Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion Essay

1342 words - 5 pages

Philo indicates in the first premise of his first argument of Part X, that the only way society was able to implement religion and a supreme Deity that would also build longevity, needed some sort of image of association. Philo is classified as a skeptic, he interjects that the idea of there being a God has no proof of existence through the sentiments of man that claim no real testimony of divine intervention of any higher intellect without using some sort of system. There is no order of cohesion that determines what should give sufficient enough reason for religion; but to implement such ideologies’ into existence would require some type of human characteristics (anthropomorphism). Philo is trying to prove that creating a source for inspirational for all to believe without question of a God that seems to have human characteristics should be considered blasphemy. In my eyes humans are more acceptable to beliefs of others before questioning possibilities. What respect doe God's grace and mercy actually resemble the grace and mercy of humans? If God created evil and good, then Philo asks if God is impotent, or malevolent, or both? It is possible to see the things on this planet and make observations of order which Cleanthes compares vegetation and animals are more like machinery. Yet machines do not have the capability to feel happiness or sorrow to preserve them from propagation of life. Philo then questions how are people to believe in the understanding of attributes from a perfect God that is incomprehensible.

Demea thinks that all man should understand the truth of religion and should not enter into a higher consciousness or reasoning of a Deity, this would be considered blasphemy. He constantly questions how one should view the religion and the concepts of the ills of life, but he values the conversation and topic concerning human misery with an atheist. In Demea’s response to Philo's argument, he uses the comparison of the world to universe and life’s moments to eternity. That the evil phenomena are proven in many religions and possible future endeavors. Even though mans’ eyes are open to the views of general laws as a whole. He thinks that these laws are connected with adoration and benevolence of God's Devin Spirit.

Cleanthes immediately says No to all such claims by calling them superstition, regardless of fact, views, and undiscovered information. He questions how is it possible for anyone to know this type of information, and how can one prove a hypothesis be proven beyond what is already known? The only way to prove such understanding would be from senseless thinking. Cleanthes also thinks it is not possible for anyone to have enough understanding of mentality to go beyond Devine Benevolence. The only way to support this type of thinking, one would have to reject all misery and wickedness of man. Then Cleanthes criticizes Philo's presentation by saying that it is exaggerated. That the words Philo uses to explain his theories to...

Find Another Essay On Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

Teleological Argument for the Existence of God

2740 words - 11 pages . In his Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Hume offers many objections through the voice of the sceptic Philo, with whom he seems to sympathise. Hume's proposal is basically that the premises of the teleological argument do not entail the conclusion of the existence of an omnipotent, omniscient and benevolent god with any necessity. He points out that the properties of the world do not seem to match up with the essential theistic notion of

Homosexuality, Nature or Nurture? Essay

1652 words - 7 pages that we are living in. Although the approach to proving whether it is a causal of the environment and condition that one grows up in or natural innate properties that make them that way, they are still trying to prove the same point.In the dialogues of "The Symposium," Socrates discusses the nature of homosexuality. Many of the great philosophers that we refer back to for knowledge were homosexuals; which proves that sexual orientation is not a

Notes on Enlightenment Thinkers

746 words - 3 pages and becomes the first person to use it to study the moon and planets-Religion cannot explain natural phenomena, only math canNewton1643-1727Principia Mathematica(The Mathematical Principals of Natural Philosophy)*The universe is desrcribed as a giant clock and all parts work together perfectly in ways that could be expressed mathematically.OpticsLaw of gravity*Every object in the universe attracts every other object*The degree of attraction


3598 words - 14 pages were composed at different times or by differenthands. And the supposition that the Republic was writtenuninterruptedly and by a continuous effort is in some degree confirmedby the numerous references from one part of the work to another. The second title, "Concerning Justice," is not the one by whichthe Republic is quoted, either by Aristotle or generally in antiquity,and, like the other second titles of the Platonic Dialogues, may therefore be

The Reasons Why Some Thinkers Rejected the Cosmological Argument

862 words - 3 pages completing its task. However, amongst all the supporting theories for the Cosmological argument, and all those who supported it, there are also many critics and conflicting ideologies. Many thinkers have rejected the Cosmological argument. Firstly, possibly the most influential and studied critic of the Cosmological argument was David Hume. In "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion" (1779) Hume asked why we must

Plato to Darwin to DNA – A Brief History

974 words - 4 pages BIO 11 Lab Queens College This book has been molded to be a breakdown of how various fields in science have progressed over centuries as mankind has advanced. The book starts off introducing the idea that the telling of natural history has changed numerous times as humans have evolved. We also learn to agree that our knowledge has been shaped by the tools available and the perceptions of its users. In the earliest stages of life, Muehlbauer

The Path to the Future: Science or Religion?

1242 words - 5 pages plague of Power, not germs.” (R.J. Rummel’s, N/A) Currently there are several institutions encouraging dialogues between science and theology, which include: The European Society for the Study of Science and Theology, the Science and Religion Forum, and the Berkeley Center for Theology and Natural Science. This institutes have placed prominent scientists, like Stephen hawking, with prominent theologist, like John Polkinghorne, and the result has

Plato and The Renaissance

1843 words - 7 pages cultural leader, insisted that the investigation of natural phenomena was trivial by comparison to that of human nature, because true wisdom is a matter of values and not facts.13 This view agrees with Plato's teachings, and is apparent all throughout his Republic as he supports claims concerning education to politics with core ethical principles.14 Salutati also came to the conclusion that real truth is always just out of reach, in full

Conscience Created versus Innate

2097 words - 8 pages . Believing instead that they are cultivated in the same way our social patterns and our personalities are. David Hume is a familiar name associated with empiricism. In his famous “Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion,” he speaks of ones mind as a “blank tablet at birth. . . all knowledge is gained exclusively through the senses”. So we have a dichotomy, as it were, in understanding of what conscience is. On one side, it is innate to all. On the

An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion

6399 words - 26 pages from making statements concerning truth and falsity of any religion. In our time the question of truth of religion has increased its significance in a new cultural context constituted by the plurality of religions we find today. Existing pluralistic cultures are torn by competing claims of religious orthodoxy. Previously for an European there were only two questions concerning truth of religion: truth of religion in general and truth of

The Problem of Evil in Hume's Dialouges on Natural Religion and "Candide"

1398 words - 6 pages each address this issue in Candide and Dialogues on Natural Religion, respectively. Voltaire does so in a more lighthearted approach typical of the philosophes, employing his wit to address weighty issues of philosophy and at the same time entertaining his readers. Candide makes this point with an amusing story and its brutal satire; Hume does so in a more pedagogical style. However, the Dialogues do employ a sort of plot that helps to draw the

Similar Essays

An Analysis Of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

4432 words - 18 pages An Analysis of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion ABSTRACT: Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779) may be read in the way Cleanthes (and Philo as well) reads Nature, as analogous to human artifice and contrivance. The Dialogues and Nature then are both texts, with an intelligent author or Author, and analogies may be started from these five facts of Hume's text: the independence of Hume's characters; the non

David Hume And Karl Marx’s Critiques Of Religion

1287 words - 5 pages expresses a statement that one can derive by reason alone. Religion suggests that the world operates on cause and effect and that there must be a First Cause, in this case God. In Hume’s worldview, causation is assumed but ultimately unknowable. Hume’s critique of religion at the time was very risky during the 18th century so when he wrote “Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion” he masked his beliefs and arguments as a story with characters

Paley Vs. Hume This Is A Inductive Argument About The Origin And Nature Of God, Religion, And The Universe

1025 words - 4 pages Paley vs. HumeI read William Paley's, "The Argument from Design", and David Hume's, "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion." What I established after reading these two arguments is that it is extraordinarily difficult to come to any conclusion about the origin of the universe and the world. Both are inductive arguments about the origin and nature of God, religion, and the universe; things that can never be proven true and absolute.In Paley's

God Creator Or God As Creation Is A Very Controversial Topic

1174 words - 5 pages believe. And Number five the last one God exists both in reality and in the mind - provided that we accept the possibility of 'the greatest being'.David Hume a philosopher in the early 1700's wrote " Dialogues concerning Natural Religion" In this break he uses their characters to argue for and against the existence of God. Philo argued the course and effect argument, saying that you don't cut your finger with out it bleeding, and you don't build a