This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Problems With Rape Trials Essay

3212 words - 13 pages

Problems With Rape Trials * It is proposed to replace the current s.38 of the Crimes Act
(Victoria) with the following definition of rape:

* s.38 A person commits rape if -

* (a) He or she intentionally sexually penetrates another person
without that person's consent and

* (b) (i) Is aware that the person is not consenting or might not be
consenting;

* (ii) A reasonable person would, in all the circumstances, have
been aware that the person was not consenting or might not be
consenting.

Critically assess this proposal in terms of its likely impact on

(a) What the prosecution is required to prove; and

(b) Current problems with rape trials in Victoria.

At common law, the crime of rape appears to have required the
application of unlawful and felonious violence against the will of the
victim and completed sexual intercourse by force (Rush P & Yeo S,
2000). Over the years however, these essential elements have been
modified, and the common law offence of rape was abolished by s6 of
the Crimes (Rape) Act 1991, which came into force on 1 January 1992.
These modifications "softened" the crime of rape (Wallace et al, 2001
pp294), lending the focus from the original need for violence, to the
acknowledgement that violence need to be evidenced to prove that rape
or sexual offence occurred, in fact the focus being on the consent (or
otherwise) of the victim (Papidimitropoulos v R).

This essay will focus on the current prosecutorial requirements with
regards to consent issues, and the effect that the proposed
legislation modifications to the mental element will have on the
burden of proof for prosecution, and potentially affect the conviction
rates in sexual assault. It will also highlight the current problems
in rape trials in Victoria, and how these affect the rate of
conviction, and the impact on the victim.

The current Crimes Act (VIC) 1952 [s38] reads that

1. A person must not commit rape

Penalty, Level 2 Imprisonment (25 years maximum)

2. A person commits rape if -

(a) He or she intentionally sexually penetrates another person without
that person's consent while being aware that the person is not
consenting or might not be consenting; or

(b) After sexual penetration he or she does not withdraw from a person
who is not consenting on becoming aware that the person is not
consenting or might not be consenting.

To establish the offence of rape based on the current legislation, the
prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt:

1. That the accused sexually penetrated another person;

2. That the accused did so without the consent of that other person

3. That the act of sexual penetration was intentional

4. That the...

Find Another Essay On Problems With Rape Trials

Does the Rape Shield law support Nesson's View that verdicts are to instill confidence in the public rather than maximizing the truth

1297 words - 5 pages report rape incidents.Public confidence in verdicts is promoted a result of the Rape Shield Laws. Prior to this law, some courts restricted evidence of the victim's sexual relations with men other than the defendant to testimony of general reputation. Witnesses could be asked if the victim is known to be unchaste in the community. Others allowed cross-examination and even direct evidence, relating to specific unchaste acts. Also when a woman took a

Date Rape and Acquaintance Rape Essay

2272 words - 9 pages support. In addition to psychological effects of date rape, there are possible physical problems that necessitate medical attention. When a rape victim receives medical attention, the doctor will typically check for tears in the vaginal lining, any injuries received during the attack, pregnancy, and sexually transmitted diseases. A morning after pill can be taken with 72 hours of the rape to terminate any possible pregnancy. Tests for sexually

"The Color Purple": Compare the conflict in Alice Walker's "The Color Purple" to a conflict in real life

496 words - 2 pages Over the summer, I read "The Color Purple" by Alice Walker. Set in the early to mid 1900s, the themes and conflicts of the story reflect important issues that have a high impact on our society today. The novel is laden with themes such as racism, homosexuality and rape, issues that are rarely addressed in current times. Celie, the protagonist, and other characters, suffer through trials during a time where inequalities and prejudices are

Club Drugs and Date Rape

1255 words - 5 pages expectancies, behaviors, and to increase skills that help with life’s stress. Recovery groups for people that are addicted to MDMA through drug abuse might be very effective with the combination of behavioral interventions to support long-term drug-free recoveries. As of right now these are the best ways to receive treatment to an addiction to MDMA (“The Recreational Use of Ecstasy Is Harmful”). There are many cases of rape due to club drugs, most commonly

“Rape Fantasies”: A Text Worthy of Study in the Eleventh Grade Curriculum

3028 words - 12 pages shown to correlate with the choice not to intervene in during sexual assault scenarios (Brown 504). Rape myths are dangerous problems that lead to the continuation of violence against women in our society. Through the discussions of Atwood’s short story, “Rape Fantasies”, the prevalence of rape myths could be diminished. According to Sally A. Jacobsen, a member of the faculty at Northern Kentucky University, this short story has been shown to be

Date Rape

1981 words - 8 pages , including confusion, depression, sleep problems, drug craving, severe anxiety, and paranoia during and sometimes weeks after taking the drug. Not only that but physical symptoms such as muscle tension, involuntary teeth clenching, rapid eye movement, nausea, blurred vision, and faintness persist.The harmful effects of the date rape drugs mentioned provide the audience with an understanding of what the victim endures while being raped. The abuser is at

The Scottsboro Trials

1228 words - 5 pages for any more black citizens. The women identified themselves and then Ruby Bates told the search men “We’ve been raped. All those colored boys raped us.”(Uschan 14).This caused an uproar throughout America not because rape was a horrible crime, but because back then a white woman having sexual relations with a black man was considered one of the worst things a person could do. The act was considered so terrible because people believed that the

Rape: A Crime

1743 words - 7 pages The definition of rape is: The unlawful compelling of a person through physical force or duress to have sexual intercourse. Basically, rape is a forceful act in trying any way possible to make someone have sex with them. This crime is still being committed to this day and is not viewed as big of an issue as it truly is. In order to prove rape is a disgusting and unnecessary crime, the following essay will consist of the history, laws, the costs

Rape Culture: How Society Reacts to Rape

1540 words - 6 pages What do you think and feel when you hear the word rape? Do you feel uncomfortable? Maybe even angry? Your certain feelings and emotions towards this word is a result of rape culture. Rape culture, essentially, is how a society as a whole sees and reacts towards rape or instances of rape. In 2013 rape was defined by the FBI as, “Penetration… of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person

The Scary Truth About Date Rape

1024 words - 4 pages rape.That's extremely scary to me that young women and men do not know what the legal definition of date rape is.Uscience.edu says the legal definition of date rape is non-consensual sexual intercourse by a friend of acquaintance.Non-consensual means without any agreement. You are saying no and they do not stop.Force is typically involved. But doesn't always have to be involved because the person could be passed-outLove is never involved with date

The Scottsboro Trials of the 1930´s

779 words - 4 pages of the third day of the trials, the judge gave the eight boys their sentence (Carter 42). Every one of them was sentenced to death, besides Roy, who was 13 at the time and the jury could not agree on a verdict (Carter 48). In 1933, the Communist Party hired a lawyer for Patterson. During this trial, Ruby Bates dropped her rape testimony, but the jury still sentenced him to death. Since the judge did not agree with this sentence he ordered another

Similar Essays

An Ananlysis Of Rape Culture In America From 1960 To Present

1830 words - 8 pages Due to advances made by the American mass media, the way Americans react to and interact with rape culture has changed dramatically changed from 1960 to the present. News coverage of major rape trials, movies and books involving rape have caused the American people to change their perspectives and reshape the way trials are carried out and the way female rape victims are viewed and treated during and after trials. During the 1960’s, due to

Rape Essay

1124 words - 4 pages woman was raped by four men. The trial testimony showed that the woman had previously had sex with three of those four men. However, the jury still found the four men guilty of rape. They felt that "Sexual consent between a man and a woman on one occasion does not mean the man has access to her whenever it strikes his fancy". Although these types of trials do not always end with the same verdict, a few years ago, women would not have even pressed

Spousal Rape Essay

1072 words - 4 pages Can a husband rape his wife? I find myself amazed by the number of people who believe that they can’t. It seems, the common mindset is that when a man and woman marry, the woman somehow become the man’s property, for him to do with what he wants, whenever he wants, regardless of her feelings. Well, I disagree completely and feel it is my duty as a past victim of spousal rape, to set the record straight that rape is rape, regardless of marital

Pevelance And Effects Of Rape Essay

1409 words - 6 pages rape victims are concentrated to one specific class or race. However, “American women aged 16–24 are considered to be at the greatest risk of sexual assault” (Aronowitz, Lambert, and Davidoff 173). The majority of rapists are age twenty-five and younger. Almost all rape cases have female victims with male offenders. Men account for only 10% of all rape victims, and in some cases their rapist is also male. In regards to statistics, rape appears rare