This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay

1137 words - 5 pages

In the Sixth Meditation, Descartes makes a point that there is a distinction between mind and body. It is in Meditation Two when Descartes believes he has shown the mind to be better known than the body. In Meditation Six, however, he goes on to claim that, as he knows his mind and knows clearly and distinctly that its essence consists purely of thought. Also, that bodies' essences consist purely of extension, and that he can conceive of his mind and body as existing separately. By the power of God, anything that can be clearly and distinctly conceived of as existing separately from something else can be created as existing separately. However, Descartes claims that the mind and body have been created separated without good reason. This point is not shown clearly, and further, although I can conceive of my own mind existing independently of my body, it does not necessarily exist as so.
On page 56, when Descartes talks about how sailors are related to ships and why the mind body union is different, he is vague on the metaphorical analogy. To try to get his point across, dualism is used. Descartes is talking about something called interactionist substance dualism. He is stating that the mind and body causally interact with one another. This can be summed up to say that as easily as the mind can cause changes in the body, the body can also cause changes in the mind. Therefore the mind and body must be intimately united. An example of this is having the intuition to raise your hand. Your mind thinks about raising your hand and your body automatically does so. Contrary to this, if you step on a pin, your body tells your brain it has stepped on something sharp, thus causing pain, and your brain tells you that you have pain and to get off. In order to follow this, you must have a strong belief in the existence of God. For only God has the means necessary to make me certain that the two things exist separately of each other. This is because God is a perfect entity, and is capable of countless things whose true causes are beyond my knowledge.
To try to explain Dualism through God, we must talk about corporeal bodies and our knowledge of them. Regarding the nature of corporeal bodies and what is known about them and given Descartes premises, the conclusions he draws in Meditation Six are generally the correct ones. He again invokes the causal to argue that the ideas of bodies we have within our minds must be caused by something with at least as much formal reality as the ideas have objective reality. By saying this he means that a formal reality is expressed as an infinite substance, finite substance, or finite mode. And by objective, we are talking about ideas or representations that we have of these finite substances, infinite substances, and finite modes. One could theoretically be producing these ideas, but Descartes dismisses this possibility for two reasons; first, that the idea of corporeality does not presuppose thought and second, that our will...

Find Another Essay On Descartes Sixth Meditation

Descartes & John Locke Essay

2345 words - 9 pages establishes. In the First Meditation Descartes begins to examine what is certain and what is doubtful. Descartes wants to establish that his knowledge is certain and not doubtful. He states, ...I had accepted many false opinions as being true, and that what I had based on such insecure principles could only be most doubtful and uncertain; so that I had to undertake seriously once in my life to rid myself of all opinions I had adopted up to then, and

The development of the imagination, as examined by Descartes

1655 words - 7 pages . In addition, in the sixth meditation Descartes makes the argument that the imagination depends on something outside of ourselves, and therefore is not essential. The means by which he reached such a position will be explored through the relationship that exists between the imagination and the understanding. Through a critical analysis of Descartes reasoning this paper shall explore the different approaches that led him to his conclusion at the

Mind Body Dualism

951 words - 4 pages to doubt the existence of the body but not the mind. Descartes cannot doubt that he has a mind , but can doubt he has a body therefore Descartes is a thinking thing and not a body. He can exists as a thinking thing without a body because the body's existence can be doubted. Descartes continues the distinction in the Sixth Meditation, where he observes the body is by its nature divisible where the mind is completely indivisible. Descartes knows

Descarte's Meditation on First Philosophy: Sixt Meditation

1095 words - 4 pages Untitled Essay #2: Descartes In the Sixth Meditation, Descartes argues that, "there is a great difference between the mind and the body (59)." In this paper I will challenge Descartes' by showing that his idea of the mind and the body as two separate entities, or "mind body dualism" is invalid. At a very early stage in Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes attempts to rid himself of everything


1244 words - 5 pages The next stage in the system, as outlined in the Meditations, seeks to establish that God exists. In his writings, Descartes made use of three principal arguments. The first (at least in the order of presentation in the Meditations) is a causal argument. While its fullest statement is in Meditation III, it is also found in the Discourse (Part IV) and in the Principles (Part I §§ 17–18). The argument begins by examining the thoughts contained in

The Sixth Meditation And Material Falsity

1028 words - 4 pages The Sixth Meditation and Material Falsity In the Third Meditation, Descartes' meditator says that ideas are "as it were the images of things" (CSM II 25/AT VII 37). But just a few pages later, he says that material falsity "occurs in ideas, when they represent non-things as things" (CSM II 30/AT VII 43). How can an idea be of a thing, yet represent a non-thing? This problem has worried many of Descartes' readers, including his contemporary

Rene Descartes

2268 words - 10 pages doubts, understands, affirms, denies, is willing and unwilling, imagines, and has sensory perceptions, even if at times he cannot fully trust his senses. In Descartes’ Sixth Meditation he continues to identify what an individuals personal identity is by looking closer at the role of the body. Adding to the sensations Descartes described being related to a thinking thing, emotions. An individual feels emotions, which are reactions to other

Descartes' Second and Sixth and Meditations

1183 words - 5 pages Throughout Descartes second and sixth meditations there seems to be a tension rising between the fact of whether or not the mind and body are distinct. By analyzing both meditations it appears that Descartes’ perspectives are contradictory of each other and need to be further evaluated in order to reveal his true meaning. By saying, in the second meditation, that we perceive things by means of our intellect alone, and in the sixth meditation

Descartes' arguments for immateriality of mind/soul based on the notion of dualism: body is extended object and mind/soul is non-extended

1858 words - 7 pages mind is immortal or not.The Real Distinction arguments as Descartes defines it, is found the Sixth Meditation. In this argument he tries to convey the immortality of mind by this dualistic distinction between mind and body. So Descartes states that he has a 'clear and distinct idea' of himself as mind - non-extended object, and on the contrary, he has an idea of body as extended, non-thinking thing. So he concludes that he (his mind) is distinct

Descartes' Failure

5140 words - 21 pages Writings Vol 1. Discourse on the Method, p131 [8] Descartes Selected Philosophical Writings Sixth Meditation, p113 [9] Philosophical Writings Vol 1. Discourse on the Method, p120 [10] Descartes Selected Philosophical Writings Meditations on First Philosophy, p114 [11] Philosophical Writings Vol 1. Discourse on the Method, p127 [12] Descartes Selected Philosophical Writings Meditations on First Philosophy, p80 [13] ibid. p82 [14

Objections to Descartes’ Interactionism

1582 words - 6 pages , Concerning the Union of Mind and Body." The Essential Descartes. Ed. Margaret Dauler Wilson. New York: New American Library, 1969. 37380. Print. Descartes, René. "Sixth Meditation: The Existence of Material Things, and the Real Distinction between Mind and Body." Meditations on First Philosophy. Ed. John Cottingham. New York: Cambridge UP, 1996. 5062. Print. Descartes, René. "The Passions of the Soul, Part I." The Essential Descartes. Ed. Margaret Dauler Wilson. New York: New American Library, 1969. 35368. Print.

Similar Essays

Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay

1368 words - 5 pages , as they are two very close entities, although the body cannot exist without the mind, like the mind can without its extension. Descartes sixth very conclusive meditation has similarly to the first very basic concepts. What makes Descartes meditations so remarkable is his methodological approach to his philosophy. He starts right at the foundation of knowledge building his own basis and thoroughly working himself upward. Even though some of his

Descartes’ Ultimate Purpose Of The Meditations

1836 words - 7 pages deviating from the Cartesian method, since Cartesian method relies heavily on the doubt of everything (Descartes: 15-16). If Descartes is presupposing God, he cannot doubt God; therefore God’s existence cannot be proved with the Cartesian method. “There can be no reliable knowledge until after God’s existence is proved;” (Cottingham: 48) since God is not proved in the third meditation, the fourth, fifth and sixth meditations cannot be

Descartes Philosophy Of The Mind Essay

946 words - 4 pages the wax is applied to various situational environments, the characteristics of the wax change. However, one thing stayed constant in that no matter what changes the wax underwent it remained to be wax (77,2). So no matter what would happen to his physical body Descartes would always remain to be Descartes. This is why Descartes finds him self to be a non-extended thinking thing.In the sixth meditation Descartes points out that he is closely

Is God A Deceiver? Essay

1245 words - 5 pages Rene Descartes, in Meditations on First Philosophy, dedicates his third meditation to attempting to prove the existence of God, an omnipotent, infinite and perfect being. He presents two arguments, both of which end with him concluding that God exists. However, there are gaps in his arguments and contradictions in his writings that lead one to believe otherwise. Through the course of this paper, I will discuss whether Descartes contradicts