This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Descartes’s Conception Of Certainty And The Cartesian Circle

2632 words - 11 pages

Introduction
Descartes’s Meditations on First Philosophy are dedicated to establishing absolute certainty and “anything at all in the sciences that was stable and likely to last” (Meditations I.18). Descartes demolishes all his old beliefs and attempts rebuilds his foundations from the beginning. He employs a series of hyperbolic doubts and dismisses all his preconceived notions formerly taken for granted and works back to establish certainty in all his clear and distinct perceptions. Prima facie, Descartes’s philosophical arguments seem very logical and plausible. However, a closer look shows reveals Descartes seems to have committed the fallacy of epistemic circularity. The first such criticisms were raised by Arnauld in the Fourth Objections that Descartes “avoids reasoning in a circle when he says that it’s only because we know that God exists that we are sure that whatever we vividly and clearly perceive is true. But we can be sure that God exists only because we vividly and clearly perceive this” (CSM 2:150). Could Descartes have actually overlooked such an obvious circularity that could make all his ‘sciences’ fallible?
In my paper, I will introduce another interpretation of the Meditations to break free from the vicious nature of Descartes’s circle. I claim that the problem of circularity arises from an ambiguity in different ways of reaching the epistemic status of certainty. Rather than the his perceptions that serve as premises to the existence of a non-deceiving God being certain from the fact that they are absolutely free from doubt, these clear and distinct perceptions are certain through a different way, through what Descartes calls a “natural light.” While indubitability is a condition for certainty, proving a proposition’s indubitability is not the means by which the certainty of the proposition can be guaranteed.

Circularity and the 3M Premises
Let us take a closer look at Descartes’s arguments. His two broader arguments seem to unfold in a manner that is suggestive of a circle. More precisely, his arguments are as follows:

Arc 1: The conclusion that a non-deceiving God exists (Existence of God) is derived from premises that are clearly and distinctly perceived (i.e. 3M premises).
Arc 2: The general principle that propositions that are clearly and distinctly perceived are true (i.e. The Rule of Truth) is derived from the existence of a non-deceiving God (Existence of God).

Were the 3M premises not accepted because we knew the Rule of Truth? If Descartes was not certain about the Rule of Truth, how did he prove the existence of God from the 3M premises? The two arcs seem to form a vicious circle that can undermine each other mainly because Descartes uses the 3M premises that may not necessarily be epistemologically certain at the point of argument. In Arc 1, he seems to be using the Rule of Truth, which he proved in the Arc 2, in order to conclude that a non-deceiving God exists. On the other hand,...

Find Another Essay On Descartes’s Conception of Certainty and the Cartesian Circle

Faith's Movements in the Age of Certainty

2150 words - 9 pages Abraham’s situation. Much of this is derived from the demand for certainty that accompanied the age of reason, this newly scientific age characterized by philosophical processes. Certainty, as pursued by reason, prevents attainment of faith and complicates Abraham’s already paradoxical circumstance. Kierkegaard attempts to resolve the problem of faith and the possibility of its movements through both a poetic and philosophic discussion of the

The Circle of Fantasy Essay

774 words - 4 pages In the play Streetcar Named Desire, Tennessee Williams uses his writing to bring life to his characters in the story. One of the big themes is illusion. The play is all about illusion and fantasy to show how people are stuck in a circle of fantasy where they cannot get out of without any help. In the play A Streetcar Named Desire, by Tennessee Williams, the author shows fantasy through Blanche and Stella who escape from realities and act like

The Circle of Life

853 words - 4 pages Roger Allersand and Rob Minkoff directed the animated Disney movie, The Lion King. The particular song I will be discussing, “Circle of Life,” composed by Elton John and scored by Hans Zimmer, plays at the very beginning of the movie and serves as the introduction of Simba to the animal kingdom as well as to the viewing audience. The scene starts out with a sunrise and then cuts to numerous different camera shots of animals from all over the

The Circle of Life

979 words - 4 pages helplessness” when he discovered all his hard labor towards the field had been done for nothing (Markandaya 40). Nonetheless he accepted what had occurred, and reassured Rukmani that “the storm cannot last, and the storm will abate by morning” (Markandaya 40). The next morning the storm did stop, and Nathan made the most of it. He found tons of fish in the field, and he and his family ate them. Nathan never once complained or cried out. He knew

The circle of lies

1222 words - 5 pages insecurities and to create a false identity for himself due to his low self-esteem. Holden’s constant tendency to lie makes him lie in situations where he doesn’t have to. When Holden takes the train, he meets his classmate, Ernest Morrow’s mother. Holden does not like Ernest, much like most of the other boys at Pency, but Holden still tells Ms. Morrow how “He adapts himself very well to things. He really does. I mean he really knows how to adapt

The Platonic and Aristotelian Conception of the Soul

2456 words - 10 pages of their theories are quite similar in theme, however, Aristotle seemed to have adjusted or perhaps refined many of the Platonic theories on the soul. Themes such as immortality, functionality, and knowledge are all present in both philosophical works but each philosopher offers a different perspective. Plato's conception of the soul is an integral part of works, The Republic, and Phaedo. The microcosm and macrocosm analogies between an

The Hermeneutic Conception of Culture

4328 words - 17 pages values and norms turns out to be false because of the strong contextualism implicated by Heidegger's version of the hermeneutic circle. An hermeneutic conception of culture cannot provide what traditional theories of culture are expected to provide: universal standards, stability and elimination of relativism. Quite on the contrary, hermeneutics teaches us that all meaning is context-dependent and therefore unstable. The resulting conception of

Descartes and Knowing with Certainty of God's Existence

1075 words - 4 pages Descartes and Knowing with Certainty of God's Existence Descartes, Pascal, and the Rationalist Credo Pascal asserts that we can know only by the heart, whereas Descartes would have us believe through his truths that we can know with certainty of Gods existence. The factors that go into their views on reason will be compared and accented within this essay. The order of the universe is knowable to Descartes. He proves these by using

Satre's Conception of the Work of Art

1594 words - 6 pages We will first discuss what Sartre means by existentialism by expounding his twofold conception of being after which we will undertake his view on imagination and then try to support his view that all authentic works of art are unreal with examples of painting, drama, music e.t.c. This will also substantiate his view that there is no transition between the state of imagination and reality.Sartre maintains that existentialism is a doctrine that

Mill and Locke's conception of Freedom

1980 words - 8 pages John Locke believes that man ought to have more freedom in political society than John Stuart Mill does. John Locke's The Second Treatise of Government and John Stuart Mill's On Liberty are influential and potent literary works which while outlining the conceptual framework of each thinkers ideal state present two divergent visions of the very nature of man and his freedom. John Locke and John Stuart Mill have different views regarding how much

The Conception of Hero in Iliad

2153 words - 9 pages Joyce LanIntroduction to Western Lit., Friday 789Oral PaperJan, 4 2013The Conception of Hero in IliadGenerally, we regard Homer's epic as stories about hero, these heroes maybe have wisdom, chivalry, strong sense of manliness or meritorious military service. In Iliad, the sentence "hero" is used frequently in the text like character's dialogue and the narrator's words. However, the background of Iliad is in at least past two thousand years ago

Similar Essays

The Cartesian Circle Is Wrong Essay

1944 words - 8 pages it if not for a higher, supreme, infinite substance, we cannot doubt the existence of God. The reason we cannot doubt the existence of God is because of clear and distinct perceptions that God exist. To conclude, because of clear and distinct perception, Descartes conveys that God exists. Though his argument seems intriguing, Descartes argument has been treated with dubious standpoints. The reason of doubt, better known as the Cartesian circle

Alan Gewirth’s The Cartesian Circle Reconsidered

947 words - 4 pages . Gewirth’s response to critics of Descartes is that Descartes use different types of certainty to prove the existence and veracity of God compared to accuracy of clear and distinct ideas. The latter of these types of certainty, metaphysical certainty, is what he focuses on in The Cartesian Circle Reconsidered. Gewirth details three interpretations of why simple propositions are susceptible to metaphysical doubt: operational, conceptual, and

The Certainty Of Doubt Essay

941 words - 4 pages Everyone makes mistakes. Whether intentional or accidental, a mistake is a mistake, and one often tries to better it. My amma always told me, “It only takes one mistake for people to call you bad, but a hundred good deeds for someone to say you are good.” For some reason, people haven’t applied this “virtue” to St. Thomas the Apostle. He has been branded as “Doubting Thomas,” the one who didn’t believe until he saw the risen Christ in front of

The Significance Of The 'cogito' For Cartesian And Modern Philosophy

2186 words - 9 pages solutions and further criticisms of this so called Cartesian circle would warrant a paper in themselves so now I will orientate towards the wider effects of the Cogito on modern philosophy. There were French followers of Cartesianism immediately during and after Descartes life but for many other philosophers the questions of epistemology, method of science and philosophy of mind were well posited by Descartes but not well answered in the Cogito