Cameras In The Courtroom Essay

1414 words - 6 pages

Cameras in the Courtroom


This fall, Zacarias Moussaoui is scheduled to go to trial for his participation in the airplane bombing of the World Trade Center in New York City. Along with the media frenzy that accompanies a trial of this magnitude, a separate battle is being waged between Courtroom Television Network LLC (Court-TV) and the U.S. Government over the right of the former to televise trial proceedings.
The Government of the United States’ opposition is stated in a legal brief dated January 4, 2002. Their stance is that “the televising of federal criminal trials is prohibited by both Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 53 (‘The taking of photographs in the courtroom during the progress of judicial proceedings or radio broadcasting of judicial proceedings from the courtroom shall not be permitted by the court.’) and Local Rule 83.3 of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.” The Government contends that Rule 83 does not allow individual judges to grant the right to televise criminal proceedings, but that the rule applies “in all situations with no exceptions.”
In section II of the brief, the prosecution attacks the claims by Court-TV that the First Amendment protects their televising of proceedings. In summarizing several Supreme Court cases where the issue of cameras in the courtroom was brought to the forefront, the U.S. Government effectively shows that Court-TV cannot claim First Amendment protection.
Section IV finds the prosecution attesting that Court-TV has given no valid argument as to why the proceedings should be televised. They claim that while opening the courtroom to the public assures that the proceedings are conducted fairly, “there is no reason to believe that televising the proceedings widely would enhance the benefits to the administration of justice obtained through open trials.”
The prosecution also admits that the televising of proceedings increases the audience, and therefore increases the educational benefits, but argues that this alone “does not warrant a constitutional requirement that television cameras be allowed at criminal trials.”
The Government points out that in Estes v Texas, 381 U.S. 532 (1965), many potential pitfalls of televised proceedings are listed, including: “(1) the possibility that televising the proceedings will have a ‘direct bearing on (a juror’s) vote as to guilt or innocence’, (2) the possibility that jurors will be ‘preoccupied with the telecasting rather than with the testimony’, (3) the possibility that jurors will be influenced by television broadcasts of the proceedings or subjected to commentary or criticism from members of the public, (4) the difficulty of obtaining an unbiased venire if a retrial is required in a case where the first trial was televised….”
Court-TV’s brief requests allowance for cameras in the courtroom. It opens with the statement that all while fifty states permit some type of television coverage, and...

Find Another Essay On Cameras in the Courtroom

Macbeth is in a courtroom being trialed for being a murderer, usurper and tyrant. Write a final speech in the voice of a prosecutor.

608 words - 2 pages soul rest in peace) as the rightful King of Scotland. Today we have a man before us who has clearly defied the laws of our society and the laws of the Lord.Do we dare leave his crimes unpunished?Do we dare give peace to the man who has acted against God?Honorable members of the jury, today you must decide whether this man, Macbeth, is guilty of these monstrous crimes. Macbeth's deceitful and blood-thirsty manner is indubitably shown by his lack of

Teanage Sex Education Essay

1724 words - 7 pages this is about what cameras sitting in a courtroom do to society. The topic of this discussion is the mere effects of the media becoming involved in the judicial system.The uncertainty amongst the jury is nothing new; there have been cases of a hanging jury or even mistrials because the jury can't seem to come to a concrete decision. However, with the media as their backbone and the battery the media uses to toy with their minds; is the direct

Courtroom Spacial Distribution and Positioning

1627 words - 7 pages Through observing legal proceedings undertaken at the Downing Centre’s district and local courts, it can be seen that power and power relations are expressed in the courtroom through many different aspects of the court performance. The courtroom is an intentionally organised space and therefore the structure of the courtroom and the positioning of key players are suggestive of the existing power disparity. The internal architecture of the

Camus Symbol

998 words - 4 pages Courtroom symbol:In the courtroom drama that comprises the second half of The Stranger, the court symbolizes society as a whole. The law functions as the will of the people, and the jury sits in judgment on behalf of the entire community. In The Stranger, Camus strengthens this court-as-society symbolism by having nearly every one of the minor characters from the first half of the novel reappear as a witness in the courtroom. Also, the court's

Surveillance Cameras

1254 words - 5 pages percent drop in Airdrie, Scotland, a 68 percent reduction in Glasgow, Scotland, and a 57 percent drop in Northampton” (Taylor 44+). Without the use of cameras everywhere, there would be an excessive amount of accidents, killings, burglaries, drugs, and illegal acts. The use of law enforcement cameras help decrease drug trades, capture traffic violations, and protect neighborhoods without affecting the privacy of citizens. Surveillance cameras

Speed Camera Analysis Essay

930 words - 4 pages used in order to catch speeding drivers but also as a source of government income through numerous examples of ill-placement of these cameras. Kelton points out that 'black spots' or high incident areas have been found to have a lack of speed cameras surrounding them, with the majority of them not being used where accidents occur. By using this information it is brought to the attention of the reader that, although speed cameras do actually catch

Traffic Cameras Should be Forbidden

2014 words - 8 pages With the increasing emergence of traffic cameras around the nation, there has emerged a debate about whether the cameras are effectively functioning to keep drivers safe or whether they are just another source of revenue for cites. Facts have proven that the purpose for the traffic cameras is simply generating more money for the cities. The estimated amount of money that the city of Denver will be making in 2011 from these cameras (Kaminsky

Surveillance Cameras: Invasion of Privacy

957 words - 4 pages Since surveillance cameras have been invented for security reasons at shopping malls and stores they have also been place in public areas such as stoplights, parking lots, hallways, bus stops, and more. I mainly think that our privacy maybe invaded due to the cameras being placed in a mass of public areas privacy can easily be invaded I don’t like it because if your on the phone and the people that watch the tapes can read lips can see what

Legally Blonde

1068 words - 5 pages that she has received the Criminal Law Internship Award. Happy People Don’t Kill begins with a loud orchestra and the sound of Elle’s heels clinking on the floor as she enters the courthouse. After the meeting in the courtroom Elle returns to the nail salon in “Bend & Snap!” and the delivery man enters to “That’s The Way” by KC & The Sunshine Band. Elle teaches Paulette sensual moves in order to seduce him as “Sex Machine” by Mya plays. Trial

There were twenty or more pre-trials or trials that day. The speed in which they were handled was surprisingly

1434 words - 6 pages we quickly went to the fifth floor courtrooms to find a trial. Upon reaching the fifth floor we found that on that particular Thursday there were several pre-trials being held instead of a single trial. These are the observations that we made in Courtroom 2B on that day. The courtroom was very busy that day as we entered. Many well-dressed attorneys were scrambling about the courtroom talking to their own clients

Questioning the Truth of the News

4138 words - 17 pages -trial interviews and speculate on the cases before they begin. According to Chief Justice Edward R. Becker (2004), having cameras in the courtroom can do irreparable damage to a citizen’s right to a fair and impartial trial. He also feels as though having cameras in the courtroom can intimidate litigates and jurors resulting in a negative effect on the trial at hand. A federal Judicial Study has also proven that people become more nervous around

Similar Essays

Cameras In The Courtroom Essay

2610 words - 10 pages Cameras in the Courtroom Throughout history there have always been issues concerning judicial courts and proceedings: issues that include everything from the new democracy of Athens, Greece, to the controversial verdict in the Casey Anthony trial as well as the Trayvon Martin trial. One of the more recent and ever changing issues revolves around cameras being allowed and used inside courtrooms. It was stated in the Handbook of Court

Cameras And The Courtroom Essay

1755 words - 7 pages have access to the goings on inside a courtroom but this is sadly not true. Due to the lack of cameras inside the courtroom, only those privileged enough to obtain a seat in the court may view the session, even though every single American has the right to view the proceedings, whether they want to or not. Cameras must be allowed in all courtrooms in order for the public to see the trials as well as for the benefit of those present. With the

False Memories In The Courtroom Essay

2292 words - 9 pages you helped convict a man based on an eyewitness testimony, and twenty-four years down the road you find out that new DNA evidence exonerated him? It is safe to say no one wants that kind of guilt on his conscience. For these reasons it is pertinent to examine memory, its fallibility, and its role in the courtroom. Before diving into specific problems in memory, it is imperative to understand the basics of memory, which goes through

Categories And Types Of Evidence And Their Use In The Courtroom

1551 words - 6 pages , parties and juries give out then closely inspect the different forms of proof ata court trial is all governed by the law of evidence. In a way, evidence forms an extension ofcriminal procedure. It also forms an extension of civil law. In the Unites States, the FederalRules of Evidence (FRE) are the rules the federal courts follow. Most of the laws of evidence areencompassed in the Federal Rules of Evidence. The Federal Rules of Evidence has played