Digging Into Holmberg's Mistake Ib History Of The Americas Assignment

512 words - 3 pages

Hannah Cho
IB History of the Americas I
September 9, 2017
Holmberg’s Mistake
Charles C. Mann, in his novel 1491, introduces a concept he called “Holmberg’s Mistake.” The concept is derived from Allan R. Holmberg's novel Nomads of the Longbow in which he describes the Sirionó people and their nomadic, impoverished lifestyles. His observations embodied the Sirionó as “[one of] the most culturally backwards peoples of the world” (8 Mann) who, before Columbus, had no prior history and "floated changelessly through the millennia" (8). In his book, he concluded that the Sirionó were uncivilized people who had no history before Columbus. But in fact, he was wrong. The reason for their poverty-stricken state was due to an epidemic devastating "more than 95 percent in less than a generation" (9). The consequence of such great losses resulted in a state of mental instability as the Sirionó lived in constant fear, and later, the effects became obvious as they passed through a genetic bottleneck.
Holmberg's "mistake" is his misunderstanding about the Sirionó, resulting in several repercussions. First and foremost, his discovery created a generalization adapted to ‘South American Natives’ in general and became a widely accepted truth in the academic field. The notion that South American Natives were “incurably vicious barbarians” (12) was embraced in society. The social repercussion of this impression is that “Natives” in society were viewed in a generally negative light. Due to such assumptions, Natives became a thing of ridicule in society and discriminated for their savage nature. In effect, such discrimination encouraged...

Find Another Essay On Digging Into Holmberg's Mistake - IB History of the Americas - Assignment

The Worse Mistake in Human History

1713 words - 7 pages closer look, we can see that with the advent of agriculture came class division, gender inequality, less leisure time, overpopulation, diseases, deficient diets and starvation. The transition from hunting and gathering to agricultural food production may have been the worst mistake in human history. Hunter-gatherer is a term applied to those people that exist by gathering wild plants, fishing, hunting, and foraging for other types of food stuff

"Digging deeper into frankenstein" rediscovering teh true work of literature

829 words - 3 pages Frankenstein as a story. The novel was turned into a meaningless thriller because the novel is a complete contradiction of our culture, as defined by Arnold. What was originally a deep, interpretive piece of literature was turned into a meaningless horror flick. To find the true meaning of the work we must forget the popular escapist version of Frankenstein and return to the original. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein challenges our ideas to the extent of being

Analysis of the Worst Mistake in Human History by Jared Diamond

918 words - 4 pages longer and harder to achieve these things, but humans have also become rather lazy as well. For example, the average American spends their day in an air-conditioned work-space then comes to an air-conditioned home to watch television and use various electronic devices after hitting the local fast-food place for dinner. The population of America alone would be quite drastically reduced if some catastrophic event forced them to once again become hunter-gatherers. Works Cited Diamond, J. (1987). The worst mistake in the history of the human race. Discover, 8(5), 64-66.

The Blackfeet of the Americas

1118 words - 5 pages Who are the Blackfeet and how do they refer to themselves Though referred to as the Blackfeet or Blackfoot, they prefer to refer to themselves as the Nitsitapiksi, which means “Real People.” This term is not only used by the Blackfeet to refer to themselves but to all First Peoples of the Americas (Ni-tsi-ta-pi-ksi, The Blackfoot Gallery Committee, 2001, 3). The Blackfoot Nation is a confederacy of three Nations, the Kainai, the Pikani and

A Glimpse into the History of Psychiatry

1561 words - 7 pages A Glimpse into the History of Psychiatry Purpose: A review of the earliest practices in the treatment of mental illness. Objectives: 1. Identify the earliest treatments and protocols as documented through history. 2. Understand the historical stigmas and terminology in regards to mental illness. 3. Awareness of the progression in treating the mentally ill. The Earliest Known History of Psychiatry. Unearthed skulls dating back to 6500

IB summer film assignment, reflection of film and role as cinematographer - IB film - Essay

5884 words - 24 pages Cinematographer, you are responsible for the camera and the footage, lighting, staying on time with your shooting goals and finding the shooting location. As the Cinematographer, you also must do a lot of preproduction work. I had to do a lot of research about focus, aperture and basic camera functionality, and look for a suitable location to shoot our film. I was also responsible to take the script, analyze it and then turn it into a movie by creating a

modern day historians challenged the traditional accountsof the Spanish conquest of the americas - University college dublin, Debates in history - essay

3220 words - 13 pages , and Italy in medieval times’’[footnoteRef:15]. This shows that Spain was not the first to bring these trials into their society, although it is the Spanish inquisition that has long been remembered as the bloodiest and ruthless in history. While the details of the inquisition in this modern day can be viewed as grim reading, but if you were to place yourself back in the time of the inquisition it would make for far less grim reading as the

The Free Trade Area of the Americas

582 words - 2 pages American nations. This will be called the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA).NAFTA is supposed to promote conditions of fair competition in the free trade area, and increase investment opportunities. It's also supposed to provide effective protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights.The debate over NAFTA divides members of both the Democratic and Republican parties. Many fear that jobs are lost because the agreement makes it easy

Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA)

1573 words - 6 pages What is the FTAA In 1994, the leaders of the thirty-four democratic countries of the Western Hemisphere launched the process of creating a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA). The FTAA will be established by 2010 with the aim of gradually eradicating barriers to trade and investment in the region. The final characteristics of the FTAA will be determined through negotiations by government officials from the thirty-four participating

Discuss the negative and positive aspects of the development of agriculture. Was it, or was it not the worst mistake in the history of the human race?

1710 words - 7 pages Discuss the negative and positive aspects of the development of agriculture. Was it, or was it not the worst mistake in the history of the human race?Agriculture is not just a way of growing food; it involves in whole spectrum of cultural changes and adaptations by early human communities. The demands and effects of practicing agriculture as a means of survival created a new kind of community life, with new opportunities and new problems for

Hand Symbol in The Paper Menagerie - IB English - Assignment

903 words - 4 pages ” (Liu 1). Connotatively, the action of her hands letting go reflects her sharing her story and their culture, which reinforces the idea that her hands are filled with the history of their origin. The narrator further on states: “ I didn’t know this at the time, but Mom’s kind was special. She breathed into them so that they shared her breath, and thus moved with her life. This was her magic” (Liu 1). Jack referred to his mother as “kind” implying

Similar Essays

Foreign Policy Of Later U.S. Presidents (Kennedy To Clinton) Ib History Of The Americas

1148 words - 5 pages history. However, with different changes in ideology, the types of policies and actions taken by the presidents also changes, affecting Latin American countries differently. The policies and actions of later U.S. presidents mirror the actions of early 20th century president, rather than the ones after the Great Depression, reflecting both continuity and change from the policies and actions of their predecessors. The actions of the later presidents

The Introduction Of Slavery Into The Americas

795 words - 3 pages The African Slave trade (more commonly referred to as the Triangle Trade) was the main support of the English trade with the Americas, in 1745 according to a British author. Without the slave trade, the American society would never be the same. With the extremely large profits turned by the English, French, Spanish, Dutch, and Portuguese the economy skyrocketed on the slave market. All three continents affected by the African Slave Trade were

Comquering Of The Americas Essay

1452 words - 6 pages From the early days of European colonization many people know that Columbus was the first European sailor to reach the Americas. That is taught in grade school, the epic voyage of the three ships crossing the ocean to reach new land. Before Columbus made the so-called monumental trip it is widely read of his troubles acquiring funds to fuel his voyage to a new land. From country to country he went begging for men and supplies to reach the new

Civilzations Of The Americas Essay

727 words - 3 pages geography, astronomy, and agriculture. Meso-american civilizations were advanced prior to European contact in ways such as adapting to their geography. One example includes the Incas terrace farming. The purpose for this method is to collect rainwater because the Incas lived in mountainous regions such as the Andes Mountains. Terrace farming is when there are ridges cut into a mountain that resemble steps. It was a type of irrigation