Direct Combat Roles For Women Essay

2662 words - 11 pages

Section I: Introduction

Women have been in the military, or associated with combat for decades. “The most famous example of the ability of a woman to not only be involved in combat but to lead forces is that of Joan of Arc's legendary battles leading the French army when she was just a teenager.”(Gerber 1) Women have been involved in espionage and even posed as male soldiers during the Civil War. Conflicts such as, WWI, WWII, Panama, and as recent as our current wars in Iraq and Afghanistan women have served with distinction in many ways. In our most recent conflict, over 100 military women have given the ultimate sacrifice. Today with changes in our society and the global environment in which we live two controversial arguments arise concerning women in combat. Basically the debate whether or not women should be allowed to participate in direct combat or not. As our society and cultural beliefs change so does what we except as social norms. Both sides of this argument bring many reasons for and against allowing women to participate in direct combat. Taking into account both views of this controversy it will show, that not only a social change has occurred, but the dynamics of the battlefield has in fact already placed female service members into direct combat.

Section II: Opposition to Direct Combat Roles for Women

Social Norms

Those that are strongly against it base their criticism on a number of reasons that are based on social norms that have existed for centuries. Our social and cultural norms have in the past and will far into the future dictate how we address these issues. Societies have from the beginning of time set certain norms of what men and women should be. These expectations are referred to as gender norms and are deeply rooted in our history.

Gender Norm

Physically men have been perceived to be stronger and have always been expected to leave the home and provide for the family. Women in contrast have always been expected to manage the home and raise children. Our society has always placed the main responsibility to protect and provide for the family unit on the male. The female gender has been expected to be subservient and reliant. Staying home nurturing the children and building a home were the social norms that our society expected women to be. Women were not expected to display what would be thought of as masculine tendencies. Playing football was not acceptable for a young girl where as playing jump rope was acceptable. “Most of the women who served in the military before the Viet Nam war didn’t tell anyone about it. Not their friends, neighbors, and sometimes the families didn’t even know about their military service. When they came home from the war, the United States did not want to acknowledge the part they played in it.”(Casey 1) Our society has defined roles that both men and women have had to fill.

Unacceptable Danger

Placing women or allowing women to be placed in a situation that may lead to rape is...

Find Another Essay On Direct Combat Roles for Women

Society's Restrictive Roles for Women Exposed in The Awakening

1332 words - 5 pages oppresion. She is merely expected to run the house, care for the children and do her best to please her husband. Nevertheless, she finds the role unbearable. She cannot give her life, her identity to others. It is better to die" (Aull). However, this almost methodical way of life affected Edna worse than many other women. Others, such as Adele Ratignolle, who is described as the perfect Creole "mother-woman," accepted their female roles with

The Roles of Women in Ancient Greece and the Reasons for their Subordination

1024 words - 4 pages The Roles of Women in Ancient Greece and the Reasons for their Subordination Women in Greece were treated very differently from the men, they were thought of as less and weak men. The men controlled the lives of the women and made sure the women felt this way and knew their place. “Married women in Greece had three main jobs raise their children for the sake of Athens, show no weakness than was natural to their sex and avoid gossip.”(J. Coffin

Women in Combat

1248 words - 5 pages controversy rages. Technically, women are barred by law/ policy from what is defined in narrow terms as direct combat. Each of the United States Armed Services excludes females from active combat. The nature and extent of the exclusion varies with each service. In today’s military, women were no longer confined to traditional roles in the medical and administrative fields. Almost all military job categories and military occupational

Women in the Military: The Combat Exclusion Law

1304 words - 5 pages The question originally posed in the Combat Exclusion Law, regarding placement of females in combat, continues to be debated as women are placed in combat roles without adequate training (Sanchez, 2011). What distinguishes some positions as being acceptable while others are not? Who has the authority to approve exceptions, and what exceptions have been made? On May 13, 2011, a bill placed before the House of Representatives addressed the

Job Opportunities for Women in the Army

1468 words - 6 pages positions that women are unable to apply for. This is because of a commonwealth law excluding women from serving in direct combat roles. About 93 per cent of all jobs in the Australian military are currently open to women, with the 7 per cent of jobs closed to women mostly in the army and a smaller percentage in the Navy and Air Force. The following positions are currently not available to females: All Royal Australian Infantry Corps, All

Women in Ground-Combat Units

793 words - 4 pages On January 3, 2013 women were being considered for roles in ground-combat operations, causing a debate, can women effectively participate in combat? Some men and women are ready for the change and feel women can do anything a man can do. Others feel that it will affect unit cohesion and morale. Training standards being lowered to allow women to join more elite combat groups is another concern. Many people think women joining ground-combat

Why Women Should Not Be Allowed In Combat Occupations?

1502 words - 7 pages it’s not just the physical differences, there is also the risk of sexual assault. Due to the detrimental impact on the military, soldiers, and society, women should not be allowed to be in combat occupations. The Women's Armed Services Integration Act created in 1948 formed a force of women in all the military departments. This was considered a step in the right direction while also being responsible for current combat restrictions. The act

Women In Combat

2916 words - 12 pages Quarterly Weekly, 1996, p. 368). The only focus of my paper is whether there is still a need to ban women from direct combat. First, let me explain the distinction between combat support units and direct combat units. The military changed its definition of direct combat for women. This opened up more jobs for women that had been off-limits (Congressional Quarterly Researcher, 1992, p. 844). The performance of women in these positions was tested

Is the exclusion of women from frontline combat sexism?

1087 words - 4 pages Excluding women from frontline combat is essentially sexist. Regardless of the many substantial contributions women have made to the United States military from the American Revolutionary war to the contemporary Iraq and Afghanistan wars, it has long been a sanctuary of masculinity, which consequently, has resulted in the organization’s steadfast resistance against women’s direct martial participation. The opponents of women frontline combat

Women In Combat

2160 words - 9 pages In the United States military combat units at battalion level and below have always been closed to women. However, change has been building up over the past decade on opening those closed positions and the Pentagon has decided to officially allow women on the front lines. Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta lifted the Defense Department's ban on women in direct ground combat roles January 24, 2013 and on January 1, 2016 women will be able to

How the United States can Solve the Debate on Female Soldiers in Combat

1752 words - 8 pages combat roles. It’s also very important to ensure that civilian women aren’t included in the draft. These proposals are within reason, and I believe that with them in place, the implementation of women into combat will be successful. The first precaution I mentioned was that women should not be held in a double standard, meaning that the combat physical fitness requirements should not be lowered for them. We wouldn’t be doing female

Similar Essays

Women Serving In Combat Roles In The Military

1889 words - 8 pages line was often blurred" (Holm 445). It is rather simple for a group of people to sit around a table and say that certain assignments are more likely to involve direct combat incident and should therefore be off-limits to women. However, reality often proves to be much different than hypothesis. In Operation Desert Storm, women were frequently exposed to enemy fire even though they were assigned to non-combat positions. One of the strongest

Women Deserve To Be Assigned Combat Roles In The Military

1005 words - 5 pages fundamental reasons too. Over the years, it has been thought that man is the only one able to do this work. However, a woman can be better prepared physically that a man. Therefore, women deserve to be assigned combat roles in the military. A few decades ago the role of women in society was to perform household chores and the care of children. Today there are thousands of women working as military. Physical differences between men and women are remarkable

Persuasive Essay About Women Being Allowed To Fight Alongside Men In Combat Roles In The Military English 1101 Essay

1062 words - 5 pages qualified to perform duty efficiently. More specifically, people question the availability of a female soldier if she falls pregnant and the standards that are set for women. Naysayers believe that if women are allowed to serve in combat roles they may purposely become pregnant in order to avoid a deployment. This is highly unlikely because women who put in the extra effort to make it into a combat role will more than likely not want to miss

Women Roles Changed For The Better

1412 words - 6 pages more independent and autonomous after the war. Overall, it was the hard work and determination by women in ww1 that changed their traditional roles for the many years to come. Now, with women's past in mind, what heights will they take humanity to in the future?