Dicuss Similarities And Differences Between Homer's Iliad And The Movie Troy With Reference To What The Movie Has Brought To Modern Day Western Culture

1912 words - 8 pages

The ancient legend of Troy, recorded in Homer's epic poem "The Iliad" Oxford (trans. Robert Fitzgerald University Press 1974) has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film "Troy" (2004, Wolfgang Peterson). "Troy" is a basic retelling of the myth, lacking many elements of the book thus containing many inaccuracies. However, it appeals to a modern day audience shortening and condensing stories from the "Iliad", "Odyssey" and "Aenead" and greatly reducing the time span of events. Some might say "Troy" is sacrilegious, but could merely be viewed as another interpretation of events as "The Iliad" is, too, a secondary source of evidence. The texts differ greatly from one another but contribute to pass on valuable tales to Western culture; all that is left of Greek history.

As for the site of Troy itself, researchers have found that descriptions in Homers "Iliad" coincide with their findings, which is more than the film's representation can say. Troy, or Ilium, existed on the West Coast of what is modern day Turkey, around 1200 BC. There are many layers of strata and evidence suggesting that Ilium was indeed attacked and burned to the ground. Hittite texts also make reference to the characters of Homer's "Iliad" and a possible war. Archaeologists are still questioning their finds and searching for evidence to support or disprove the many theories that evolve around Troy.

Between the book and the film there are a wealth of differences, and similarities only lie in the basic, undisputed ideas. "The Iliad" begins in the ninth year of the ten year siege of the Greeks upon Troy, whereas the movie shows Paris taking Helen away from Troy angering Menelaus in the process. The Greeks sail across the Aegean Sea (in ships of a questionable eighth century design www.archaeology.org/onlinereviews/troy) for vengeance upon Priam's Kingdom, with the assistance of Achilles. Fighting and bloodshed follow, culminating in the well-known wooden horse stealth attack and the burning of Troy. This part of the myth is told in "The Aenead", as "The Iliad" ends with Hector's funeral - a main difference between the two texts.

Another obvious difference is the absence of divine intervention of the Greek gods in the film, or indeed any direct evidence of their presence. As the gods where what made the ten year war come to pass in the first place making "The Iliad" an epic battle of wills, "Troy" falls short of providing this resonance to its audience, and also lacks credibility in its plot. The catalyst of the war was triggered by Aphrodite when she promised to beautiful Helen of Sparta to Paris. She shields the lovers from Menelaus's gaze, and when the battle between Menelaus and Paris takes place, transfers Paris to the safety of Helens bedchamber (Book 6 pg 106). As the movie can't do this Hector has to save Paris instead.

Intervention by the...

Find Another Essay On Dicuss similarities and differences between Homer's Iliad and the movie Troy with reference to what the movie has brought to modern day western culture

This essay is about "What Makes a Meaningful Life" and "Why are we here?" In reference to the movie "Contact" with Jody Foster.

628 words - 3 pages Early on, Ellie was curious about communicating to far away lands. Her father, Ted, helped arouse her interest in distant communication by showing her how to use a HAM radio. She asks her dad if it could be possible to talk to someone on the moon with her radio. He says "Well, if it's a big enough radio, I don't see why not." This leads her to question if it could be possible to talk to her mom if she had such a radio. Ellie's mother died when...

An investigation into the impact IT has had on the modern world with particular reference to business and social problems.

3375 words - 14 pages ReportIt is true to say that IT (Information Technology) has revolutionised the way in which people live today. This applies in industry, commerce, offices, and out of work activities. The impact of this revolution has benefited and it can also be argued, had a negative effect on all areas of day-to-day life.A good example of how IT...

“Society during The Great Depression with reference to the movie To Kill a Mockingbird

2740 words - 11 pages 8Society during The Great Depression with reference to the movie To Kill a Mockingbird.The Great Depression in America began in 1929 with the stock market crash and the effects were very much prominent during the 1930s. It was a time which affected both the poor and the rich. During the next three years after October 1929, stock prices in the United States continued to fall. This strained banks and other...

Title: Homer and The Iliad Task: Write a report on the significance of Homer and the Iliad to ancient Greece and to Western culture.

604 words - 2 pages Homer, who has been known as a historic poet throughout many centuries, was very significant to ancient Greece and to Western culture. He orally passed down two monumental epics, the Iliad and the Odyssey. This...

Differences and similarities of Eastern dragons and Western Dragons Now with the original text

519 words - 2 pages Differences between Eastern dragons and Western dragonsThere are many differences between Western and Eastern Dragons. Western Dragons are perceived as mean, cruel, and vicious nasty creatures. They are mean in many ways to humans and are hated by many people who believe...

The Western Movie Genre

1398 words - 6 pages Westerns are the most important genre of the American film industry, a reflective tribute to the early days of the grand, wild American frontier. They are one of the oldest, most prevailing and versatile genres and one of the classically American genres in their mythic origins. The popularity of westerns has changed over time. Their most productive period was in the 1930s to the 1960s, and most lately in the 90s, there was a restoration of the...

The Differences and Similarities of Color Words between English and Chinese Culture

3829 words - 15 pages English and Chinese culture are quite different from each other, because of different language habits, historical background, traditional customs and so on, The cultural differences between them are reflected obviously not only on literature, arts, thought etc, but also on something inconspicuous, such as the usage of color words. There are a large quantity of English color words. According to etymology, they can be divided into two kinds,...

Differentces and similarities of the movie othello and the movie "O"

878 words - 4 pages The play "Othello" vs. "O" the movie portrays the main characters in various similarities and differences. In the play "Othello" there are two characters that make the play what it is. The movie "O" has those same characteristics with the characters roles. The two main characters in the play "Othello" are Othello and

All Quiet on the Western Front Comparison Between the Book and the Movie

1048 words - 4 pages After reading the novel and watching the movie "All Quiet on the Western Front" the novel proved to be a lot better for learning about World War I. The novel is called the best war novel for a reason. Erich Maria Remarque's novel is so...

"All Quiet on the Western Front": Movie and the Book

798 words - 3 pages In contemporary culture, many of the classic stories have been promoted as motion pictures and became major celebrations of literature, including Erich Maria Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front. Using advanced technology, the globe can see Paul Bäumer's story being vividly retold. However, there are both strength and weakness about the film...

Creating a Modern-day Movie Adaptation of The Glass Menagerie

919 words - 4 pages Creating a Modern-day Movie Adaptation of The Glass Menagerie Dysfunctional. Codependent. Enmeshed. Low self-esteem. Personal struggles of the twenty-first century or those of the past? In his play, The Glass Menagerie, Tennessee Williams portrays a southern family of the 1940’s attempting to cope with life’s pressures, and each of their own conflicts, after they have been deserted by their father and husband. In attempting to create a...

Similar Essays

"To Kill A Mockingbird" Similarities And Differences Between The Book And The Movie

520 words - 2 pages To Kill a Mockingbird EssayTo Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, is one of the most famous novels in American literature. Consequently, it was inevitable that someone would make a film adaptation of the book. There are many similarities, as well as differences, between the movie and the book.There are many similarities between the movie and the novel versions of T.K.A.M., dealing with characters, plot, setting, and theme. One...

Comparing And Contrasting The Movie "Troy" And The Book "The Iliad"

732 words - 3 pages Between the novel "The Iliad" by Homer and the movie "Troy" directed by Wolfgang Peterson, there were mostly great similarities, yet there were also some strong differences. Although most of the movie was on point according to the storyline and dialogues of the characters, there were still some major differences among the two. If I was ever to make my own version of the Iliad into a movie, this would be what I would change; I would make the...

Gladiator. Comparison From The Movie To Actual History. Similarities And Differences.

851 words - 3 pages In the movie, many things portrayed are the same as what really happened in Roman history. Some things though, are a little different in the actual history of Rome than in the movie. Scenes were changed in the movie too, to make the plot more interesting. I connected what I could between the movie and the actual history of Rome.Maximus was the general of...

The Tempest: 3 Differences Between The Play And The Movie

1144 words - 5 pages 3 Differences Between The Play And Movie “The Tempest” “The Tempest” is a play written by William Shakespeare in early 1600s that has been previewed in different kinds of movies, such as the one made in 2010, directed by Julie Taymor. It is a play containing themes such as; revenge, allusion, retribution, forgiveness, power, love and hatred. When it is compared to the play, there are specific differences seen in the movie, such as; Prospero...