This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Descartes' Arguments For Immateriality Of Mind/Soul Based On The Notion Of Dualism: Body Is Extended Object And Mind/Soul Is Non Extended.

1858 words - 7 pages

Descartes' Arguments for the immateriality of the mind/soulDescartes is one of the rationalists, who believed that the only way to acquire knowledge is through reason; as opposed to empiricists, who thought it is possible only through sense experience. This shaped Descartes' view of human nature as dualism. He believed that human mind/soul and body are totally different entities. He defined mind as non-extended entity with notions of thought, sensation and imagination, where body as extended subject, occupying the space. So he based his argument of the immateriality of mind/soul on dualism. Firstly, he made it clear that the mind and the soul is the same thing and it is the self. From this he drew that the self actually exists by asserting that the ability to reason proves his existence. Then he moves to claim that the mind and body are distinct entities and that mind can exist without body. This would imply the possibility for an after-life, thus the immateriality of mind/soul.So Descartes starts his argument to prove immateriality of soul by asserting that self exists as mind/soul. After doubting everything in his Second Meditation, that is rejecting the possibility of the existence of extension, movement, senses and bodies, even his own; thus concluding that the only thing is certain that there is no certainty. But if he does not exist, what triggers these thoughts? So if the physical world does not exist, he does not exist as well? But by having all these doubts Descartes must exist. He formed the Cogito argument, involving the notion I am, I exist (Descartes, p.17). He defined this 'I' as the body, mind or soul with the attributes of nourishment, movement, sensation and thinking. He could doubt everything except that he can think and that he exists as long as he is thinking, therefore he concluded that 'I am a thing that thinks'.After proving that he exists, because he can reason about the world, tries to show that the body and mind/soul are distinct entities, concerning dualistic notion of self. He identified this as Real Distinction. This involved a substance which is not dependent on any other thing in order to exist; only god can interfere with it; while the mode is an attribute of that substance, which depends on not only God but also on the substance to exist. The example is given of a sphere; its shape is a mode of a sphere and it must be a three dimensional object in order to exist. Otherwise the conflict occurs as unextended sphere could not be perceived. On the other hand, the substance can be realized to exist independent from other objects. For example, a piece of wax exists by itself. The modes of shape and size belong to it. Therefore, if the wax piece was melted, the shape and size disappear. But the piece of wax is not an attribute of something else and does not depend on it, so the wax itself exists even without its properties. So Descartes demonstrates here, considering mind and body, that each thing can exist by itself and...

Find Another Essay On Descartes' arguments for immateriality of mind/soul based on the notion of dualism: body is extended object and mind/soul is non-extended.

Your Body, Your Mind, and Your Soul

701 words - 3 pages . That is what must get you up in the morning.      There are three main things that make up who you are, Caleb. Those three things are your body, your mind, and your soul. Your body is what other people can see and touch. It can be bent or broken, or bruised and abused. You must train your body to do what you want it to do. When you want to study, your body is not going to want to so it may become restless. You must control

Mind and Soul Essay

1348 words - 5 pages information of our surroundings based on sensory input. However, it is important to stress that Swinburne believes that the soul is not responsible for the functioning of a body, the life sustaining functions are carried out by the brain. Given this divide, we can see a system taking place wherein the soul serves our higher mental thought and the brain keeps the soul informed and regulates bodily function. In terms of the souls mortality

Descartes’ Arguments for the Existence of Body as Distinct from the Mind and His Justifications to Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia

1722 words - 7 pages that it is equally essential as thought, and later that it may be a non-essential, but still present, property of the soul (p.21). In both responses to Elizabeth, Descartes invokes three primitive notions. First, the notion of the mind: an essentially and only a thinking thing, known through understanding alone (p.18). Second, the notion of the body: an essentially and only an extended thing, known through the understanding aided by imagination

Descartes on the Mind and Body

834 words - 4 pages incorrect. As a result Descartes has not proved that there are two distinct substances in the world and thus his understanding of substances is incorrect. According to Descartes the two substances the world is made of are matter and the mind. He states that matter is defined by its ability to be extended in space, thus anything that takes up space can be considered matter . He states that the mind is the ability to think, this means that intellectual

Title: Mind and Body: An interpretation on the works of Rene Descartes and Benedictus de Spinoza -Talks about "Dualism" and "Double Aspect Theory"

1152 words - 5 pages dubitable. The first are material attributes, or extensions, such as "these general things (eyes, head, hands, the whole body) (233)" which Descartes goes on to explain "are true and exist (233)." Second is the category in which things are immaterial or un-extended, for example, the mind as a "thinking and un-extended thing (235)." In Descartes' point of view there is a clear distinction between the material and the immaterial. It is possible to

Descartes - Mind and Body

2270 words - 9 pages perceive. He begins to explore this notion that he had previously dismissed to doubt. He inquires whether his senses give him reason for bodies to exist. He comes to the conclusion that they do because God has given us "a great inclination to believe that these ideas proceeded from corporeal things." ( ) This proof progresses into the nature of how mind and body co-exist. Descartes beliefs are as follows: It is from nature that we distinguish other

How have dualist tried to explain the apparent two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism is the most plausible theory of mind?

1144 words - 5 pages or see the power of the spiritual mind, does not mean that it is non-existent. These arguments, combined with Descartes' Conceivability Argument, Spatial Location Arguments, etc, gives clear indication that a) the mind is separate from the body, and b) causal interaction between the mind and body exists.Parallelism is the theory of dualism that states it is by mere coincidence that the spiritual and physical worlds are running in succession, and

Personal Identity, refers to the mind, body, and soul; comments on the author John Perry

568 words - 2 pages ) cannot be based on bodily identity, for one can judge who one is without having to make any judgments about the body. Perry continues to elaborate on this by saying even if he woke up one day and found he had a different body or form (going as far as to refer to Kafka's The Metamorphosis) he would still be the same person (possessing the same character, beliefs, memories, etc.) Perry then identifies that at the heart of the soul and memory of a

Do all dualists believe that there is two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism – Cartesian dualism, parallelism, or epiphenomenalism – is the most plausible theory of...

1103 words - 4 pages Jake Radowski Do all dualists believe that there is two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism - Cartesian dualism, parallelism, or epiphenomenalism - is the most plausible theory of mind?The theory of dualism is based on the separating of the body and the mind into two types of substances-material and immaterial or material and mental. Substance dualists hold the belief the mind consists of spiritual stuff not

Mind Body Dualism

951 words - 4 pages cannot be divided, such as smell; there cannot be half or a quarter of a smell. The mind is not an a corporeal or extended substance like the body therefore it is not capable of being divisible. Since the body and the mind do not share the same property of being divisible or indivisible the mind and body are distinctly different. Descartes claim for mind body dualism can be seen as false, I will argue that the mind and body are not distinct as they

How far is Descartes’ Argument from Indivisibility successful as a justification for the need of a metaphysical distinction between mind and body?

841 words - 3 pages arguably best understood as an application of Descartes' notion of extension, first outlined in Principles of Philosophy, Book I, as constituting the "...nature of corporeal substance..." (Descartes, 1644). For Descartes, if an object is extended (res extensor), it is a physical thing which can be quantitatively described, and thereby divided. 
 Upon, what seems to be an almost prima facie consideration of the mind, Descartes reasons that he is

Similar Essays

Descartes’ Arguments For The Real Distinction Of Mind And Body

1915 words - 8 pages Descartes’ Arguments for the Real Distinction of Mind and Body Descartes argues has three main arguments for minds and bodies being two different distinct types of substance. These are known as arguments for substance dualism and are as follows. * The Argument from doubt : Descartes argues that while he could pretend or think that he had no body and therefore did not exist in any place, he could not think or

The Meaning Of The Mind And Soul

1059 words - 4 pages is used for communication with the body (Calef). Since we can arguably say that humans consist of two parts: The physical body, and the non-physical mind. It is fair to say that the mind does not have to obey the physical laws that influence the death of our bodies, and the mind can potentially live on in its non-physical form separate from space and time. However, I cannot argue as to what form our minds or soul will take, and what the

Essence Of Mind And Body For Descartes

1096 words - 4 pages with his argument for dualism, which is the possibility that the mind was distinct from the body. In Descartes' Mediations on First Philosophy, he is able to construct his arguments for the real distinction of mind from body, by understanding how the physical world operates based on the notions he sets. His claim will eventually be refuted because of his lack of understanding of how a non-extended mind affects an extended bodyDescartes' main

Analyzing Individuation And Identity In Descartes´ Philosophical View Of The Mind Body Dualism

1292 words - 5 pages entity may be intimately connected to the body, however the non-corporeal entity is not a material entity as is the body. Descartes has contributed several arguments for this belief , one them was the conceivability argument which necessarily involves a degree of tautology. Descartes states that since the idea of the separate existence of the mind and body is conceivable, that it is then possible. If the possible exist that two things can exist