This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Different Perceptions Toward Written Correction Essay

2227 words - 9 pages


The debate on written corrective feedback (CF) has attracted much attention since Truscott (1996) claimed that it is not effective, has no support from research, and may even be detrimental for learners. Responding to this claim, Ferris (1999) argued that Truscott’s judgment was premature. She further stated that there should be more studies conducted on this topic to provide a clear answer. For more than a decade later, many studies have been conducted in response to Ferris’ (1999) call (e.g. Bitchener, 2008; Bitchener and Knoch, 2008, 2009; Ellis, Sheen, Murakami and Takashima, 2008) and recent studies have proven that under some circumstances, written CF could be effective to improve learner’s linguistic accuracy without altering the syntactic complexity of their writing (Hartshorn, Evans, Merril, Sudweeks and Strong-Krause, 2010; Van Beuningen, De Jong and Kuiken, 2011).
Although the studies on the efficacy of written CF are quite large in number, the literature on teachers’ and learners’ belief and perception about written CF is very limited. It is unfortunate, because knowing teachers’ point of view about this topic is important, for “teachers must constantly make decisions about what to do‒and what not to do‒ in their classes,” and “these decisions are necessarily made under conditions of uncertainty: research never puts an end to doubt. But the choices still must be made, and made constantly” (Truscott, 1999, p. 121).
Similar to Truscott’s view, Kumaradivelu (1994) pointed out that when theories and studies have not yet provided a firm and clear solution for a problem, teachers usually response pragmatically and this response is based on their experience, training, observation, and even intuition. Thus, investigations on teachers’ (and learners’) belief and perception about written CF are important, because they may provide information to comprehend the function of written CF in a holistic way.

Research questions
This paper aims at investigating teachers’ and students’ perception about written CF. This paper will specifically try to answer the following questions:
1) To what extent written corrective feedback is actually applied in classrooms?
2) How teachers and students perceive written corrective feedback?
To answer the questions, I will start by defining written CF. Having a clear definition is important to set up a clear parameter, so it would be easy to decide what should and should not be included in the discussion. After that, I will provide a brief review of some studies conducted on perceptions about written CF, and then move to a discussion to answer the questions. Possible implication and suggestion will also be addressed at the end of the discussion.

Defining Written Corrective Feedback
Truscott (1996) defined written CF as “correction of grammatical errors for the purpose of improving a students’ ability to write accurately” (p.331), making the term focused on the grammatical accuracy of learner’s...

Find Another Essay On Different Perceptions Toward Written Correction

Components of the US Judicial System

845 words - 3 pages parts of the criminal justice system operate together under the rule of law and principal means of maintaining the rule of law within society. Now its time to study each component system's organization and administration: what is the standard organizational structure for police,courts and correction? Police police organization structure : The following seven elements are the core dimensions of a police organization structure.(Adapted from

Kentucky Adult Corrections: Inmates with Mental Health Issues and the Facilities

3933 words - 16 pages organization whose board of directors is comprised of individuals named by 34 national professional associations. The primary purpose is to work toward improving health service to jails, prisons, and juvenile confinement facilities. One of the issues arising was the incarceration of adolescent offenders in adult correction facilities. They adopted the following position statement, along with published standards, and assist in designing procedures on

Analysis of Learning Experience with Theories of SLA

2374 words - 9 pages -production). In this teaching mode, I could learn a certain grammatical item within quite a short time. But it was rather different for me to use what I have learned into real communication. I did receive some grammar correction from the teacher, especially in a composition. However, some problems about tense and subject-verb concord might still occur next time. Maybe this is why grammar correction is not suggested in teachers’ feedback. What can be

How To Facilitate Improvement in Student Writing Ability

1235 words - 5 pages and energy on providing written error feedback on EFL learners’ compositions. The value of providing error correction feedback is often not highly thought of, even though the practice is quiet widely practiced. Researcher Lee (2009) cites many researchers who view written response as frustrating (Ferris, et al.1997), gruelling and anxiety ridden (Stern and Solomon 2006) and tedious and unrewarding (Hyland 1990). Most teachers would not begrudge

What kind of evidence does violence in children's literature provide of changing attitudes in twentieth century Britain toward children?

3658 words - 15 pages overwhelmingly negative, and gives an indication of rising popular concepts about education from the 1960s.Shifting gender rolesThe conspicuous differences between the violent content apparent in boys and girls literature are powerful clues as to society's expectations and perceptions of gender at different times. Boys, typically labelled as more active, aggressive and physically resilient than girls, have attracted a far greater share of books

Adolescent Writers in Second Language Situations

1312 words - 5 pages Mark O. James studied whether L2 students were preoccupied with surface error correction during the process of generating texts and whether this regular interruption in composition resulted in poorer writing quality. He also wanted to know whether the L2 perceptions of their behaviours accurately reflected observed behaviours and if there were significant differences in fluency of composition between Polynesian and Chinese students. The data was

A Summary of Cyert & March's Behavioural Theory of the Firm

1400 words - 6 pages subunits in the organization. Information about the consequences of specific courses of action in a business organization is frequently hard to obtain and of uncertain reliability. As a result, both conscious and unconscious biases in expectations are introduced. Thus, local priorities and perceptions obtain. In addition, there is some evidence of more conscious manipulation of expectations.Communication in a complex organization includes considerable

Pride and Perception in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

850 words - 3 pages Elizabeth's eyes, and his alteration of perception concludes. Elizabeth learns during the course of the novel that first impressions should not determine a person's complete perception. "Austen engages us both intellectually and emotionally in [Elizabeth and Darcy's] painful progress toward greater self-awareness, toward recognition of their different kinds of pride and prejudice, and thus toward greater perceptiveness regarding those around them" (Moler, 6). Elizabeth sees her fault in the original perception of Darcy and Wickham, and willing recognizes and alters those first perceptions.

time management

5782 words - 23 pages using a self-administered tool with a Nursing Image Scale and a Staff Nurse Role scale, and 39 students participated in 5 focus groups. The perceptions of self- public image were generally high, with self being higher than public. More nurses viewed that they do not demonstrate expertise (p=0.002) or competency (p<0.001) in all tasks, while more students thought they could manage more responsibilities (p=0.004). More nurses had the feeling of

The Invention of Childhood by Hugh Cunningham

1189 words - 5 pages publication of Philippe Ariès’ L’enfant et la vie familiale sous l’ancien regime in 1960 helped to stimulate an upsurge of interest in the field, with Ariès managing to convince most of his readers that childhood had a history, and that ideas about childhood and the experience of being a child had changed over time and in different cultures. In this area of study, there has often been a belief that the ‘true nature’ of childhood emerged in the

The Extent of Historical Revisionism

1887 words - 8 pages history is influenced by the era in which it is written, where it is written and whom it is written by. The roles played in perception, reason and language by emotion and prejudice can easily be seen from the accounts of warring countries, seeming to describe two irrelevant events where as they only represent different points of view. Apart from the description part of the historical knowledge, its classifications are as well as inconsistent in the

Similar Essays

The Effect Of Active Student Response On College Age Students Learning Vocabulary Definitions: An Experiment Done In An Experimental Psychology Class

2498 words - 10 pages ' ability to learn scientific vocabulary terms were demonstrated. During ASR error correction the subject repeated the experimenters correct response for those words which were defined incorrectly.Drevno et al. (1994) used five children from three different fourth grade classes that varied in intellectual ability ranging from, academically talented students, to students labeled as being at risk for failure. Using pretests, twelve unknown science

Three Study Boxes: Written Corrective Feedback

1371 words - 5 pages Study Box 1 Background This study investigated how both teachers and ESL students perceive written corrective feedback (WCF), focusing on their perception about the usefulness of different types and amount of WCF as well as their reasons for having such perceptions. Research questions 1. What amount of WCF do ESL students and teachers think is most useful, and why? 2. What types of WCF do students and teachers think are most useful, and why? 3

Research Critique 1 Essay

784 words - 4 pages researcher aimed to answer in this study: 1. Does focused written corrective feedback (CF) have an effect on intermediate ESL learners' acquisition of English articles? 2. Is there any difference in the effect of direct correction with and without metalinguistic feedback on ESL learners' acquisition of English articles? 3. To what extent does the learners’ language analytic ability mediate the effectiveness of CF? To answer these questions, the

Second Language Acquisition Essay

3146 words - 13 pages of correction for improving learners’ writing ability” (Truscott and Hsu, 2008: p.292). Similarly, Kepener (1991) studies showed that students who received written feedback in their journals did not perform significantly better. However, Bruton (2009) had identified flaws in Truscott & Hsu’s research arguing that even though same number of errors were made by both groups, errors made by group A were different to the errors corrected when feedback