Defining Marriage Essay

1905 words - 8 pages

The purpose of this essay is to analyze fastidiously and personalize Warner’s Beyond Gay Marriage article. Three convergent points of Warner’s argument will be broken down, and examined. First, the concept that marriage consecrates some pairs at the cost of others. Second the question of why marriage has become such a prevalent organization in gay politics. Finally, the definition of marriage in public, private, and state terms.
Marriage is far beyond what it has been previously defined in history. Present day American society has made marriage a significant right of passage, a way to show maturity, or the complete path to becoming a functioning member of society. The act of becoming married truly states to society “I am ready to comply with social norms, and therefore become accepted.” Existing and participating in this structure unconsciously states that this relationship is more worthy than others.
The benefits of marriage comply with this by rewarding the couple in unison, and rewarding when they divorce. As Warner eloquently describes “the ennobling and demeaning go together” (Warner 82). The legalization of gay marriage would, in turn, be only furthering the deep etching of oppression that marriage brings on people who choose other lifestyle routes. “But what about the gay people who want marriage? Would they not in turn derive their sense of pride from the invidious and shaming distinction between the married and the unmarried? ”(Warner 82).
For someone like me who has been truly against the, in my opinion, absurd reasoning for marriage, it is hard for me to completely understand why anyone would want to battle for such a domineering institution. The way that marriage is, in society, just another oppressor, I cannot understand the “fight for equality” aspect of it. Marriage is in no way shape or form an equal and accepting structure. It contradicts the egalitarian basis of the movement. It excludes the possibility for any other intimate relationships. It rewards benefits where benefits should not be rewarded, and it demeans other relations as inadequate. Marriage, in short, is the most unequal construction existing in society. I do not necessarily want to say that gay marriage should not be legalized, but I believe instead of looking at it in terms of accepting another group into a structure, that we need to evaluate, instead, the whole structure and its impacts on society.
That sense of a utopian, out of the box analysis, is far from the minds of many gay marriage activists. Not until the early 90’s, has the fights for gay marriage become such a prevalent topic in politics, and what a force has it become. The media, politics, and gay activists have turned the situation into the defining political ties, similar to abortion and gun law debates. As if to say that stating for or against gay marriage can define one’s political stance. The gay marriage issue has left the terms of debate behind, in the fact that...

Find Another Essay On Defining Marriage

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1246 words - 5 pages politics whether it is a positive or negative effect. An example is the Defense Marriage Act, which gave the power to each state to accept same-sex marriage or be against it. President Obama is even working on legalizing gay marriage in all of 50 states, and with his support of gay marriage, he has received a lot of positive feedback from gay rights groups ever since his 2012 election. “In law, defining marriage as the union of a woman and a man does

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1260 words - 6 pages Marriage Acts. Thirty states have defined marriage in their constitutions” (NCSL.org). Nine states, as well as the District of Columbia, have no laws prohibiting same-sex marriage. There have been several attempts to amend the federal Constitution, defining marriage as between one man and one woman and ensuring that states would not be required to recognize same-sex marriages form other states. Opponents of this amendment site Federalism concerns

Gay Marriage Should Be Legal in All States

1215 words - 5 pages /2013/03/the-e.html Blankenhorn, D. (2007, April 2). Defining Marriage Down ... Is No Way to Save It. The Weekly Standard. Blankenhorn, D. (2012, June 22). How My View on Gay Marriage Changed. New York Times. Covert, B. (2013, June 26). Why Marriage Equality Is Good For The Economy And The Budget. Retrieved November 17, 2013, from ThinkProgress RSS: http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/06/26/2219571/marriage-equality-economy/ Gilgoff, D

Gay Love and Marriage is Natural

1288 words - 5 pages citizen alike” (Sullivan). I agree with Theodora Ooms in her essay regarding marriage and that it is less about the value of promoting marriage and more about whether government rather than individuals, communities, or faith institutions, should be in charge of defining marriage (Ooms). The commitment of two people exclusively to each other for the rest of their lives whether it be same-sex, traditional, or any other type is worthy of respect

The Tragedy of Gay Marriage

2073 words - 8 pages . How did this confusion come into being? There are many ways of defining a marriage, and even if they contradict, it does not mean that one of the contradicting definitions is wrong. Marriage has evolved over time. Once, far back in history, when states were run in close cooperation with religious leaders, a marriage was strictly the dominion of the church, and the only definition was much like the one above (though they were more lax in avoiding

Same-sex Marriage

1738 words - 7 pages Church is weakening. Same-sex marriage is one of the major reasons of the slowly-but-surely division of the Church. Experts and people who oppose same-sex marriage says that marriage calls for a man and a woman because “that is the defining essence of marriage, the requirement for Judeo-Christian tradition, and the modern Western nation state has structured society around the reality that only different-sex marital unions are allowed” (Eskridge

Legalization of Gay Marriage in Virginia

2284 words - 9 pages Virginia and the laws and restriction of same sex couples. Same-sex sexual activity is legal in Virginia, but the same-sex couples are not eligible for all the protections available to opposite-sex married couples. In November of 2006 Virginia Voters ratified a constitutional amendment defining marriage as the union of a man and a woman. Thus the state recognizes no other same-sex relationship. In the state statues the same restrictions and definition

Discouraging Teenage Marriage

1934 words - 8 pages , Gordon B.. "Early Teen Marriage and Future Poverty." US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of Health . N.p., 1 Aug. 2010. Web. 6 Mar. 2014. . Dobson, James C.. 5 essentials for lifelong intimacy. Sisters, OR: Multnomah Publishers, 2005. Print. Hudson, Holly. "Marriage & Relationships." Defining Divorce. Focus on the Family, 1 Jan. 2002. Web. 21 Mar. 2014.

Same sex marriage

1196 words - 5 pages marriage says that marriage calls for a man and a woman because “that is the defining essence of marriage, the requirement for Judeo-Christian tradition, and the modern Western nation state has structured society around the reality that only different-sex marital unions are allowed” (Eskridge 1421). The promoters of same-sex marriage propose something quite distinctive. They propose the union between two men or two women. This denies the plainly

Choose one issue covered in the course and compare how it relates to TWO religions of your choice.

1773 words - 7 pages men in her life defining her as daughter, wife and mother. With marriages there is a requirement from the bride's family to pay a dowry to the groom's family, which is now a commonplace with all castes and the average payment has increased dramatically (Srinivasan & Bedi 2007).Child marriage is still very common practise in India and most of South Asia with it affecting more that 60 million women worldwide (Raj, Saggurti, Balaiah &amp

Legalization of Same Sex Marriage

2510 words - 10 pages religious groups opposing same sex marriage. More importantly lack of unanimous agreement within the Christian faith itself, which has had the most persuasion to date in this debate, brings to the forefront the ongoing, issues, controversy, and fight for legal recognition of same sex partnerships. These largely based Christian groups have had historical roles in defining what relationships are and what marriage is. They have been very high profile in

Similar Essays

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage Essay

1293 words - 5 pages ) officially added a definition of marriage to our United States Code which included verbiage federally restricting marriage to one man and one woman. Title 1 of the United States Code section 1 provides that “unless the context indicates otherwise-words importing the masculine gender include the feminine as well” (1. U. S. C. § 1). To ensure clarity addressing context, DOMA added the words opposite sex when defining the word spouse (Defense of

The Spark That Lit The Gay Rights Movement

2164 words - 9 pages ban same-sex marriage before any changes could be made, the action sparked national debate and led Congress to pass the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) in 1996, defining marriage as between a man and a woman (“Hawaii”). Not until 2003 did the Supreme Court rule the anti-sodomy laws still in use in 12 states unconstitutional in Lawrence v. Texas (Levy). The year proved to be momentous for the gay rights movement when the Massachusetts Supreme Court

Should Same Sex Marriage Be Legalized? Essay

1549 words - 6 pages possible, partial explanation to why there is a division on the same-sex marriage issue in the US. Like defining marriage or the nature of homosexuality, The Loving v. Virginia court case (that marked an end to interracial marriage bans) is essential in both of the writer’s arguments. While Barber claims there is no comparison that can be made between Loving v. Virginia and modern gay-marriage cases, Quindlen claims there is. When describing the

Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Allowed

1202 words - 5 pages marriage as a union of a man and woman as husband and wife. The amendment should fully protect marriage, while leaving the state legislatures free to make their own choices in defining legal arrangements other than marriage. America's a free society, which limits the role of government in the lives of our citizens. This commitment of freedom, however, does not require the redefinition of one of our most basic social institutions”. Conclusion