Evolution V. Creation Essay

1715 words - 7 pages


Evolution
     Should the stork theory appear in books on reproduction? How about astrological lore in expositions on astronomy? It would be unreasonable to even consider those ridiculous concepts. This is why the idea of creation should not be considered as the answer to how life began. Rather, the theory of evolution accounts for the creation of life. Charles Darwin is credited with creating the theory of evolution. Evolution assumes that all natural forms arose from their ancestors and adapted over time to their environments, thus leading to variation. In evolution, there are many rules the environment places upon the survival of a species. “There are many misconceptions that creationists have about evolution. A large part of the reason why creationist arguments against evolution can sound so persuasive is because they don't address evolution, but rather argue against a set of misunderstandings that people are right to consider ludicrous” (Isaak). Evolution refers to change, or transformation over time. “There are numerous ways in which evolution occurs, the most noted are Natural Selection and Adaptation” (“Evolution v. Creationism”). As Savage said, “We do not need a listing of evidences to demonstrate the fact of evolution any more than we need to demonstrate the existence of mountain ranges” (v).
     A very popular, although erroneous, argument given by creationists is that evolution has never been observed. Evolution at its simplest involves relatively minor changes in the gene pool of a particular population from one generation to the next (Savage 32). One example of evolution being observed is insects developing a resistance to pesticides over the period of a few years. Even most creationists recognize that evolution at this level is a fact. “What hasn't been observed is one animal abruptly changing into a radically different one, such as a frog changing into a cow. This is not a problem for evolution because evolution doesn't propose occurrences even remotely like that. In fact, if we ever observed a frog turn into a cow, it would be very strong evidence against evolution” (Isaak). According to Isaak, what they don't appreciate is that this rate of evolution is all that is required to produce the diversity of all living things from a common ancestor.
     Another inaccurate argument against evolution is that there are no transitional fossils. A transitional fossil is one that looks like it's from an organism intermediate between two lineages, meaning it has some characteristics of lineage A, some characteristics of lineage B, and probably some characteristics part way between the two (Prinze). To say there are no transitional fossils is simply false. The fossil record is still spotty and always will be; erosion and the rarity of conditions favorable to fossilization make that inevitable. Prinze continues, “Transitions may occur in a small population, in a...

Find Another Essay On evolution v. creation

Creationism and Evolution Taught in Schools

2124 words - 8 pages free country that allows its citizens to pick their own religion and beliefs. This case basically clarified that the government should not be involved in the teachings of evolution and creationism in the public school system because this is not a dictatorship (Armenta, 2). McLean v. Arkansas Board of Education: In 1982 Arkansas passes the ‘Balances treatment for creation-science and evolution-science Act’. This Act allowed evolution and

Evolution Theory vs Creation Worldview Essay

1195 words - 5 pages These days, most of the textbook only presents evolution theory as a fact to interpret the origin of life and the earth. More and more people get to reject creation unconsciously because they had no opportunity to compare and evaluate both worldview in same degree. I interviewed my three close acquaintances and heard a various responses from many people including my interviewees. Some of them had same belief with me, but some people had

Creationism Vs. Evolution

1370 words - 5 pages Where do we come from? The creation of the world has been told through many different stories, and from a variety of religions across the world. The argument between evolution and creation has been debated back and forth for years. So how do we know which claim is correct? Has all life evolved from simple bacteria to all the species that appear today, or did life on earth begin with God's creation of Adam from dust and his partner Eve from

The Problem With Teaching Creationism in the Science Classroom

1363 words - 5 pages curriculum by passing the following resolution: “Students will be made aware of gaps/problems in Darwin’s theory and of other theories of evolution including, but not limited to, intelligent design” (Kitzmiller v. Dover). The school board was brought before a court and presiding judge, John E. Jones, found “that the Board's ID Policy violates the Establishment Clause” and that “ID cannot uncouple itself from its creationist, and thus religious

Teaching Origins in 20th Century American Public Schools

6468 words - 26 pages particularly controversial, and texts that stressed evolutionary principles and the similarities between humans and animals were forced out of classrooms after a trial period in the 60s and 70s. By the 1980s, the space devoted to evolution in high school textbooks had once again fallen. In 1968, the US Supreme Court ruled in Epperson v. Arkansas that all laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution were unconstitutional. Creationists tried other

Science Teachers and Professors Should Not Teach Creationism

1598 words - 7 pages taught so people can understand what the debate is about,” it is up to the school to teach evolution, while families or other educators should inform their children and students about creationism or any other type of creation myth or legend. As a matter of fact, a transparent explanation for this tenet efficiently emerges: the “sides” of the debate are more than two; therefore, there is no reason to consider evolution and creationism, but not the

The Debate Over Teaching Evolution In Schools

1988 words - 8 pages Berlatsky. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2012. At Issue. Rpt. from "Foreword." Voices for Evolution. Ed. Carrie Sager. 3rd ed. Oakland, CA: National Center for Science Education, Inc., 2008. v-vi. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 18 Nov. 2013. Glynn, Patrick. "Creationism Should Be Taught Alongside Evolution." Religion and Education. Ed. Tom Head. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2005. At Issue. Rpt. from "Monkey on Our Backs." National Review 51 (13 Sept

Teaching Curriculum of Science Classes

1808 words - 8 pages that might not be their own or that go against their beliefs. Throughout the years, the Supreme Court has deemed state and local laws unconstitutional because of the First Amendment. “In 1968, in a case called Epperson v. Arkansas, the Court invalidated an Arkansas law that prohibited teachers from teaching evolution, finding that the law was motivated by a completely religious purpose” (Scott and Branch 85). In another case, “the Court held

The Debate of Orgin: Creationsim versus Evolutionism

1247 words - 5 pages is that creationist beliefs and ideals are less common among religious folk than the theory of Evolution. As a total, 36% of High School students said they believed in Creationism, and of that only 23% said they wish to be taught it in schools. That means 64% do not believe it and 77% of students wish to be taught only Evolution. So science, true science with evidence and testing supporting it, is more popular than the belief of creation. So why

Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District

1630 words - 7 pages ? [397 U.S. 664]. The 1987 case Edwards v. Aguillard requires any religiously-related instruction to have ?a clear secular purpose? [482 U.S. 578]. The legislation addressed in this case?the Creationism Act?required teachers who chose to teach evolutionary theory to also spend an equal amount of time on creation theory. The United States Supreme Court concluded that the Act was, in fact, in violation of the Establishment clause of the US

Entering the Discourse

978 words - 4 pages classrooms the educational boards would be forcing students to accept Christianity values and the idea that a God exist and he is the creator of life. The argument was recently seen in the Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District Case. In this federal case intelligent design was found to be a form of creationism, the idea that the universe originates from a divine creation, and therefore was unconstitutional to teach in American public schools (Schyeman

Similar Essays

The Issue Of Teaching Creationism In Public Schools

1456 words - 6 pages The Issue of Teaching Creationism in Public Schools Introduction The issue of teaching creationism in the public schools has long been debated. Over the years, many different arguments have been made. First, creationists tried to have the teaching of evolution outlawed. This issue went to the Supreme Court in 1968, where in Epperson v. Arkansas the high court ruled against banning the teaching of evolution. Soon after this decision

Teaching Creationism In Schools Essay

1419 words - 6 pages of evolution. Ruse writes that "philosophically and methodologically the creationists do not act like scientists, and that substantively the creationist's contentions are without scientific merit" (Ruse 290). Ruse also states that "science must be explanatory, testable, and tentative" (301). Some believe that creation science is "a jumble of half-truths" (In the 17). In the _Epperson v. Arkansas_ decision the argument that creationism is

The Case Of Evolutionism Vs. Creationism

1094 words - 4 pages that when evolution was taught, then creation theory had to be taught as well. Lower courts had ruled that the State's actual purpose was to promote the religious doctrine of "creation science", but the State appealed to the Supreme Court. Edwards v. Aguillard was the court case that came about, and was heard by the Supreme Court of the United States in 1987. The Court ruled that a Louisiana law requiring that creation science be taught in public

Evolution Essay

633 words - 3 pages design supporters argue Evolution, they completely disregard science. In this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1xUiuZvUuw, a scientists at a Creation Museum says “If we find some experiment that seems to disagree with the word of God, we go with the word of God.” What that means, as a scientist, he would be throwing his education and profession away over something he merely believes in. In the creation museum there are displays of humans