Diagnosing Lionel Tate Using Different Psychological Theories

862 words - 3 pages

Diagnosing Lionel Tate Using Different Psychological Theories


On January 26, 2001, 13-year-old Lionel Tate was convicted in the first-degree murder of Tiffany Eunick. The incident occurred in July of 1999 in Pembroke Park, Florida. Tate, then twelve, claimed he was imitating pro wrestlers when he killed six-year-old Eunick. He claimed to have picked the girl up and accidentally thrown her into a stair handrail and wall while trying to throw her onto a sofa. Experts all agreed that Eunick was beaten for a period of time. The autopsy report showed that the girl suffered a fractured skull, lacerated liver, broken rib, internal hemorrhaging, and cuts and bruises. One expert said her injuries were comparable to falling from a three-story building. Tate was much larger than Eunick – 170 pounds compared to her forty-eight. Not even his defense could claim that he did not beat the girl to death, although they did stick to the claim that professional wrestling was the central issue in Eunick’s death. They said Tate was immature and did not understand that pro wrestlers were trained to look as though they beat each other without hurting each other. A spokesman for the World Wrestling Federation claimed, “A twelve-year-old knows the difference between the real world and entertainment and can make that distinction.” The jury obviously agreed, because after only a three-hour deliberation, they returned with a guilty verdict.
B.F. Skinner, a behaviorist, claims that people tend to repeat responses that lead to positive outcomes. He goes further to say that they tend not to repeat responses that are followed by a negative or neutral response. If Skinner were looking at the case of Lionel Tate, he would say that Tate must have in some way been rewarded for this type of behavior in the past. Tate is a large boy (170 pounds). He most likely wrestled with his friends, and due to his size, would usually be able to overtake them. This would be considered a positive attribute to twelve-year-old boys. Tate could possibly have “beaten up” other children before where his friends would have cheered him on. But in these instances, he was most likely fighting with boys much closer to his own age and size. When it came to Tiffany Eunick, who was just a little girl, he outweighed her by 120 pounds and was much stronger.
Sigmund Freud would have taken a much different approach when diagnosing why Lionel Tate killed Tiffany Eunick. Freud believed that behavior is governed by...

Find Another Essay On Diagnosing Lionel Tate Using Different Psychological Theories

Juvenile Homicide Offenders Essay

1465 words - 6 pages her kids when she left 12-year-old Tate and 6-year-old Eunick to play unsupervised. Kathleen stood upstairs preparing for her grade yard shift for as a Florida State Trooper (Leniency for Lionel Tate?, ABC news.) After the two children had been playing for a while the 12 year old boy ran to his mother explaining how his young playmate had stopped breathing. Tate was an abnormally large twelve year old standing at nearly six feet tall and

A Look at Justice’s Voting Behavior

1657 words - 7 pages started made me realize that the different ideologies of the justices do play a factor in the way they vote. Finally, Political scientists also looked to see if the justices’ political party played a role in the way they voted on cases. Researchers Tate and Handberg believed, “Political party identification should have an impact on the decision making of Supreme Court justices” (Tate, C. Neal and Roger Handberg 1991, p. 464). Political scientist

Should Juveniles Offenders be Tried and Punished as Adults?

682 words - 3 pages one serious felony charge. Lionel Tate was the youngest juvenile tried as an adult for homicide. Tate was charged with first degree murder, for wrestling with a six year old that ended in death. Tate’s first charge was overturned because he was not mentally checked out before the trial. With the sentence being overturned, Tate was sentenced to one year house arrest and ten years’ probation. As he grew older, Tate violated his probation with a

Lionel, Wounded Knee, and Intertextuality . Characteristic of character in Thomas Kings "Running water"

726 words - 3 pages and the AIMoccupation of Wounded Knee, we would see many similarities. The first similaritywould be both Lionel's and AIM's reputations. Before the troubles for both of them,they had very good reputations. Lionel had a great job, AIM was well supported. Thenthey both went to a peaceful demonstration.Both demonstrations were about the same place, but at different times. AIM'sdemonstration was about the land around Wounded Knee, and their rights

Psychoanalytic Criticism

1155 words - 5 pages Psychoanalytic Criticism Introduction The psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud spent much of his life exploring the workings of the unconscious. Freud's work has influenced society in ways which we take for granted. When we speak of Freudian slips or look for hidden causes behind irrational behavior, we are using aspects of Freudian analysis. Many literary critics have also adopted Freud's various theories and methods. In order to define

American Philosophy Story

919 words - 4 pages matters is accurate. Throughout the episode, she particularly questions Tate's existence, which leads her to conduct an extensive amount of research. Using this research, Violet is able to reach a conclusion regarding her perception of Tate; she realizes that Tate is no longer living and that he remains trapped in her house as a ghost. Strictly speaking, she uses her reason to realize which of her previous knowledge is true and which is not

Jeffrey Dahmer:Bilogically Determined Killer

4351 words - 17 pages to support the conclusion that genetic factors predispose to crime.? ( Moffitt and Mednick, 1988 ) For example the case of Jeffery Dahmer. A man with a average upbringing who develops into a alcoholic, sexually deviant serial killer. Environment and learned behaviour theories simply do not account for this shift from typical kid to monster. While Dahmer had fantasies about killing men and having sex with their corpses as early as age fourteen, he

Making Connections: Observation/Analysis of The King’s Speech

934 words - 4 pages emotions. On many occasions when he gets frustrated with his stammering he tends to yell and curse, especially when he is in therapy with Lionel. Bertie does not have emotion regulation which according to Berger (2011) is “the ability to control when and how emotions are expressed” (p.265). Lionel ends up using Bertie’s temper to help him with his stammering by having him curse when he is having trouble speaking. Without emotion regulation Bertie has

Television Violence

1754 words - 7 pages committing a violent act towards another youth occurred in Florida in 1999. Twelve year old Lionel Tate who weighed 170 pounds and had nothing wrong mentally was playing with six year old Tiffany Eunick, a friend of the family. Lionel had been watching wrestling on television and decided to try out some wrestling moves on the considerably smaller Eunick. Tate ended up beating the child to death and told prosecutors that he was simply imitating

Messi

1024 words - 5 pages name of this little 5 feet 7 inches Argentinean is mentioned because his skills are amazing; the touch, the control, the speed and then the finish; is the thing that made him the best soccer player around the world. There are few finer sights than Lionel Messi using a mixture of pace and trickery to beat multiple defenders from his position in the center of the Barcelona attack (Coggin). Messi is known as La Pulga's (The Flea). This nickname was

Irrational Fears: Agoraphobia

1407 words - 6 pages Agoraphobia According to Klasco (2011), psychological disorders "are abnormalities of the mind that result in persistent behavior patterns" that can have an impact on daily tasks and life in general. There are many different groups of psychological disorders, one of those being anxiety disorders, which King (2013) states features "motor tension, hyperactivity, and apprehensive expectations and thoughts" (p. 448). There are also many subgroups

Similar Essays

Discuss The Cause Of Binge Drinking In America By Using Psychological Theories And The Impacts Of Stress In Relation

5 words - 0 pages 第一幕(開門聲)唐太太:呀!你們…!唐英年:你…你為什麼會那麼早回來的?唐太太:你這女人快跟的滾!滾出去!走!(拍門聲

Dianosis Essay

733 words - 3 pages is aware that he is a ghost. The disorders that I am diagnosing Tate Langdon with are antisocial personality disorder and schizophrenia. Antisocial personality disorder is a disorder in which a person, typically a male, in which they exhibit a lack of conscience of wrongdoing. Antisocial personalities also inhibit impulse and they feel and careless towards family, friends, and their actions. Antisocial personality disorder can be both biological

Juvenile Justice Essay

651 words - 3 pages turned as of late. Three years after Tate was sentenced, 12 at the time, he was free walk out of jail after his defense attorney found a flaw in his trial; Tate had not been given psychological testing. Our juvenile justice system had run into a brick wall and three long years of protests and clemency request had finally paid off. But should Tate have been locked up to begin with? That question leads to my own interpretation of "the law". You

The King's Speech

869 words - 4 pages . Lionel’s intention was to ignore the King and make the situation frustrating and extremely hard to “voice” his statement. However in the end, the kings broke through the difficult obstacles of trying to communicate how he was feeling by yelling to Lionel “I Do Have A Voice” During this scene Lionel pushed the King to his limit and made him understand that he does have a voice. Getting a message across an audience or a person can be different