"Different Cultures Have Different Truths". "A Truth Is That Which Can Be Accepted Universally". What Are The Implications For Knowledge Of Agreeing With These Opposing Statements?

1295 words - 5 pages

"Different cultures have different truths". "A truth is that which can be accepted universally". What are the implications for knowledge of agreeing with these opposing statements?The two statements are contradictory as they essentially convey opposing theories about truth; relativism - the belief that what is true is what is accepted by one's culture or community - and absolutism - the branch of thought which claims that a statement is either absolutely true or absolutely false and therefore, nothing can be true for a culture or era and yet be false for another. Nevertheless, both absolute and relative "truths" can be obtained from the different areas of knowledge.Knowledge is generally accepted as a justified true belief, and if relativism and absolutism is in discordance about the truth, its validity can be questioned. The implications for knowledge can vary depending on whether we agree with the opposing statements collectively or individually. The first statement in itself, "different cultures have different truths", surely suggests that a culture itself is identified by a shared belief of what is true by its people, and what the "truths" are to each culture is what differentiates them from others. The implication for knowledge for accepting these statements collectively is that truths can vary if we consider the relativists point of view that there can be "different truths", while absolutist would claim that there is only one universal truth. Thus at least one of the "cultural truths" will not be corresponding to the "facts of the matter" if truth is absolute. Therefore, how can there be any validity in their knowledge - their justified true beliefs - considering it was derived from a truth which was potentially independent of the "facts of the matter" or inconsistence with the universal truth?A second problem that the relativists' view implies on knowledge is caused by the fact that the determining factor for the truth can often be what is accepted by the majority as such. In the case of social relativists, the argument states that "if the majority of a particular society believes that A is true, then A is true. It is therefore possible to cause A to be true, simply by having the majority of a particular society believe it to be true. Whatever the majority of a society believes to be true, then, is true. Thus, the majority of a society is infallible."Abiding by this argument, it's possible that the truth can be changed, causing many implications to the validity of knowledge acquired from these beliefs. Was it not common belief and therefore not true that the Earth was flat a few centuries ago? And does a change in belief constitute a change in truth, or in other words, did the Earth change its shape? And say if Columbus only shared his discovery with a certain culture, it would be possible for two different truths about the Earth's shape to theoretically co-exist.To some extent this could even be exemplified by the occurrences in months...

Find Another Essay On "Different cultures have different truths". "A truth is that which can be accepted universally". What are the implications for knowledge of agreeing with these opposing statements?

" A person has a body ". " A person is a body ". Which of these statements more accurately expresses the truth about personal identity?

885 words - 4 pages " A person has a body ". " A person is a body ". Which ofthese statements more accurately expresses the truth aboutpersonal identity?When considering the content of the question there are twoquestions which must be considered before an adequate conclusion can befound; what really and fundamentally identifies and distinguishes personsat a single time and what enables us to reidentify them over time? Thesecond question of course deals with how

What are "Spirituality, Religion, and the Supernatural"? How are they the same? Different? Can one exist without the others? Why or why not? How have these concepts affected you (or not) in the...

1320 words - 5 pages Untitled Niya Doncheva Eric C. Paison Assignment 3 Anthropology 2 Understanding Spirituality Religion and the Supernatural Spirituality can be defined many different ways for many different people of different ages, cultures, religious faiths and nationalities. Generally spirituality can be defined as a search for the Truth and ultimate meaning. A spiritual person is one who will always seek the answers to life's

Five Different Types of Knowledge That I Nurse Can Use to Care for Patients

2199 words - 9 pages that we provide” (as cited in Bungay, 2005). Bungay stated that “this way of knowing can be considered the art of nursing. It is how we use the knowledge was we have” (Bungay, 2005). Two instances where Allison applied esthetic knowledge was when she determined Mr. Nelson’s oxygen supply and demand to be at an acceptable level through empirical knowledge. Based off this knowledge, Allison applied esthetic knowledge by focusing on a different part

To what extent is faith a legitimate basis for knowledge claims, in religion and different areas of knowledge?

1574 words - 6 pages and there would be no way to construct any sort of knowledge system. My purpose in this essay is to establish the validity of this assertion and to demonstrate that not only is faith a legitimate basis for knowledge claims in religion, but also in all areas of knowledge.To start with, in order to effectively answer a question concerning "religious beliefs", we must first define the term. Obviously, there are many different religions, each with

The Role of Truth in Different Areas of Knowledge

1018 words - 4 pages In three areas of knowledge - art, science and history truth is very different and distinguished from one another. Especially the meaning and the role that the truth plays are very different. The dictionary definition of truth according to the oxford diction is “that which is true or in accordance with fact or reality” or “a fact or belief that is accepted as true”. Finding truth in the three areas of knowledge hugely depends on how the person

Different Cultures, Different

966 words - 4 pages George. Her smiling conveys her lack of appreciation for his help during the procedure. The Indian woman feels that, what the uncle George and the doctor perceive as help, is an intrusion of her privacy and her privilege to have her baby with out the assistance of anyone else. These two different groups of people because of the cultures to which each one belongs cannot share this situation. The question of whether the doctor is a hero in the story

Show how code switching can be used for strategic purposes. In what way is code switching similar to or different from style shifting as a strategic tool.

2365 words - 9 pages used for strategic tool. Then I will show other findings that are similar to Monica Heller's article. Finally I will compare and contrast between codeswitching and style shifting as a strategic tool. (Swann, 2002)Let us begin with Heller's (1988) study of how codeswitching can be used as a strategic tool to achieve the following that I have classified into four main groups. They are to achieve rights and obligations associated with different

Contrast the symptoms of Alzheimer's disease with those of Parkinson's disease. What causes these different symptoms and how does this affect the treatment of these disorders?

3174 words - 13 pages environmental factors are thought to play a part. Most people who get Parkinson's are over 60, but there have recently been more cases in younger men and women.In terms of symptoms, AD can be very upsetting for the friends and family of a sufferer who will notice a rapid decline over a relatively short space of time (1). The symptoms can be categorised into three different groups. Mild symptoms which present(1) NINDS Alzheimer's Disease Information Page

Burial in different cultures (

1372 words - 5 pages constructed and the body placed upon it.Also placed on the pyre were items that the deceased held dear in life withthe hope that they would follow him into the next world.In order tosurvive in the afterlife, the deceased "is also presented with a small coinwhich came to be known as the ferrying fee for Charon." This can belikened to the Egyptian practice of introducing coinage into the tomb insome cases. Homer also speaks of the psyche, which slips out of

Universal Truths: "If knowledge can create problems, it is not through ignorance that we can solve them." Isaac Asimov

1195 words - 5 pages complicity and profundity. With the expansion of our knowledge our horizon extends as well. Thus, the boundary with the Unknown becomes bigger and since the Unknown contains only problems and uncertainties, one has more contact with them. Also, knowledge may be uses in order truth to be defined. Since the ways of achieving truth are not perfect, this leads to a lot of uncertainties which create problems. Thus, the cycle is completed and reiterated- bigger

Discuss some ways in which statistics are used or misused in different Areas of Knowledge to assist and mislead us.

1007 words - 4 pages thought that fast food is the main cause leads 300,000 Americans die each year. In fact, people certainly have a level of personal responsibility for this case 'everyone eats it, and everyone knows it is not healthy, especially when eaten regularly, because it is cheap and convenient, people become less active and more isolated, children take much of their time on watching TV and playing video Games. Parents buy what they want and have less activity

Similar Essays

Are Ethical Statements (Axioms) Different From The Statements Of Science?

1157 words - 5 pages "Ethical axioms are found and tested not very differently from the axioms of science. Truth is what stands the test of time."- Albert EinsteinFirst of all, we have to understand what exactly the term 'axiom' or saying is. Axioms are "self evident truths" or "universally accepted principles or rules." The first definition can be applied more closely to ethical axioms while the latter more closely to the scientific ones.In this sense, an ethical

In What Sense Can It Be Said That People In Different Cultures 'think Differently'?

2883 words - 12 pages mentality is something that can be related to all societies, not specifically the primitive groups which have been subjected to much scrutiny by anthropologists. From anthropologist's fieldwork it is often impossible to identify any theory or source behind such beliefs, because often the people being studied are themselves not aware of this. This theory for beliefs is often what relates mentalities of one society to another, even if on the surface

Descartes Claims That His Existence Of A Thinking Thing Is The One Certain Truth, Which Can Serve As The Foundation For All Other Knowledge.

931 words - 4 pages Descartes claims that his existence of a thinking thing is the one certain truth, which can serve as the foundation for all other knowledge. With nothing more than just the knowledge that he is a thinking thing, Descartes goes on to further meditate on more monumental topics. Not only does this realization of his existence serve as the foundation for all other knowledge, it served as the starting point of a new era of modern western philosophy

”The Vocabulary We Have Does More Than Communicate Our Knowledge; It Shapes What We Can Know.” Evaluate This Claim With Reference To Different Are...

1407 words - 6 pages (assuming that you are not aware of the French word); making it more difficult for you to express your experience than if you knew the word. Here the lack of vocabulary makes the communication and expression more difficult, but it does not reduce the knowledge. According to Whorf, language is the way we humans unravel what we see as central problems with our perception. His theory is that people literally think in a language, and that people