This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Dimmesdale A Sinner Or Not? Essay

1127 words - 5 pages

In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Scarlet Letter, the novelist suggests how Dimmesdale, a priest who is obligated to the church, has commited adultery, but keeps it a secret to keep the political and societal structure of the Puritan community. Throughout the first half of the novel Dimmesdale is portrayed as a small insignificant character that seems to have a strange liking for Hester Prynne in which the reader does not pinpoint why, until he and Hester meet in the forest. Dimmesdale struggles throughout the novel dealing with his private and public life. Hawthorne defines that characters in the novel are made of how they deal with their own adverse situations.

Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale, a petite character who gives compelling sermons and is a vital part of the Puritan community has a difficult time dealing with his duty to the church. The reader knows that Dimmesdale is the only one preventing himself from telling the community the truth, but he feels it will disrupt the society. Dimmesdale gets interrogated by Chillingworth, which leads him to physical and emotional trauma resulting in a heart condition that has a superficial meaning of his death later on in the novel. The real reason for his death is of a much deeper meaning it is because he has finally revealed his sin on the scaffold. We as readers do not know this for sure but we can infer it from context when the author sets the mood as he describes the scene “Pearl kissed his lips. A spell was broken” (Hawthorne 234). This scene is almost like a Disney movie in which a spell is broken. In this case it is a sin being lifted and a transformation unlike the frog prince but a transformation into death almost as if god rewarded him in an unconventional way for revealing his sin.

Thomas Payne once said, “These are the times that try men’s souls” (Thomas Payne). This quote reinforces one of the main messages in the novel which is that the deeper the characters the more they have overcome adverse situations. This abject insecurity Dimmesdale is feeling is assuaged when he and Hester share a passionate kiss at the forest. This is first time the blanket of guilt seems to be raised from underneath him. The reader can tell from the text, “Thou shalt not go alone” (Hawthorne 182), that Dimmesdale and Hester have discovered a plan to be together forever in which they board a ship to go to London, but this plan goes awry. Chillingworth, Hester’s original husband whom she was forced to marry out of callowness disrupts the plan. Dimmesdale gives a very powerful final sermon, but he would also tell the community of his sin when the author reveals this by saying, “With a convulsive motion he tore away the ministerial band from before his breast. It was revealed! But it were irreverent to describe that revelation (Hawthorne 234). The author shows that Dimmesdale has a scarlet letter A similar to Hester meaning the he was an adulterer too. Hawthorne shows that even through love and passion a sense...

Find Another Essay On Dimmesdale a Sinner or Not?

A Longer School year or Not?

901 words - 4 pages when they have quality time with their family whether they take a vacation or learn a skill at home. All students should not be in school longer. The parents of Children should be involve with what they do in school so that education will not be a problem. Tina Bruno, an executive director of the coalition for a Traditional School Calendar and a mother herself said “ I do believe that if children have not mastered a subject that, within a week

Teenage Violence: A Problem Or Not?

1466 words - 6 pages next cure is pointed out by Spivak and Prothraw-Stith. They say, "a constructive approach must be taken to minimize or avoid labeling children inappropriately and ensure that conclusions are not drawn prematurely, thereby risking inappropriate responses, interventions, or disciplining actions" (3). They believe that since a lot of violent tendencies stem from children being labeled by society as a risk to be violent just because of where they live

Is RMS Lusitania a conspriacy or not?

711 words - 3 pages Strips flag in January, one month before the German declaration. During that time, neutral flags were no longer considered as a sign of safety. Thus RMS Lusitania was remarkably highlighted by her identity, and easily attracted the U-boats to attack, though the German Embassy issued a warning under the demand of a group of German-Americans, which eventually led RMS Lusitania to an absolute tragic voyage. Last but not least, according to the

"Death of A Salesman": A Tragedy or Not?

2997 words - 12 pages A Tragedy or Not a Tragedy? That is the Question.Tragedy or not? That is the question. Is "Death of a Salesman" correctly labeled as a tragedy according to the Aristotelian view of a tragedy? To determine this, the Aristotelian views should be examined along with the play to determine whether or not the play fits the description of an Aristotelian view of a tragedy. Throughout the reading of "Death of a Salesman" it becomes clear that the author

Deciding Whether a Case Should be Prosecuted or Not

1254 words - 6 pages evidence is reliable and can it be used in court. This means carefully assessing the quality of the evidence from all related witnesses before reaching a final decision. Grand jury indictments will be presented by the prosecutors only when and if a criminal case has not been diverted, downgraded, or dismissed. In order to compose a Grand jury citizens are selected from tax lists drivers license and voters registrations. In order to formally

The Debate on Whether Alcoholism is a Disease or Not

1466 words - 6 pages The Debate on Whether Alcoholism is a Disease or Not Many specialists today are in a debate on whether alcoholism is a disease or not. I looked up the word disease in the new American Webster dictionary. It stated that a disease is a condition ill health, or malady. Malady is defined as any disordered state or condition. Alcoholism causes illness and disorder. Someone who is an alcoholic has a dependency on the drug alcohol. If

A National Curriculum: To Be Uniform or Not?

972 words - 4 pages national curriculum. Providing national curriculum would stabilize learning for students and make it easier for them to adapt to changing schools if needed. There are thousands of students every year who move and change schools because their parents change jobs or they have parents in the military. A uniform national curriculum would greatly benefit these students because once they are enrolled in a new school; they would not be introduced to a new

To Kill a Baby, or Not to Kill?

1472 words - 6 pages . They feel that the mother has the right to decide what she does with her body. Why do they not take into consideration the choice of the unborn child? They may feel that the fetus is not a person. It us just another part of the body like the tonsils or appendix that can be removed without a problem. I, on the other hand, feel that this is completely untrue. This unborn child has a heart. It has lungs. It begins to develop facial features at eight

Is Brutus a hero or not - english 2 - persuasive essay

827 words - 4 pages A Manipulated Hero What is a Hero? We all have someone that we think are heros; someone we look up to like a superhero, a celebrity, or even a parent, but what makes them a hero. Well according to the definition a hero it is a person who is admired for their courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities. In the play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare written in 1599, but it was originally published in 1623. A hero is a central

To Date or Not to Date a Multicultural Girl

1161 words - 5 pages To date or not to date a multicultural girl? That is the question. Nowadays, one of the hardest things to do in our lives is to find the right girl for us. We all know that we live in a ethnic country, that racism doesn’t have a meaning anymore. Junot Diaz is a Dominican-American writer who wrote “How to date a brown girl, black girl, white girl, or a halfie”, which the textual analysis of its contain a Multicultural. In this story we can

To Declaw or Not to Declaw: A Feline Issue

1077 words - 5 pages however, seemed depressed or just gave up on trying to function like they used to. Cats have a very high pain tolerance. However, when they do experience pain, they do not like to show their pain because it would make them seem weak and vulnerable. Dr. Gary Landsberg, a graduate of the Ontario Veterinary College in Guelph, Ontario, explains in his studies that all organisms are different after surgeries with their pain. "People will want to stay in

Similar Essays

Reverend Dimmesdale Is A Sinner Essay

735 words - 3 pages Arthur Dimmesdale has continually suffered because of the sin he has committed. He is tortured by his only friend who is really his enemy. He grows weaker day by day because he will not confess his sin. He starves himself and whips himself. He has a daughter but no one can know. People look up to him and he does not want to let them down. If only people knew that he committed adultery with Hester Prynne. In Nathaniel Hawthorne's, The Scarlet

A Pseudonym Or Not? Essay

2043 words - 9 pages Throughout the last century, a raging phenomenon known as the “Authorship Debate”, has come to light. It disputes whether Shakespeare himself wrote the plays and sonnets or if it was someone else writing under a pseudonym. There are countless theories of who the writer might actually be but the main suspects are Shakespeare himself, Edward de Vere, Sir Francis Bacon, Christopher Marlowe, William Stanley, Roger Manners, Sir Walter Raleigh and

A Pseudonym Or Not? Essay

1073 words - 5 pages , sometime before 1623, there was a monument made to show William Shakespeare, the poet, and to appreciate all of his works. William Shakespeare Stratford-upon-Avon was not only William Shakespeare the actor, but he was William Shakespeare the Globe-owner and William Shakespeare the writer of poems and plays. Its to be said that if someone writes a play, their name should be put on as Author, because they in-fact wrote it, not someone else. Sir

Physician Assisted Suicide: A Crime Or Not

864 words - 3 pages they think it should be done, it should be done. It's not up to the government or you or me to decide someone else's fate. If a person wants to die let them die.Daniel Zingale said,"Aids action believes that the Federal Government should not interfere with individuals will to live or to die" ( The government should not be able to make a law that a doctor couldn't help a person with an illness to commit suicide