Descartes And His &Quot;Crazy Thought Experiment&Quot;

1476 words - 6 pages

(a) Descartes' first meditation, on what can be called into doubt, is an attempt to discard everything that he has come to be known as true and existing. One might wonder what point there is to adopting such a sceptical way of thinking as, surely, it would only bring about much confusion and a kind of awkwardness which, I think, is unnecessary. However, it is only fair to fully consider an argument before criticising it. I will therefore discuss, in detail, Descartes' "Evil Demon" thought experiment; as to what type of information is it designed to undercut, and how it accomplishes the task of dismissing all his knowledge, opinions and beliefs as false.

In his pursuit of certainty, Descartes applies a special method that he has devised, known as "methodical doubt." As applied, methodical doubt has two steps; the first of which is to doubt everything that can be doubted, and secondly, never to accept anything as known unless it can be established with absolute certainty. Descartes does not analyze each and every one of his beliefs in an attempt to prove that all are fallacious. Instead he chooses to start with the principles upon which all his, now former, beliefs rested. He says that all that he has accepted as truth, until now, has come to him through his senses and further goes on to say that these senses are not trustworthy in the sense as they have deceived him before and, for this reason, are not to be trusted.

He asserts that our senses deceive us by referring to dreams. This is because, in our dreams, senses are still our most trusted source of judging truth, yet none of it really exists, questioning reality to the extent of thinking hat he might actually be dreaming instead of sitting by the fireplace. Dreams, he says, are like paintings; they are but a mere manifestation of what is real; they themselves can never represent anything that is truly unique to our imagination because they based on our imagination. Descartes' suggestion is, who is to say that our senses aren't deceiving us while we are awake, or are we even awake? There's no way of being sure of the truth because in both forms (awake, or dreaming) we base our perception on our senses. For this reason, we can never accept things that come to our knowledge through our senses as truth.

He then goes to mention God's role in all the deception that is taking place. He is confused because is convinced that God is supremely good and would not allow him to be deceived like that yet, he allows him (Descartes) to be deceived. Those who do not believe in an almighty and supreme Lord, he continues, should be even more convinced that they've been deceived ("the less powerful they make my original cause, the more likely it is that I am so imperfect as to be deceived all the time - because deceptions and error to be imperfections" ). This is where the idea of an `evil demon' comes into play. He wonders if the God he has always believed in might actually be a malevolent...

Find Another Essay On Descartes and His "Crazy Thought Experiment"

Sonnetts; "The Long Love" and "Love That Doth Reign"

821 words - 3 pages of these translated sonnet mirrors their respective poets' strength and distinguished conception of `love'. The sonnets deal with the speaker who loves a lady, but she will not permit him to declare his love. It is the portrayal of emotions complaints and personal expression of love by lover. Wyatt's sonnet is the insightful representation of the poet's dual observation of love. He exposes two sides of love, physical and spiritual but there is

A Close Ananlysis of "Daddy" and "Zonnebeke Road"

1885 words - 8 pages impression the men feel that the more savage they are and the more hatred they build up towards the enemy, the more chance they have of survival; the less they care, the better their chances are of winning the battle. The poem "Daddy", written by Sylvia Plath, deals with the subject of her relationship with her late father. It describes her feelings towards him when he was alive and how she dealt with his memory after he died. Although there

Immunity to Nihilism in Turgenev's "fathers and Sons"

843 words - 3 pages was a nihilist!", he thought. Arkady Nikolaivich's nihilism, though, is not on principle, but rather for convenience and for the pride it gives him in feeling superior to his father and uncle. When nihilism later becomes a burden prohibiting him from romanticism and romantic love, he abandons it in favour of the married life. Although at first, he even went as far as believing himself to be a nihilist, the deep instillation of the values of his

Symbolism and the Theme of Incest in "The Fall of the House of Usher"

776 words - 3 pages sister Madeline are products of incest and this haunts Roderick's mind and causes him to go crazy. When he does finally snap, he buries his sister alive in the basement. This is ironic, because in the beginning of the story Roderick has a painting of an underground chamber, which also is foreshadowing what is to come in the story. When he buries her, he thinks that if she is dead that the family curse will be broken, but she comes back and

A Correlation Between the Corpus Callosum and "developmental Language Disorders"

3785 words - 15 pages people with dyslexia, developmental learning disorders, reading disabilities, central auditory processing disorders, and x-linked adrenoleukodystrophy. Auditory processing of language in a normal brain is thought to encompass the entire brain and that is a major reason why it so difficult to come to an agreement on how language is processed (Obler and Gjerlow, 1999). A very popular model though is the Personal Model proposed in the early 1980

Cognitions on Craft and Culture in "My Last Duchess"

1515 words - 6 pages call of a female cat in heat (Merriam-Webster 156). ...    Such stuff Was courtesy, she thought, and cause enough For calling up that spot of joy. And so the Duke artfully invites his listener to compare the morality of the late Duchess' interactions with other men to the behavior of a cat.  Ironically, the clearest revelation, of course, is the pettishness of the Duke's own character. Browning weaves more ironic word

Loyalty, Honesty and Trust in "The Conscience of the Court"

1066 words - 4 pages give in and speak up on her own behalf. Laura makes a point of stating that she did bar Beasley from Celestine's home when he tried to enter and take her wealth of antique furniture and sliver. When he refused to defer his attempts she was forced to take action against him in order to prevent his unwelcome entry and theft of Celestine's property. An unusual aspect of this story becomes apparent when the judge decides to come to Laura's aid

Descartes and his theories

653 words - 3 pages 'I think therefore I am.' Man wills, refuses, perceives, understands, and denies many principles. As explained by Rene' Descartes, man is a thinking thing, a conscious being who truthfully exists because he is certain that it is so. All that man perceives is internally present and not external to him or his mind. The focal point of the third meditation that must be dealt with is: Can one perceive or confirm the existence of an idea or object

Comparing and Contrasting "My Papa's Waltz" and "Piano"

923 words - 4 pages In comparing and contrasting the poems, "My Papa's Waltz" by Theodore Roethke and "Piano" by D. H. Lawrence, the reader could also compare and contrast the childhood lives of the poets themselves. Roethke's father, Otto Roethke, was a drunk and a figure of terror to his son (Seager 26). His mother was an angry woman and Theodore was a desperate child consistently in the middle of his parent's opposition (Seager 28). D.H. Lawrence's father was a

Comparing and Contrasting "The Ring" and "Ringu"

1332 words - 5 pages Asakawa is speaking to the teenage girls, the scene seems as though all the actors are reading from cue cards and there is no real feeling in their voices. Although I can mostly credit my opinions on the cultural cinema differences and inability to understand verbally what the characters were saying, I thought it was apparent that the acting in The Ring completely outdid any attempt at acting in Ringu. Although the differences in plot were

"Bag Lady" A Critique and Analysis

1803 words - 7 pages Erykah Badu's song "Bag Lady" is a prime example of the healing power of music, and the lessons that can be taught through music. Erykah Badu's "Bag Lady" serves as a wake up call for women across the world. From the first verse of the song until the last verse when the song begins to fade, Badu's words evoke feelings of emotion that women can relate to. Badu's lyrics also help women find some type of inner peace to get over their problems, in

Similar Essays

Tennessee Williams: His Life In &Quot;Suddenly Last Summer&Quot; And &Quot;The Glass Menagerie&Quot;

3627 words - 15 pages In the study of Tennessee Willliams' plays: "Suddenly Last Summer" and "The Glass Menagerie", we can find a great deal of autobiographical connections. "The Glass Menagerie" is particularly considered the author's most biographical work. It is described by the playwright as "a memory play"; indeed, it is a memory of the author's own youth, an expression of his own life and experiences. Similarly, "Suddenly Last Summer" includes many of Tennesse

Is Descartes' Evil Demon Thought Experiment A Stronger Argument For Global Skepticism Than His Dreaming Argument? If Yes, Explain Why; If No, Explain Why Not.

1134 words - 5 pages Is Descartes' evil demon thought experiment a stronger argument for global scepticism than his dreaming argument? If yes, explain why; if no, explain why not.Descartes defined global skepticism as all of our experiences, thoughts and everything we know to be true as dubious and deceptive. Therefore we are constantly being deceived and what we perceive to be true may not be true at all. In this essay I will attempt to show how Descartes's

Reflections And Interpretations On &Quot;Digging&Quot; Essay

1015 words - 4 pages close attention to are symbolism, imagery, persona and setting. If you look at each of these and then break the poem down, you will understand the whole theme of "Digging." In the first few lines of the poem you will be introduced to the setting of the poem, or where the poem takes place. It is here that you find out that the main character is looking out the window and listening to the sounds of his father working while he is in

&Quot;Stephen Spender Experiences And Influences&Quot; Essay

1513 words - 6 pages develop a very intense interest in their father's profession. More often than not, a person's family helps in shaping the person's future. A person is usually a portrait of where he comes from, what he has been through, the hardships he has seen and the experiences that he has had through his life. Stephen Spender was born in London, England on the 28th day of February in the year 1909. His father, Edward Harold Spender was a journalist and a