This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

De Tocqueville And Mill, And The Tyranny Of The Majority

991 words - 4 pages

Threat of Tyranny of the Majority not Strong enough to "Temper" the Spirit of DemocracyIn the present political spectrum, democracy is essentially understood as both the most humane and effective means by which to govern a body politic. While democracy is currently relatively non-controversial, this was not the case during its establishment. The democratic experiment in America was viewed somewhat indifferently by many of the world's prominent political philosophers. Alexis de Tocqueville and John Stuart Mill existed among those most apprehensive of the democratic experiment. To each of these men, democracy certainly possessed certain positive attributes, but at the same time, represented a potential threat to the individual freedoms of man, through a much feared 'tyranny of the majority'.De Tocqueville and Mill both cite the possible oppression of minority groups as a significant drawback to democracy. While each author cites the 'tyranny of the majority' as a possible problem, their perceptions of the alleged problem differ in scope and definition. De Tocqueville regards the above mentioned problem largely as a hindrance to actual action on the part of minority groups and individuals; Mill discusses it relating primarily to the oppression of minority thought. De Tocqueville recognizes the ability of the government to regulate thought, but does not focus on it to the extent that Mill does.One of the fundamental questions raised by De Tocqueville is, "When a man or party suffers an injustice in the United States, to whom can he turn?" (252) In the American democratic experience three separate branches of government exist, but, de Tocqueville does not feel that this mitigates the threat towards tyranny. Furthermore, he states, "in a democracy organized on the model of the United States there is only one authority, one source of strength and of success, and nothing outside it." (255) Under De Tocqueville, this "authority" is the majority and its reign absolute. De Tocqueville's primary fear is the government, particularly the legislature, as a tool of the masses, will have no constraints upon it to stop it acting solely in its own best interest.While De Tocqueville references the majority's ability to silence minority action, Mill is more concerned with its capacity to marginalize minority thought and opinion. In the realm of Mill's world, the majority has a strong, overpowering effect on how those in the out-group think and form beliefs. The control the majority has over the minority in this respect is so great, that he goes as far to say that the minority likely will essentially lose their entire identity. To this he comments, "One whose desires and impulses are not his own, has no character, no more than a steam-engine has character." (62) Furthermore, Mill hypothesizes that through this marginalization of individual thought, the "despotism of custom" will inevitably ensue. Basically, the suppression of individual thought leads to a uniform...

Find Another Essay On DeTocqueville and Mill, and the tyranny of the majority

The tyranny of choice Essay

789 words - 3 pages Steven Waldman wrote this essay with regards to the overwhelming number of choices that consumers faced each time they go make a simple purchase. The main purpose for writing this essay is to entertain and inform a simple situation we encounter every day. Waldman highlighted the stressful behaviors that people go through when making a right decision, which he illustrate using his personal experience as an example. After he portrayed his

Comparing the Utility of Bentham and Mill

2032 words - 8 pages Comparing the Utility of Bentham and Mill utility \U*til"i*ty\, n. [OE. utilite, F. utilit['e], L. utilitas, fr. utilis useful. See Utile.] … 3. Happiness; the greatest good, or happiness, of the greatest number, -- the foundation of utilitarianism. --J. S. Mill. Syn: Usefulness; advantageous; benefit; profit; avail; service. (www.dictionary.com) One of the major players in ethical theories has long been the concept of

The tyranny of `other income`

944 words - 4 pages With the recent volatility of the rupee, more and more companies are seeing the "other income" component of their quarterly accounts bouncing around like tennis balls.This is particularly true for IT companies, whose top line has very little protection from this volatility.Equity analysts have sharpened their focus on this element of the accounts and, even though they should know better, sometimes factor this "uncertainty" into their assessment

The utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill

2070 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast the utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Which do you think is the more convincing moral theory, and why?In terms of Utilitarianism, this assignment shall outline the philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. It shall firstly illustrate the ideas of Bentham and then follow on to compare and contrast those of Mill. To continue, the assignment will view the failing qualities in both the

My Family and the Lindale Mill

1711 words - 7 pages mill has employed four generations of my family. The lives of the four generations of my family entirely revolved around the town in which they lived. The Mill in Lindale, Georgia offered my family great health resources, spiritual avenues, and practical amenities. Doctors were one of the great health resources that the Lindale Mill offered my family. One of the doctors that served the Lindale area was Dr. J.N. Cheney. Dr. Cheney started

How does the separation of powers in the US constitution both facilitate good government and check tyranny?

1367 words - 5 pages branch of leadership. The supreme power of George III and the oppression associated with his rule ensured a fear and dislike of power amongst the colonies, prompting the framers of the Constitution to create new limitations and separations of power. Tyranny was checked by the federalist system because it established 'two sovereigns ', dual federalism, instead of one. Both national and state power was limited by the independent creations of the

In the late 1800s and early 1900s the majority of American people supported a policy of imperialism

837 words - 3 pages In the late 1800s and early 1900s the majority of American people supported a policy of imperialism. Imperialism is the practice of one country extending its control over the territory, political system, or economic life of another country. Political opposition to this foreign domination is called "anti-imperialism."The U.S. had followed basic policy of isolationism since the War of 1812. The U.S. had concentrated on the Civil War, winning the

Role of the Majority in a Society

1142 words - 5 pages One of the defining principles of democratic society is the idea that “majority rules.” Despite the fundamental nature of this principle, it has been challenged by some of the greatest thinkers in history. Henry David Thoreau, Emmeline Pankhurst and Karl Marx are among these great thinkers who have commented on the role of the majority in different political and social situations. In works such as, “Civil Disobedience,” “Why We Are Militant

The Majority Of Texas Voters Are Republicans

653 words - 3 pages Based on the data we collected while completing this assignment, it can be concluded that the majority of Texas voters are Republicans. Yet we learned by reading our books that even though Republicans tend to vote more than Democrats, that does not mean that there are actually more Republicans than Democrats. While doing this assignment, I was actually surprised at how many Democrats there are in Texas. For example, in the 1996 General Election

The Muslim Majority State of Pakistan

1860 words - 8 pages INTRODUCTION The Muslim majority state of Pakistan was created in 1947 when the Indian sub-continent was divided. Since then, Pakistan has been plagued with domestic political hostility and regional conflicts. Originally, Pakistan was divided into two parts (east and west) to appease the complaints of Indian Muslims. The eastern part is present day Bangladesh, while the western part is the present day Islamic Republic of Pakistan (Human Rights

Minority and majority rights

1835 words - 7 pages The rights of many people versus the rights of an individual is certainly a vexing concept. Like a delicate balancing act; if one side is favoured over the other it causes a rift in the already strained relationship between the minority and majority. Evidently, the justification of taking any side must be valid, according to the theories of H.L.A. Hart. In the past, Canadian law has violated the rights of minorities; however, these violations

Similar Essays

Equality Vs The Tyranny Of Majority

3673 words - 15 pages “Tyranny of Majority” is a phenomenon in a democratic society where decisions are made by the majority group and the decision oppresses the minority group, comparable to that of tyrants. The term was first used by John Adams in 1781. It was later popularized by Alexis de Tocqueville in his book: Democracy in America; and further spread by John Stuart Mill. In their works, both Mill and Tocqueville are concerned about the existence of the

Tyranny, The Old And The New

1818 words - 7 pages Extended Antigone Essay Tyranny, The Old and The NewSophocles' dramatization of pride in the play Antigone is very relevant to modern society. Creon's hubris, inability to admit his mistakes and to relate to Antigone's beliefs at the climax of the play is a struggle between a people and it's government that can be related to the recent uprisings across the world, specifically the uprising in the Ukraine. Antigone is based around the story of a

The Tyranny Of Optimism Essay

1594 words - 6 pages undermines women’s health. In order to overturn the “tyranny of positive thinking” on breast cancer culture, we must dismantle the wave of optimism that has engulfed the breast cancer movement, and refocus our attention back on our main objective to put an end to the disease. Optimism is just one of the ways patients diagnosed with breast cancer cope with the disease, the treatments, and their uncertainty of whether or not they will survive. When

The Tyranny Of Equality Essay

723 words - 3 pages What would you do if your government dictated your every action; your every thought? Would you fight back against oppression? Michael Kort’s excerpt “From The Rise and Fall of the Soviet Union” is a nonfiction story that covers several attempted revolutions as well as Joseph Stalin’s ascent to political power in the 1920’s. Stalin subjugated his own people to cruel inhumane conditions that affected the Soviet Union for years to come. Animal Farm