This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Direct Or Inquiry Instruction? Finding The Balance To Maximize Motivation And Learning

2617 words - 10 pages

The question of how students learn best has fueled a controversial debate within the field of educational psychology and instructional design. There is limited consensus as to which type of instructional technique best supports conceptual learning. Instructional techniques cover a wide spectrum of guidance that ranges from direct instruction, which often encompasses the use of lectures and worked examples, to pure discovery learning which includes little to no teacher guidance at its most extreme interpretation. Research on cognitive load theory and motivational strategies have both touted the benefits and criticized elements of both these instructional techniques (Hiebert, Carpenter, Fennema, Fuson, Human, & Murray, 1996; Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark, 2006; Kuhn, 2007; Sweller, 1988), creating a muddled path for researchers and educators to manage for themselves.
In following the scientific and practical contributions of Pasteur (cite?), both field researchers and classroom educators would benefit from empirically supported and well-reasoned arguments on how instructional techniques can be used to maximize learning through motivation. The combination of both a psychological and educational understanding of how instruction influences learning would result in a less fragmented, more comprehensive focus for future research and current classroom application. Research comparing instructional methods often pits one technique against the other in hopes of determining a clear winner, however, such arguments do little to advance the field to a deeper understanding of how such techniques work separately to achieve similar goals. Often, contrasting perspectives of instruction have much to offer and the goal is to use the strengths of both techniques to work towards an integrative model of improved learning and instruction.
This paper is divided into four sections. First, I explore the cognitive debate regarding the limited working memory and its role in direct instruction versus inquiry instruction. Second, I discuss the relationship between learning and cognition and how learner motivation varies during direct and inquiry instruction. Next, I present an instructional model for conceptual learning that combines the unique strengths associated with both direct and inquiry instruction. I argue that using elements of inquiry and direct instruction in combination can overcome the weaknesses associated with either used in isolation. Finally, I provide suggestions for areas of future research that would help lend support to a model of combined instructional techniques.

Working memory and instruction: How much guidance is enough?
Cognitive load theory (CLT) suggests that the human cognitive architecture and working memory in particular have an extremely limited capacity for consciously processing new information (Sweller, 1988). Such limitations allow for very few pieces of information to processed at one time. This is unlike the long-term memory, which...

Find Another Essay On Direct or Inquiry Instruction? Finding the Balance to Maximize Motivation and Learning

Moving your Body to Maximize the Loss

764 words - 4 pages a trainer. If you are at home, or have access elsewhere, take the time to educate yourself with the machine. Explore the manufacture’s website for tutorials, instruction, workouts. If you do not know the brand beforehand type in the generic term “elliptical brands’” in a search engine and you’ll come up with several leading companies. This will get you started. 2. You should always enter your age and weight into the machine. This permits this

Finding a Balance Between Reality and Myth

961 words - 4 pages knew the one weakness men have – ultimate seduction. She was in control the whole time, and in the end the wolf gives in and accepts his new reality. In retrospect, the only way to find balance between the realms of reality and myth is to not just to cope with the reality you have been given, that is the easy way out of a complex set of opportunities. Like in The Company of Wolves, the girl did not simply accept that social norm of males being

Direct Teaching and Cooperative Learning

727 words - 3 pages Direct Teaching and Cooperative Learning I believe the nature of children is to want to have fun. Therefore, teachers must make learning a fun experience. Children can only learn when they are given information and materials to learn from. The overall purpose of education is to provide every child with a competent education. Education is an important aspect of everyone’s life. As a prospective teacher I hope to

Finding the Right Balance as a Teacher - According to Star Wars

1234 words - 5 pages In the movie “Star Wars” the Jedi knights were fighting to have balance in the force. Today many people are also trying to find balance, but others always lean heavy on the other side. Today teachers either try to be cool and get walked on by their students or they are not assertive enough so they do not crack down on them. Some are aggressive and mean and therefore scare their students and still do not get any respect. If teachers can have

Balance of Values and Academic Freedom of Inquiry

542 words - 2 pages In the process of life we face many challenges and manycrossroads. We have many choices and many decisions to make.In making these decisions we must keep in mind the moralvalues our parents have taught us since we were born. ThoseChristian values should guide our lives and the choices wemake. These same values should also guide at school as well. Inour pursuit of knowledge, we should keep these values in mind.In our never-ending road of learning

Inquiry Based learning in the current trend

1705 words - 7 pages , traditional or in other word old trend, is not active in long run for students’ learning. It enables students to answer their questions for the purpose and not for their understanding of the knowledge. For example, the old trend enables students to gain the answer needed but this answer disables students to explore on the different results which may occur during the process of finding out. Hence, students will be immobile and their thinking skills are

The Effectiveness of Inquiry-Based Techniques in Place of Explicit Instruction

2414 words - 10 pages teachers, whose professional careers are based on test score achievement, must provide the most effective methods of instruction for success on highly valued tests. Because it is more challenging to design inquiry based lessons and students are tested on their understanding of the content standards, teachers are more apt to instruct using direct or explicit instructional methods when teaching science. Can the content be learned through inquiry

Combining Management and Leadership to Maximize Employee Productivity

681 words - 3 pages both extrinsic and intrinsic. An example of this would be an extra bonus for improving the methods of operation, giving paid time off to volunteer in developing country or employee recognition in a meeting. Rewards like recognition are part of the motivating factors of Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory. The theory states that motivation is achieved through motivating factors that “use employees well” through positive achievement, recognition, the

Explain how Andrew Marvell uses allegory and/or classical allusion to direct the reader's response to history in one or more of his civil war poems'

1322 words - 5 pages the classical dictionary and the witty, individual transmutation in Marvell's occasional allusions to classical mythology!' (Leishman, P90).As an example he goes on to quote: 'The brotherless Heliades/Melt in such Amber Tears as these.'(99) and this is a direct reference from Ovid. Heliades were the sisters of Phaethon who cried so much over his death that the Gods transformed them into Poplar trees. Further classical reference can be seen in line

Strategy to Maximize Profits for the Clipboard Tablet Company

968 words - 4 pages Introduction Time has warped again, which allows me an opportunity to utilize the cost, volume and profit analysis to develop a new plan for the next four years. The strategy is to maximize profit for the Clipboard Tablet Company for the next four years. After accessing the strategy from 2012-2015, we will calculate variable cost, variable cost per unit, contribution margin, contribution margin per unit, contribution margin ratio, break-even

Motivation and styles of learning

1339 words - 5 pages Motivation and styles of learning have been proven to affect success in school.However, each individual brings her or his own strengths, weaknesses, preferences, gender and learning style to the classroom. In this light, this essay will discuss the many factors that influence motivation and accommodate different learning styles.A co-operative learning strategy can be used to emphasise co-operation rather than competition in learning. This

Similar Essays

The Paradigm Shift From Instruction To Learning

2645 words - 11 pages corporations, medical centres, important banks, human resource consulting firms, county councils, adult learning inspectorates and universities, such as Ashridge Business School, which, in 2004, launched an on-line MBA module. But, as Andrew Ettinger and Viki Holton (2004: 22) show, due to significant barriers encountered in implementing e-learning, the "initial wild enthusiasm" was later replaced by a more cautious approach, or even by reluctance and

Finding The Balance Between Privacy And Security

1535 words - 6 pages struggled with this balance. What brought these laws on in the rst place was the lack of balance; security dominated privacy during the Vietnam War to an unacceptable point. While FISA, in reality, did not do much, it did set a precedent for later acts. Its wording was built on over decades, slowly evolving it into something eective. As time went on, technology expanded even more. With the creation of the Internet, and other technological

Finding Balance Between Chaos And Order In Woolf's To The Lighthouse

2650 words - 11 pages tides will turn and chaos will crash, spurred on by whatever opposing viewpoint there may stand to the previous one. This belief could mean that the world ultimately functions in chaos, that unless people achieve permanent order, no order truly occurs. However, besides the possibility that perhaps having a balance between order and chaos would actually provide the “true order” desired, it seems that rather then focusing on the society's order or

Finding The Balance Of Love And Freedom In Jane Eyre

1591 words - 6 pages redemption and discovery that she truly is liberated. Throughout Charlotte Bronte’s classic novel Jane Eyre, the story’s protagonist Jane, struggles to achieve the balance of both autonomy and love, without sacrificing herself in the process. Although written during both the Victorian and Gothic time period, Jane Eyre draws upon many revolutionary influences that ultimately enabled it to become one of the most successful books of all time. Jane Eyre is