Digital Piracy And Jewish Law Essay

2300 words - 9 pages

The rapid development of technology over the past few centuries has certainly left an impact on the world of halacha¸ or Jewish Law. Poskim, the formulators of the halacha, have had to make decisions on a variety of topics to accommodate fast-paced advancements in areas ranging from travel (When does one crossing the International Date Line celebrate a holiday?) to home appliances (Under what circumstances may one use a refrigerator on the Sabbath?). One issue that has been particularly relevant in recent years is that of digital piracy. The ubiquity of personal computers, the Internet, and the spread of peer-to-peer programs like Napster and BitTorrent have made a never-ending stream of media accessible to many Orthodox Jews. Naturally, this has kindled an interest in the matter of copyright. Does Jewish Law provide any protection to the author of an original work? What are the halachic implications of violating a copyright?
These questions were particularly troubling to me, as I am an avid pirate, regularly sharing gigabytes of music, movies, and software a week. Of course, as a practicing Orthodox Jew, I wanted to be sure that I was not violating any halachic prohibitions. Thus began my voyage through the vast sea of Jewish Law for clarity on this issue.
Soon after starting this project, though, it became clear that there would be no simple answer to these questions. Most of the rabbinic literature on the topic of intellectual property rights deals with physical media such as books and audio tapes. How these rulings apply to digital piracy is not always obvious. Furthermore, many of the responsa are terse and cryptic. This is increasingly frustrating when the rabbis, as they often do, disagree with each other. For these reasons, I decided that I was not prepared to choose a side of the debate. What follows is an overview of some of the legal models used by the poskim to reach their respective positions.
Shiyur
In an article published in Techumin, an Israeli halachic journal, Rabbi Zalman Nehemiah Goldberg, rosh yeshiva of Sadigua and the Jerusalem College of Technology, deals with a particular set of questions involving the legality of making unauthorized copies of audio cassettes. To answer these questions, Rabbi Goldberg writes a detailed analysis of a novel approach to the issue of copyright: shiyur.
To understand the legal concept of shiyur, Rabbi Goldberg describes a case from the Talmud. This case involves a person who gives a coin to a poor man, stating that he may only buy a shirt with the money. The poor man is not legally permitted to purchase anything other than a shirt. The Talmud explains that this case is an application of the rule of “whoever violates the wishes of the [original] owner is considered a thief” (Bava Metzia 78a). But what exactly is the poor man stealing? Rabbi Goldberg first presents the possibility that he is stealing the coin, as he only acquires the money on the condition that he...

Find Another Essay On Digital Piracy and Jewish Law

Digital Piracy Essay

1772 words - 7 pages On the demand side, the digital consumption of media products is accompanied by the emergence of digital piracy. Whilst copying had already been technically feasible during the era of video cassettes, it required certain equipment and piracy behaviour was limited (Waterman et al., 2007). The rise of the computer and World Wide Web, however, simplified the unauthorised duplication and storage of copyrighted content and caused movie piracy to soar

Account for the increase in illegal downloading of music or film and discuss the effect of this trend

1014 words - 5 pages There are many reasons for increasing the illegal downloading for music in the last years. The technology development of computer and communication led to increase the illegal downloading of digital multimedia (e.g. music). In general, there is no change in the behavior of buyers, but starting of internet network and uprising of computerized systems, result in latest rise in piracy. The digital revolution has been one of the most important

The Era of Internet Piracy

2085 words - 8 pages for these industries. The RIAA claims (Recording Industry Association) “that more than 2.6 billion files of music were illegally downloaded every month on unauthorized peer-to-peer (P2P) systems" (Roda, 2003). Companies are trying to protect copyright infringement by implementing digital encryption technologies and strict laws that prohibit tampering these encryptions. The Beginning The era of internet piracy began in May of 1999 when a college

piracy trends and effects

1184 words - 5 pages communication led to increase the illegal downloading of digital multimedia (e.g. music). In general, there is no change in the behavior of buyers, but starting of internet network and uprising of computerized systems, result in latest rise in piracy. The digital revolution has been one of the most important causes in control of piracy. As the arrival of the digital revolution, it has become not difficult to copy digital information without

Online Piracy: Threat to the Entertainment and Software Business

1597 words - 7 pages a shorter time to pirate music due to the ease of downloading and sharing online than other forms of digital files, such as a software. Their study focused on information on causes, attitudes, and reasons for online piracy, which can help companies be better prepared to face piracy and stimulate legal commerce of their products. They proposed that secondary incentives, which may be harder to pirate or may not be pirated, would possibly make

Piracy of Digitized Music

1009 words - 4 pages The music industry has developed in a series of technological advances, from the development of vinyl to the digitization of music and the creation of formats such as compact disc (CD), digital audiotape, and minidisk (Leyshon 2001). Although the digitized music facilitates consumers, it causes the appearance of piracy and the drop of sales. The subject of piracy has occurred for a certain period. Since 1920's, music piracy has appeared into the

Companies and Copyright Infringement Protection

1970 words - 8 pages the potential profit for these industries. The RIAA claims (Recording Industry Association) “that more than 2.6 billion files of music were illegally downloaded every month on unauthorized peer-to-peer (P2P) systems" (Roda, 2003). Companies are trying to protect copyright infringement by implementing digital encryption technologies and strict laws that prohibit tampering these encryptions. The Beginning The era of internet piracy began in May

Music Industry in a Battle for Recovery

2127 words - 9 pages activity. As the entire music industry experienced diminishing revenues, the executives reached out for legislative assistance. As a result, there is a primary law regulating digital copyrights in the United States, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) was created in the attempt to fight the music piracy (Upshaw and Babin, 16). Furthermore, Boehm describes taht the purpose of the copyright law “is to fulfill a constitutional directive to

The impact and persistence of rising internet piracy and illegal file-sharing. This report shows how internet piracy put effect on music industry

2178 words - 9 pages impact and persistence of rising internet piracy and illegal file-sharing which had resulted in a 30% drop in value in the music market between 2000 and 2004.The April 2005 (Vol 7, Iss 4) issue of e-commerce law & policy (www.e-comlaw.com) highlighted attempts by the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) to stamp copyright infringements by major 'uploaders' who illegally put copyrighted songs (and even films) on the

Why The Laws Regarding The Prohibition Of Piracy Are Wrong

1023 words - 5 pages “Everybody does it." it is, of course piracy, currently an illegal act which one third of people in Europe do everyday. Piracy is when you digitally download something you haven’t paid for and is not licensed for you to use. The Digital Economy Act (DEA) was passed in 2010 by the last labour government. This ‘law’ is supposed to protect content producers by blocking what's known as torrent websites which allows you to download music, film and

Movie Piracy is Stealing

1356 words - 5 pages that “those caught operating a recording device in theaters face a $2,500 fine and up to one year in jail” (Garrison). This law is currently enforced in California, but what about the other states? Piracy can happen in any city in any state. We must enforce this law nationwide if we plan on making a difference. With these laws and the added security, pirates will know we are not playing around and will think twice before attempting to wield a

Similar Essays

Women And Jewish Law Essay

1698 words - 7 pages not a capital crime and therefore there is no capital punishment for its death. The biblical law in Exodus 21 gives the fetus the status of an object, and not that of a person (Biale, p 220-221). This gives a good indication of how Jewish tradition views the fetus. It is seen as an object and not a person.Jacob Emden is one of the only halakhists who wrote on the subject of the abortion of a fetus that was conceived through adultery. His reply is

How Does The Practice Of Jewish Law And Tradition Change Over Time?

1708 words - 7 pages adaptations to technological change. The early Jewish diaspora resulted in Jews living in diverse locations, from Europe to Asia. Ignoring the extreme cultural differences across this large area, the mere geographical differences brought up significant questions of application of Jewish law, the most important of which being, how do Jews living in various geographic locations adhere to Jewish laws that are based on the time zone and climate of

Title:Jewish Ethics On Abortion Author: Brett Novick It Answers The Question: "Is Abortion Allowed In Jewish Law?" And Under What Conditions It Is Allowed. 837 Words 3 Pages

875 words - 4 pages standing idly upon the blood of your neighbor and you are breaking Jewish law. In addition, if the mother is forced to have sexual relations with somebody against their own will they may also abort because of the psychological harm that may cause both the child and the mother. Even though it is a mitzvah to "...be fruitful and multiply..."8 this commandment is only talking about having children after you are married.In conclusion, one may not abort

Battling Digital Piracy Essay

1330 words - 5 pages Internet gives the offenders a sense of anonymity where the risk of getting caught is relatively low and that of punishment almost absent. With all the technology that exists today, it will be next to impossible to completely banish digital piracy. The actual content producers: the artists, scientists, engineers, software and game programmers are severely affected by piracy. The law-abiding consumers are the ones on losing side as they are paying