This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Descartes’ Arguments In The Third Meditation

1531 words - 7 pages

In this essay I will be examining the logical impasse of not being able to attain certain knowledge without accepting the certainty of his sense of reason the meditator faces in meditations on first philosophy and discuss possible interpretations of the text that would explain the meditator’s use of circular argument.

The meditator’s endeavor in Rene Descartes’ meditations on first philosophy is introduced through a biographical account, with which any reader can relate. Realizing how in the past he had “accepted many false claims as true” and “how everything [he] had later constructed on top of those falsehoods was doubtful”, he feels the need to “tear everything down completely and begin from the most basic foundations”. His objective is to establish a body of knowledge which is absolutely certain.

To achieve this objective, the mediator takes two stages in meditations on first philosophy. The first is the demolition of what is uncertain and the second is the rebuilding of a new certain body of knowledge.

The process of demolition is reduced to the single task by the principle that knowledge is doubtable if what the knowledge is contingent upon is uncertain. Following the belief contained in the Aristotelian dictum that ‘nothing is in the intellect that was not first in the senses’, proving the uncertainty of knowledge gained from the senses is all that is necessary to prove that all the knowledge the meditator has about the world is uncertain. Tentatively beginning with cases in which he believes that he is misguided, such as optical illusions, he next resorts to more drastic measures, which he calls ‘hyperbolic doubt’. He imagines scenarios that would result in him being sensorially deceived such as hypothesizing that he is insane or that there is an omnipotent being making him sense what is not there. He rejects the insanity hypothesis saying that, “I myself would appear no less demented if I took something from them and applied it to myself as an example”. The reasoning here is that by hypothesizing his own madness he would invalidate anything he comes up with due to the inability of the mad self to reason correctly, and the exercise would thus be a self-defeating. This is an important move the meditator makes, because it is telling of his reluctance to cast doubt on his faculty of reason, which will be relevant to the main argument later on in this essay. The hypothesis the meditator does accept as rendering all perception doubtful, is the scenario where there is an all-powerful God using his unlimited capacity to make the mediator believe in not only the appearance of the external world, but in the existence of the external world itself when nothing actually exists.
Cast into a whirlpool of uncertainty, the meditator abortively grasps for something knowable until he finally feels something firm as he uncovers the famous cogito. Simply put, it is the idea that one’s existence is demonstrated by the fact that one thinks. But, again,...

Find Another Essay On Descartes’ arguments in the Third meditation

Meditation in the Religious World Essay

2106 words - 8 pages practiced by people of various religions in the world. Being mindful can help people cope with change and uncertainty, becoming more comfortable with the unknown, and avoid rigid, scattered thinking (Hall 16). Scientific studies have proven meditation is beneficial to the human body causing happier, healthier people who are less stressed and more attentive; thus using any of these various types of meditation is an effective way to improve quality

The Certainty of the Mind: Arguements from Rene Descartes' Meditation II

799 words - 4 pages It is human nature to question our origins and wonder if we have purpose in this world. Rene Descartes sought to answers these questions by examining himself and God through his Meditations. In Meditation II, Descartes believes his mind is certain because he is able to perceive and understand thoughts. His many questions lead him from one idea of certainty to the next. The explanations of these ideas are clear enough for his argument to be

Aristotle's speech from the Symposium and Descartes' epistemology from his Meditation

665 words - 3 pages competitor. It is not merely a rival force in these cases, it is a force that keeps reason from fully using its power. Lastly, passion can make someone impetuous. Here its victory over reason is so powerful that the latter does not even enter into conscious reflection until it is too late to influence action.Part II, Question 1:At the very start of the Meditation, Descartes writes that his reason for "making a clean sweep" and "beginning again

The Third Murderer in Macbeth

792 words - 3 pages magical and as elements of the supernatural.   Shakespeare intends for this unknown person to take part in the play to arise suspicion out of the audience. Out of the three main characters suggested as being the third murderer, each could be backed with evidence as to why they could or could not fill this role. Some arguments are superior to others, but none of them are so foolproof and clear that they offer a solution as to who this unknown identity is.   Work Cited Shakespeare, William.  Tragedy of Macbeth . Ed. Barbara Mowat and Paul   Warstine. New York: Washington Press, 1992.  

Conflicts in the Third World

1372 words - 5 pages In this essay I will discuss why the Third World has been the sight of most of the world's conflicts since 1945. The conflicts that have transpired have been mostly internal and not just between these countries and their neighbors. They range in wars regarding religion, liberation, rebelling, and civil wars to name a few. I will consider these conflicts and their make up in regards to countries involved in the most serious conflicts along

Descartes’ Arguments for the Existence of Body as Distinct from the Mind and His Justifications to Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia

1722 words - 7 pages comprehensive attempt to answer the question. In this paper I will examine Descartes’ arguments for the existence of body as distinct from the mind; outline Elisabeth’s objections and proposed solutions, and argue that Descartes’ responses to Elisabeth are inadequate to address the problem of mind-body interaction without resulting in contradiction. Descartes sets out in meditation six to determine what justification there might be for the existence of

The Mind-body problem in Descartes Meditations

1402 words - 6 pages Many people have tried to explain and interpret cognition over time. One of the earliest such philosophers was Descartes. He wrote many works on the subject, one of his most famous being the Meditations collection. The collection is also very beneficial to theories today, even though it needs to be refined to fit more modern ideasIn the third meditation, Descartes tries to prove God's existence and that He is not a deceiver, thereby allowing us

The Importance of God in Descartes' Philosophy

1299 words - 5 pages translation cannot always be correct. The main components of the proof are always present.In Descartes meditation III, Descartes uses the idea of perfection to prove that God exists. This is one interpretation of Descartes proof of the existence of God.1) I think, therefore I am.2) I cannot be mistaken about the ideas that I have.3) There can never be more objective reality in the effect (i.e., the idea) than there is formal reality in the cause (i.e

Give an account of Descartes' arguments from dreams, being careful to show which beliefs are allegedly undermined along the way

1842 words - 7 pages Rene Descartes (1596 - 1650) was not only a philosopher but also a mathematician and scientist. As a philosopher he used the notion of scepticism as a means to find truth stripped of all ambiguity. In 'meditations one: what can be called into doubt' Descartes states that he shall "doubt everything that can possibly be doubted"1 in order to build a belief system which is indubitable. Descartes attempts to ascertain which of his opinions are false

The Invisible Revolution in the Third World

1864 words - 8 pages caused corruption to flawlessly growing. This made Peru to become a third world corrupted state. Since the Peruvian mercantilism continue to decline. Obviously, it is impossible that it will regain social relevance and that the situation will not continue to deteriorate. In 1985, new government took office, “the minister of the interior informed Parliament that there had been 282 land invasions in Peru so far that year, 153 of which had

All Paths Lead to Love in the Practice of Meditation

1463 words - 6 pages All Paths Lead to Love The path which one chooses to follow is unique and often idiosyncratic in comparison to those around them. In the novel, Siddhartha, by Herman Hesse, the young protagonist quickly separated himself from the path of his brethren in search of his own destiny. Much is similar in Geshe Michael Roach’s Meditation and Jess Row’s For You, where the main characters of both short stories escape their comfort zones in search for

Similar Essays

Descartes Third Meditation: Proof Of Gods Existence

1350 words - 5 pages Descartes' Third Meditation: Proof of God's Existence In Rene Descartes Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes is seeking to find a system of stable, lasting and certain knowledge, which he can ultimately regard as the Truth. In his methodical quest to carry out his task, Descartes eventually arrives at the proverbial fork in the road: how to bridge the knowledge of self with that of the rest of the world. Descartes’ answer to this is to

Descartes' Fifth Meditation This Essay Provides Insight Into Descartes' Fifth Meditation And The Existence Of God

629 words - 3 pages In his Fifth Meditation, Descartes' attempts to once again prove the existence of God. He comes up with a number of examples that relate aspects from the material world in order to further his belief that God really does in fact exist. He states his theories favoring God's existence, most notably in his second ontological argument. At the same time he also presents several possible objections that could come into play, and refutes them

The Existence Of God: The Arguments Of Locke And Descartes

1366 words - 5 pages sensations and mental images exist in him as aspects of his thinking. He says that he knows definitively that he exists because he sees clearly and distinctly the composite parts that make up his entire self; therefore, anybody who says that he does not exist is making a false statement because he, as a thinking being, is able to clearly and distinctly grasp his being and thus it is true that he exists. Descartes' idea of God is one who is

Descartes’ Arguments For The Real Distinction Of Mind And Body

1915 words - 8 pages Descartes’ Arguments for the Real Distinction of Mind and Body Descartes argues has three main arguments for minds and bodies being two different distinct types of substance. These are known as arguments for substance dualism and are as follows. * The Argument from doubt : Descartes argues that while he could pretend or think that he had no body and therefore did not exist in any place, he could not think or