of this paper is to review some of the managerial tools and technology used my nurse managers to promote managerial control and increase performance of employees. The days of sitting at nurses’ station and hand writing the documentation into the patients’ chart are long gone. While it did take longer to establish computers into the world of patient care, computers have evolved to

Quality and Safety Education for Nurses

996 words - 4 pages patients and pay special attention to their body language. As is it well known that non-verbal cues are more eloquent than words. Arguably, LaValley (2008) claims that nurses attempt primary the patient’s urgent need and communication is neglected. Concerns for improving patients' lives should never supersede the needs for adequate and meaningful communication. The underlying causes of clinical event can be hidden on a facial expression or body


2143 words - 9 pages experiences. They derive their reasoning from theories such as utilitarianism, deontology, virtue ethics and relativism to explain their actions in a morally challenging circumstance. When deciding rules, regulations and guidelines to be followed in a business organization, everybody experiences the challenge of agreeing with one’s idea without argument due to the complication of dealing with human nature. Therefore, business industries are trying

Compare and Contrast two ethical theories

2167 words - 9 pages means.Fletcher's theories are almost the exact opposite of Kant's views. Fletcher believed that there are three types of ethical theories; legalistic ethics, antinomian ethics and situation ethics. Deontology would be considered legalistic as it uses moral law as a set of prefabricated rules - much like in Christian traditions, which focus on natural moral law and the commandments from the bible. According to Fletcher this would lead to problem s when life's

Finding an Educational Standard for Nursing Students and Practicing Nurses

1444 words - 6 pages With the demand for nurses at an all-time high and more individuals entering the nursing profession, the question must be posed of what the educational standard for students entering the nursing profession should be? Although this debate has been prevalent for some time, the rising demand for registered nurses resurfaces the question with more emphasis and urgency than ever. While associates degree in nursing (ADN) programs made up roughly 60

Pocket Digital Assistants And Use For Staff Nurses

3074 words - 12 pages , approximately 25,000, of all nurses were using the PDA in their practices. Currently the PDA is used in a fairly limited manner. Many people use the PDA as a personal organizer, memo pad and phone book whereas many healthcare professionals use it as a resource for patient care. However, some healthcare professionals use it to organize patient data, track patient visits, in addition to writing and transmitting

The Golden Rule in Kant and Mill’s Ethical Theories

1615 words - 6 pages Ethics refers to what people consider good or bad and right or wrong. It is a theory dealing with values that relate to human behaviour; with respect to their actions and purpose. The two most important philosophers that deal with ethics are Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill. Kant’s ethical theory is Kantianism or deontological ethics. Mill’s ethical theory is utilitarianism. Both philosophers’ theories have many differences; Kant’s theory

Learning Theories and Implications for Educational Technology

1629 words - 7 pages Learning Theories and Implications for Educational Technology Abstract The theories of Vygotsky, Gardner, and Gagne present vary different models of learning. Vygotsky and Gardner see culture as an important factor in how a child learns, and see growth and development and individual thing. Gagne, however, focuses on a formal model of instruction, with the method used depending upon the content being taught. All three theories have a role

Similar Essays

An Examination Of Deontology And Utilitarianism In Deeply Moral Situations

1305 words - 5 pages An Examination of Deontology and Utilitarianism in Deeply Moral Situations Samuel Adams (1722 - 1803), an American patriot and politician, once stated, "Mankind are governed more by their feelings than by reason"[1]. This statement is significant, as it undermines two of the primary ethical doctrines in philosophy - the deontological perspective defended by Immanuel Kant (1724 - 1804) in Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals

Normative Ethics: Utilitarianism And Deontology: Module 1 <Tab/>Case Assignment<Tab/>

1375 words - 6 pages projections about their companies' future performance (Bell, 2008). Most investors had no idea that Congress had eliminated the liability of corporate executives for even deliberate lies. This is one of the most astonishing parts of the 1995 Act. (Bell, 2008)ConclusionIt has become evident that there are companies today who need to reevaluate their management's ethical behaviors and intentions. Though there are plenty of companies out there who are

Problems And Prospects For Utilitarianism Essay

1919 words - 8 pages This essay will deal with the problems and prospects for Utilitarianism, outlining the basic tenants of its philosophy and the problems that can occur while using it as a basis for moral living. It will outline, evaluate, and dismiss three different strands; act utilitarianism, rule utilitarianism and the last which is a combination of both. The history should be illustrated putting into context why utilitarianism was initially attractive; this

Ethical Dilemmas And Normative Theories Essay

1618 words - 7 pages Essay Questions: How does the situation facing John constitute an ethical dilemma? Using two normative theories of ethics comment on the ethical aspects of the situation. Business is an organisation or economic system where products and services are traded for money, a product or services. Businesses need investment or customers to make a profit and survive. In business, ethical issues may arise for example false advertising, misleading the