Different Definitions Of The Word "Pious" Depicted In Plato's Socratic Dialog Euthyphro

1307 words - 5 pages

Plato's Socratic dialog Euthyphro is in many ways archetypal of the sort of philosophy that Socrates is thought to have been interested in. In it (as in most classic 'Socratic dialogs'), Socrates seeks out a person who claims to have a certain sort of knowledge. He then proceeds to show that these experts do not possess this knowledge by getting them to contradict themselves. With this in mind, I will discuss the three definitions of the word 'pious' that the character Euthyphro gives to Socrates, and Socrates' problems with each of these definitions.
The dialog begins with Socrates and Euthyphro meeting at the king-archon's court; Socrates has been summoned with charges of corrupting the youth and impiety, and Euthyphro wishes to prosecute his father for leaving one of his servants, a murderer, to die. It is at this moment that Socrates first asks Euthyphro, a young priest who considers himself an expert on piety, what is pious. Socrates claims that if he can convince the court that he has learned the meaning of piety from Euthyphro, they might dismiss the charges against him. It is clear from the start that a lexical definition of piety is not what Socrates is interested in. Rather, he is looking for a practical definition of the pious. A definition of Socrates approval would allow him to look at any action and determine as to whether or not it is pious.
Euthyphro's first definition of piety reads, “I say that the pious is to do what I am doing now, to prosecute the wrongdoer, be it about murder or temple robbery or anything else, whether the wrongdoer is your father or your mother or anyone else...” (5E) This initial definition is rather specific, and claims that piety is just to prosecute or punish people when they commit some sort of crime or immoral act.
Socrates too thinks that this definition is too narrow. He asks Euthyphro if there are other actions which count as pious, to which Euthyphro admits that there are. (6D) If there are actions other than punishing wrongdoers that count as pious, then Euthyphro's initial definition is consequently rendered invalid. A definition of a word ought describe all instances of that word, and Euthyphro has just admitted that there are actions outside of his definition which also count as pious. It might be that it is pious to prosecute wrongdoers, but this in not an exhaustive description of all pious actions.
Socrates presses Euthyphro for another definition of piety, begging that he answer the question properly. Euthyphro replies, “...what is dear to the god's is pious, what is not is impious.” (7A) This is a much different definition than the first—it has a much greater scope. Euthyphro argues that the gods have some ability such that their love of something makes it pious. Similarly, the gods have some power such that what they disapprove of or simply do not like is consequently impious. This is precisely the sort of definition that Socrates is looking for; if it is true, then all...

Find Another Essay On Different Definitions of the Word "Pious" Depicted in Plato's Socratic Dialog Euthyphro

Plato's view of Justice in The Republic

2931 words - 12 pages Discuss Plato's view of Justice in The Republic.Having lived an extraordinarily long life (for his time), with no consistent doctrine of belief, it has become customary to divide Plato's writings chronologically into three periods, Early, Middle and Late. The Republic, a collection of ten books, is thought to have been written after Phaedo during the 'middle-period' of Plato's life. It is during this period that Plato's philosophy becomes his

Accounts of Eros in the Plato's "Symposium"

1797 words - 7 pages The word love carries with it many, many different interpretations. In modern day, our views on what is appropriate love is much different from the views from the time of Socrates and Plato. To them love was eros, a direct translation of the word love.However, the word itself wasn't the only thing that was different about love. In Plato's 'Symposium', there is a celebration for Agathon. He had just won a dramatic contest in Athens, Greece two

Knowledge of Good in Plato's The Republic

970 words - 4 pages than to return to the darkness of the cave. He is not offering any real proof to support his belief. So he really has no solid evidence to back him up. If there is no evidence to show that the capacity for goodness is innate in human beings and that people who have seen what goodness is will want to be good, then there is also no justification for the belief that attaining the idea of good is sufficient for being good. Basically, Plato's vision

Double-decker Definitions: the Role of Frames in Meaning Explanations

10076 words - 40 pages Double-decker Definitions: the Role of Frames in Meaning ExplanationsThere are certain kinds of structured background information (or "frames") should be treated as essential components or accompaniments of word definitions.1 For ordinary print dictionaries, the provision of such information would amount to a very large investment. Market limitations on the price of the book or on the size of the budget that can be devoted to a given dictionary

The Role of Fear Depicted in Arthur Miller’s The Crucible

763 words - 3 pages , proctor is accused of lying to the court. When Proctor confesses his sin of lechery he feels better and his internal guilt is freed. This is different to the end of the play where he signed the confession to witchcraft. He later rips it up as could not live with himself if he were to allow Abigail to get away with her lies, through confessing to something he did not do. In ripping up the confession he is also able to keep his good name which he says

Environmental Issues Depicted in Hardin's "The Tragedy of the Commons"

744 words - 3 pages group “caught” all the M&M’s we did not receive any more. In the real world the same thing is happening. Fishermen are fishing violently so they can have the most for themselves and so they can benefit and they do not once think of the bigger picture, they are destroying the common and will eventually cause extinction. In Harding’s article, he mentions a quote similar to what I am saying above; ‘As a rational being, each herdsman seeks to

The Allegory of the Cave in Plato's Republic

1312 words - 5 pages the different types of knowledge and experience available to human beings, from the purely speculative and academic to the experiential. In this way, the guardian emerges, after fifty fully realized years, the only person capable and worthy of ruling the ideal State. He is, in Plato's terms, the perfect, or at least the complete and just, ruler, the philosopher-king, just as the State can be the only truly just state. The Allegory of the Cave

The example of the slave boy in Plato's meno

1039 words - 4 pages The example of the slave boy in Plato's meno helps to support Plato's argument that we do not just have knowledge, and that we know things only by recollection. The theory of recollection investigates if we have already learned knowledge by previous experiences. There are several questions to raise with this theory such as where knowledge comes from in the first place and what exactly it is that we are remembering. The theory tries to help solve

The Effect of Different Types of Organized Lists on Word Recall

2853 words - 11 pages Different Types of Organized Lists on Word Recall The study of human memory has stirred many interests in research. The process of memory is encoding, storing, and retrieving information. Learning is aided by the ability to store newly formed memories for periods of time and recalling them when needed. One of the main components in memory is the short-term memory (STM), which is responsible for storing information temporarily. Even though the

19th Century Women Depicted in The Story of an Hour

772 words - 3 pages divorce her husband. Society put a lot of pressure on women to be faithful, untainted, and obedient wives that made disobeying ones husband unacceptable. As she goes through the stages of grief she realizes that time will be different from then on. While sitting in the chair by the window, “She breathed a quick prayer that life might be long. It was only yesterday she had thought with a shudder that life might be long.” It seems that when living

The Light and Darkness of Suffering Depicted in Sonny's Blues

2439 words - 10 pages “white,” orderly outlook on life. The narrator believes he has escaped life’s sufferings until the death of his daughter and the troubling news about his brother being taken in for drug possession broadside him to the reality of life’s inevitable suffering. In contrast, his brother, Sonny has been unable to escape his childhood hardships and has ended up on the wrong side of the law. While their lives have taken different paths, they relate to each

Similar Essays

Researching Socratic Pedagogy And Education In Plato's Republic

4911 words - 20 pages Researching Socratic Pedagogy and Education in Plato's Republic ABSTRACT: Though Plato never wrote a dialogue that explicitly asks, "What is education?", few argue that he is uninterested in the subject; after all, Plato, like Socrates, was a teacher. In his magnum opus, the Republic, Plato deals with education repeatedly. The eduction of the guardian class and the allegory of the cave present two landmark pedagogical passages. Yet to catch

The Different Types Of Prejudice Depicted In Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird

2219 words - 9 pages The theme of prejudice in To Kill a Mockingbird broadens to a further extent than just the situation of racial discrepancy between the blacks and the whites. Although, the racial discrimination mainly towards the blacks is the most prominent occurrence of injustice at Harper Lee’s time- the early Twentieth century, the whole novel includes several, other forms of prejudice that portray the unfavourable effects that was endured by innocent people

The Nature Of Socratic Philosophy Essay

672 words - 3 pages The Nature of Socratic Philosophy The original word for philosophy steams from the Greek word philosopha,meaning 'love of wisdom'. Although Socrates himself never claimed to have any answers to the questions he raised, his views and methods of philosophy are the cornerstone of what philosophy is today. The nature of philosophy, as viewed by Socrates, is centred around the wellness of the soul, virtue being defined as knowledge and the

Plato's Ideas About Philosopher Kings Depicted In Republic

1737 words - 7 pages In Plato's most famous work 'Republic' he puts forward the view that only the study of philosophy would allow man to see what was good and just. Therefore to cure the ill's of society it would be necessary to either make kings philosophers or make philosophers kings. I intend to show how Plato justifies this view and then attempt to point out some possible problems with this justification and to forward my own view that 'the people' should