Defining Community Essay

975 words - 4 pages

Defining Community

What makes a community? To get a better handle on this question, it may be useful to analyze a specific encounter between the individual and his community(s). Let's take, for example, the much-publicized soccer match between Mexico and the U.S. in the summer of 1996. This game received a great deal of media attention because, even though the match was held in Los Angeles, on U.S. soil, the vast majority of fans were cheering for the Mexican team. The U.S. team members, on the other hand, were greeted with a chorus of boos and were pelted with various objects on the field. This trend in urban areas of largely Hispanic support for the teams of other countries was hardly new for U.S. soccer; the players and coaches had been complaining for a long while about the lack of support they received in their home country. And this match against Mexico was one of the most extreme instances of support for non-U.S. teams by U.S. citizens, which, as a result, generated much debate in op-ed sections around the country.

Some lamented Americans' lack of patriotism and suggested that those who supported the Mexican team didn't take their oath of citizenship seriously enough. Others argued that the game didn't signify too much because, hey, it's just a game. People can root for whichever side they want without committing any acts of national treason. Divided loyalties are a fact of life because we all belong to different communities simultaneously. However, many of these same it's-just-a-game people added that, had the choice between countries had any higher stakes, it would have been a different matter altogether. For example, if war broke out between the U.S. and Mexico, and some U.S. citizens chose to support or even to serve in the Mexican armed forces rather than the U.S. military, then there would be a definite conflict of interests with serious consequences. And most of the editorials agreed that when it comes to armed conflict, citizens should support their country of citizenship or have their privileges of citizenship revoked.

With this event as a backdrop, let's explore some of the more difficult questions relating to community. What level of obligation should we have to the several communities of which we are a member? We are all affiliated with more than simply the national community. We may include ourselves in other communities by virtue of ethnicity, religion, gender, and the like. What, then, does it mean that our relationship with the national community is formally, contractually-created, while our relationship with non-political communities may be more organically-conceived? We often feel that our membership in certain communities is more essential than our membership in the national community. So which of these competing claims to community is more legitimate? Should we necessarily privilege one set of obligations simply because it is formally contractual, while the other has arisen organically? And also, what...

Find Another Essay On Defining Community

Religion In Our Lives Essay

1476 words - 6 pages with natural communities consisting of individuals going "unconsciously" into their beliefs, we can observe the whole spectrum of religious community.      However, Weckman goes beyond this simple defining statement to explain what it is that actually constitutes these two groups of communities. After further analysis, the distinction becomes less clear. The author states: "Even though one is born into

Community Benefit Analysis

1720 words - 7 pages , Massachusetts, and Texas. The GAO performed this study because previous study results had indicated that nonprofit hospitals might not be defining community benefit in a consistent manner that would allow policymakers to hold the hospitals accountable for providing benefits in exchange for tax-exempt status. The GAO study specifically examined the IRS’s community benefit standard and states’ requirements, guidelines nonprofit hospitals use to define the

Hawthorne and Winthrop Comparison - American Literature - Essay

279 words - 2 pages that questions the fundamental doctrines of the Christian faith. As a Puritan minister, Winthrop preaches upon defining Christian charity, which love is central to what binds a Christian community as, “Love is the bond of perfection.” (Winthrop, 183) The quintessential claims that Winthrop asserts is that a true Christian follows the doctrines “to do justly, to love mercy… Hawthorne shows his understanding, and rather reservations, of the

Critically examine the conditions, which the author argues would impact both positively and negatively on the police procedures required to implem

853 words - 4 pages implemented community oriented philosophy, after the major restructure in the year 2004. It is not seem fully successful. The reason might be the political instability, lack of training and belief of the organization, the bad image within the public and insufficient resources. To make the implementation successful continuous training is vital for the organization. Works Cited What is community policing?, n.d, “the challenge of defining community

Community-Based Participatory Research

1249 words - 5 pages , researchers needed a similar model to aid in their investigations (Lightfoot et al., 2014). CBPR was constructed to link medical researchers to a community. Researchers wanted to find and assess existing strategies to community issues in which they were studying. This sort of research is often conducted by, “identifying the research question, defining the boundaries of the community, identifying the types of assets that will be inventoried

The Importance of Building Community

1175 words - 5 pages who have the skills and training to be leaders in industry and in their communities (jwu).” While there are many differences between community development in large urban areas and smaller rural communities, there is one thing they have in common, the importance of relationships and relationship-building as a means to meeting local goals (ced). A sense of shared purpose, establishment of boundaries defining who is a member and who is not

Assignment 3: Challenges in Identifying Mental Disorders

867 words - 4 pages example would be an individual who might be judged or have actions taken upon him/her because of failure to behave as recommended by one's family, church, employer, community, culture, or subculture. Theoretical approaches This approach towards defining abnormality starts with a theory of personality development. “If normal development can be defined, then abnormality is defined by the failure to develop in this way.” (Dewey, n.d.) For example, a

Social Issues

1046 words - 5 pages to involve themselves in finding a resolution to this issue lead to constructive contributions to the community (Alston, 2009). To define a profession can sometimes mean placing limits or restrictions on it. It is difficult to find a universal way of defining both community development and social work practice as they both incorporate a range of perspective, ideologies and characteristics. However, I feel it is difficult to separate the two

Jürgen Habermas’ Idea of the Public Sphere

2247 words - 9 pages conference has various speakers and programs that will discuss the broad categories of gender, health and wellness and social justice, among many others. By having the GLBT Knowledge Community help plan and promote this event, they are presenting higher education members with a chance to discuss their sexuality as simply another part of their intersecting identities, rather than as a defining trait. Mainstream media often presents issues in the gay

Aquinas' Notion of the Law Maker

936 words - 4 pages Adrienne Blonski Aquinas' Notion of the Law Maker The focus of this argument is derived from Aquinas' four defining characteristics of law. The following considerations provide a convincing argument against Aquinas' notion stating that "all laws must be issued by the one responsible for the common good". Based on the suggested definition of law, as well as the concept of past precedent and case law developed by

Community policing

1103 words - 5 pages Community and police are words that we hear frequently through our day-to-day life. Somehow these are not words that we often put together, although these two words are very important. Our community has a way of defining us and we count on our police to keep our families and us safe. As a young girl, the first phone number I was ever though was 9-1-1. I’ve never heard about community policing until very recently. Although I’ve heard a lot about

Similar Essays

Defining Community Essay

521 words - 2 pages Defining Community Before studying the definition of a community, one might associate the word with life back in their hometown.  After reading through the definitions of community in numerous dictionaries, it is clear that community is so much more than the place you grow up in. It is interesting that the definition of one word could change so drastically over a decade. According to A Dictionary of American English, (1847) the definition

Defining Community Essay

594 words - 2 pages What do you think about your neighbours? How do you feel about your schools? What do you think about your community? Community has always been a big part of our lives and it has been here since the day we were born. We might even live on the same street, but we grow up in different households and this results in many different views on communities. The many definitions of our community may include our home, our heritage, and even our religion

Definition Essay The Many Meanings Of Community

548 words - 2 pages is interesting to see that community goes from meaning a common interest or defining characteristics to living in the same society with other people that could have no common interests or defining characteristics.  It seems that the word was used in much broader terms as time passed, and lost some of its original meaning.  In looking through the dictionary there are always the common definitions that would be expected, but there are also the

Project: Addressing Obsesity As A Health Issue In Northwick Community

995 words - 4 pages “Better Choice Healthy Life” Intervention in Northwick Community Social marketing steps Defining the problem The problem of interest in this intervention is addressing obesity as a health issue. Is effective communication an essential component in social marketing to effect behavior change in regards to healthy eating and engaging is physical activity? How do we increase the likelihood of improving healthy nutrition behavior through the media