This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Descartes Man Vs Animal Essay

2056 words - 8 pages

     Movies and novels such as “Planet of the Apes” and 2001: A Space Odyssey are called Science Fiction because they portray situations that seem extremely unrealistic concurrent with contemporary philosophy. “Planet of the Apes” depicts a world where apes rule while humans are subjected to servitude and confinement. These apes speak intelligibly and are human-like in appearance and behavior. In 2001: A Space Odyssey, the highly advanced computer, HAL 9000, an acronym for “Heuristically programmed ALgorithmic computer,” controls the bulk of spaceship operation. It makes declarative statements, learns from mistakes and, in the beginning, interacts well with the crew. In both works non-human entities, apes in one and a robotic system in the other, make spontaneous declarations and perform functions based upon previously acquired “knowledge” which goes against what most consider to be normal animal/machine behavior, thus it is termed Science Fiction. In 1637, celebrated French philosopher and mathematician, René Descartes (1596-1650), published Discourse on Method, Optics, Geometry, and Meteorology in which he maintains that he had established two universal criteria to distinguish animals and machines from humans, and thus those entities without souls from those with. His criteria are the entity must have the capacity for speech and act from knowledge. His justifications that machines do not meet these two criteria are sound; however, he fails to verify that animals do the same. Descartes’ argument that humans have an infinite capacity to make appropriate responses is true as well as his implication that this capacity is non-material.
Descartes’ first argument is only humans have the capacity for speech. In the opening of Discourse on Method Descartes remarks that machines and animals
could never use speech or signs as we do when placing our thoughts on record for the benefit of others. For we can easily understand a machine’s being constituted so that it can utter words, and even emit some responses to action on it of a corporeal kind, which brings about a change in its organs….but it never happens that it arranges its speech in various ways, in order to reply appropriately to everything said in its presence. (Descartes)
Speech can simply be defined as the faculty or act of expressing or describing thoughts, feelings, or perceptions by the articulation of words, whereas talking is just an utterance of sounds. Therefore the argument can be reduced to a capacity for speech versus talking because speech, according to Descartes, requires some sort of non-materiel entity capable of the formulation of these statements, which he attributes to the soul. However, simply the utterance of sounds does not require any such entity. Since humans are the only animals that use speech, we must be the only animals equipped with a soul. He also points out that it is not the lack or organs or physical capacity that prevents speech and...

Find Another Essay On Descartes Man vs Animal

Descartes: true belief and knowledge Essay

3146 words - 13 pages ' (Pitte 458). Simply put, it implies that whatever thinks also exists. Having established this, he asked himself: "What is this 'I' which necessarily exists?" (Descartes 65). He now began to explore his inner consciousness to find the core of his being. He argued that he was a "rational animal" for this idea is difficult to understand. He scrutinized whether perhaps he was a body infused with a soul, but this idea was rejected since he could not be

Searching for the Origin of Psychology

2343 words - 10 pages neuropsychology, Descartes became my favorite philosopher because of his ideas of the mind, which later followed Galen’s ideas. Galen proposed that nerves are hollow and animal spirits flowed through them. Descartes proposed that nerves are hollow but fluid flows through them, which he liked to call the ‘hydraulic model’. This was a great discovery at the time, however, when Descartes presented his idea that humans were nothing but machines, it did not go

Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy

644 words - 3 pages B. MitchellK. HamstraPhilosophy RGC19 June 2003"For as long as I think; for it might perhaps happen, if I totally ceased thinking, that I would at the same time completely cease to be."-Rene Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy: Meditations I and II (Descartes, 26)I agree with Descartes' statement. In order to experience the world in its entirety, we must be able think. Without the ability to reason, human beings are just another animal

Existence of God Benedict De S

1989 words - 8 pages Existence of God Benedict De Spinoza vs. Rene Descartes In Spinoza's view God is a substance that includes eternal attributes and their necessity. One of the proofs for existence of such a substance is that something does not exist if and only if something else prevents its existence. For example, people walk on earth instead of flying on it, because there are rules of gravity that prevent people from flying on earth. Gravity influences

PHL 101

1520 words - 7 pages 1. Pascal’s wager is the name given to an argument that was present by Blaise Pascal who was a French mathematician, physicist, and philosopher. Pascal had a strong belief for God’s existence. The argument hypothesizes and attempts to prove that there is more to be obtained from venturing on the existence of God rather than the rejection of the existence of God. Pascal’s wager states that man loses nothing in believing in God instead of reason

The Right to Life and The Right to Liberty Analysis

1868 words - 7 pages animals. In Tom Regan's “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs,” he brings up Rene Descartes' argument that “because they lack the ability to use a language such as French or English” animals cannot have “any sort of mental life” (34). However, Regan brings up the argument that very young human children can not speak, yet “must be aware of things before they learn to use a language.” If we were not aware of our surroundings at a young age, we would never

Fantasy vs. Reality in J. M. Coetzee's Disgrace

1774 words - 7 pages from the sublime to the ridiculous; people will step over a man lying in his own urine to spit on someone wearing fur. It is not this sort of fanatical expression of concern for animals that is indicative of efficacious compassion, but more a general concern for their actual daily existence, an empathy, an acknowledgement of the soul, mortal, dark or otherwise. Animal ethicists seek to shed light on this soul by inserting normative values where

Cartesian Dualism vs Logical Behaviorism

1775 words - 7 pages logical behaviorism, being in a mental state (such as being surprised or angry) is the same as being in a physical state. How Ryle overcomes Descartes’ problem is with the solution that any statement about the internal realm of individuals can be translated into a statement about observable actions (Southwell). For example, the young man who stubbed his toe would say “Ow! I stubbed my toe,” and this would in turn be translated into a description of


2228 words - 9 pages they feel to man, but neither can children or the intellectually disturbed yet we do not consider that we have the right to use them in experiments.In addition, Evolution Theory states that man and animals evolved from simpler life forms, that man evolved from an animal form and is related to the Ape. If this is so, and Man is related to other animals, then the evolutionary scientist shouldn't be able to justify the inhumane treatment of animals


590 words - 2 pages man. But the animals wouldn't be able to reach success in the end. Napoleon ruins the animals' ideas of a perfect world completely. In Animal Farm, Orwell uses fable format as a vehicle for a savagely ironical allegory of how socialist political ideas became corrupted. The world is the real world but the talking animals are fantastic.Also in Bacon's The New Atlantis (1627), we see a utopian community of scholars and scientists who are very happy among themselves and live of the land they rule. The technical and social innovations, which have not taken place, may well happen in the future so utopian societies are fantastic

My Life, My Fantasy, My Philosophy

2033 words - 8 pages ourselves that our beliefs are justified. We cement our predisposed beliefs in a way that allows us to pick out certain instances that support this belief, rather than take in all the information available and thus arriving at a conclusion. We do just as Descartes did with his defense of God. There is another type of self-deception that I feel I must bring into account. We, as man kind, make ourselves believe, or disbelieve, something not

Similar Essays

Scientific Inquiry Of Bacon And Descartes

1219 words - 5 pages traditional Aristotelian school of thought, and each believed that the old scientific processes were useless in proving beneficial theories. Both men used God to support and justify their systems of scientific inquiry. Although Bacon and Descartes disagreed in their use of mathematics, and inductive reasoning vs. practical analogies, both contributed to improving the scientific process.Francis Bacon's scientific inquiry was based on induction, which

Descartes: Imagination Essay

2540 words - 10 pages notion of imagination. In Treatise on Man, Descartes explicitly locates both the "sensus communis" and the imagination on the surface of the pineal gland, upon which images both of sense and of memory or fancy are inscribed. Aristotle's conception of phantasia/imagination is closely bound up with the "common sense" or sensus communis. This is the part of the psyche responsible, among other things, for apprehending the so called "common sensibles

Pudh Essay

1483 words - 6 pages discourse by means of which they might make their thoughts understood,” however there are not any animals amongst the species that can even come close in doing so. The foundation of his argument focuses on the basis of language being one of the easiest tasks accessible to man, except animals. Descartes believes animals, or beasts, to be merely machines created by God who have organs similar to humans. Although these organs function in the same

Reasoning Within Animals Essay

1312 words - 6 pages Rene Descartes and David Hume lived in two completely different time periods, yet they shared interest in some of the same philosophical categories. Could animals reason? How did humans expand their knowledge compared to animals? Questions like these were answered both by Descartes and Hume even though they had two opposing views. Descartes was the first to address the questions about animal instincts, and later on Hume set out to refute some of