Did Racial Segregation Improve The Status Of African Americans?

1001 words - 4 pages

Did Racial Segregation Improve the Status of African Americans?

     “Whites were there because they chose to be; blacks were there because they had no choice.” (p. 158) This quote, from the essay written by Howard N. Rabinowitz, encompasses many, if not all of the ideas that go along with racial segregation. It is a well-known fact that racial segregation did create a separate and subordinate status for blacks, however, seeing as how at the turn of the century the integration of blacks and whites was a seemingly unrealistic idea, segregation could be seen as somewhat of an improvement from the blacks’ previous position in the U.S. as slaves.
     “Everything is forgiven in the South but color”. (p. 159) On the contrary to the above ideas, this quote, spoken by a black woman in Alabama, and seen in Leon F. Litwack’s essay opposing the idea that segregation improved the status of African Americans; shows how blacks in the late 19th and early 20th centuries were characterized by increased inequality because of their skin color. What is looked at as an improvement by Rabinowitz is seen as “an informal code of exclusion and discrimination” (p. 160) by Litwack.
     Although congress reconstructed the exclusion policy in 1867, many white Southerners still remained committed to the exclusion policy. As a result of this, the military and other forces, to grant new privileges and services to blacks, forced the whites. After all, segregation was the alternative to integration, and whites didn’t want integration. In Rabinowitz’s essay, entitled From Exclusion to Segregation: Southern Race Relations, 1865-1890, many examples are shown in regards to how the exclusion of blacks was transformed into the segregation of blacks from whites. Some examples of this were seen in bars, athletic events, parks, trains, etc. An idea was presented by certain Republicans that said that separate provisions for blacks was not a violation of civil rights as long as the facilities and accommodations were equal to those of whites. Rabinowitz states: “They [blacks] accepted segregation because it was seen as an improvement over exclusion and because they believed, or at least hoped, that separate facilities could be equal.” (p. 156) The segregation of blacks was also seen by Rabinowitz as the chance to form a group identity among blacks. “When the white community persisted in its policy of exclusion, blacks responded by opening up their own hospitals, orphanages, hotels, ice cream parlors, and skating rinks.” (p. 157) Although these actions can’t really be compared to the racism shown by whites, by implementing their own establishments, blacks showed that they too could contribute to the separation of blacks and whites.
      The Black Codes, as well as the few segregation laws that were passed by the post Civil war government, failed to carry on through the Reconstruction...

Find Another Essay On Did Racial Segregation Improve the Status of African Americans?

Did the rights of African Americans decline between 1865 and 1900?

1091 words - 4 pages Americans were equal to white Americans, both were citizens of America and could vote, under the democratic values segregation occurred, proving to African Americans that they still were not accepted as equal.In 1865 it did seem to many African Americans that things were improving. The reconstruction of the south begins and the 13the amendment is passed, abolishing slavery. Still though they were seen both in the eyes of the law and that of white

Why did African Americans increasingly turn to violent methods of protest during the 1950s to 1960s?

698 words - 3 pages King's campaign for Civil Rights became less influential. With this slowing of the movement, many young and radical supporters began to question the effectiveness of King's non-violence. As non-violence was becoming seemingly ineffective, African Americans looked elsewhere for Justice. And this movement to violence brought about results and attention in the short run. In 1964, a bill was signed outlawing racial discrimination in employment

In what ways did black Americans secure improve civil rights during the years 1945-63?

2654 words - 11 pages During the years of 1945 to 1963 many black Americans began to gradually work their way into securing their equal rights in America. In order to achieve their aim they went through a lot and many risked their lives in the hands of the whites as they demonstrated against the public segregation imposed on all blacks on services such as the bus, toilets, restaurants etc. There were many factors that needed to be tackled in the minds of many blacks

How did African- Americans attempt to deal with issues of racism in the period between 1898-1930?

783 words - 3 pages racial balance within cities, exacerbating hostility from both black and white Northerners. Stereotypic schemas of Southern blacks were used to attribute issues in urban areas, such as crime and disease, to the presence of African-Americans. Overall, African-Americans in Northern cities experienced systemic discrimination in a plethora of aspects of life. Within employment, economic opportunities for blacks were routed to the lowest-status and

How did African- Americans attempt to deal with issues of racism in the period between 1898-1930?

783 words - 3 pages racial balance within cities, exacerbating hostility from both black and white Northerners. Stereotypic schemas of Southern blacks were used to attribute issues in urban areas, such as crime and disease, to the presence of African-Americans. Overall, African-Americans in Northern cities experienced systemic discrimination in a plethora of aspects of life. Within employment, economic opportunities for blacks were routed to the lowest-status and

Did American Policy Favor African-Americans, Native Americans, and Factory Workers in the mid-to-late 1800's?

654 words - 3 pages During the mid to late 1800's, America policy did not favor African-Americans, Native Americans, and factory workers. Laws prevented African-Americans from voting and allowed for segregation between them and the whites. The Dawes Act was an attempt to Americanize the Native Americans, but it failed. The federal government favored big business in this time and helped limit the progress of unions. However, child labor laws were eventually passed

How did World War One improve opportunities for women's empowerment and elevate women's status in society?

2143 words - 9 pages compared with domestic work, war work "offered escape from jobs of badly paid drudgery."(Goldstein). However it is unreasonable and idealistic to expect such drastic changes in such a short period of time, so the simple fact that there was discussion and consensus by authorities to improve women's rights speaks volumes for the leaps that women's empowerment had. The highly important work that women did in the munitions industries during the war

Improve the Quality of Healthcare for Americans

1786 words - 7 pages flaws already in our healthcare system; it’s clear that we, as a country, need an immediate plan to improve things for the quality of life for Americans. Almost one-fourth of the U.S population lacks any variety of healthcare insurance. Many are even under-insured. The illegal population in this country also contributes to lack of insurance (Census Bureau, 2010). As a result, many Americans receive little or no healthcare at all. Some are

The Persecution Of African Americans

1436 words - 6 pages to find work (Maafa21 film)”. ‘All in all African Americans struggled to survive but they did whatever they had to in order for them to survive. African Americans had no knowledge of their homeland any more. They knew slim to nothing about neither their culture, religion, Native tongue, nor the outstanding riches their country possessed. This America was all they knew; blood sweat and tears went into building this country so what sense did it

The History of African Americans in Film

2058 words - 8 pages were lead to believe that this was how every African American sang and danced and failed to realize that this was simply the way one man did it. Actual African American actors were rare at the time. There were only a few African Americans that actually appeared on stage and those who did only had minor roles such as servants or shoe shiners. This was mainly because the world was used to African Americans being slaves doing jobs such as these and

The History of African Americans: Slavery

2542 words - 10 pages bondage” (The American People 63). To slaves who were forced to complete laborious tasks for the “superior” race had their rights stripped from them and worked long hours that did not even guarantee safety, the next meal, or another day. However, the separation of races not only created a racial superiority complex, but the idea of slavery also desensitized Americans to the truth behind slavery. Reflecting on the cruelty of slaves from 1619 to

Similar Essays

In What Ways Did The Position Of African Americans Improve In The Period 1870 1919?

2078 words - 8 pages be illegal and stated that it was not specifically referring to racial problems. In 1882 the Supreme Court also said that in cases of murder and assault it was solely the responsibility of the state to find the culprit and bring them to justice. In the south this led to many blacks being imprisoned for crimes they did not commit.There were many outstanding men who contributed to the lives of black Americans in an attempt to improve their lives

To What Extent Did Kennedy And Johnson Improve Civil Rights Of African Americans?

1333 words - 5 pages little Kennedy actually accomplished as president but how much Johnson and the civil rights movement achieved thanksTo be able to compare and objectively see the extent to which these two presidents improved civil rights for African Americans, we must first ascertain what their goals were and if they accomplished them or not; establish the extent of what they did with president each of the surrounding circumstances.In the early 1960S, the drive

Racial Beauty: African Americans Essay

584 words - 2 pages African-Americans are represented as people who suffer from white people othering, internalizing the white beauty ideal and scapegoating, which convinces them they are inferior to white people. African-Americans feel unworthy to white people, as a result of white people trying to distance themselves as far as possible from African-Americans. White people want to have clear boundaries between me and not-me, in order to retain their identity. In

African Americans And Segregation: The Civil Rights Movement

1691 words - 7 pages . They encountered racial discrimination, segregation, and unequal opportunities. Within the play Fences, by August Wilson, we can see just how the play exemplifies what is happening in the world around them. African Americans experienced the hatred of the whites everywhere they went and soon it was advancing to having in their own homes. When the television was advancing and becoming popular, everyone wanted one, including African Americans; but