Describe, With Examples If Possible, The Four Orientations Of Criticism Found In The First Chapter Of M. H. Abrams 'the Mirror And The Lamp'.

1099 words - 4 pages

In the first chapter of the Orientation of critical theories entitled The Mirror and the Lamp (1953) M. H. Abrams concentrates on four main elements; the universe, the audience, the artist, and the work and relates them to four broad critical theories that explain the nature and worth of art. He explains that almost all theories will make use of at least one of these elements, some all four. That is a critic will derive from one of these terms his principle categories for defining, classifying and analyzing a work of art, as well as the major criteria by which he judges it value. The four critical theories of orientation that Abrams relates them to are mimetic, pragmatic, expressive and objective and I will start by describing mimetic.Mimetic theories explore art as imitations of the universe. From the days of Plato and beyond mimetic orientations operated with three categories; that of everlasting ideas, that of the natural and artificial world and that of reflections, mirror images, shadows and the fine arts. However more recent mimetic theories usually have only two categories, the imitation and the imitable.In the tenth book of Plato's The Republic, Plato (427-384BC), Socrates and Glaucon discuss the nature of art around the three stage category. Here Socrates makes the point that there are three beds; the essence and idea of the bed, made by God, the bed made by the carpenter and the bed found in a painting, (thus the artist is an imitator). Then Platodiscards the divinely inspired poets' work as a mere imitation of the transitory actual world, stating that the 'creation of poets and artists are copies of copies of ideal reality, they are third hand distortions of the truth, valueless and potentially misleading.'However, Aristotle's The Poetics, argued that poetry creatively represents what is universal in human experience, stating that men enjoy being naturally imitative, and that they learn by it. It ascertains that the form of literature, not just the content, has to be taken into account. Here Aristotle (394-322BC) argues that we do not react to what we are shown, as Plato assumes, but also to how we are shown it. However it became clear that imitation was only instrumental toward producing effects upon an audience. Therefore in later theories the focus of interest shifted from work to universe to work to audience and pragmatic theories came into play.Pragmatic theories explore art in terms of its effects and reception. Their critics examine the authors 'nature' and powers which enables him to convert, teach and delight the audience, they rank poems on their abilities to evoke an effect which they are suited to achieve, and they derive the norms of the poetic arts from the needs and demands of the audience.Sidney (1554-1586) held a pragmatic approach stating (as Horace (65-8BC) did) that 'Poesy, is an imitation of art [....] to delight and teach'. With this in mind he classified poetry from the point of view of the moral and social...

Find Another Essay On Describe, with examples if possible, the four orientations of criticism found in the first chapter of M. H. Abrams 'The Mirror and the Lamp'.

Aladdin and the lamp Essay

701 words - 3 pages version made Aladdin's character wise. In the book, the main character, Aladdin lived in China with both his mother and father. Aladdin preferred to play on the streets rather than earning a living hereby making his father die of shame and his mother was forced to take up weaving to subsidize his laziness. The story began when a magician tricked to get a magical lamp. On seeing the cave, filled with treasures, Aladdin then goes in to get the lamp and

Describe one problem associated with urbanisation and evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of at least two possible solutions

1484 words - 6 pages Travelling places to places in a short period of time is no longer an empty talk nowadays. With the rapid development of transportation, people are difficult to get rid of transports as they derive us speed and convenience. Meyer, Kain and Wohl pointed out World War2 almost completely halted the construction of urban facilities of both private and public vehicles. It led to an all-time high in the use of transit. (J.R. Meyer, J.F. Kain, M. Wohl

Ambition, death, and power: themes found in the first scene of Macbeth by Shakespeare

734 words - 3 pages During a low point in Macbeth’s life he faces struggles with power, ambition and the thoughts of death surrounding him. Grabbing ahold of him strongly he is shown many ideas that are very promising at first, especially when the witches tell him of all of the control he could have, he wants the power, the fame and will do anything to get it. In act 1, scene 3, lines 140-145 Macbeth is recalling a conversation with the witches which brings

Human Nature in Chapter Four of Lord of the Flies

556 words - 2 pages Golding's views about human nature are displayed and developed quite extensively in chapter four. This essay is going to explore what they are and how they are portrayed throughout the duration of this chapter. The chapter reveals that Golding feels that humans enjoy, or are at least fascinated with controlling things. This is first shown when Henry was sitting at the beach and "tried to control the motions of the scavengers", with a stick

The First Chechen War and the Four Faces of Power

1208 words - 5 pages rewards, were apparently not a viable option. Furthermore, the conflict was perpetuated by lack of foreign intervention. On the part of the US, none was taken because the administration preferred to mend relations with Putin after NATO bombing in Yugoslavia. January 31, 2007 Political Science 160-002 UMID: 70084250 The First Chechen War and the Four Faces of Power - 3 - Works Cited 1. Stasys Knezys & Romanas Sedlickas. The War in Chechnya. Texas

The Mirror of Frost

771 words - 3 pages of which we can catch a glimpse of our own life, but a framework upon which our world can be illustrated. Each of Frost's poems has the ability to speak to each of us in a very different way. Perhaps the sense of separation found in "The Mending Wall" strikes a chord, or the timeless tug along "The Road Not Taken" is one personally felt.When I first read the "Mending Wall" I was struck with how much it reminded me of society today. In the

The Mirror of Death

817 words - 4 pages think about him anymore. He doesn’t love you. You can’t help yourself, so you think about him anyways. He started at your feet with your socks and quickly disposed of the rest of your clothing. Remember the way his hands caressed your thighs as he removed your shorts. Feel the ghost of his fingers slide up your ribs and under your shirt slipping it over your head. Why do you do this to yourself, princess? He hasn’t touched you in months. Step 3


2820 words - 12 pages 4.0 INTRODUCTION This chapter provides the findings, conclusion and recommendations based on data gathering, analysis, comparison and research conducted regarding the laws regulating fixed-term contract worker in Malaysia and United Kingdom. 4.1 THE FINDING OF RESEARCH 4.1.1 ABSENCE OF STATUTORY DEFINITION The literatures that have been gathered and observed by researchers, scholars from all over the world has succeeded in pointing out that

Mirror, Mirror in the Soul

799 words - 3 pages defense. When on the defense, no one wants to find out why they might be wrong; it’s painful to look inwards and find you’re wrong. With practice, this can be a trigger for self-evaluation. An ideal situation is a constant state of self-evaluation. I am convinced that if we do this, we will understand ourselves better and enjoy ourselves more. How do we apply this? Let’s try an experiment. Remember the past few social settings you’ve been in. As you

Describe and evaluate research into attachment and/or sociability in the first few years of life

1879 words - 8 pages environment and returns to the attachment figure in times of anxiety, distress or other potentially threatening situations (eg the presence of a stranger) to seek reassurance. Also if they show distress when separated from caregiver.As with sociability research by Schaffer & Emerson (1977) has shown that attachment is not a sudden process and this too occurs in stages - ie four stages (assuming that the infant is in an environment that would

How does John Steinbeck set the scene in the first chapter of "Of Mice and Men"?

658 words - 3 pages John Steinbeck in the first chapter of "Of Mice and Men" attempts to make the setting appear as paradise or as the Garden of Eden. Yet, later in this play the paradise changes into the opposite of what it was and many of the descriptions are foreshadowing, for example, the dead mouse in Lennie’s pocket represents the fate of people who are in the dark or are weak. In these ways, he attempts to use the paradise setting to catalyze the

Similar Essays

Describe New Zealand’s Four Waves Of Migration And Explain Using Specific Examples How Each Migrant Group Has Contributed To New Zealand’s National Character

1077 words - 4 pages Cristy Yun ! Describe New Zealand's four waves of migration and explain using specific examples how each migrant group has contributed to New Zealand's national character. ! New Zealand's four waves of migration are the Maori, the Colonial Europeans, Pacific Islanders and Asians. In each of the groups, there has been many positive and negative perceptions they have had on their homeland and New Zealand, which are referred to as push and pull

Brief Biography Of Hitler And Examples Found In The Novel Night By Elie Wiesl

1282 words - 5 pages things as he dropped out of school. Art became his main focus and with his father now dead no one could stop him. As an unguided child would do, he did as he pleased. Visiting museums, perusing the streets of Austria, and attending operas, Adolf had set his goal. Was it destiny or just luck that Adolf found a person that shared in his wild and artistic ways? August Kubizek was the buffer to Adolf’s insanity. He absorbed Hitler’s wild ideas and

Discuss The Importance Of The 'mirror' In Psychoanalytic Terms With Reference To Lacan's Theory Of The Mirror Stage And Angela Carter's Short Story 'flesh And The Mirror'

1829 words - 7 pages a language' with the unconscious being fully aware of this.Lacan created different categories in his theories to try to explain the path from infant to adulthood. His three main concepts are of the Imaginary, the Real and the Symbolic; called the Mirror Stage, the 'fort/da game' and the Phallus (borrowed from Freud's original Oedipus Theory). The sphere of the Imaginary is the demand for the fullness and the entirety of the 'other' that will stop

Evidence And Examples Of The Four Learning Outcomes

2846 words - 12 pages ENG 3010 is an intermediate writing course that prepares students for reading, research, and writing. Students develop writing skills in their own discipline or professional communities by analyzing texts, evidence and writing conventions (Bell, 2014). Four course learning objectives provide a foundation in which by the end of the semester a final research paper is produced with a narrowed definitive focus on a particular subject. Each