Describe The Nature Of A Totalitarian Regime, And Compare And Contrast Hitler's Nazi Regime With That Of Stalin In Communist Russia

3998 words - 16 pages

In order to accurately compare and contrast Hitler and Nazi Germany with that of Stalinist Russia it is important that we first discuss and fully understand the nature of the totalitarian regime. This will be achieved through an illustration of each separate entity of the totalitarianism system of state bureaucracy; economy management; legislature and the executive. The restriction placed upon civil society achieved through established social control agencies such as the police and judiciary and then the importance of the military machine to the totalitarian regime. Further, to understanding the similarities and differences between Germany and Russia it is important that we discuss both countries in terms of their political history and the resulting effect on their economies and how both Hitler and Stalin used these to develop and support their own 'cult of personality's'. Finally it is essential to the question that we examine both fascism and communism and show how both these ideologies although at different ends of the political spectrum were used respectively to achieve and support powerful nations based on state supremacy and nationalism.The reality of the totalitarian state is a terrifying form of government, centring mainly upon the personality of the chosen leader and the ideology of a single political party, but it also excavates elements of anti-Semitism and European imperialism. The complexity of the origins of totalitarianism arise form the interconnecting ideological perceptions of totalitarianism. State bureaucracy in all totalitarian states is an extension of, and based upon the dictatorial doctrine of the political regime. Initially the totalitarian regime creates a command economy, a means by which, the regime gains growing control over bankers and financers, industrialists and the workforce. This command economy was apparent in both Germany and Russia however, it is important to note that in Germany industry and finance remained in private ownership - with bankers and industrialist still able to keep the profits made by their respective businesses. Unlike in Russia where all aspects of the economy were eventually nationalised and became state run. Parliaments or assembles (legislature) within the totalitarian regime cease to be affective in terms of their ability to restrict the government - utilised by the totalitarian regime to support their policies - simply rubber stamping their directives. For example, in Italy a section of the seats in the national assembly were reserved for industrialists and financiers. Similarly the totalitarian state executive again had no real power. Hitler and Stalin were all powerful - both leaders head of the government, each ruled strictly by decree. However, Hitler unlike Stalin was also head of state. Nevertheless in both examples each leader was answerable to no one. Mussolini however, never attained to this level of power, as the King, Emmanuelle III still remained head of state, thereby...

Find Another Essay On Describe the Nature of a Totalitarian Regime, and Compare and Contrast Hitler's Nazi Regime with that of Stalin in Communist Russia

The Communist Regime in Romania Essay

1985 words - 8 pages Romania and Communism The Communist Regime in Romania was overall one of the toughest compared with what happened in other countries in Central-Eastern Europe; except, of course, the Soviet Union under Stalin. Communism in Romania is presented from the politic and economic points of view, as well as social perspective through the lack of freedom that affected Romanians’ lifestyle for many years. The history of Romania sees

The Nazi Regime Essay

2608 words - 10 pages involving an attempt on Hitler’s life that showed that there was some opposition to the Nazi regime. This opposition involved communist and social democrat parties youth groups, churches and the army. An example of opposition arose when two members of the white rose organization, Hans and Sophie Scholl began distributing a series of anti Nazi pamphlets depicting the negative side of its regime. They were quickly dealt with

Increase in Presecution of Jews by the Nazi Regime

1035 words - 4 pages Increase in Presecution of Jews by the Nazi Regime Response as to why the Nazis persecuted the Jewish community was not simply Hitler's hatred of the Jews but it has its roots in a much broader grounds. German society and long lasting historical opinions of the Jews made the Nazis attitude a relatively long-standing concept. Hitler's personal hatred of the Jews is widely believed to have originated in his time in

The Nazi Regime

1113 words - 4 pages The rise of the Nazi regime in Germany in the early part of the 20th century was an impressive, and nearly unforeseen incident that had long-lasting implications on the rest of the Western world. While the Nazi party was extreme in their ideologies, the circumstances in which they came to power were dire; Germany had been crippled by a massive depression and was being forced to pay reparations through the “Young Plan” which required Germany to

The Aims and the Results of the Attempts by the Nazi Regime to Transform German Society

4650 words - 19 pages but could not afford to lose their livelihood and their career over the issue. In this way the Nazis ensured that there was little outright opposition to the Nazi regime within schools and universities. The overall effect that Nazi ideology had on the educational system was massive. It is however harder to ascertain whether the ideology had such a large impact on the youth of Germany. As will be described with the

The Berlin Book Burning and the Beginning of the Nazi Regime

2376 words - 10 pages strengthen everyone’s opinion to be with or against whatever the leaders may be burning. Burnings of books appear all over history, and all over the world, so they were not a rare sight to see or hear of. The Nazi regime burned books on May 10, 1933 in Berlin; it was one of the first book burnings that they preformed around Germany before and during WWII. The German poet Heinrich Heine in 1822 perfectly predicted what the Nazi regime was going to do

Albert Speer's claim in the Nazi regime.

1335 words - 5 pages Albert Speer's claim that he was nothing more than an apolitical manage and that he had no direct involvement in the criminal activities of the Nazi regime is untrue. His appointment as Minister for Armaments and Hitler's 1942 decree transforming his department into a 'super-department' with wide-reaching powers allowed him unprecedented control over German industry. In this role Speer utilized forced labour from the concentration camps of

"Compare and contrast the internal policies of Mussolini and Stalin."

1289 words - 5 pages "Compare and contrast the internal policies of Mussolini and Stalin."Mussolini and Stalin were two of the most significant dictators of the 20th century. Both aimed to establish a totalitarian system but their different characters and circumstances in their respective countries resulted in two very different approaches in obtaining their goals.At the beginning of Mussolini's era, Mussolini was supported by the Liberals in parliament. With their

Compare and contrast the role of Lenin and Trotsky in establishing and contributing to the communist state in Russia from 1917-1924.

786 words - 3 pages totalitarian state was needed until Russia was fully communist.He also introduced an economic policy called war communism through the civil war. It was very harsh: farmers were prohibited from selling their surplus, all forms of private business forbidden, and there was absolutely no human freedom.It can thus be seen that Lenin's motives to become a communist leader was more from a desire to become an important figure himself. He showed no mercy in

Compare and contrast the view that ‘An Arrest’ is a tale of nature

1422 words - 6 pages Compare and contrast the view that An Arrest is a tale of nature rejecting a human villain with the view that it is concerned only with a vengeful superego ‘An Arrest’ is an ambiguous story. You can look at it in different ways. One way to see it is as a tale of nature rejecting a human villain. This view is put forward right from the beginning. When the narrator uses words such as “confined” and “fugitive” to describe the state of

To what extent, and by what means, did Hitler create a totalitarian regime?

1031 words - 4 pages conducting interrogative torture sessions, were characteristic of the Nazi regime and effectively dissolved pockets of rebellion. By dictating many facets of daily life and ruthlessly removing any opposition that arose, Hitler achieved extensive control of German society.A totalitarian society only became possible through Hitler's supreme dictatorial position, which gave him a comprehensive command over German politics. Following his appointment as

Similar Essays

Effect Of Hitler's Regime In Germany (And The World?).

1116 words - 4 pages and morally acceptable. Holding rallies much like Hitler's and encouraging people to join their cause.Hitler was a very influential man, now being a household name. Many hear his name and associate it with a dark period in history. Hitler was the cause of the Despair of Germany and the Nazi party was merely a platform for him to lecture on. Hitler gained the necessary public support for the Nazi party, using his charismatic abilities, but the Nazi

Tsarist Rule Vs. Communist Regime In Russia

2612 words - 10 pages Tsarist Rule vs. Communist Regime in Russia From 1856-1917, up until a communist takeover, the USSR had three Tsarist rulers, Alexander II (the Reformer 1855-1881), Alexander III (the reactionary Tsar 1881-1894) and Nicholas (1894-1917). After the February Revolution of 1917, Lenin took control forcibly through the Civil War, but died in 1924. After several years of fighting opposition, Stalin took power in the late

Lord Of The Flies And Hitler’s Nazi Regime

1280 words - 5 pages both gained support through using fear. Dehumanization is also present in the form of young Piggy and the Jewish People is Lord of the Flies and Hitler's Nazi regime respectively. Lord of the Flies features a group of former choir boys more commonly know as the hunters and this group of boys have much in common and shared many tactics with Hitler’s Gestapo police force. The Hunters in The Lord of the Flies used violence as a way to intimidate

The History Of Hitler And The Nazi Regime

4390 words - 18 pages ). During this two year period, Hitler reorganized the Nazi party, because he needed to have a smooth transition, if, in fact, he took control of the Reich government. In 1928, Hitler met Joseph Goebbels, a Nazi member, and quickly made him chief propaganda man. With Goebbels working hard making posters, billboards, signs, Hitler gained more and more support. In 1929, the American stock market crashed, and Hitler felt that it was time to seize the