This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Differences Between Stakeholder And Shareholder Theory Singapore Management University Assignment

1354 words - 6 pages

Brandon Pang
In light of recent debates about the purpose and social responsibility of the modern corporation, the principle of shareholder and stakeholder theory is brought to comparison with each other, to determine which principle corporation should follow.
This commentary critiques the arguments that Anant K. Sundaram and Andrew C. Inkpen has raised which supports the principle of shareholder theory, as well as the refute via stakeholder theory by R. Edward Freeman, Andrew C. Wicks, Bidhan Parmar.
Value Maximisation & Entrepreneurial Risk Taking
Sundaram & Inkpen argues for the primacy of shareholder value maximisation via their first two points that it maximises the value of the whole firm and that appropriate risk to allow for the firm’s growth will be taken. The reason for their argument is that shareholders are ‘residual claimants’ with appropriate incentives to make any discretionary decisions - as such it makes sense that when the residual claimants’ value are maximised, naturally the stakeholders’ shares have been maximised as well1. This also relates to stakeholders being ‘fixed claimants’, would avoid high-growth investment opportunities for firms, as they would “prefer the prospect of permanence from cash flow stability” for their second point. However the assumptions that Sundaram & Inkpen made is that only shareholders will ultimately want to maximise value to the firm, and that stakeholders will deviate the firm’s objectives away from value maximisation.
Freeman et al points out that Sundaram & Inkpen separates shareholders from stakeholders, but the fact that shareholders are stakeholders too cannot be avoided. This reinforces stakeholder theory that via value maximisation for stakeholders, it ultimately leads to increase productivity as well as profit due to betterment of products. Moreover the idea of entrepreneurial risk in context of joint stake holder relationship, dispels the notion that stakeholders are risk averse. Instead, it shows that stakeholders are willing to take the risk if they are educated on the exponential benefit that such risk brings.
Overall Freeman has proposed a better argument for stakeholders for the first two arguments, but we cannot entirely rely on either principle for a firm. Firstly, there is asymmetric information between the shareholder and the stakeholders; owners versus managers and workers of the firm. This is because of the hands on experience that stakeholders have dealing with consumers, they possess information about the conditions of a successful implementation of the business strategy. Secondly if we just rely on stakeholder theory, there might be possibility that managers hide their actions from owners. This shows incompleteness in the principle-agent contract, and therefore performance-based contracts as well as reputation for the managers will be used as incentives for satisfying investors’ demands, or, in short: maximize the firm’s shareholder value2.
Single Objective versus...

Find Another Essay On Differences between Stakeholder and Shareholder theory - Singapore Management University - Assignment

Discuss the differences between Romanticism and Realism - University of Nottingham - Essay

1995 words - 8 pages Discuss the difference between Romanticism and Realism From the beginning of the nineteenth century, and continuing into the latter half of that century, the primary style of writing employed by American authors was that of romanticism. With a central focus on the author as the sole creator, the romantics were not concerned with accurate portrayal of events; the author has ‘a right to present that truth under circumstances, to a great extent, of

Stakeholder Theory and Competing Concept Essay

1738 words - 7 pages ), 20-26. Edward, R.F. & Reed, D.L. (1983). Stockholders and Stakeholders: A new perspective on Corporate Governance. California Management Review, 25(3), 88-106. Freeman, R.E., Harrison, J.S., Wicks, A.C., Parmar, B.L. & Colle, S. (2010). Stakeholder Theory: The State of the Art. Cambridge University Press. Freeman, R.E., Wicks, A.C. & Parmar, B. (2004). Stakeholder Theory and The Corporate Objective Revisited, Organization Science, 15(3

Freight Rate Management and Shareholder Value

2292 words - 9 pages , M & Visvikis, I 2004, ‘Market interactions in returns and volatilities between spot and forward shipping freight derivatives,’ Journal of Banking and Finance, vol. 28, pp. 2015–2049. Kavussanos, M & Visvikis, I, 2006, Derivatives and risk management in shipping, Witherbys Publishing, London, UK. Kavussanos, MG & Nomikos, NK 2000, ‘Hedging in the freight futures market,’ The Journal of Derivatives Fall, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 41-58. Manoliu, M

Differences and Similarities Between Risk Management and Patient Safety

918 words - 4 pages and similarities between risk management and patient safety.” (Youngberg, 2011). Offering a safe environment for patients is one of the main commitments of patient safety, whereas analyzing the consequences of an unsafe environment would be the concern of risk management. “One of fundamental differences between risk management and patient safety is the difference between fixing problems and driving change toward creating a safer environment

Functions of Management/Delegation Paper University of Phoenix Management: Theory, Practice, and Application MGT 330

754 words - 3 pages Delegating is a very common process that managers or directors use to distribute work among the individuals in the department setting. It is an important step to getting various tasks accomplished and keeping team members involved on the happenings of the company. This paper will discuss the benefits of delegating within each of the four functions of management, how delegation should be used to achieve those benefits and how delegation could be

What are the connections and differences between diversity management and organisational culture?

1080 words - 4 pages Control plays a critical role to connect a relationship between management and organisational culture. Under this situation, diversity management can build a creative workplace and assist employees to be more productive and satisfied in the workplace. Regarding the organisational culture, it can motivate the employees to work harder and focus on thinking how to improve the performance of the organisations. It will discuss how they connect with

Differences Between Buddhism and Christianity

1835 words - 7 pages differences between them are more significant. As we can know, Buddhism, Christianity, and Islamism are the three largest religions all over the world. They all play a very significant role in our life. Nonetheless, Christianity and Buddhism are the largest population around the world. Through our religious distribution map around the world, there are seven billion followers who believe in Buddhism while twenty billion followers who believe in

Differences between men and women

1607 words - 6 pages What is the difference between males and females? We notice the different dressing styles, different roles in the workplace and how we spend our leisure time, how we wear our emotions, and also how differently we think. But a question arises. Are males and females really different in every aspect? The first question we ask when a baby is born is: "Is it a boy or a girl?" Though most people accept most of the socially prescribed roles for the

Differences Between Men and Women

2378 words - 10 pages the future they want to be reassured that they will have high perspective in producing an heir to live on after they are gone. When examining the differences between a woman's and a man's body image many different qualities come into play, for example, genetics and physical outlook. The genetic differences start as soon as the child is produced in the womb. Women have XX chromosomes while men have XY chromosomes as indicated by

Differences between ariel and caliban

1048 words - 4 pages Ariel and Caliban are both servants but this doesn’t mean that they wont have any differences. The most major difference between them is their relationship and attitude towards Prospero. Also they have different characteristics, and in the book they represent two different and opposite things. These differences between the two servants may affect people’s thoughts and feelings about the two characters. Ariel is the air spirit as well

Differences Between Men and Women

1221 words - 5 pages think with white matter, this consists of more connections between the neurons. These neurons are also closely packed together; this explains why women think more complexly and faster (Edmonds 2). Genetics plays a big role in almost everything that we are as living creatures. Genes influence everything from hair color to the way we act every day. They also influence biological differences in men and women. Men are born with an X chromosome and a

Similar Essays

Similarities And Differences Between Organized Crime And Terrorism Pace University Organized Crime Research Paper

1389 words - 6 pages Nick Hannon Organized crime 12/10/17 Prof. O’Sullivan Similarities & Differences between Organized Crime and terrorism Terrorism is the greatest threat to our generation. In the last few years however, another great problem has come up, Organized crime. This type of group has a new way of committing their crime, making it another huge threat. In trying to determine the relationships between organized crime groups and terrorist organizations, it

Differences Between The Social Contract Theory Of John Locke And Thomas Hobbes

2347 words - 9 pages Page 1 of 7 What is Social Contract Theory? The concept of social contract theory is that in the beginning man lived in the state of nature. They had no government and there was no law to regulate them. There were hardships and oppression on the sections of the society. To overcome from these hardships they entered into two agreements which are:- 1. DzPactum Unionisdz; and 2. DzPactum Subjectionisdz. By the first pact of unionis

Ap English S Ummer Assignment "Differences Between Native American Cultures"

862 words - 3 pages Similarities and Differences Between Native American Cultures Native Americans are indigenous peoples that lived throughout the continent forthousands of years before the Europeans began exploring the "New World" circa the 15thcentury. Native American literature and speeches often reveal many similarities with otherpeoples and cultures, as well as containing information that confirms their own distinct cultureand identity. "Speech of

Discussion About The Relationship Between News Release And Organization Boston University Assignment

437 words - 2 pages Jiaqi Ou Prof. Sender CM331 News Release II Journalist Bob Brown: “Print is Dead” On March 1, Bob Brown held a speech in Boston University about his transition from print to online journalism and said that the print format is dead, and many journalists seek to change their jobs. “I once thought print journalism for life after I graduated from Boston University in 1985. But I had to change my career and adapt the growth of the digital,” said