Desecration Of The Flag Should Be Prohibited

939 words - 4 pages

Desecration of the Flag Should be Prohibited


Is it necessary to allow all forms of protest to protect the right of citizens to express grievances against their government?  It is not a violation of free speech to outlaw burning of the flag because it is not speech.  It will not lead to the limiting of other avenues of protest, of which many are more expressive of specific problems. All attempts to protect the flag short of a Constitutional amendment have failed in the end.  A change to the constitution to prohibit the desecration of the U.S. flag is a necessary step to protect one of our most sacred national symbols.


            Several methods to protect the flag have been tried over many years.  Between the late 1800's and into the early 1900's many of the states passed laws protecting the flag.  There were numerous prosecutions for flag desecration during the Vietnam era and afterwards, until 1984 when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled these laws unconstitutional.  The controversy peaked in 1989 and 1990 when a federal law to prohibit flag desecration was passed and subsequently struck down by the Supreme Court.



            The first amendment guarantees its citizens the right of speaking freely, but is the act of burning a flag "speech"?  It is an inflammatory action that should not be protected by a clause meant to insure that citizens would not be suppressed in their efforts express unhappiness with the government or its actions.  Limiting a person's right to free expression is not a radical new idea either; speaking or writing false statements that harm others (slander and libel) are illegal and have been for a long time.  To allow desecration of a national symbol based on the "free speech" clause is a flimsy misuse of the constitution.


            The act of burning a flag does not address any specific grievance; it only expresses unhappiness with the United States in general.  Persons who are generally unhappy with this country should be able to find a better way to express their displeasure.  The ineffective nature of protesting in this manner is summarized well by Robert Goldstein:"a generally high counterproductive political tactic - one that mostly alienates people and makes them turn away before they have a chance of grasping any particular message that such conduct seeks to convey" (preface, Pg XI).  Flag burning is not a necessary or effective way to protest against any particular action.


            The flag is not a symbol representing the government of the United States; burning it portrays displeasure, not with government policies, but with the country itself.  This is why so many...

Find Another Essay On Desecration of the Flag Should be Prohibited

The act of burning the American flag

1097 words - 4 pages people believe that the American flag stands for somethingimportant and shouldn't be destroyed in that manner. I'm one of them, others believe thatflag burning is a statement that one should be able to make without major repercussions.Both sides have valid opinions and both sides state their case well. Although I am neithernor or against the burning of the flag, I believe the right should be earned and not betaken away. I believe that if a group of

The Meaning of the American Flag

1104 words - 4 pages Flag Essay The Flag Essay—What It Represents The flag of the United States is very important to the citizens of the United States and their afflicted nations. The patchwork of stars and stripes gave relief to many, hope to even more, and a sense of impending doom to it’s enemies. Through history, the flag went through many tests, in which the flag that represented the Unites States proved victorious. It represented

A review of Under The Black Flag

1151 words - 5 pages what most interests historians today about pirates and their voyages of blunder and destruction. "Under the Black Flag" by David Cordingly gives very good insight into what is believed to be the motives on both sides of the equation; what is the ruler getting and what is the privateer getting?Let us look first at the idealistic pirate. A person who can really not be known to be a pirate, a corsair, or a privateer. He was all of these; Sir Henry

The Use of Ritalin Should be Limited

5773 words - 23 pages , friends and families. However, my claim in this paper is that the use of Ritalin should be restricted because it has become too accessible, too easy to prescribe, and the number of students being treated today with this dangerous drug is alarming. The harsh side effects outweigh the benefits. A drug does not become "safe" simply because it is prescribed by a doctor.It is my intention in this paper to explore the side effects of taking Ritalin. This

Should the age of maturity be lowered?

560 words - 2 pages Should the age of maturity be lowered?Currently, the United States recognizes that a person "matures" when he or she reaches the legal age of 21, but I think the age of maturity ought to be lowered to18 instead. Certainly, we can all agree that 21 is an arbitrary number. Many 18-year-olds are in positions where they must act responsibly: they enlist in the armed forces, work full time, marry and even raise children. Shouldn't we recognize their

The American Flag: Symbol of the Vanishing American Dream

1049 words - 4 pages don't believe in is the way I see the flag being used. I don't believe that children should be trained at such an early age to honor the flag. That is a type of brainwashing that might lead children to believe that our country is perfect, when indeed it is not. I also don't agree with people using the flag as a status symbol. If we're going to have a symbol of America, shouldn't it be outside of everyone's home, not just the people who think

Brown versus Board of Education and Raising the Confederate Flag

1977 words - 8 pages racism; it should be lowered as soon as possible. ~~For many American citizens, a controversial flag such as the Confederate flag flying above a government edifice delivers a great amount of pain. Emett Burns, an African-American involved in the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, spoke of his views on the Confederate flag: "It [the flag] says to me 'If I could put you in your place, I would.'" (qtd in Schaiver) The

Arguments in Favor of Changing the Australian Flag

1383 words - 6 pages online comments, 'Our Australian flag is just that - our Australian flag. And just like our country, Australia, love it or leave it’. This false analogy reduces the ethos of the argument. An inappropriate statement, implies that Indigenous Australians did not agree with the flag, they should leave Australia This overly “patriotic” language shows the overwhelming sense of praise that isolated individuals have for Australia’s history (Platt

Persuasive Essay: The Confederate Flag As A Symbol Of Hate

579 words - 2 pages prejudice and hatred still exists when it is displayed anywhere ignorantly.In this day in age, there is no room for division. It is time that we stand together as one country and stop judging people solely on appearances. Think of how much more could be accomplished if we were able to share our ideas and our views as one united community. Separation is no way to live and there is no good to come from boundaries created by hate. The Confederate Flag is one symbol we can afford to forget, it is one boundary we can afford to break down.

Blanket of flags: What the flag really stands for

1309 words - 5 pages postmodern patriotism how many people actually cared if you said the Pledge or flew a flag. Now it seems to be a requirement if you want anything to do with this country. "It looks as if anyone who feels loyalty to their home countries or simply isn't gung-ho about America should go along with the crowd if they don't want trouble" (Sahramaa, 240).The country is united not because of loyally but because of fear. This is not the same country founded by

Abortion should be kept out of the Criminal Code

1346 words - 5 pages health was threatened by her pregnancy. Thebill died in the Senate in Jan 1991. 5In the case of Campbell v. Attorney-General of Ontario (1987) the allegations inthe statement of claim that the effect of the stay was to deny s.7 and s,15 rights to unbornchildren aborted or about to be aborted support a reasonable cause of action. The lawdoes not regard unborn children as independent legal entities prior to birth, so that it isonly at birth that

Similar Essays

Should Euthanasia Be Prohibited? Essay

1926 words - 8 pages diagnosed annually worldwide, it is not a surprise that doctors and families see euthanasia as a viable alternative for the terminally ill. Indeed, euthanasia has become a common practice in society and a number of people, doctors and families alike, believe that is it the right thing to do. However, euthanasia should be prohibited in all circumstances because it goes against the doctors’ Hippocratic Oath, violates patient rights, leads to a

Desecration Of The American Dream In Glengarry Glen Ross

748 words - 3 pages Desecration of the American Dream in Glengarry Glen Ross Glengarry Glen Ross portrays a harsh view of American business that not only contradicts, but also befouls the values of the "American Dream." The idealistic importance of fairness, equality, and the idea that hard work brings success included in this "dream" of American society is clearly not reality in this play. The values of work ethic, and equal opportunity are

The Public Display Of The Confederate Flag

995 words - 4 pages part of their history when the flags are forcibly removed. While political correctness is important in this country, there are good reasons why the flags design should not be destroyed. This discussion is centered on the design of the Confederate Battle Flag but what is important to understand is that there appears to be a double standard being applied, sometimes in ignorance, sometimes blatantly towards this issue. The history of the flags design

The Governmental Display Of The Confederate Flag

1963 words - 8 pages in Georgia did decide to change their flag to one that is more agreeable to everyone. The new one is a blue field with a banner at the bottom displaying some of the past flags of Georgia as well as the American Flag. It is clear that in Georgia, the NAACP accomplished its goal, and that should be the end of it; however, the old state flag (with the “rebel flag” displayed on it) is still present on the new one, so the battle may not be over yet