This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Dialogue Of Good, Evil, And The Existence Of God By John Perry

2301 words - 9 pages

Dialogue of Good, Evil, and the Existence of God by John Perry

In John Perry's book Dialogue on Good, Evil and the Existence of God, he used three characters in the dialogue in order to clarify the positions of the three characters (Weirob, Miller, and Cohen), the arguments they provide in support their positions and the "end state" of their discussion. This allows us to examine our understanding of the good, evil and the existence of God.
Perry shows a clear position of Weirob, Miller, and Cohen. Weirob is a philosopher who is not a Christian. She does not believe God exist. She only believe evil exist without God. She thinks if God really exists in this world, then God is a monster (evil) because God lets her suffered. She challenges with Miller's belief and claims that there is no God exist. She wants Miller to proof there is possibility of his beliefs. Miller is a Christian who believes in God. He thinks evil and God can both exist in this world. Therefore, he has to convince Weirob to believe there is possibility that God and evil are both exist in order to win the debate and also pray for her. Cohen is a neutral one between them. He is the judge. He helps Weirob and Miller to figure out what is their own point of view all the times and also he raises some useful ideas to solve their arguments. It seems that he is so helpful in this debate.
Weirob does not believe in God, so she does not admit Miller to pray for her. First, Weirob claims, "how in the world does a prayer help?" (p.2) to raise the debate of good, evil and the existence of God. She thinks Miller simply would be communication to his omniscient God for what God already knows, thereby wasting God's time and his time. In fact, she believes there maybe no God exists. So she claims that " perhaps there is no God. Or perhaps there is, but he is ignorant, or weak, or mean" (p.4) She thinks God must not care her because God lets her suffered. She provides a main argument to support her position which is "the existence of suffering is inconsistent with the existence of the all-perfect God." (p.17) She thinks there is evil but without God. Miller wants to convince Weirob to believe the possibility of God exists. His argument is that this world is the creation of an all-perfect Being, even if we admit that there is suffering in it. He claims that the existence of suffering is consistent with the existence of the all-perfect God. Their arguments are opposed to each other. So Miller has to convince Weirob that Christian God he believe in--- all perfect, omnipotent, omniscient, and benevolent -- could possibly exist, even given as unimportant a bit of suffering as her flu.
Miller first raises some examples to proof his argument is possible but doesn't have to explain to Weirob what plan God has in mind. The example is about a painting can have ugly parts but been more beautiful or deep because of them or a dull...

Find Another Essay On Dialogue of Good, Evil, and the Existence of God by John Perry

Good vs. Evil in John Cheever's The Five-Forty-Eight

1310 words - 5 pages Good vs. Evil in John Cheever's The Five-Forty-Eight John Cheever was an award winning American author of the twentieth century. His work often possessed 'psychological and religious vision' with central themes of 'sin, deception, and redemption' (Kennedy, 551). Cheever's short story entitled 'The Five-Forty-Eight' portrays a struggle of good vs. evil. Following the themes of sin, deception, and redemption, we read of a young woman (good

Is It Possible For God To Be All-good And All-powerful While There Is Evil In The World?

1235 words - 5 pages evil: Moral evils were discussed by Augustine and later adopted by Aquinas.(Stumpf , 1983). Evil, by Aquinas is not a thing, it is the absence of a the good. The same as for the blind the absence of sight. In this context the question is, why does God allows the evil to exist whether it exist per se or by the absence of good? Aquinas replies that the perfection of the universe required the existence of various kinds of beings, including bad as

Good vs. Evil, Wars in "A Separate Peace" by John Knowles

1177 words - 5 pages John Knowles novel, A Separate Peace, portrays wars on three distinct levels.These levels could be described as outer, inner, and world. There is a very gooddefinition of these wars at the closing of the novel which shows us the levels:'I could never agree with either of them. It would have been comfortable, but Icould not believe it. Because it seemed clear that wars were not made by generationsand their special stupidities, but that wars were

John Gardner's novel, "Grendel". Gives the reader a new perspective on the classic 'good vs. Evil'

860 words - 3 pages John Gardner's novel Grendel give the reader a new perspective on the classic 'good vs. Evil' plot. From the start of the book the reader can tell that there is something very unique about the narrator. It is evident that the narrator is a very observant being that can express himself in a very poetic manner. The story is one the reader has most likely seen before, the battle between the glorious thanes and the 'evil' beast. In this case

The Existence of Evil

3317 words - 13 pages The Existence of Evil Ten children are killed every day in the United States by guns; people are murdered senselessly; Columbine High School; Over one-third of middle school children in Cascade County have used illegal drugs and over one-half have tried alcohol; innocent people in foreign countries are being wiped out (Kosovo); The Holocaust; Hiroshima; Vietnam; poverty, starvation and oppression in third world countries; Capitalism

The Existence of God

2488 words - 10 pages in the degrees of goodness. In all the degrees of goodness, there is still a supreme good. Everything in the universe represents goodness and the creator and controller of all the goodness is the supreme good. This represents the existence of god. Thomas Aquinas' fifth and final premise argues the fact of harmony and order in nature. Beings that do not possess knowledge do not move forward are good unless they are guided by someone or

The Existence of God

1022 words - 5 pages , and not framed by me, nor in any degree dependent on my thought “ -Descartes (Meditations) Descartes definition of God is a “supremely perfect being,” a being with ALL perfections.He seeks to simply establish the existence of God through this definition. As necessary (eternal) existence is a perfection, therefore a supremely perfect being must exist necessarily. If asked would you rather have a £10 note which didn’t exist, or one which did

The Existence of God

2245 words - 9 pages this is that it almost does away with the idea of God. If all Gods proofs and arguments for existence can be ignored, is this any different to saying that God is only a metaphor for a certain attitude to life? If God just like Father Christmas? In conclusion, the argument from experience to prove the existence of god rests on the view that belief in god is reasonable not because its truth is entailed by a series of

The Existence Of God

1209 words - 5 pages as a defect no matter what the justification may be; moreover, this implies that God did indeed make a mistake by creating a being that has faculties that lack perfection. From this we can derive at the possibility that God may be imperfect, and this is a contradiction to Descartes' argument of God as a perfect being. In the " Meditation Five," Descartes attempts to prove his hypothesis of the existence of God based on the theory of

The Existence of God - 1724 words

1724 words - 7 pages ). Given such characteristics draws criticism and ire considering that on any given day the world as we know it is plagued by death, pain, suffering, and an overall unsatisfactory life. It goes on to say that if God was what he is thought to be and more shouldn’t his power reflect as a utopian world? First of all, before using human suffering as an excuse to deny the existence of God it is necessary to establish the origins of suffering which fall

The Existence of God - 736 words

736 words - 3 pages Saint Aquinas defines the existence of God with the upmost clarity. Saint Anselm and William Paley attempt to tackle the existence of God but are weighed down by weaknesses within their argument. Even with Saint Anselm being a Christian theologian, he does not incorporate his personal religious beliefs into his argument. St. Anselm relies purely on logic and ontology to define what he constitutes as God, defined as a being in which nothing

Similar Essays

Perspective Of Evil And The Existence Of God

1579 words - 6 pages make and the choices other people make. “The problem of evil revolves around how we understand God” (Brown 31). Evil is subjective to the person in question and how they perceive God, whether the have religion or not. The problem of evil does not necessarily indicate the existence of God does not exist through history of suffering and the suffering through which people experience in day to day life. The problem of evil, or suffering among the

The Problem Of Evil: Is The Existence Of Evil Evidence Against The Existence Of God?

2232 words - 9 pages standpoint, and claims that the very nature of a theistic God is incompatible with the existence of evil. In his article, "Evil and Omnipotence", Mackie defines evil as any kind of pain and suffering, which is the generally accepted definition of evil among philosophers. He then presents the following premises:1) God is omnipotent.2) God is wholly-good.3) Evil exists.Mackie argues that these claims are logically incompatible with one another. However

John Steinbeck's East Of Eden Good Versus Evil

993 words - 4 pages Good Versus Evil in East of Eden   The idea of good versus evil is illustrated in several ways in John Steinbeck's East of Eden. This is seen through the external conflicts in the novel, the internal conflicts of the characters, and a universal understanding of the battle between good and evil.   External conflicts between the main characters, Cathy and Adam, reflect the idea of good versus evil in their relationship. Cathy, who is

How Evil And Good Is Portrayed In "Paradise Lost" By John Milton

1258 words - 6 pages The original sin that led to humanity's fall in the Garden of Eden is by far the worst sin committed by humankind. It is this sin that led to future sins. This original sin must be emphasized by writers to depict the evil involved in it. In writing Paradise Lost, John Milton recognizes this fact and uses a variety of literary techniques to stress the evil in the story over the good. The techniques used include a series of parallels with the