Deontology Will But Utilitarianism Will Not

1351 words - 5 pages

Deontology Will but Utilitarianism Will Not

My brother once introduced a song to me that described a scene so gruesome and so cruel that I could not help but shed a tear or two. This particular song was based on an experience by rapper, Immortal Technique. He encountered this in his youth when he was swept away by a lifestyle that promised riches and lavish things at a very expensive cost, the life of a gangster. The song starts off with a solemn tune and then moves on by telling the tale of Billy, a feeble young man desperate to prove he was evil; but what ever the case may be his greed over took him and he then decides to roll with the big thugs. Unfortunately, for Billy at least the crew he wants to be a part of doubts him and decides to test him; his test is that he must help rape a young woman and then kill her. Billy now has a choice either return to his old lifestyle or become a real gangster and be part of the crew, and once again his greed overtakes him and he decides to go through with it. They find a woman going home coming from work, they decide that she is their target. They take her to the top of the roof under the dark-lonely night and proceed to brutally rape her, one after the other, and in the end Billy finds out that this forsaken woman is his own mother and doesn't hesitate to kill himself there after (Immortal). Under the principle of utilitarianism this rape will be justified as the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Since there were more people deriving pleasure than pain the gruesome rape of Billy's mother is justified only because the ratio of happiness versus pain is three to one. Is this fair, or should there be a better way to think about things?
Given the same scenario how would deontology manage this act? Deontology is based behind the idea “act in such a way where you always treat humanity whether in your own person or in the person of any another, never simply as means, but at the same time as an end” (O'Neill). In fewer words deontology would never justify an act so cruel and would absolutely never treat a human being as an object or mere means, but they will be treated with respect. Since the Billy's mother was treated as an object and not as the person she really is; this act is thus, forbidden. Although both theories have their pros and cons the theory of Deontology stands as the better theory because it will, for the most part, cause good not harm to the human race.
Nobody is ever perfect and this applies for theories as well. To verify this statement a pros and cons list is preferable. Beginning with utilitarianism an exceptional thing that can come from this ideology is the fact that most people can agree with the common truth: a good life is often associated with happiness, which is true right? To be happy or to establish pleasure should be the number one goal in life and if people could be happy their entire lifetime, and experience no pain why wouldn't they? Theoretically speaking, if...

Find Another Essay On Deontology Will but Utilitarianism Will Not

Gun Control Laws Will NOT Reduce Crime

1777 words - 7 pages staff. Many myths regarding gun control reducing crime have been abolished after years of research. Not only will stricter gun control laws or banning guns have little effect on reducing crimes, but it is unconstitutional to infringe on the right to bear arms according to the Second Amendment. Works Cited Fund, John. "The Facts About Mass Shootings." National Review Online | Print. N.p., 16 Dec. 2012. Web. 23 Oct. 2013. Garrett, Ben. "Who Is

Gun Control Laws Will NOT Reduce Crime

2339 words - 9 pages , gun laws will not stop them from obtaining the weapon. It is like a drug. Drugs are illegal, but every day you see someone either with, on, or recovering from a drug habit. What about for defense right to own guns to protect your family if part of your constitutional rights. Rights that are supposed to be unalienable rights. Although in this day in time, they are always trying to take away guns either by trying to pass laws or taxing guns and

Gun Control Will Not Reduce Crime

1367 words - 5 pages gun control laws. However, the problem will not be solved by taking guns away from people who are registered and licensed to carry them. Americans have never responded well historically to prohibitions. For example, during prohibition of alcohol, many ways were found to obtain alcohol illegally, Gun control could result in similar methods of obtaining weapons illegally. These already exists and gun control would make the problem worse. This

Police corruption can be minimised but will never go away.

2106 words - 8 pages society they are harvested from, and people being but only human, are not infallible. The single significant thing that these cases and history, as a whole, has shown is that if there be but one constant, it is human nature. Corruption is essentially criminal - a universal human condition. Consequently, crime and hence, corruption, though diminishable, will forever exist.BIBLIOGRAPHYBarker, T. & Carter D.L. (1993), Police Deviance, 3rd edn

Private Schools Will Not Fix the American Education System

1411 words - 6 pages do not emphasize the importance of a quality education. However, according to the democratic principle, their children should be able to receive the same small classes, up to date textbooks and motivated teachers as offered by private schools. Change will not be easy to enact, and I believe it must begin at the national level. I know the suggestions of governmental discouragement of private grammar and secondary schools seem radical, but it

"School to Work Will Train, Not Educate" By Phyllis Schlafly.

941 words - 4 pages not going to go on to a four-year college, but instead this program allows students to get a well-grounded idea of what to expect when they actually get out into the workforce.Instead of going through the "traditional function of education (of) ... reading, writing, math, science, history, etc.," as Schlafly argues should be followed, some students want to focus more on what they believe they will actually have to do when they finish the program

Small Change: Why the Revolution Will not be Tweeted

1895 words - 8 pages social movement and effective social action, as opposed to whether it can serve as a satisfactory substitute for that process. Referring to the previous stated example, a phone is certainly not a branch of government, but a phone if properly utilized can mobilize a large group of people to vote for changes in the particular branch of government in question. When Malcolm Gladwell proclaims that the "the revolution will not be tweeted," he is basically

You Can Shave the Beast, But Will the Fur Grow Back?

1930 words - 8 pages -fed images of hate-drenched violence penetrated our consciences. Now, we are immune, desensitized. It's okay to hate, for there's no one to love. Having pondered this, I've told myself that this attitude can't possibly evolve into a formula for happiness, but being too busy clawing and biting my way around the real world, I was not keen enough to contemplate change yet. I wonder if I acquire an education, will I become human or merely a smarter

Fate, Destiny and Free Will in Robert Frost's The Road Not Taken

1229 words - 5 pages The Road Not Taken:  The Paradox of Free Will Robert Frost's poem, "The Road Not Taken", is a profound philosophical approach illustrating the paradox of free will.  In the first line, Frost uses the metaphor "Two roads diverged" (1), to establish not only the dilemma of the traveler in the poem, but life itself.  The decisions we make in life, like the traveler in "The Road Not Taken", are not to be taken lightly.  There is a

A Narrative written about a girl struggling on if she will have an abortion or not.

1142 words - 5 pages find out?” “What will Jack think?” Then another kind of thought crossed her mind. “An abortion!” she said out loud. She thought about this and how it could save her pain and months of labor and maybe even some embarrassment when her friends find out that she is pregnant. Then the other side of this situation was that that will be killing a baby, murdering a living thing. Ally did not like the thought of that but she was still torn between yes and no

"We cannot assume that early inadequate experience will some how be cancelled by later experience. Lasting consequences of early inadequate experiences may be subtle and complex...But there will be...

1491 words - 6 pages "We cannot assume that early inadequate experience will some how be cancelled by later experience. Lasting consequences of early inadequate experiences may be subtle and complex...But there will be consequences" (Sroufe, 1979). Discuss.Alan Sroufe (1979) stated that lasting consequences of early inadequate experiences may be subtle and complex but there will be consequences. Whilst there are numerous ways in which these consequences may manifest

Similar Essays

My Computer Will Not Turn On

1595 words - 6 pages , 2014) Tim Fisher, “How To Fix a Computer That Turns On But Displays Nothing”, (, [Online], (accessed April 18, 2014) Tim Fisher, “How To Fix a Computer That Shows No Sign of Power”, (, [Online], (accessed April 18, 2014) My computer will not turn on, Puget Systems, [Online 2014], https

School Uniforms Will Not Reduce School Violence

1565 words - 6 pages not help students personally, either. Not all clothing fits students the same. Society is made up of different body types and uniforms are just that, uniform. Wearing something that does not fit right is extremely uncomfortable and distracting. If a student sitting in the classroom is trying to pay attention to a lesson, but has to constantly adjust their clothing in a worthless attempt to get comfortable, this can be extremely disruptive to the

Shifting Blame Will Not Resolve Our Problems

1145 words - 5 pages not need such a forum to sit down together and seek to find consensus on key issues. They could always to that but seldom do. So there is some room for suspicion as to the real intent of creating the high-level mechanism. In the worst case scenario, the mechanism will work as the super government and undermine the de facto government. This body has had such ambitious personalities as Girija Prasad Koirala, Pushpa Kamal Dahal, both former prime

My Computer Will Not Turn On

1426 words - 6 pages this is correctly done, attempt to mount the CPU, and if it does not slide correctly into the socket, try repeating the process over. Do not attempt to shove or jam the CPU, this will cause more bent pins, and can possibly cause the CPU to break. Another technique that seems very unique involves a sewing needle and a mechanical pencil (.55mm mechanical pencil). Basically what you would want to do first is locate the bent pin. But be careful